Chiropractic Boards Part III: Clinical Competency Review
The complete book on one page. Use the button at the bottom right to save it as a PDF.
- Chapter 1: The Case History
- Chapter 2: The General Physical Examination
- Chapter 3: The Neuromusculoskeletal Examination of the Spine
- Chapter 4: Extremity, Neurologic and Peripheral Vascular Examination
- Chapter 5: Imaging Decisions, Protection, Positioning and Report Writing
- Chapter 6: Clinical Laboratory and Special Studies in Cases
- Chapter 7: Clinical Impression I: Musculoskeletal and Neurologic Presentations
- Chapter 8: Clinical Impression II: Systemic, Visceral and Special Population Presentations
- Chapter 9: Chiropractic Technique Decisions
- Chapter 10: Supportive Interventions
- Chapter 11: Case Management
- Chapter 12: Image Interpretation I: Arthritic Disorders
- Chapter 13: Image Interpretation II: Congenital Anomalies, Variants, Scoliosis and Trauma
- Chapter 14: Image Interpretation III: Tumors, Miscellaneous Osteoarticular Disease and Soft Tissue
The Case History
On Part III, the history is where the case is won or lost: the vignette hands you a few words from the patient, and the item asks what you should ask next, what the answer means and which diagnosis it makes likely. In the clinic the same skill decides whether a patient with back pain gets an adjustment, an x-ray or a same day trip to the emergency department. This chapter teaches you to turn a vague complaint into a focused, defensible history that has already narrowed the differential before you lay a hand on the patient.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Organize the history of present illness with OPQRST and OLDCARTS and explain what each answer suggests about the tissue at fault.
- Use the mechanism of injury and the timeline to predict the injured structure and the likelihood of fracture.
- Explain how past medical, surgical, medication, family and social history raise or lower the probability of specific diagnoses.
- Run a systematic review of systems and ask the exact questions that uncover cancer, infection, fracture, cauda equina syndrome, vascular and visceral causes of spinal pain.
- Recognize yellow flags that predict chronic disability and name the screening tools that measure them.
- Separate mechanical, nonmechanical, inflammatory, radicular and visceral pain patterns from the history alone.
- Apply pretest probability and pattern recognition to build a ranked differential with a must not miss alternative.
- Adapt history taking for pediatric, geriatric, pregnant and non-English speaking patients, including proper use of interpreters.
- Document the history in a clear, defensible record that supports the diagnosis, the plan and informed consent.
Section 1The chief complaint and history of present illness
What the history is for
Studies in primary care have shown for decades that the history alone leads to the correct diagnosis in roughly 70 to 80 percent of patients; the physical examination and tests add comparatively little once a good history is in hand. For a chiropractor the history has three jobs. First, it sorts the patient into one of three diagnostic bins: serious pathology (about 1 to 2 percent of spinal pain patients), radicular syndrome (about 5 to 10 percent) and nonspecific mechanical pain (about 90 percent). Second, it generates a short list of hypotheses that the examination will test. Third, it establishes the baseline against which you will judge progress and on which your record stands if the case is ever reviewed.
The standard order is: identifying data, chief complaint (CC), history of present illness (HPI), past medical history (PMH), medications and allergies, family history (FH), personal and social history (SH), and the review of systems (ROS). Part III items test the logic inside each part: which question best discriminates between two diagnoses, which answer is a red flag, and which piece of history is missing.
The chief complaint
The chief complaint is recorded in the patient's own words, with its duration: "Low back pain going down my left leg for three weeks." It should not be a diagnosis ("sciatica" or "subluxation") because a premature label closes the mind. If a patient has several complaints, list them, ask which matters most, and take a separate HPI for each one, because a new symptom (for example, a headache in a patient who came for neck pain) may have a completely different cause.
OPQRST and OLDCARTS
Both mnemonics cover the same ground. OPQRST is Onset, Provocation and Palliation, Quality, Region and Radiation, Severity, and Timing. OLDCARTS is Onset, Location, Duration, Character, Aggravating factors, Relieving factors, Timing and Severity. What matters on the board is not the acronym but what each answer means.
| Element | Key question | Answer | What it suggests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Onset | How did it start? | Sudden with a specific load (lift and twist) | Mechanical injury: disc, facet, muscle strain |
| Onset | How did it start? | Insidious, no event, steadily worsening | Degenerative, inflammatory, neoplastic or infectious; ask red flag questions |
| Onset | How did it start? | Sudden, severe, "worst ever", no trauma | Vascular (dissection, aneurysm, hemorrhage) until proven otherwise |
| Provocation | What makes it worse? | Sitting, bending, cough, sneeze, strain | Discogenic or radicular (raised intradiscal or intrathecal pressure) |
| Provocation | What makes it worse? | Standing, extension, walking downhill | Facet joint or central or lateral stenosis |
| Palliation | What makes it better? | Lying down, rest, position change | Mechanical pain |
| Palliation | What makes it better? | Nothing; or exercise helps and rest does not | Nonmechanical (tumor, infection, visceral); exercise relief suggests inflammatory spondyloarthritis |
| Quality | What does it feel like? | Deep ache | Somatic (joint, ligament, muscle, annulus) |
| Quality | What does it feel like? | Burning, electric, shooting, pins and needles | Neuropathic or radicular |
| Quality | What does it feel like? | Tearing or ripping | Arterial dissection |
| Region and radiation | Where does it go? | Narrow band below the knee to the foot | Radicular pain (nerve root) |
| Region and radiation | Where does it go? | Diffuse, buttock and thigh, stops above the knee | Somatic referred pain (facet, SI joint, disc) |
| Severity | 0 to 10, and what can you not do? | Rating plus functional loss | Baseline for outcome measures (NPRS, Oswestry, NDI) |
| Timing | When is it worst? | Morning stiffness over 30 to 60 minutes | Inflammatory arthritis |
| Timing | When is it worst? | Night pain, unrelieved by position | Red flag: tumor or infection |
| Timing | When is it worst? | End of day, after activity | Mechanical or degenerative (osteoarthritis) |
Mechanism of injury
The mechanism is the history's best predictor of which tissue failed and whether a fracture is possible. Ask exactly what happened, the forces and their direction, the position of the body, what the patient felt and heard, and what they could do immediately afterward.
- Flexion with rotation under load (lifting a box and turning) concentrates stress on the posterolateral annulus: classic disc injury.
- Axial load (fall from height onto the feet or buttocks, diving into shallow water) produces compression or burst fractures, most often at the thoracolumbar junction (T11 to L2). A calcaneal fracture from a fall onto the heels travels with a lumbar fracture in about 10 percent of cases, so ask about heel pain and examine both.
- Repetitive hyperextension (gymnastics, football linemen, cricket bowlers, divers) stresses the pars interarticularis: spondylolysis in adolescents.
- Acceleration and deceleration in a motor vehicle collision causes whiplash associated disorders. Ask about direction of impact, whether the head was rotated (worse outcome), headrest height, seat belt and airbag, speed, awareness of the impending impact, and whether symptoms began immediately or the next day.
- Fall on an outstretched hand injures the scaphoid, distal radius, radial head and shoulder.
- Minimal trauma (a cough, stepping off a curb, lifting a grandchild) producing sharp thoracic or lumbar pain in an older or steroid treated patient is an osteoporotic compression fracture until proven otherwise.
- No mechanism at all is itself a finding: insidious pain without an event points away from simple strain and toward degenerative, inflammatory, neoplastic or infectious disease.
The timeline
Duration classifies spinal pain as acute (under 6 weeks), subacute (6 to 12 weeks) and chronic (over 12 weeks, or 3 months). The trajectory matters as much as the duration. Most acute mechanical episodes improve substantially within 2 to 6 weeks; a course that is steadily progressive despite rest and appropriate care is a red flag in itself. Ask about previous episodes, because a recurrent pattern of short mechanical episodes with full recovery between them is reassuring, while a first episode at age 55 or later deserves more caution. Ask what treatment has been tried and with what result: failure to improve after about four weeks of appropriate conservative care is a common trigger for imaging or referral.
Aggravating and relieving factors in more depth
The behavior of pain under load is one of the strongest clues to the pain generator. Flexion intolerance (worse with sitting, bending, lifting, driving, getting out of a chair, morning) fits a discogenic source, because flexion loads the anterior column and pushes nuclear material posteriorly. Extension intolerance (worse with standing, walking, lying prone, reaching overhead) fits the facet joints or stenosis, because extension loads the posterior elements and narrows the canal and foramina. Pain that is worse with cough, sneeze or straining (Valsalva) suggests a space occupying lesion that raises intrathecal pressure on a sensitized root, usually a disc herniation but occasionally a tumor. Pain relieved by sitting or flexing forward and brought on by walking, with leg symptoms, is the hallmark of neurogenic claudication from lumbar spinal stenosis, while leg pain on walking that eases with simply standing still suggests vascular claudication.
Worked examples: turning a vague complaint into a focused history
Reasoning: Flexion plus rotation under load, leg pain worse than back pain, pain below the knee in an S1 distribution and cough aggravation make a right L5 to S1 posterolateral disc herniation with S1 radicular pain the leading hypothesis. Your examination is now focused: straight leg raise, slump, S1 myotome (plantarflexion, toe walking), Achilles reflex and lateral foot sensation. The negative cauda equina questions must be documented. Do not stop at "sciatica"; record the dermatome and the absence of red flags.
Reasoning: Relief by flexion (sitting, leaning forward, the "shopping cart sign"), not by simply stopping, and tolerance of cycling point to neurogenic claudication from lumbar spinal stenosis rather than vascular claudication. The must not miss alternative is peripheral arterial disease, so palpate pedal pulses and consider an ankle brachial index. Asking only "Does walking hurt?" would not have separated the two.
The history of present illness turns a vague complaint into a testable hypothesis. Onset and mechanism predict the injured tissue and the risk of fracture; behavior under load separates mechanical from nonmechanical and flexion from extension intolerance; distribution separates somatic referred from radicular pain. A focused history makes the examination short and pointed.
Section 2Past, family, personal and social history
Why the background history matters
The background history changes pretest probability. The same complaint of thoracic pain means one thing in a fit 25 year old rower and something very different in a 70 year old woman on long term prednisone or a 60 year old man treated for prostate cancer five years ago. Each element below should be asked with a purpose: to raise or lower the probability of a specific diagnosis, or to identify a contraindication to a specific treatment.
Past medical and surgical history
- Prior episodes of the same complaint, how they were treated and how they resolved. Recurrent mechanical episodes predict recurrence; previous good response to manipulation predicts a good response again.
- Prior injuries and fractures, including fragility fractures (wrist, hip, vertebra) that indicate osteoporosis.
- Prior spinal surgery (discectomy, laminectomy, fusion, disc replacement), with dates and levels. Fusion and instrumentation alter technique choice; failed back surgery syndrome changes prognosis; recent surgery with new fever or wound drainage suggests postoperative infection.
- Cancer, at any time. A history of cancer is the single strongest history predictor of malignancy as the cause of back pain (positive likelihood ratio roughly 15). The cancers that most often metastasize to bone are breast, prostate, lung, kidney and thyroid.
- Systemic disease: diabetes (neuropathy, infection risk, delayed healing), rheumatoid arthritis (atlantoaxial instability), inflammatory bowel disease and psoriasis (spondyloarthritis), osteoporosis, connective tissue disorders such as Ehlers Danlos and Marfan syndromes (hypermobility, arterial fragility), cardiovascular disease, kidney stones, and any immunosuppression (HIV, transplant, chemotherapy).
- Down syndrome: atlantoaxial instability in about 10 to 20 percent of patients.
Medications and allergies
Medications both reveal hidden diagnoses and change what you can safely do. Ask about prescription drugs, over the counter drugs, supplements and recreational drugs, and record allergies with the type of reaction.
| Medication | Why it matters in the case | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Anticoagulants (warfarin, apixaban, rivaroxaban, dabigatran) and antiplatelets | Bleeding risk: epidural or soft tissue hematoma, bruising with deep soft tissue work | Modify force; avoid high velocity thrust if anticoagulation is unstable; document INR if on warfarin |
| Long term corticosteroids | Osteoporosis, compression fracture, avascular necrosis of the femoral head, infection risk, masked fever | Lower threshold for imaging after minor trauma; gentle, low force techniques |
| Fluoroquinolones (ciprofloxacin, levofloxacin) | Tendinopathy and Achilles rupture, especially with steroids and age over 60 | Ask in any new tendon pain; avoid aggressive loading |
| Statins | Myalgia; rarely myopathy or rhabdomyolysis (dark urine, weakness) | Diffuse muscle pain after starting a statin: refer to prescriber, CK testing |
| NSAIDs | GI bleeding, renal impairment, hypertension; may mask inflammatory symptoms | Ask about black stools and epigastric pain |
| Opioids | Constipation, sedation, dependence; long term use predicts chronicity | Note dose and duration; yellow flag |
| Bisphosphonates, denosumab | Indicate known osteoporosis; rare atypical femoral fracture (thigh pain) | Modify thrust; image new thigh or groin pain |
| Oral contraceptives, estrogen | Venous thromboembolism risk; slight stroke risk | Consider DVT in calf pain and swelling |
| Antihypertensives, diuretics | Orthostatic hypotension, dizziness, cramps (electrolytes) | Rise slowly from the table; consider in dizziness |
| Antidepressants, anticonvulsants (gabapentin) | Indicate depression or neuropathic pain; dizziness | Yellow flag context; fall risk in older adults |
| Isotretinoin, aromatase inhibitors | Arthralgia and myalgia as side effects | Consider drug cause of diffuse pain |
Family history
Family history raises the probability of conditions with a genetic component. A first degree relative with ankylosing spondylitis or other spondyloarthritis, psoriasis or inflammatory bowel disease supports inflammatory back pain (HLA-B27). A family history of abdominal aortic aneurysm raises AAA risk several fold. Family history of premature cardiovascular disease (a male relative under 55 or a female relative under 65) matters in chest, jaw and arm pain. Ask also about cancer (breast, colon, prostate), osteoporosis and hip fracture in a parent (a FRAX risk factor), scoliosis (adolescent idiopathic scoliosis clusters in families), gout, rheumatoid arthritis, diabetes, migraine, connective tissue disorders and sudden cardiac death in a young relative (relevant to athletes).
Personal and social history
| Element | Ask about | How it changes the working diagnosis |
|---|---|---|
| Occupation | Posture, lifting, vibration, repetitive tasks, job satisfaction, time off work | Heavy lifting and whole body vibration (drivers) predict disc disease; keyboard work fits upper crossed syndrome and carpal tunnel; job dissatisfaction is a yellow flag |
| Physical activity and sport | Type, volume, recent change | Recent training increase suggests stress fracture or tendinopathy; hyperextension sports suggest spondylolysis |
| Tobacco | Pack years, current use | Lung cancer (Pancoast tumor with shoulder and C8 to T1 pain), disc degeneration, poor bone and wound healing, PAD, AAA |
| Alcohol | Quantity; CAGE or AUDIT C screening | Pancreatitis (epigastric pain to the back), avascular necrosis, falls, neuropathy, osteoporosis |
| Recreational drugs | Injection drug use | Spinal epidural abscess, vertebral osteomyelitis, endocarditis |
| Sleep | Hours, waking from pain, position | Waking from pain that no position eases is a red flag; poor sleep amplifies pain and predicts chronicity |
| Stress and mood | Life events, depression and anxiety screening (PHQ-2) | Psychological distress predicts chronic disability; muscle tension headache |
| Diet and weight | Recent weight change, calcium and vitamin D, eating disorders | Unexplained weight loss is a red flag; low energy availability in athletes causes stress fractures |
| Sexual and travel history | New partners, recent travel | Reactive arthritis after chlamydia or enteric infection; disseminated gonococcal arthritis; tuberculosis exposure |
| Home and support | Who is at home, stairs, falls | Fall risk and fracture in the elderly; ability to follow a home program |
| Litigation and compensation | Open claims, lawyer involved | A yellow flag for slower recovery, not proof of exaggeration |
How each piece changes the working diagnosis
Think of each answer as a weight on a scale. Age over 50, prior cancer, unexplained weight loss and failure of a month of care push toward malignancy. Fever, injection drug use, recent infection (urinary tract, skin), immunosuppression, diabetes and recent spinal procedures push toward infection. Older age, osteoporosis, steroids and trauma push toward fracture. Age under 40, morning stiffness, alternating buttock pain, uveitis, psoriasis, inflammatory bowel disease and a family history of spondyloarthritis push toward axial spondyloarthritis. Smoking, hypertension, male sex, age over 60 and family history push toward AAA. A young, active, healthy patient with a clear mechanical onset sits firmly at the benign end.
Reasoning: Minimal trauma, older age, long term corticosteroids and a prior fragility fracture make an osteoporotic vertebral compression fracture by far the most likely diagnosis. The next step is radiographs of the thoracic spine before any manual therapy. High velocity thrust to the thoracic spine is contraindicated until fracture is excluded and bone quality is known. Ask also about weight loss and cancer, because a pathologic fracture from myeloma or metastasis is the must not miss alternative.
Reasoning: Onset before 40, insidious onset, improvement with exercise but not rest, night pain improving on getting up, alternating buttock pain, prior anterior uveitis and a suggestive family history make axial spondyloarthritis (ankylosing spondylitis) the leading diagnosis. Order or request HLA-B27, CRP and imaging of the sacroiliac joints, and arrange rheumatology co-management. Treating as simple mechanical back pain would delay disease modifying therapy.
The past, family, personal and social history set the pretest probability of each diagnosis and expose contraindications. Cancer history, steroid use, anticoagulation, injection drug use, smoking and a family history of spondyloarthritis or aneurysm should each reshape the differential and the treatment plan.
Section 3Review of systems and red flag questioning
The systematic review of systems
The review of systems (ROS) is a structured head to toe inventory of symptoms the patient may not connect with the chief complaint. Its purpose in a chiropractic case is to find the patient whose musculoskeletal complaint is really systemic or visceral disease, and the patient who has a second problem that needs attention. A written intake questionnaire covers the ground efficiently; the clinician then asks follow up questions about every positive answer and about the systems most relevant to the complaint.
| System | Key questions | A positive answer may point to |
|---|---|---|
| Constitutional | Fever, chills, night sweats, fatigue, unexplained weight loss (more than about 5 percent in 6 to 12 months) | Cancer, infection, inflammatory disease, endocrine disease |
| Skin | Rash, psoriasis, new or changing moles, bruising | Psoriatic arthritis, melanoma, Lyme disease, bleeding disorder, shingles |
| Head, eyes, ears, nose, throat | Headache pattern, visual loss or double vision, red painful eye, hearing loss, tinnitus, vertigo | Giant cell arteritis, uveitis (spondyloarthritis), vertebrobasilar insufficiency, acoustic neuroma |
| Cardiovascular | Chest pain on exertion, palpitations, leg swelling, calf pain on walking | Angina, arrhythmia, heart failure, DVT, peripheral arterial disease |
| Respiratory | Cough, hemoptysis, dyspnea, pleuritic pain | Lung cancer, pneumonia, pulmonary embolism, pleurisy, tuberculosis |
| Gastrointestinal | Dysphagia, heartburn, nausea, change in bowel habit, black or bloody stools, pain related to meals | Peptic ulcer, pancreatitis, cholecystitis, colorectal cancer, inflammatory bowel disease |
| Genitourinary | Dysuria, frequency, hematuria, flank pain, retention, discharge, menstrual relationship | Pyelonephritis, kidney stone, prostate disease, cauda equina, endometriosis, ectopic pregnancy |
| Musculoskeletal | Other joints, morning stiffness, swelling | Inflammatory arthritis, polymyalgia rheumatica, gout |
| Neurologic | Weakness, numbness, gait change, clumsy hands, falls, seizures, speech or swallowing change | Myelopathy, stroke, multiple sclerosis, peripheral neuropathy |
| Psychiatric | Low mood, loss of interest, anxiety, sleep disturbance, suicidal thoughts | Depression, anxiety; yellow flags |
| Endocrine | Heat or cold intolerance, polyuria, polydipsia | Thyroid disease, diabetes |
| Hematologic and lymphatic | Easy bruising, enlarged nodes, recurrent infections | Leukemia, lymphoma, myeloma |
Red flag questions by category
Red flags are features of the history and examination that raise the probability of serious pathology. Individually most are weak; their value lies in combinations and in the strong ones. Know the question to ask for each threat and the urgency of referral if it is positive.
| Threat | History red flags | Urgency if suspected |
|---|---|---|
| Malignancy | Prior cancer; age over 50; unexplained weight loss; failure to improve after 4 to 6 weeks; constant, progressive pain; night pain unrelieved by position; thoracic pain | Urgent (days) workup; same day if new neurological deficit (metastatic cord compression) |
| Infection (osteomyelitis, discitis, epidural abscess) | Fever or chills; injection drug use; immunosuppression; diabetes; recent UTI, skin infection or spinal procedure; constant pain | Same day medical evaluation; emergency if neurological signs |
| Fracture | Significant trauma (or minor trauma in the elderly); osteoporosis; long term steroids; age over 70 | Image before manual therapy; emergency if unstable or neurological deficit |
| Cauda equina syndrome | Urinary retention or new incontinence; saddle (perineal) numbness; fecal incontinence; bilateral or progressive leg weakness or sciatica; sexual dysfunction | Emergency: same day emergency department for MRI and surgical decompression |
| Abdominal aortic aneurysm | Age over 60, male, smoker, hypertension; deep, boring or tearing back or abdominal pain unrelated to movement; pulsatile abdominal mass | Emergency if symptomatic or unstable; known small aneurysm needs vascular follow up |
| Cervical artery dissection | Sudden severe unusual neck pain or headache, often after minor trauma; dizziness, diplopia, dysarthria, dysphagia, drop attacks, ataxia, nausea, nystagmus, numbness (the 5 Ds and 3 Ns); Horner syndrome | Emergency: stroke pathway |
| Myelopathy | Clumsy hands, dropping things, unsteady gait, bilateral paresthesias, bladder change | Urgent referral; emergency if rapidly progressive |
| Visceral disease | Pain unchanged by movement; related to eating, urination or menstruation; associated systemic or organ symptoms | Depends on organ: same day for suspected ectopic pregnancy, MI, pancreatitis, pyelonephritis |
| Inflammatory arthritis | Age under 40, morning stiffness over 30 minutes, better with exercise, uveitis, psoriasis, IBD | Routine to soon rheumatology co-management |
| Giant cell arteritis | Age over 50, new headache, scalp tenderness, jaw claudication, visual disturbance, polymyalgia symptoms | Same day: risk of permanent blindness |
Cauda equina syndrome: the questions you must ask
Cauda equina syndrome results from compression of multiple lumbosacral roots below the conus medullaris, most often by a large central disc herniation at L4 to L5 or L5 to S1, less often by tumor, abscess, hematoma or severe stenosis. The single most sensitive finding is urinary retention (sensitivity about 90 percent); with retention, overflow incontinence follows. Ask every patient with back pain and leg symptoms, in plain words: "Have you had any trouble starting or stopping your urine, or any leaking?" "Any numbness between your legs or around your back passage, for example when you wipe after the toilet?" "Any change in bowel control?" "Any new problem with sexual function?" "Is the leg pain on both sides, or getting worse?" Document both positive and negative answers. Incomplete cauda equina syndrome (altered urinary sensation, reduced saddle sensation, retained control) carries a much better outcome after decompression than the retention stage, which is why the question must be asked early and the patient told to return immediately if any of these symptoms appear.
Vascular and visceral causes from the history
Visceral pain refers to the spine through shared segmental innervation, and its giveaway is that it does not behave mechanically: posture, movement and palpation do not reproduce it, while eating, urination, menstruation or exertion do. Kidney stones cause colicky flank pain radiating to the groin, with restlessness (the patient cannot get comfortable, in contrast to the stillness of mechanical pain) and hematuria. Pyelonephritis adds fever and dysuria. Pancreatitis gives boring epigastric pain through to the back, eased by leaning forward, often after alcohol or a fatty meal. Peptic ulcer on the posterior duodenal wall gives midthoracic pain related to meals. Gallbladder disease refers to the right scapula after fatty meals. Myocardial ischemia refers to the left arm, jaw, neck and interscapular region with exertion, sweating and dyspnea. Aortic dissection causes sudden tearing chest or interscapular pain. Gynecologic disease (endometriosis, ovarian cyst, ectopic pregnancy) causes low back and pelvic pain related to the menstrual cycle; in any woman of reproductive age with low abdominal or back pain, ask the date of the last menstrual period.
Cervical red flags and the vertebrobasilar screen
Before treating the neck, ask about the features of cervical artery dissection and vertebrobasilar insufficiency: recent onset of severe, unusual neck pain or occipital headache (often described as different from any previous headache), especially after minor trauma, sport or prolonged neck extension; and the brainstem symptoms summarized as the 5 Ds and 3 Ns: dizziness, diplopia, dysarthria, dysphagia, drop attacks, ataxia of gait, nausea, nystagmus and numbness (often facial or perioral). Internal carotid dissection may produce an ipsilateral Horner syndrome (ptosis, miosis, anhidrosis) and pulsatile tinnitus. A thunderclap headache (maximal within a minute) suggests subarachnoid hemorrhage. Also ask about features of upper cervical instability: rheumatoid arthritis, Down syndrome, recent trauma, a sense that the head is heavy or unstable, and bilateral paresthesias.
Reasoning: New, severe, unusual neck pain and headache after minor rotation, followed by brainstem symptoms (diplopia, ataxia), is the classic picture of vertebral artery dissection. This is an emergency: do not examine with provocative positional tests and do not treat the neck; arrange immediate transfer to the emergency department for vascular imaging (CT angiography or MR angiography). Document the time and the advice given.
Yellow flags: predicting chronicity
Yellow flags are psychosocial factors that predict persistent pain and disability rather than serious disease. They include fear avoidance beliefs (the belief that movement or work will cause harm), catastrophizing, low mood and depression, anxiety, passive coping (waiting to be fixed), poor sleep, social withdrawal, job dissatisfaction and conflict at work, compensation and litigation issues, and a history of long time off work. Related color flags include blue flags (the worker's perception of the workplace) and black flags (system or contextual barriers such as employer policy or the compensation system). Orange flags denote psychiatric disorders such as major depression or personality disorder that require referral.
| Tool | What it measures | How it is used |
|---|---|---|
| STarT Back Screening Tool | Nine items stratifying low, medium or high risk of poor outcome in low back pain | Matches treatment intensity to risk; high risk patients need psychologically informed care |
| Fear Avoidance Beliefs Questionnaire (FABQ) | Fear avoidance for physical activity and work | High work subscale predicts delayed return to work |
| Pain Catastrophizing Scale | Rumination, magnification, helplessness | Identifies catastrophizing as a treatment target |
| Orebro Musculoskeletal Pain Questionnaire | Broad psychosocial risk of long term disability | Screening in workers with spinal pain |
| PHQ-2 and PHQ-9 | Depression | Two question screen; refer positive and any suicidal ideation |
| Oswestry Disability Index, Neck Disability Index | Function in low back or neck pain | Outcome tracking; a 10 point change is a common clinically important difference on the Oswestry |
The review of systems finds the systemic and visceral disease that hides behind musculoskeletal complaints. Ask the red flag questions for cancer, infection, fracture, cauda equina syndrome, vascular and visceral disease in every spinal patient and document the answers; screen yellow flags in everyone, because they predict who will become chronic.
Section 4Building differential diagnoses from the history
From pattern recognition to probability
Experienced clinicians reason in two modes. Pattern recognition (fast, intuitive) matches the story to an illness script stored from experience: "young man, lift and twist, leg pain below the knee worse with sitting: disc." Analytical reasoning (slow, deliberate) lists possibilities systematically and weighs evidence for each. Pattern recognition is efficient but vulnerable to cognitive biases; analytic reasoning is the check on it. Good practice is to form an early hypothesis from the pattern and then deliberately ask, "What else could this be, and what must I not miss?"
Pretest probability is the probability of a diagnosis before a test is performed, and it comes chiefly from prevalence in the setting and from the history. A test result moves probability, and the size of that move is captured by the likelihood ratio (LR). A positive LR above 10 or a negative LR below 0.1 produces a large, often decisive shift; LRs of 2 to 5 (or 0.2 to 0.5) produce small but sometimes important shifts; an LR near 1 changes nothing. Every history question is a test in this sense. A history of cancer in a back pain patient carries a positive LR near 15; age over 50 alone carries a positive LR near 2.7; "pain not relieved by bed rest" has an LR barely above 1. A highly sensitive finding, when absent, helps rule a condition out (SnNout); a highly specific finding, when present, helps rule it in (SpPin).
Mechanical versus nonmechanical pain
The first branch point in any spinal differential is whether the pain is mechanical. Mechanical pain changes with posture, movement and load, has a position of relief, can be reproduced on examination, and usually follows a recognizable onset. Morning stiffness is brief (under 30 minutes). Nonmechanical pain is constant or progressive, does not change with position, is often worse at night, and is accompanied by systemic or organ specific symptoms. Nonmechanical pain has three broad sources: systemic disease (tumor, infection, inflammatory arthritis, metabolic bone disease), visceral referral and neuropathic or central pain. A mixed picture is common, for example a mechanical overlay on a metastatic lesion, so a mechanical component never excludes serious disease when red flags are present.
| Presentation | Key clue in the history | Most likely diagnosis | Must not miss alternative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acute low back pain after lifting, no leg pain | Clear mechanical onset, eased by rest | Nonspecific mechanical low back pain (strain, facet, annular) | Compression fracture in older or steroid treated patient |
| Back and leg pain below knee, worse sitting and coughing | Dermatomal radiation, leg worse than back | Lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy | Cauda equina syndrome; tumor if constant and progressive |
| Older adult, leg pain on walking, eased by sitting and bending | Flexion relief, shopping cart sign | Lumbar spinal stenosis (neurogenic claudication) | Peripheral arterial disease |
| Young adult, morning stiffness, better with exercise | Inflammatory profile, uveitis or psoriasis | Axial spondyloarthritis | Infection (discitis) if fever |
| Adolescent athlete, extension pain | Repetitive hyperextension sport | Spondylolysis | Osteoid osteoma (night pain relieved by aspirin or NSAIDs) |
| Older smoker, deep constant back and abdominal pain | Not changed by movement, vascular risk | Abdominal aortic aneurysm | Pancreatic cancer, retroperitoneal disease |
| Thoracic pain with night pain and weight loss | Nonmechanical, constitutional symptoms | Metastatic disease or myeloma | Infection; aortic disease |
| Fever, constant back pain, injection drug use | Infectious risk factors | Vertebral osteomyelitis or epidural abscess | Endocarditis with septic emboli |
| Flank pain to groin, restless, hematuria | Colicky, cannot get comfortable | Ureteral calculus | AAA (can mimic renal colic in older men) |
| Neck pain, clumsy hands, unsteady gait | Bilateral, upper motor neuron symptoms | Cervical spondylotic myelopathy | Multiple sclerosis, cord tumor |
| Arm pain into thumb, worse with neck extension | Dermatomal, positional | C6 radiculopathy | Pancoast tumor (smoker, C8 to T1, Horner) |
| Widespread pain, fatigue, poor sleep, tender points | Diffuse, nonanatomical, chronic | Fibromyalgia | Hypothyroidism, polymyalgia rheumatica, inflammatory arthritis |
Radicular, referred and central patterns
Separating the distribution of pain is the second branch point. Somatic referred pain arises from a spinal structure (facet joint, disc, sacroiliac joint, muscle) and is felt as a deep, diffuse, poorly localized ache in the same segmental territory, usually not below the knee in the lower limb or below the elbow in the upper. Radicular pain arises from an irritated nerve root and is sharp, shooting or burning, felt in a narrow band, often extends below the knee into the foot, and is usually worse in the limb than in the back. Radiculopathy is the objective loss of root function (dermatomal sensory loss, myotomal weakness, reduced reflex). Myelopathy is cord compression with bilateral symptoms, clumsy hands, gait disturbance and upper motor neuron signs. Visceral referred pain follows the dermatomes of the organ's sympathetic afferents (heart to T1 to T4 and the left arm; gallbladder to the right scapula; kidney to the flank and groin; pancreas to the upper lumbar region). Nociplastic pain (central sensitization) is widespread, disproportionate, with allodynia and hyperalgesia.
Avoiding cognitive traps
- Anchoring: locking onto the first impression (the patient said "I pulled something") and discounting later contradicting facts (weight loss, night pain).
- Premature closure: stopping the search once one plausible diagnosis is found. A disc herniation and a prostate cancer metastasis can coexist.
- Availability bias: overweighting diagnoses seen recently or vividly.
- Confirmation bias: asking only questions that support the favored hypothesis. Deliberately ask a question that would disprove it.
Reasoning: The patient's anchor is gardening, but the history is nonmechanical: constant pain unchanged by position, night pain, weight loss, age over 50 and heavy smoking. The leading considerations are metastatic disease (lung, prostate), multiple myeloma and an abdominal aortic aneurysm, with pancreatic cancer also possible. Before examining, the history already demands abdominal palpation for a pulsatile mass, a neurological screen, radiographs, and laboratory tests (CBC, ESR or CRP, calcium, alkaline phosphatase, PSA, serum protein electrophoresis) or prompt medical referral. Manipulation is deferred until serious disease is excluded.
Reasoning: Colicky pain radiating from flank to groin, restlessness, nausea and hematuria, unaffected by spinal movement, point to a right ureteral calculus. Ask about fever and dysuria (an infected obstructed kidney is an emergency) and the last menstrual period (ectopic pregnancy is the must not miss alternative in a woman of reproductive age). Refer the same day for urinalysis, pregnancy test and imaging; this is not a chiropractic lesion.
A good history yields a ranked differential before the examination begins: a leading diagnosis from pattern recognition, a must not miss alternative from red flags, and the specific examination findings that will separate them. Mechanical versus nonmechanical behavior and radicular versus referred distribution are the two most useful branch points, and pretest probability decides how hard to look.
Section 5Communication, special populations and documentation of the history
Asking questions well
Begin with open ended questions ("Tell me about the pain," "What brings you in today?") and allow the patient to speak without interruption for the first minute or two; most patients finish their opening statement in under two minutes, and interrupting early loses information. Then narrow with focused questions ("Where exactly does it go?") and finish with closed questions that confirm or exclude specific features ("Any numbness between your legs?"). Avoid leading questions ("The pain doesn't go down your leg, does it?") and compound questions that ask two things at once. Use facilitation (nodding, "go on"), clarification ("What do you mean by dizzy: is the room spinning, or do you feel faint?"), reflection and summarizing ("Let me check I have this right...") to confirm accuracy. End by asking, "Is there anything else you think I should know?" and "What are you most worried this might be?" The second question often reveals a fear (cancer, paralysis, losing a job) that shapes the patient's recovery.
| Technique | Example | When to use it |
|---|---|---|
| Open ended question | "Tell me about your back." | Opening the history; exploring the patient's perspective |
| Focused question | "What makes the leg pain worse?" | Characterizing a symptom |
| Closed question | "Have you had any fever?" | Red flag screening, ROS, confirming details |
| Clarification | "When you say numb, do you mean you cannot feel touch, or that it tingles?" | Vague or ambiguous terms (dizzy, numb, weak) |
| Summarizing | "So the pain started after lifting, goes to your left foot and is worse sitting?" | Checking accuracy and showing you listened |
| Empathic statement | "That sounds very frightening." | Emotional content; builds trust and disclosure |
| Leading question (avoid) | "You haven't had any bladder trouble, have you?" | Never: it invites the answer you suggested |
Clarifying vague terms
Patients use words that mean different things to different people. Dizziness may be vertigo (a spinning illusion, vestibular or brainstem), presyncope (near fainting, cardiovascular or orthostatic), disequilibrium (unsteadiness on the feet, neurologic or proprioceptive) or vague lightheadedness (often anxiety or medication). Numbness may mean loss of sensation, tingling or a feeling of heaviness. Weakness may mean true loss of strength, fatigue or pain inhibition.
Special populations
| Population | Adaptations to the history | Diagnoses to keep in mind |
|---|---|---|
| Infants and young children | History from the parent or caregiver; birth history, milestones, feeding, sleep; ask the child directly when old enough; watch for inconsistent stories | Infection, leukemia, neuroblastoma, discitis (refusal to walk), nonaccidental injury; back pain under 10 years is rarely mechanical |
| Adolescents | Interview partly without the parent where appropriate; sport, growth spurt, school, mood | Spondylolysis, Scheuermann disease, scoliosis, slipped capital femoral epiphysis (knee or groin pain), osteoid osteoma, Ewing sarcoma, osteosarcoma |
| Older adults | Allow more time; check hearing and vision; involve family with consent; full medication list (polypharmacy); falls history; cognitive screen if memory is uncertain | Osteoporotic fracture, malignancy, stenosis, AAA, polymyalgia rheumatica, giant cell arteritis, elder abuse |
| Pregnant patients | Gestational age, obstetric history, complications; ask about bleeding, contractions, fluid leakage, headache and visual change | Pregnancy related pelvic girdle pain; must not miss preterm labor, placental abruption, preeclampsia (headache, epigastric pain, visual change, edema), DVT, pyelonephritis |
| Non-English speaking | Use a trained medical interpreter (in person, phone or video); speak to the patient, not the interpreter; short sentences; confirm understanding with teach back; document the interpreter's name or ID | Missed red flags from miscommunication; cultural differences in describing pain |
| Hearing impaired | Face the patient, good lighting, written questions, sign language interpreter | As for the general population |
| Cognitive impairment | Simple questions, caregiver input, observe behavior (grimacing, guarding) as pain indicators | Delirium from infection or medication; occult fracture after falls |
Interpreters
Family members, and especially children, should not interpret a clinical history except in an emergency: they may filter or omit sensitive information (bladder, sexual or abuse history), lack medical vocabulary and compromise confidentiality. A trained medical interpreter translates exactly and keeps confidentiality. Speak in the first person directly to the patient, and document the language and the interpreter's name or ID, using the same approach for informed consent.
The pregnant patient
Low back and pelvic girdle pain affect more than half of pregnant women, and most is mechanical, related to relaxin mediated ligamentous laxity, weight gain, an anterior shift of the center of gravity and increased lumbar lordosis. The history must still screen for obstetric emergencies. Rhythmic low back pain that comes and goes with tightening of the abdomen may be preterm labor. Vaginal bleeding with constant abdominal or back pain and a rigid uterus suggests placental abruption. Headache, visual disturbance, right upper quadrant or epigastric pain and sudden swelling after 20 weeks suggest preeclampsia; check blood pressure. Fever with flank pain suggests pyelonephritis, which is more common in pregnancy. Unilateral calf pain and swelling suggests DVT, whose risk is several times higher in pregnancy and the postpartum period. In the first trimester, unilateral pelvic pain with spotting raises ectopic pregnancy.
Documenting the history in a defensible record
The record is a clinical, legal and billing document. It must allow another clinician to understand what you found, what you thought and why you did what you did. A defensible history has these features:
- Legible, dated and signed (or authenticated in the electronic record), written at the time of the visit or promptly after.
- Chief complaint in the patient's words with duration; HPI with each OPQRST element; mechanism of injury with specific details (for a collision: direction, speed estimate, seat belt, head position, onset of symptoms).
- Pertinent negatives: "Denies saddle anesthesia, bladder or bowel dysfunction, fever, weight loss, night pain." If it is not written, a reviewer will assume it was not asked.
- Baseline functional status and outcome measures (pain scale, Oswestry or Neck Disability Index, activities the patient cannot do) and the patient's goals, which justify the plan and later demonstrate medical necessity.
- Medications and allergies and relevant comorbidities that modify care.
- Objective, nonjudgmental language: record what the patient said in quotation marks rather than labels such as "malingerer" or "drug seeker."
- Corrections made by a single line through the original entry with the date, time and initials, never by obliterating or rewriting; late entries labeled as such with the current date. Altering a record after a complaint or claim is one of the most damaging things a clinician can do.
- Communication with others (phone calls, referrals, advice to go to the emergency department, refusals) with time and content.
Reasoning: Rhythmic back pain with uterine tightening and possible rupture of membranes at 28 weeks is preterm labor until proven otherwise. The correct action is immediate referral to labor and delivery (or emergency services), not treatment of the back. Document the time, symptoms, the advice given and the patient's response. The lesson is that pregnancy related mechanical pain is a diagnosis made only after the obstetric red flags have been asked about.
Good communication produces better histories: open questions first, then focused and closed questions, with vague words clarified and no leading questions. Adapt the history to children, older adults, pregnant patients and patients who need an interpreter, and document it so that another clinician, a reviewer or a court can see what was asked, what was found and why the plan followed.
The chapter in one breath
- The history makes most diagnoses; it sorts patients into serious pathology, radicular syndrome and nonspecific mechanical pain.
- OPQRST and OLDCARTS organize the HPI; onset and mechanism of injury predict the injured tissue and the risk of fracture.
- Flexion intolerance with cough aggravation suggests disc; extension intolerance suggests facet or stenosis; relief by sitting and bending forward is neurogenic claudication.
- Background history sets pretest probability: prior cancer (LR+ about 15), steroids, anticoagulants, injection drug use, smoking and family history of spondyloarthritis or aneurysm all reshape the differential.
- The review of systems uncovers systemic and visceral disease; visceral pain does not behave mechanically and relates to organ function.
- Ask every spinal patient the red flag questions for cancer, infection, fracture, cauda equina syndrome (urinary retention, saddle numbness) and vascular disease, and document the negatives.
- Before neck care, screen for cervical artery dissection: sudden unusual neck pain or headache and the 5 Ds and 3 Ns.
- Yellow flags (fear avoidance, catastrophizing, low mood, work and compensation issues) predict chronicity; screen with tools such as STarT Back.
- The two key branch points are mechanical versus nonmechanical behavior and radicular versus somatic referred distribution.
- Guard against anchoring, premature closure and confirmation bias by always naming a must not miss alternative.
- Use open questions first, clarify vague terms, avoid leading questions, and use a trained medical interpreter, never a child.
- A defensible record is contemporaneous, includes pertinent negatives and baseline outcome measures, and is corrected only by a single line with date and initials.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Chief complaint | The main reason for the visit, recorded in the patient's own words with its duration. |
| History of present illness | The detailed chronological account of the current complaint, usually organized with OPQRST or OLDCARTS. |
| OPQRST | Mnemonic for the HPI: onset, provocation and palliation, quality, region and radiation, severity, timing. |
| Mechanism of injury | The forces, direction and body position involved in an injury; it predicts which tissue failed. |
| Review of systems | A structured inventory of symptoms in each body system to uncover problems the patient has not mentioned. |
| Pertinent negative | The documented absence of a symptom that would have changed the diagnosis or plan, such as no saddle numbness. |
| Red flag | A history or examination feature that raises the probability of serious disease such as cancer, infection or fracture. |
| Yellow flag | A psychosocial factor, such as fear avoidance or low mood, that predicts persistent pain and disability. |
| Cauda equina syndrome | Compression of multiple lumbosacral roots causing urinary retention, saddle anesthesia, bowel and sexual dysfunction and leg weakness; a surgical emergency. |
| Mechanical pain | Pain that varies with posture, movement and load and has a position of relief. |
| Nonmechanical pain | Constant or progressive pain unaffected by position, often worse at night, suggesting systemic or visceral disease. |
| Inflammatory back pain | Back pain with onset before 40, insidious onset, improvement with exercise, no improvement with rest and night pain; typical of axial spondyloarthritis. |
| Somatic referred pain | Deep, diffuse pain felt away from a spinal source such as a facet or sacroiliac joint, usually not below the knee, without neurological deficit. |
| Radicular pain | Sharp, shooting pain in a narrow band from an irritated nerve root, often extending below the knee or elbow. |
| Radiculopathy | Objective loss of nerve root function: dermatomal sensory loss, myotomal weakness or reduced reflex. |
| Myelopathy | Spinal cord dysfunction from compression, with bilateral symptoms, clumsy hands, gait change and upper motor neuron signs. |
| Neurogenic claudication | Buttock and leg pain or heaviness on walking from lumbar stenosis, relieved by sitting or bending forward. |
| Vascular claudication | Exercise induced calf or buttock pain from arterial insufficiency, relieved by simply standing still. |
| Pretest probability | The probability that a patient has a condition before a particular test or finding is considered. |
| Likelihood ratio | How much a finding changes the odds of a diagnosis; above 10 or below 0.1 is a large, often decisive shift. |
| SnNout and SpPin | A negative result on a highly sensitive test helps rule out; a positive result on a highly specific test helps rule in. |
| Anchoring | A cognitive bias of holding onto the first impression despite later contradictory information. |
| 5 Ds and 3 Ns | Brainstem warning symptoms: dizziness, diplopia, dysarthria, dysphagia, drop attacks, ataxia, nausea, nystagmus, numbness. |
| Fear avoidance | The belief that activity will cause harm, leading to avoidance, deconditioning and disability. |
| STarT Back tool | A nine item questionnaire that stratifies low back pain patients into low, medium or high risk of a poor outcome. |
Check yourself
The General Physical Examination
A chiropractor is a portal of entry provider, which means you may be the first clinician to see a patient whose back pain is really an aneurysm, whose neck pain is a thyroid mass, or whose headache is a blood pressure of 210 over 125. Part III cases routinely slip a single abnormal vital sign or physical finding into a musculoskeletal story and ask what it means and what you should do next. This chapter teaches the general physical examination as a set of decisions: what to look for, what is abnormal, and how each finding changes management.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Perform a general survey and interpret BMI, blood pressure, pulse, respiration, temperature and oxygen saturation, including the values that require same day or emergency action.
- Measure blood pressure correctly and classify it, and recognize orthostatic hypotension and a significant interarm difference.
- Examine the eyes, ears, nose, throat, lymph nodes, thyroid and carotids, and interpret Weber and Rinne tests.
- Use inspection, palpation, percussion and auscultation of the chest to distinguish consolidation, effusion, pneumothorax and obstructive disease.
- Identify normal and extra heart sounds, the classic murmurs, an elevated JVP, and grade peripheral pulses.
- Calculate and interpret the ankle brachial index and separate vascular from neurogenic claudication.
- Recognize suspicious breast and axillary findings and the abdominal findings of AAA, organomegaly and the classic special signs (Murphy, McBurney, psoas, Cullen, Grey Turner).
- Interpret hernia, testicular, prostate and rectal tone findings, including saddle sensation and the anal wink.
- Integrate physical findings into a problem list and decide whether to treat, co-manage or refer, and how urgently.
Section 1General survey and vital signs in the case
The general survey
The general survey begins as the patient walks in. Note apparent age versus stated age, level of distress (calm, guarding, writhing, unable to sit), body habitus (cachexia, obesity, central adiposity), posture and movement, skin color (pallor, cyanosis, jaundice, flushing), hygiene and dress, speech, affect and alertness. A patient lying perfectly still because any movement hurts suggests peritonitis; a patient who cannot find a comfortable position suggests renal or biliary colic. A patient leaning forward to ease epigastric pain suggests pancreatitis, while leaning forward to ease leg symptoms on walking suggests stenosis. Cachexia with temporal wasting suggests cancer or chronic disease. Jaundice points to liver or biliary disease; pallor to anemia; a malar rash to lupus; a moon face, central obesity and purple striae to Cushing syndrome; a tall slender build with long limbs to Marfan syndrome (aortic root dilation and dissection risk).
Body mass index and anthropometrics
BMI is weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared. Waist circumference adds information about visceral fat and cardiometabolic risk. Unexplained weight loss of more than about 5 percent of body weight over 6 to 12 months is a red flag for cancer, infection, endocrine disease or depression.
| Measure | Category | Clinical meaning |
|---|---|---|
| BMI under 18.5 | Underweight | Malnutrition, eating disorder, malignancy; low bone density and stress fracture risk |
| BMI 18.5 to 24.9 | Normal | Reference range |
| BMI 25 to 29.9 | Overweight | Higher risk of osteoarthritis of weight bearing joints and of low back pain |
| BMI 30 and above (class 3 at 40 and above) | Obese | Diabetes, hypertension, sleep apnea, knee osteoarthritis; table and technique modification |
| Waist over 102 cm (40 in) in men, over 88 cm (35 in) in women | Central obesity | Metabolic syndrome, cardiovascular risk |
Blood pressure: technique
Measurement errors routinely move blood pressure by 10 mmHg or more, so technique is tested. The patient avoids caffeine, exercise and smoking for 30 minutes, empties the bladder, and sits quietly for 5 minutes with the back supported, feet flat and legs uncrossed. The arm is bare, supported at heart level. The cuff bladder should encircle about 80 percent of the arm circumference and its width should be about 40 percent; a cuff that is too small reads falsely high, one that is too large reads falsely low. Estimate the systolic pressure by palpating the radial pulse as the cuff inflates, then inflate 20 to 30 mmHg above that point to avoid missing an auscultatory gap, and deflate at 2 to 3 mmHg per second. Systolic pressure is the first Korotkoff sound (phase I); diastolic is disappearance (phase V). Take two or more readings and average them, and at the first visit measure both arms, using the higher arm thereafter.
| Adult category | Systolic (mmHg) | Diastolic (mmHg) | Action in a chiropractic office | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normal | Under 120 | and | Under 80 | Recheck at routine intervals |
| Elevated | 120 to 129 | and | Under 80 | Lifestyle advice |
| Stage 1 hypertension | 130 to 139 | or | 80 to 89 | Lifestyle advice; recheck; inform primary care |
| Stage 2 hypertension | 140 or higher | or | 90 or higher | Confirm on repeat; refer to primary care for evaluation |
| Severe (hypertensive urgency) | Over 180 | and/or | Over 120 | No target organ symptoms: same day or next day medical contact; defer vigorous treatment |
| Hypertensive emergency | Over 180 | and/or | Over 120 | With chest pain, dyspnea, severe headache, confusion, visual loss or neurological deficit: call emergency services |
Special blood pressure findings
- Interarm difference above about 15 to 20 mmHg systolic suggests subclavian artery stenosis (subclavian steal), aortic dissection (with tearing pain) or coarctation. A consistent difference over 10 mmHg is also a marker of cardiovascular risk.
- Orthostatic hypotension is a fall of at least 20 mmHg systolic or 10 mmHg diastolic within 3 minutes of standing. Causes include dehydration, blood loss, antihypertensives and diuretics, autonomic neuropathy (diabetes, Parkinson disease) and prolonged bed rest. It explains dizziness on rising from the treatment table and is a fall risk.
- Leg pressures are normally equal to or slightly higher than arm pressures. Lower leg than arm pressure in a young hypertensive patient suggests coarctation of the aorta (with radiofemoral delay and rib notching on chest radiographs).
- Wide pulse pressure (systolic minus diastolic, normally about 40) occurs in aortic regurgitation, hyperthyroidism, anemia and stiff arteries of aging. Narrow pulse pressure occurs in aortic stenosis, heart failure, tamponade and shock.
- Pulsus paradoxus, a fall of more than 10 mmHg in systolic pressure on inspiration, suggests cardiac tamponade, severe asthma or COPD exacerbation.
Pulse, respiration, temperature and oxygen saturation
| Vital sign | Adult normal | Abnormal finding | What it suggests and what to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pulse rate | 60 to 100 per minute | Over 100 (tachycardia) | Pain, anxiety, fever, dehydration, anemia, hyperthyroidism, pulmonary embolism, arrhythmia; over 120 at rest or with symptoms needs urgent evaluation |
| Pulse rate | 60 to 100 per minute | Under 60 (bradycardia) | Normal in trained athletes; beta blockers, hypothyroidism, heart block; refer if dizziness or syncope |
| Pulse rhythm | Regular | Irregularly irregular | Atrial fibrillation: stroke risk; check anticoagulation; refer if new |
| Respiratory rate | 12 to 20 per minute | Over 20 (tachypnea) | Pneumonia, pulmonary embolism, heart failure, acidosis, anxiety; over 24 is a marker of serious illness |
| Temperature (oral) | About 36.5 to 37.5 °C (97.7 to 99.5 °F) | 38.0 °C (100.4 °F) or higher | Fever; with back pain think discitis, osteomyelitis, epidural abscess, pyelonephritis |
| Oxygen saturation | 95 to 100 percent | Under 92 percent at rest (88 to 92 target in COPD) | Hypoxemia: pneumonia, embolism, heart failure, COPD; refer urgently if new |
| Pain | None | Numeric rating 0 to 10 | Often called the fifth vital sign; record as a baseline |
Count the radial pulse for 30 seconds and double it if regular, or for a full 60 seconds if irregular, noting rate, rhythm, amplitude and symmetry. Count respirations without telling the patient (for example, while appearing to continue taking the pulse), because awareness changes breathing. Note the breathing pattern: Kussmaul (deep, rapid; metabolic acidosis such as diabetic ketoacidosis), Cheyne Stokes (cycles of crescendo breathing and apnea; heart failure, brain injury) and pursed lip breathing in COPD. Oral temperature is reduced by recent cold drinks and mouth breathing; older adults and immunosuppressed patients may mount little fever despite serious infection.
The sepsis and instability screen
A patient with suspected infection who has two or more of the quick SOFA criteria (respiratory rate 22 or more, altered mentation, systolic blood pressure 100 or less) has a high risk of a poor outcome and needs emergency care. More generally, any combination of hypotension, tachycardia, tachypnea, hypoxemia, fever and confusion signals a physiologically unstable patient who is not a candidate for office treatment that day.
Reasoning: Readings above 180 and/or 120 without symptoms of target organ damage fit severe hypertension (hypertensive urgency). Defer manipulation and vigorous treatment, contact his primary care provider the same day for prompt medication review, and document readings and advice. Had he reported chest pain, dyspnea, confusion, visual loss or focal weakness, this would be a hypertensive emergency requiring emergency services.
The general survey and vital signs are the fastest screen for serious disease. Classify blood pressure on repeated, correctly measured readings and act on symptoms as well as numbers; treat fever, tachycardia, tachypnea, hypoxemia or hypotension in a back pain patient as a sign of systemic illness until proven otherwise.
Section 2Head and neck, thorax and lungs
Eyes
Inspect the lids, conjunctivae and sclerae, then test pupils, extraocular movements, visual fields and, when indicated, the fundus. The findings that matter in a chiropractic case are those that indicate neurological, vascular or systemic disease.
| Finding | What it suggests | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Ptosis, miosis and facial anhidrosis on one side (Horner syndrome) | Interrupted sympathetic chain: carotid dissection, Pancoast tumor, brainstem lesion | With neck pain or headache: emergency referral; in a smoker with shoulder pain: chest imaging |
| Dilated pupil that reacts poorly, with ptosis and eye down and out | Oculomotor (CN III) palsy; compressive (posterior communicating artery aneurysm) if pupil involved | Emergency referral |
| Papilledema (blurred disc margins, swollen disc) | Raised intracranial pressure: tumor, hemorrhage, idiopathic intracranial hypertension | Urgent referral |
| Arteriovenous nicking, copper wiring, flame hemorrhages | Hypertensive retinopathy | Blood pressure control; flame hemorrhages with papilledema indicate malignant hypertension |
| Red painful eye with photophobia and small pupil | Anterior uveitis (spondyloarthritis, sarcoidosis) | Same day eye care |
| Yellow sclerae | Jaundice: hepatitis, biliary obstruction, hemolysis | Medical referral; with weight loss and back pain think pancreatic cancer |
| Exophthalmos, lid lag | Graves disease (hyperthyroidism) | Thyroid testing and referral |
| Nystagmus | Vestibular or cerebellar disease; brainstem ischemia if with other 5 Ds and 3 Ns | Characterize; vertical or direction changing nystagmus suggests central cause |
| Blue sclerae | Osteogenesis imperfecta | Avoid forceful thrust; fracture risk |
Ears, nose and throat
Otoscopy shows a pearly gray tympanic membrane with a cone of light in the anteroinferior quadrant; a red, bulging membrane indicates acute otitis media, and a retracted membrane suggests eustachian tube dysfunction. Hearing is screened with the whispered voice test, then characterized with a 512 Hz tuning fork. In the Weber test, the vibrating fork is placed on the vertex; normally sound is heard equally in both ears. In the Rinne test, the fork is placed on the mastoid until the sound fades, then held beside the ear; normally air conduction is heard longer than bone conduction (a "positive" Rinne).
| Hearing loss type | Weber | Rinne on affected side | Causes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conductive | Lateralizes to the affected ear | Bone conduction longer than air conduction (negative) | Cerumen, otitis media, perforation, otosclerosis |
| Sensorineural | Lateralizes to the unaffected ear | Air longer than bone (positive), both reduced | Presbycusis, noise, Meniere disease, acoustic neuroma, ototoxic drugs |
Unilateral sensorineural hearing loss with tinnitus and imbalance suggests an acoustic neuroma (vestibular schwannoma) and needs MRI. Sudden sensorineural hearing loss is an emergency for steroid treatment within days. In the nose, note septal deviation, polyps and bleeding; in the mouth and throat, look for tonsillar exudate, dental abscess (a cause of jaw and neck pain), leukoplakia and nonhealing ulcers (oral cancer in smokers and drinkers).
Lymph nodes
Palpate the cervical chains systematically: preauricular, postauricular, occipital, submental, submandibular, tonsillar, anterior and posterior cervical, and supraclavicular. Describe each node by size, consistency, tenderness, mobility and whether it is matted. Small (under 1 cm), soft, mobile, tender nodes are usually reactive to infection. Hard, rubbery or fixed, nontender nodes over about 1.5 to 2 cm, nodes that persist beyond 2 to 4 weeks, and any supraclavicular node are suspicious for malignancy. A left supraclavicular node (Virchow node) suggests abdominal malignancy, especially gastric cancer; a right supraclavicular node suggests lung, mediastinal or esophageal cancer. Rubbery, painless nodes with fever, night sweats and weight loss suggest lymphoma.
Thyroid and carotids
Examine the thyroid from behind with the neck slightly flexed, asking the patient to swallow; the gland moves upward with swallowing. A diffusely enlarged gland (goiter) may be hyper or hypothyroid; a single hard nodule, fixation, hoarseness or associated nodes raise suspicion of cancer. Look for systemic signs: hyperthyroidism (tachycardia, atrial fibrillation, fine tremor, warm moist skin, weight loss, proximal weakness, exophthalmos) and hypothyroidism (bradycardia, dry skin, weight gain, delayed relaxation phase of reflexes, carpal tunnel syndrome, myalgia and fatigue). Hypothyroidism is a treatable cause of diffuse muscle pain and carpal tunnel syndrome.
Palpate each carotid separately (never both at once, and gently in older patients because of the carotid sinus reflex) and auscultate with the bell for a bruit, a whooshing sound from turbulent flow that suggests stenosis. An asymptomatic carotid bruit is a marker of atherosclerosis; a bruit with transient ischemic attack symptoms (transient monocular blindness, called amaurosis fugax, hemiparesis, aphasia) requires urgent referral. A murmur from aortic stenosis can radiate to the carotids and must be distinguished.
Thorax and lungs
Examine the chest in the order inspection, palpation, percussion, auscultation. Inspect for shape (barrel chest in emphysema with an increased anteroposterior diameter; pectus excavatum and carinatum; kyphoscoliosis restricting ventilation), use of accessory muscles, intercostal retraction, and symmetry of expansion. Palpate for tenderness, crepitus and tactile fremitus (vibration felt as the patient says "ninety nine"), which is increased over consolidation and decreased over fluid or air. Measure chest expansion at the fourth intercostal space; less than about 2.5 cm suggests restriction (ankylosing spondylitis, chronic lung disease). Percuss comparing side to side: resonance is normal over lung, dullness indicates consolidation or effusion (stony dull), and hyperresonance indicates air (pneumothorax, emphysema). Auscultate with the diaphragm comparing side to side.
| Condition | Percussion | Fremitus | Breath sounds | Added sounds, trachea |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Consolidation (pneumonia) | Dull | Increased | Bronchial | Crackles; egophony (E to A), whispered pectoriloquy; trachea midline |
| Pleural effusion | Stony dull | Decreased | Decreased or absent | Large effusion pushes trachea away |
| Pneumothorax | Hyperresonant | Decreased | Decreased or absent | Tension pneumothorax pushes trachea away, with hypotension |
| Emphysema (COPD) | Hyperresonant | Decreased | Decreased, prolonged expiration | Wheezes; barrel chest |
| Asthma | Normal or hyperresonant | Normal or decreased | Prolonged expiration | Expiratory wheezes |
| Atelectasis (lobar collapse) | Dull | Decreased | Decreased | Trachea pulled toward the affected side |
| Heart failure | Normal or dull at bases | Normal | Normal | Bibasilar crackles; S3; raised JVP |
| Pulmonary fibrosis | Normal | Normal or increased | Normal | Fine end inspiratory "velcro" crackles; clubbing |
Adventitious sounds: crackles (discontinuous; fluid or reopening airways in pneumonia, heart failure, fibrosis), wheezes (continuous, musical; narrowed airways in asthma and COPD), rhonchi (low pitched, clear with coughing; secretions), stridor (inspiratory, high pitched, over the neck; upper airway obstruction, an emergency) and pleural friction rub (creaking with breathing, localized; pleurisy, pulmonary infarction). Pleuritic chest pain that changes with breathing can mimic a rib or costovertebral lesion, so ask whether it also changes with trunk movement and whether there is fever, cough or dyspnea.
Reasoning: C8 to T1 pain and sensory change plus Horner syndrome in a heavy smoker with weight loss is the classic picture of a Pancoast (superior sulcus) tumor of the lung apex invading the lower brachial plexus and the cervical sympathetic chain. The next step is chest imaging (radiograph with apical views, then CT) and prompt medical referral, not treatment of the shoulder or cervical spine. A thoracic outlet syndrome or C8 radiculopathy would not explain the Horner syndrome or weight loss.
Head, neck and chest findings point beyond the spine: Horner syndrome, a hard fixed or supraclavicular node, a thyroid nodule, a carotid bruit or an asymmetric lung finding each raises a diagnosis that manual care will not address. Know the patterns and the urgency, and refer accordingly.
Section 3Cardiovascular and peripheral vascular examination
Inspection and palpation of the precordium
With the patient supine and the trunk raised about 30 to 45 degrees, inspect for visible pulsations and palpate the point of maximal impulse (PMI), normally a dime sized tap in the left fifth intercostal space at the midclavicular line. A PMI displaced laterally and downward, or larger than about 2.5 cm, suggests left ventricular enlargement (dilated cardiomyopathy, chronic regurgitation); a sustained, forceful PMI suggests left ventricular hypertrophy (hypertension, aortic stenosis). A thrill (palpable vibration) accompanies loud murmurs of grade 4 or higher.
Auscultation areas and normal heart sounds
Listen with the diaphragm (high pitched sounds: S1, S2, regurgitant murmurs, rubs) and the bell (low pitched sounds: S3, S4, the rumble of mitral stenosis) in each area. S1 is closure of the mitral and tricuspid valves at the start of systole, loudest at the apex. S2 is closure of the aortic and pulmonic valves at the end of systole, loudest at the base. On inspiration, increased venous return to the right heart delays pulmonic closure and S2 splits physiologically; a fixed split that does not vary with respiration suggests an atrial septal defect, and a paradoxical split (widening on expiration) suggests left bundle branch block or severe aortic stenosis.
Extra heart sounds
An S3 (ventricular gallop, "Ken-tuc-ky") occurs in early diastole as blood fills a volume overloaded ventricle. It is normal in children, young athletes and pregnancy but in an adult over about 40 suggests heart failure or severe regurgitation. An S4 (atrial gallop, "Ten-nes-see") occurs in late diastole as the atrium contracts against a stiff ventricle (hypertension, left ventricular hypertrophy, ischemia, aortic stenosis); it is absent in atrial fibrillation. A pericardial friction rub is a scratchy, three component sound heard best with the patient leaning forward; with sharp chest pain eased by sitting up and leaning forward, it indicates pericarditis. An opening snap in early diastole indicates mitral stenosis, and a midsystolic click indicates mitral valve prolapse.
Murmurs
Describe a murmur by timing (systolic or diastolic), location, radiation, intensity, pitch, shape and response to maneuvers. Intensity is graded 1 to 6: grade 1 is barely audible; grade 3 is moderately loud without a thrill; grade 4 has a thrill; grade 6 is audible with the stethoscope just off the chest. Diastolic murmurs are always pathological and require referral. Soft, short midsystolic murmurs (grade 1 to 2) without other findings are often innocent flow murmurs, particularly in children, pregnancy, fever and anemia.
| Lesion | Murmur | Best heard and radiation | Clinical clues |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aortic stenosis | Midsystolic crescendo decrescendo, harsh | Right second ICS, radiates to the carotids | Older adult or bicuspid valve; angina, syncope and dyspnea on exertion; slow rising, weak carotid pulse (pulsus parvus et tardus) |
| Mitral regurgitation | Holosystolic, blowing | Apex, radiates to the left axilla | Dyspnea, atrial fibrillation; after MI or with MVP |
| Mitral valve prolapse | Midsystolic click then late systolic murmur | Apex | Young women; Marfan and Ehlers Danlos syndromes; click moves earlier on standing |
| Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy | Midsystolic crescendo decrescendo | Left sternal border; does not radiate to carotids | Louder with Valsalva and standing, softer with squatting; syncope; leading cause of sudden death in young athletes |
| Aortic regurgitation | Early diastolic decrescendo, blowing | Left sternal border, leaning forward in expiration | Wide pulse pressure, bounding (water hammer) pulse; associated with ankylosing spondylitis, Marfan syndrome, syphilis |
| Mitral stenosis | Opening snap then low pitched diastolic rumble | Apex with the bell, left lateral decubitus | Rheumatic heart disease; atrial fibrillation and embolic stroke |
Most murmurs from the right side of the heart get louder with inspiration and most from the left side get louder with expiration. The two murmurs that get louder with Valsalva and standing (which reduce preload) are hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and mitral valve prolapse; nearly all others get softer.
Jugular venous pressure
With the patient reclined at about 45 degrees and the head turned slightly left, identify the highest point of pulsation of the right internal jugular vein. Its vertical height above the sternal angle is normally 3 cm or less (the right atrium lies about 5 cm below the sternal angle, so this corresponds to about 8 cm of water). An elevated JVP indicates raised right atrial pressure: right heart failure, fluid overload, tricuspid disease, pericardial tamponade or constriction, or superior vena cava obstruction. The hepatojugular (abdominojugular) reflux test applies firm pressure over the abdomen for 10 seconds; a sustained rise in the JVP of more than 3 cm supports heart failure. Unlike the carotid pulse, the jugular pulse is not palpable, has a double waveform, is obliterated by light pressure above the clavicle, and changes with position and respiration.
Peripheral pulses and the vascular examination of the limbs
Palpate the carotid, brachial, radial, ulnar, femoral, popliteal, dorsalis pedis (lateral to the extensor hallucis longus tendon on the dorsum) and posterior tibial (behind the medial malleolus) pulses, comparing sides. Grade amplitude on a 0 to 4 scale: 0 absent, 1+ diminished, 2+ normal, 3+ increased, 4+ bounding. An isolated absent dorsalis pedis with a normal posterior tibial pulse may be a congenital variant. Auscultate for bruits over the abdominal aorta, renal, iliac and femoral arteries. Examine the skin for signs of chronic arterial insufficiency (cool, shiny, hairless skin, thickened nails, pallor on elevation, dependent rubor, delayed capillary refill over about 2 seconds, painful punched out ulcers on the toes and heels) and venous insufficiency (edema, brown hemosiderin staining, stasis dermatitis, varicose veins, shallow painless ulcers near the medial malleolus).
The ankle brachial index
The ankle brachial index (ABI) is measured with a handheld Doppler and a blood pressure cuff. With the patient supine for 5 to 10 minutes, measure systolic pressure in both brachial arteries and in the dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial arteries of each ankle. For each leg, divide the higher ankle pressure by the higher of the two brachial pressures.
| ABI | Interpretation | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Over 1.40 | Noncompressible, calcified arteries (diabetes, chronic kidney disease) | Result unreliable; toe brachial index or duplex ultrasound |
| 1.00 to 1.40 | Normal | No arterial insufficiency |
| 0.91 to 0.99 | Borderline | Cardiovascular risk review |
| 0.90 or less | Peripheral arterial disease | Refer for vascular evaluation and risk factor management |
| Under about 0.40 (or rest pain, ulcers, gangrene) | Critical limb ischemia | Urgent vascular referral |
Vascular versus neurogenic claudication
| Feature | Vascular claudication | Neurogenic claudication |
|---|---|---|
| Cause | Peripheral arterial disease | Lumbar spinal stenosis |
| Location | Calf most often (buttock and thigh with aortoiliac disease) | Buttock, thigh and leg, often bilateral, in dermatomal or diffuse pattern |
| Quality | Cramping, tightness | Numbness, tingling, weakness, heaviness, pain |
| Trigger | Fixed walking distance; uphill worse | Variable distance; standing alone can trigger; downhill worse |
| Relief | Standing still for 1 to 5 minutes | Sitting or flexing the spine forward; slower relief |
| Cycling | Painful | Usually tolerated (spine flexed) |
| Pulses and skin | Reduced pulses, trophic skin changes, bruits; ABI 0.90 or less | Normal pulses and skin |
| Neurological exam | Normal | May show reduced reflexes or weakness after walking |
Both conditions are common in the same age group and they often coexist, so an older patient with leg symptoms on walking needs both a pulse examination and a neurological examination. Acute limb ischemia (an embolus or thrombosis) presents with the 6 Ps: pain, pallor, pulselessness, paresthesia, paralysis and poikilothermia (a cold limb). It is a vascular emergency, with irreversible damage within about 6 hours.
Reasoning: Reproducible calf cramping relieved by standing, trophic changes, reduced pulses and an ABI of 0.68 establish right peripheral arterial disease. Refer to his primary care provider or a vascular specialist for evaluation and cardiovascular risk management (smoking cessation, statin, antiplatelet therapy, glycemic control); supervised walking exercise is a cornerstone of treatment. This is also a marker of coronary and cerebrovascular disease, so ask about chest pain and transient ischemic attacks.
The cardiovascular examination identifies heart failure (raised JVP, S3, crackles, edema), valvular disease (murmurs and their radiation) and arterial disease (pulses, bruits, ABI). For the chiropractor, its most frequent payoff is separating vascular from neurogenic claudication and recognizing the athlete, the older patient or the smoker whose symptoms are cardiovascular rather than spinal.
Section 4Breast and axilla, abdomen
Breast and axillary examination
Breast examination is performed with consent, a chaperone where appropriate and clear explanation, and within the scope of practice of the jurisdiction. Inspect with the arms at the sides, raised overhead and pressed on the hips, looking for asymmetry, skin dimpling or retraction, peau d'orange (orange peel skin from lymphatic obstruction), nipple inversion of recent onset, nipple discharge (particularly bloody or unilateral), eczematous change of the nipple (Paget disease of the nipple) and redness. Palpate in a systematic vertical strip pattern from the clavicle to the inframammary fold and from the midaxillary line to the sternum, including the axillary tail, with the patient supine and the ipsilateral arm raised. Then palpate the axillary (central, anterior, posterior, lateral), infraclavicular and supraclavicular nodes.
| Finding | Suggests | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Hard, irregular, fixed, nontender mass | Carcinoma | Prompt referral for diagnostic imaging (mammography, ultrasound) and biopsy |
| Smooth, rubbery, very mobile mass in a young woman | Fibroadenoma | Referral for ultrasound; usually benign |
| Tender, cyclic lumpiness | Fibrocystic change | Reassess after menses; image if a dominant lump persists |
| Skin dimpling, peau d'orange, new nipple retraction | Underlying malignancy, inflammatory carcinoma | Urgent referral |
| Bloody or spontaneous unilateral nipple discharge | Intraductal papilloma or carcinoma | Referral |
| Red, hot, tender breast in a lactating woman with fever | Mastitis or abscess | Medical referral for antibiotics |
| Hard, matted or fixed axillary nodes | Metastatic breast cancer, lymphoma | Referral |
| Unilateral firm mass under the areola in a man | Male breast cancer (gynecomastia is usually bilateral and rubbery) | Referral |
Breast cancer is the most common source of skeletal metastasis in women and favors the thoracic spine, ribs, pelvis and proximal femur. A woman with a history of breast cancer, even many years earlier, who develops new constant thoracic pain needs imaging.
The abdominal examination
Position the patient supine with the knees slightly flexed and arms at the sides, and examine in the order inspection, auscultation, percussion, palpation; auscultation comes before palpation so that palpation does not alter bowel sounds. Examine the painful area last.
- Inspection: contour (flat, scaphoid, distended), scars, striae, visible peristalsis, pulsation, hernias (ask the patient to raise the head), dilated veins (caput medusae in portal hypertension), and periumbilical (Cullen) or flank (Grey Turner) ecchymosis.
- Auscultation: bowel sounds are normally present every 5 to 15 seconds. High pitched, tinkling or rushing sounds suggest early obstruction; absent sounds after listening for 2 or more minutes suggest ileus or peritonitis. Listen for bruits over the aorta (midline above the umbilicus), renal arteries (just lateral to the midline above the umbilicus; a renal bruit with resistant hypertension suggests renal artery stenosis), iliac and femoral arteries.
- Percussion: tympany over gas, dullness over solid organs and fluid. The liver span at the right midclavicular line is normally about 6 to 12 cm. Dullness at the lowest left intercostal space in the anterior axillary line (Traube space) on inspiration suggests splenomegaly. Shifting dullness and a fluid wave indicate ascites.
- Palpation: light palpation for tenderness, guarding and superficial masses; deep palpation for organs and deep masses. Note voluntary guarding (reduced with distraction) versus involuntary rigidity (board like abdomen in peritonitis).
Organomegaly and aortic palpation
Palpate the liver edge at the right costal margin during deep inspiration; a smooth, tender edge suggests hepatitis or congestion (heart failure), and a hard, nodular edge suggests cirrhosis or metastases. The normal spleen is not palpable; a palpable spleen is enlarged at least two to three times (infectious mononucleosis, leukemia, lymphoma, portal hypertension). In infectious mononucleosis, splenic rupture can follow minor trauma, so contact sport and forceful abdominal or lower thoracic pressure are avoided for at least 3 to 4 weeks. The kidneys are palpated bimanually; an enlarged kidney suggests polycystic kidney disease, hydronephrosis or tumor.
Palpate the abdominal aorta deeply in the epigastrium, slightly left of the midline, placing a hand on each side of the pulsation. A normal aorta is about 2 cm wide; an expansile (pushing the hands apart, not just upward) pulsatile mass suggests an abdominal aortic aneurysm, defined as a diameter of 3 cm or more. Sensitivity of palpation rises with aneurysm size and falls with obesity, so a normal palpation does not exclude AAA in a high risk patient; ultrasound is the screening test (recommended once for men 65 to 75 who have ever smoked). Risk factors are age over 60, male sex, smoking, hypertension, atherosclerosis and family history. Aneurysms over about 5.5 cm, rapidly enlarging aneurysms and any symptomatic aneurysm need surgical evaluation; a tender aneurysm, or back pain with hypotension, suggests leak or rupture and is an emergency. Avoid deep abdominal pressure, and avoid prone lumbar thrust techniques in a patient with a known or suspected aneurysm until it has been assessed.
Special abdominal signs
| Sign | How elicited | Positive finding | Suggests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Murphy sign | Fingers under the right costal margin at the MCL; patient inhales deeply | Inspiration arrested by pain | Acute cholecystitis |
| McBurney point tenderness | Pressure one third from the right ASIS to the umbilicus | Focal tenderness | Appendicitis |
| Rovsing sign | Pressure in the left lower quadrant | Pain felt in the right lower quadrant | Appendicitis |
| Blumberg sign (rebound tenderness) | Slow deep pressure then sudden release | Pain on release | Peritoneal irritation |
| Psoas sign | Active hip flexion against resistance, or passive hip extension in side lying | Lower quadrant pain | Retrocecal appendicitis, psoas abscess, retroperitoneal hematoma |
| Obturator sign | Passive internal rotation of the flexed right hip | Hypogastric pain | Pelvic appendicitis, pelvic abscess |
| Cullen sign | Inspection | Periumbilical bruising | Retroperitoneal or intraperitoneal hemorrhage: hemorrhagic pancreatitis, ruptured ectopic pregnancy |
| Grey Turner sign | Inspection | Flank bruising | Retroperitoneal hemorrhage: hemorrhagic pancreatitis, ruptured AAA |
| Kehr sign | History or with the patient supine and legs elevated | Left shoulder tip pain | Diaphragmatic irritation from blood: splenic rupture |
| Costovertebral angle (Murphy punch) tenderness | Fist percussion over the angle of the 12th rib and spine | Sharp deep pain | Pyelonephritis, renal calculus, perinephric abscess |
| Carnett sign | Patient tenses the abdominal wall (head and shoulders raised) during palpation | Tenderness unchanged or worse | Abdominal wall source; tenderness that decreases suggests a visceral source |
What abdominal findings mean for the back pain patient
Every patient with thoracolumbar or low back pain that does not behave mechanically deserves an abdominal examination. A pulsatile mass suggests AAA; costovertebral angle tenderness with fever suggests pyelonephritis; epigastric tenderness radiating to the back suggests pancreatitis or a posterior duodenal ulcer; a positive psoas sign with fever and a flexed hip suggests a psoas abscess (often from vertebral osteomyelitis or Crohn disease) that can mimic a hip flexor strain; and a hard, fixed mass or hepatomegaly suggests malignancy. Abdominal wall pain (positive Carnett sign) and costochondral pain are reproduced by palpation and movement, unlike visceral pain.
Reasoning: An expansile, tender pulsatile mass with new back pain in an older male smoker is a symptomatic abdominal aortic aneurysm at risk of rupture. This is an emergency: stop the examination, do not perform any lumbar or abdominal manual therapy, and arrange immediate emergency transfer even though he is hemodynamically stable now. Hypotension, syncope or flank ecchymosis (Grey Turner sign) would indicate rupture.
Breast and abdominal findings frequently explain spinal pain that does not behave mechanically. A hard fixed breast mass or axillary node, an expansile aortic pulsation, costovertebral angle tenderness, organomegaly or a positive peritoneal, psoas or Murphy sign moves the case from manual care to medical evaluation, often urgently.
Section 5Urogenital and rectal findings and putting the exam together
Scope, consent and chaperones
Genital, rectal and breast examinations are sensitive. Whether a chiropractor performs them depends on the law of the jurisdiction, and many practitioners refer them to a medical colleague. Part III expects you to know what the findings mean and when they are needed, particularly for the patient with groin pain, testicular pain or suspected cauda equina syndrome. Whenever such an examination is performed, obtain and document specific informed consent, offer a chaperone, explain each step, provide privacy and draping, and stop if the patient asks.
Hernias
Groin pain in an athlete or laborer may be a hernia rather than an adductor strain or hip lesion. Examine the standing patient, inspecting for a bulge at rest and with coughing or straining. In men, the examining finger invaginates the scrotal skin up to the superficial inguinal ring while the patient coughs.
| Hernia | Anatomy | Typical patient and clue | Concern |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indirect inguinal | Through the deep inguinal ring, lateral to the inferior epigastric vessels, along the inguinal canal; may enter the scrotum | Most common hernia in both sexes; young men; patent processus vaginalis; impulse felt at the fingertip | Incarceration |
| Direct inguinal | Through Hesselbach triangle, medial to the inferior epigastric vessels; rarely enters the scrotum | Older men; weak posterior wall; impulse felt against the pad of the finger | Lower strangulation risk |
| Femoral | Below the inguinal ligament, through the femoral canal medial to the femoral vein | More common in women; bulge in the upper medial thigh | Highest risk of strangulation; refer promptly |
| Sports hernia (athletic pubalgia) | Posterior inguinal wall or adductor and rectus abdominis insertion injury without a true hernia sac | Kicking and cutting athletes; exertional groin pain, tender pubic tubercle, painful resisted sit up | Chronic groin pain; MRI and sports medicine referral |
An incarcerated hernia cannot be reduced; a strangulated hernia has a compromised blood supply and presents with a tense, tender, red bulge, vomiting and signs of bowel obstruction. Strangulation is a surgical emergency.
Testicular and scrotal findings
Scrotal and testicular disease can present as groin, lower abdominal or even low back pain, because the testis is innervated from about T10 to T12 and the scrotum from L1 and the sacral segments. The cremasteric reflex (stroking the upper medial thigh elevates the ipsilateral testis) tests L1 to L2.
| Condition | Key findings | Urgency |
|---|---|---|
| Testicular torsion | Sudden severe pain, often in an adolescent; nausea; high riding testis with a horizontal lie; absent cremasteric reflex; elevation does not relieve pain | Surgical emergency: salvage best within about 6 hours |
| Epididymitis | Gradual pain and swelling behind the testis, fever, dysuria; cremasteric reflex present; pain eased by elevation (positive Prehn sign) | Same day medical treatment (antibiotics) |
| Testicular cancer | Painless, hard mass within the testis; men about 15 to 35; may present with back pain from retroperitoneal (para-aortic) nodes | Prompt referral for ultrasound |
| Hydrocele | Smooth, painless swelling around the testis that transilluminates | Routine; ultrasound if testis cannot be felt |
| Varicocele | "Bag of worms" above the testis, usually left, larger when standing; infertility | Routine; a new right sided or nondecompressing varicocele suggests a retroperitoneal mass |
| Inguinal hernia into scrotum | Swelling above the testis, cannot get above it, cough impulse, does not transilluminate | Routine unless irreducible or tender |
Prostate and rectal examination
The digital rectal examination (DRE) is performed with the patient in the left lateral (Sims) position or bending over the table. It assesses anal sphincter tone at rest and on voluntary squeeze, perianal sensation, rectal masses, and in men the prostate. The normal prostate is about the size of a walnut, rubbery, smooth and nontender with a palpable median sulcus.
| Prostate finding | Suggests | Relevance to the spine |
|---|---|---|
| Symmetrically enlarged, smooth, rubbery, sulcus may be lost | Benign prostatic hyperplasia | Urinary hesitancy and frequency that must be separated from neurogenic bladder |
| Hard, irregular, nodular, sulcus obliterated | Prostate cancer | Osteoblastic metastases to lumbar spine, pelvis and ribs; check PSA and alkaline phosphatase |
| Boggy, warm, exquisitely tender, with fever | Acute bacterial prostatitis | Low back, perineal and suprapubic pain; avoid vigorous massage of the gland; refer |
Rectal tone, saddle sensation and sacral reflexes
When the history raises cauda equina syndrome, the examination must include the sacral segments. Saddle sensation is tested with light touch and pinprick over the perineum, perianal skin, buttocks and posterior upper thighs (S2 to S5 dermatomes); patchy or bilateral loss is significant. The anal wink (superficial anal reflex) is a contraction of the external sphincter when the perianal skin is stroked; it tests S2 to S4. The bulbocavernosus reflex (contraction of the anal sphincter on squeezing the glans or tugging an indwelling catheter) also tests S2 to S4. Reduced resting tone and weak voluntary squeeze on DRE indicate sacral root or conus dysfunction. A post void residual bladder volume over about 100 to 200 mL (by bladder scan or catheter) objectively confirms retention. In a patient with suspected cauda equina syndrome, these findings are obtained in the emergency department as part of the urgent workup; if you cannot perform them, do not delay referral to do so.
Reasoning: Bilateral sciatica, urinary hesitancy and saddle anesthesia with an absent anal wink (S2 to S4) indicate cauda equina syndrome, probably from a massive central herniation. Send her to the emergency department immediately for MRI and surgical decompression; do not treat, do not wait for the next day, and document the time, findings and the instruction given. Outcome depends on decompression before complete retention develops.
Reasoning: Sudden severe pain at rest with vomiting in an adolescent does not fit an adductor strain, and resisted adduction is pain free. The must not miss diagnosis is testicular torsion, which teenage boys often describe as groin or abdominal pain out of embarrassment. Ask directly about scrotal pain and swelling and send him to the emergency department immediately; the testis is often unsalvageable after about 6 hours.
Putting the physical examination together
A complete general examination is not performed on every patient. Instead, choose components by hypothesis: the history determines which systems need examination. Every new patient should have vital signs and a general survey. A patient with thoracic pain needs the chest, heart and abdomen examined if the pain does not behave mechanically. A patient with low back pain and red flags needs the abdomen (aorta, kidneys), pulses, a lymph node survey and a neurological examination including the sacral segments if the history suggests it. A patient with neck pain and headache needs blood pressure, a cranial nerve screen and, in older patients, palpation of the temporal arteries.
After the examination, write a problem list that includes every abnormal finding, not only the chief complaint. For each problem, decide one of three paths: treat (within scope, no contraindication), co-manage (treat the musculoskeletal component while another provider manages the other problem, for example a patient with stage 2 hypertension and mechanical neck pain), or refer, with an urgency that matches the risk.
| Urgency | Examples from the general examination | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Emergency (now) | Hypertensive emergency; tender pulsatile abdominal mass; signs of cauda equina syndrome; acute limb ischemia (6 Ps); testicular torsion; stridor; SpO2 under 90 percent; qSOFA positive with suspected infection; signs of stroke | Call emergency services or send directly to the emergency department; do not treat; document |
| Same day | Fever with back pain and spinal tenderness; costovertebral angle tenderness with fever; asymptomatic BP over 180/120; new irregularly irregular pulse with symptoms; suspected DVT; acute red painful eye | Telephone the primary care provider or urgent care; written referral; defer treatment that could worsen the condition |
| Prompt (days to 2 weeks) | Suspicious lymph node, breast or testicular mass; ABI 0.90 or less; new murmur; thyroid nodule; unexplained weight loss | Written referral with findings; confirm the appointment is made |
| Routine or co-management | Stage 1 or 2 hypertension without symptoms; obesity; stable known conditions | Inform primary care; treat the musculoskeletal problem with appropriate modifications |
Reasoning: Her neck pain is mechanical and treatable, but the examination has found a second problem: hyperthyroidism (probably Graves disease) with atrial fibrillation. Write both on the problem list. Refer her to her primary care provider the same day because new atrial fibrillation with tachycardia needs rate control and stroke risk assessment; gentle care of the neck may continue as co-management once she is medically evaluated. The lesson is that the general examination exists to find the problem the patient did not come in with.
Groin, scrotal and perineal findings can masquerade as musculoskeletal pain, and the sacral examination is the objective core of the cauda equina workup. Choose examination components by hypothesis, list every abnormal finding as a problem, and assign each one to treat, co-manage or refer with the right urgency.
The chapter in one breath
- The general survey (distress, habitus, color, posture) gives diagnostic clues before you touch the patient; stillness suggests peritonitis, restlessness suggests colic.
- Measure blood pressure seated, arm at heart level, correct cuff, two readings, both arms at the first visit; over 180 and/or 120 with symptoms is a hypertensive emergency.
- Orthostatic hypotension is a fall of 20 systolic or 10 diastolic within 3 minutes; an interarm difference over 15 to 20 mmHg suggests subclavian stenosis or dissection.
- Fever of 38.0 °C or more with back pain suggests spinal infection or pyelonephritis; qSOFA (RR 22 or more, altered mentation, SBP 100 or less) flags sepsis.
- Horner syndrome, a hard fixed or supraclavicular node, papilledema and unilateral sensorineural hearing loss all point beyond the spine.
- Weber lateralizes to the bad ear in conductive loss and to the good ear in sensorineural loss.
- Dull with increased fremitus is consolidation; dull with decreased fremitus is effusion; hyperresonance is pneumothorax or emphysema.
- S3 suggests heart failure, S4 a stiff ventricle; aortic stenosis radiates to the carotids, mitral regurgitation to the axilla; HCM gets louder with Valsalva.
- A JVP over 3 cm above the sternal angle indicates raised right atrial pressure.
- ABI of 0.90 or less is peripheral arterial disease; vascular claudication is relieved by standing still, neurogenic claudication by sitting and flexion.
- An expansile pulsatile mass above the umbilicus suggests AAA (3 cm or more); a tender one with back pain is an emergency.
- Saddle anesthesia, absent anal wink and reduced rectal tone confirm cauda equina syndrome; testicular torsion has an absent cremasteric reflex and needs surgery within about 6 hours.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Body mass index | Weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared; 18.5 to 24.9 is normal and 30 or more is obese. |
| Auscultatory gap | A silent interval between systolic and diastolic sounds that can cause systolic pressure to be underestimated if the cuff is not inflated high enough. |
| Hypertensive emergency | Severely elevated blood pressure (over 180 and/or 120) with evidence of acute target organ damage. |
| Orthostatic hypotension | A fall of at least 20 mmHg systolic or 10 mmHg diastolic within 3 minutes of standing. |
| qSOFA | Quick sepsis screen: respiratory rate 22 or more, altered mentation and systolic pressure 100 or less. |
| Horner syndrome | Ptosis, miosis and anhidrosis from interruption of the sympathetic pathway to the face. |
| Papilledema | Swelling of the optic disc caused by raised intracranial pressure. |
| Weber test | Tuning fork on the vertex; sound lateralizes to the ear with conductive loss or away from the ear with sensorineural loss. |
| Rinne test | Compares air and bone conduction; bone longer than air indicates conductive loss in that ear. |
| Virchow node | An enlarged left supraclavicular lymph node, a sign of abdominal, especially gastric, malignancy. |
| Tactile fremitus | Vibration felt on the chest wall during speech; increased over consolidation and decreased over fluid or air. |
| S3 and S4 | Extra diastolic heart sounds: S3 from volume overload (heart failure), S4 from atrial contraction into a stiff ventricle. |
| Jugular venous pressure | Height of the internal jugular pulsation above the sternal angle, normally 3 cm or less, reflecting right atrial pressure. |
| Hepatojugular reflux | A sustained rise in jugular venous pressure with abdominal pressure, supporting heart failure. |
| Ankle brachial index | Ankle systolic pressure divided by brachial systolic pressure; 0.90 or less indicates peripheral arterial disease. |
| Abdominal aortic aneurysm | Dilation of the abdominal aorta to 3 cm or more, usually below the renal arteries. |
| Murphy sign | Arrest of deep inspiration by pain on palpation under the right costal margin, indicating acute cholecystitis. |
| Psoas sign | Lower quadrant pain on resisted hip flexion or passive hip extension, from inflammation next to the psoas. |
| Cullen and Grey Turner signs | Periumbilical and flank bruising, respectively, from retroperitoneal or intraperitoneal hemorrhage. |
| Hesselbach triangle | Area bounded by the inferior epigastric vessels, the lateral border of rectus abdominis and the inguinal ligament, where direct hernias occur. |
| Cremasteric reflex | Elevation of the testis when the upper medial thigh is stroked; tests L1 to L2 and is absent in testicular torsion. |
| Anal wink | Contraction of the external anal sphincter when the perianal skin is stroked; tests S2 to S4. |
| Saddle anesthesia | Loss of sensation over the perineum, buttocks and inner thighs from compression of the S2 to S5 roots. |
Check yourself
The Neuromusculoskeletal Examination of the Spine
On Part III the spinal examination is never asked as a list of eponyms; it arrives as a patient who has already told you a story, and the item asks which test you would do next, what a positive result means, and whether this person can safely be treated. A good spinal examination is short, ordered by hypothesis and honest about what each test can and cannot prove. This chapter works through posture and gait, the cervical, thoracic and lumbopelvic regions, and segmental palpation the way the exam does: one case at a time, from the first clue to a working impression.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Read static posture, perform scoliosis screening with the Adams forward bend test and a scoliometer, and know when a finding needs a radiograph.
- Name the common pathological gaits, the lesion each one predicts, and the next test that confirms it.
- Choose and interpret cervical tests, including Spurling, distraction, shoulder depression, upper limb tension and Lhermitte, and apply the Wainner cluster for radiculopathy.
- Recognize cervical myelopathy and upper cervical instability on examination, and screen the patient for cervical artery dysfunction using history first.
- Examine the thoracic spine and ribs, perform the thoracic outlet tests with an understanding of their false positive rate, and identify red flag thoracic pain.
- Use the straight leg raise family, slump, Kemp and the Laslett sacroiliac cluster, screen the hip, and interpret Waddell nonorganic signs correctly.
- Apply static and motion palpation, classify end feel, and know the reliability of each type of finding.
- Combine findings with the PARTS framework into a defensible segmental diagnosis.
Section 1Posture and gait analysis in cases
Why posture and gait come first
Posture and gait are observed before the patient knows the examination has started: as they rise from the waiting room chair, walk down the hall and undress. That unguarded observation is often more honest than any provoked test. A patient who rises using the arms of the chair, walks with a shortened step and leans forward on the counter has told you about pain behavior, lower limb strength and perhaps lumbar stenosis before a single question about the back. The board uses posture and gait as the first clue in a vignette; your job is to translate the finding into a structure and then pick the test that confirms it.
Static posture
Static posture is assessed from behind, from the side and from the front, ideally against a plumb line or grid. From the side the ideal line falls through the external auditory meatus, the cervical vertebral bodies, the acromion, the lumbar vertebral bodies and the greater trochanter, then slightly anterior to the knee joint axis and slightly anterior to the lateral malleolus. From behind it bisects the occiput, follows the spinous processes and the gluteal cleft, and falls midway between the knees and the heels. Departures are described by region and direction, then explained by a mechanism.
- Anterior head carriage places the ear in front of the acromion. Each 2.5 cm of forward displacement roughly adds the weight of the head again to the load on the posterior cervical muscles, which is why these patients complain of suboccipital tension and headache.
- Upper crossed syndrome (Janda) pairs tight upper trapezius, levator scapulae and pectorals with weak deep neck flexors, lower trapezius and serratus anterior, giving forward head, rounded shoulders and scapular winging.
- Lower crossed syndrome pairs tight hip flexors and thoracolumbar extensors with weak abdominals and gluteus maximus, producing anterior pelvic tilt and increased lumbar lordosis.
- Flat back (loss of lordosis) is common with acute disc pain and protective spasm, and late in degenerative disease or after fusion. Sway back shifts the pelvis forward of the line with the thorax behind it.
- A lateral shift (list) of the trunk over the pelvis in acute low back pain usually reflects a posterolateral disc herniation. By convention the shift is named for the direction the shoulders move. A shift away from the painful side is classically associated with a herniation lateral to the nerve root, and a shift toward the painful side with an axillary (medial) herniation, although the rule is not reliable enough to diagnose from.
- Leg length inequality is measured with a tape. Anatomical (true) length runs from the ASIS to the medial malleolus; apparent (functional) length runs from the umbilicus to the medial malleolus. An unequal apparent length with equal true lengths points to pelvic obliquity, muscle imbalance or a lumbar curve rather than a short bone.
| Posture finding | What it suggests | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| High shoulder, prominent scapula, waist crease asymmetry in an adolescent | Structural scoliosis | Adams forward bend test with a scoliometer |
| Acute lateral trunk shift with sciatica | Posterolateral disc herniation | Neurologic examination of L4 to S1, SLR, slump |
| Rigid thoracic kyphosis in a teenager that does not correct in prone extension | Scheuermann disease | Lateral thoracic radiograph (three or more adjacent wedged vertebrae of 5 degrees or more) |
| Progressive stooped posture, loss of lordosis, young man with morning stiffness | Ankylosing spondylitis | Chest expansion, Schober test, sacroiliac testing, HLA B27 and inflammatory markers |
| New thoracic kyphosis and height loss in an older woman | Osteoporotic compression fractures | Percussion over spinous processes, lateral radiograph, bone density |
| Anterior pelvic tilt with hyperlordosis | Lower crossed pattern, tight hip flexors | Thomas test, gluteal and abdominal strength testing |
| Apparent leg length difference with equal true lengths | Functional inequality from pelvic or muscular cause | Assess pelvis, hip flexor and quadratus lumborum tone, recheck after treatment |
Scoliosis screening
From behind, look for shoulder height difference, scapular prominence, unequal space between the arm and the waist (the waist triangle), and a pelvis that is level with a trunk that is not. The Adams forward bend test separates structural from functional curves: the patient bends forward with knees straight and palms together while the examiner sights along the back from behind or in front. In a structural curve the vertebral bodies rotate toward the convexity, carrying the posterior ribs backward and producing a rib hump on the convex side; the spinous processes rotate toward the concavity. A functional (postural or compensatory) curve, for example from a leg length difference or muscle spasm, straightens or disappears in forward flexion and does not produce a rotational prominence. Seating the patient abolishes a curve caused by a short leg.
A scoliometer laid across the prominence measures the angle of trunk rotation. A reading of 5 degrees is the usual screening threshold and 7 degrees corresponds roughly to a Cobb angle of 20 degrees; at or above 7 degrees most guidelines recommend a standing PA radiograph. The most common pattern is a right thoracic curve in an adolescent girl. A left thoracic curve, a painful curve, rapid progression, or neurologic signs (abnormal abdominal reflexes, clonus, cavus foot) raise concern for an underlying cause such as syringomyelia, tethered cord or osteoid osteoma, and call for MRI and referral.
Reasoning: The rotational prominence on forward bending makes this structural, and 8 degrees exceeds the radiographic threshold. She is premenarchal and therefore near peak growth velocity, the period of greatest progression risk. The next step is a standing PA full spine radiograph for a Cobb angle and Risser grade, with orthopedic referral if the curve is 25 degrees or more in a growing child. Do not simply recheck in a year, and do not attribute the curve to "posture" without imaging.
Gait analysis
The gait cycle runs from initial contact of one heel to the next initial contact of the same heel. Stance occupies about 60 percent of the cycle and swing about 40 percent. Each cycle contains two periods of double limb support, each about 10 percent, which disappear in running. Stance is subdivided into loading response, midstance, terminal stance and preswing; swing into initial swing, midswing and terminal swing. The timing matters because each deviation belongs to a phase: foot slap happens at loading response, a Trendelenburg drop at midstance, toe drag and steppage during swing.
| Gait | What you see | Lesion it predicts | Next test |
|---|---|---|---|
| Antalgic | Shortened stance on the painful limb, quick step off it | Painful hip, knee, foot or radicular pain | Regional orthopedic tests of the painful limb |
| Trendelenburg (gluteus medius) | Pelvis drops on the swing side during stance on the weak side; compensated form leans the trunk over the weak hip | Weak hip abductors: L5 root, superior gluteal nerve, hip OA, coxa vara | Trendelenburg sign, hip abduction strength, L5 myotome |
| Steppage (foot drop) | High knee lift to clear the toe, foot slaps on contact | L5 radiculopathy, common fibular nerve palsy, peripheral neuropathy | Ankle dorsiflexion and great toe extension, hip abduction and foot inversion (spared in fibular palsy) |
| Gluteus maximus (lurching) | Trunk thrown backward at initial contact | Weak hip extensors, inferior gluteal nerve or S1 lesion | Prone hip extension strength |
| Hemiplegic (circumduction) | Stiff extended leg swung outward, arm flexed and held to the chest | Upper motor neuron lesion, stroke | Reflexes, Babinski, cranial nerves, urgent referral if new |
| Spastic, scissoring | Stiff narrow based gait, knees crossing | Bilateral corticospinal disease: cervical myelopathy, cerebral palsy, MS | Hoffmann, Babinski, clonus, Lhermitte |
| Cerebellar ataxic | Wide based, staggering, unable to tandem walk; Romberg not much worse with eyes closed | Cerebellar disease, alcohol, MS, posterior circulation stroke | Finger to nose, heel to shin, dysdiadochokinesia |
| Sensory ataxic (stamping) | Watches the feet, slaps them down; falls with eyes closed | Dorsal column loss: B12 deficiency, tabes dorsalis, severe neuropathy | Romberg (positive), vibration and position sense |
| Parkinsonian (festinating) | Stooped, shuffling, small steps, reduced arm swing, difficulty starting and turning | Parkinson disease, drug induced parkinsonism | Rigidity, resting tremor, bradykinesia testing |
| Waddling | Bilateral trunk sway side to side | Bilateral hip abductor weakness: myopathy, muscular dystrophy, late pregnancy, bilateral hip dysplasia | Proximal strength (Gowers sign in a child), CK |
| Neurogenic claudication posture | Walks flexed forward, leans on a cart, stops to sit | Lumbar spinal stenosis | Bicycle test or two stage treadmill, pedal pulses to exclude vascular claudication |
Reasoning: Steppage with foot slap means weak dorsiflexors. The two classic causes are an L5 radiculopathy and a common fibular nerve palsy at the fibular head, and the leg crossing history makes both plausible. The deciding test is hip abduction and foot inversion: both are L5 functions (gluteus medius and tibialis posterior) that are weak in radiculopathy but normal in fibular palsy, which also spares the back and gives sensory loss limited to the dorsum of the foot and lateral leg with a Tinel sign at the fibular head. A progressive motor deficit of either cause needs prompt referral and electrodiagnostic testing; do not simply treat the back and wait.
Observe posture and gait before you touch the patient, describe the deviation precisely, and convert it to a structure and a level: a rotational prominence means structural scoliosis and possibly a radiograph, a pelvic drop means weak abductors, steppage means weak dorsiflexors, and a spastic or ataxic gait means the problem may be in the cord or brain rather than the low back.
Section 2Cervical examination in cases
Order of the cervical examination
Begin with safety, not provocation. Before any test that loads the neck, the history should already have screened for trauma that needs imaging (Canadian C spine rule or NEXUS criteria), inflammatory arthritis or Down syndrome (upper cervical ligament laxity), symptoms of myelopathy, and symptoms of cervical artery dysfunction. Then observe, take active range of motion, test neurologically, and only then use provocative and relieving tests chosen by the working hypothesis. A patient with a fracture risk is imaged first and examined later; a patient with signs of cord compression or dissection is referred, not provoked.
Range of motion
Commonly taught normal active ranges are flexion 50 degrees (chin nearly to chest), extension 60 degrees, lateral flexion 45 degrees and rotation 80 degrees to each side. About half of cervical rotation occurs at C1 on C2, and about half of flexion and extension at the occiput on C1 and in the lower cervical segments. Rotation limited mainly in flexion (the cervical flexion rotation test) isolates C1 to C2 and is a useful sign in cervicogenic headache, where rotation of less than about 32 degrees toward the painful side is considered positive. Record range, the pattern of restriction and what each movement reproduces. Pain on extension and ipsilateral rotation suggests facet or foraminal compression; pain on the opposite side with lateral flexion suggests muscle or ligament stretch. Loss of rotation of less than 60 degrees toward the symptomatic side is one item of the radiculopathy cluster.
Provocative and relieving tests for radiculopathy
| Test | How it is performed | Positive finding | Suggests, and diagnostic value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foraminal compression (Spurling) | Seated patient; examiner laterally flexes the head toward the symptomatic side (often with slight extension) and presses down on the vertex | Radiating pain or paresthesia into the arm in a dermatomal pattern | Nerve root compression in the intervertebral foramen. Specificity high (about 0.85 to 0.95), sensitivity low to moderate (about 0.3 to 0.5): a positive test helps rule in |
| Jackson compression | Head laterally flexed to each side with axial pressure | Radiating arm pain on the flexed side | Foraminal encroachment; local neck pain only suggests facet irritation |
| Maximal foraminal compression | Patient rotates the chin toward the shoulder and extends the neck | Radicular pain on the concave side; local pain only on the stretched side suggests strain | Foraminal stenosis or facet |
| Cervical distraction | Examiner lifts the head gently, about 10 kg of traction, supine or seated | Relief or reduction of arm or neck pain | Foraminal or root compression relieved by opening the foramen. Specificity about 0.90; increased pain suggests ligament or muscle sprain |
| Shoulder abduction relief (Bakody) | Patient rests the hand of the painful arm on top of the head | Arm pain decreases | Lower cervical (C4 to C6) root compression, usually from soft disc; increased pain suggests interscalene compression |
| Shoulder depression | Examiner laterally flexes the head away and depresses the opposite shoulder | Pain on the stretched side: dural sleeve adhesion, root traction or muscle strain; pain on the compressed side: foraminal encroachment | Distinguishes stretch from compression; low specificity |
| Upper limb tension test A (median nerve bias) | Supine: scapular depression, shoulder abduction, forearm supination, wrist and finger extension, external rotation, elbow extension, then contralateral lateral neck flexion | Reproduction of symptoms, a side to side difference in elbow extension over 10 degrees, or symptoms that change with neck movement | Neural tension, high sensitivity (about 0.97): a negative test makes radiculopathy unlikely |
| Valsalva | Patient bears down against a closed glottis | Increased spinal or radiating pain | Raised intrathecal pressure from a space occupying lesion: disc herniation, tumor, osteophyte |
No single test makes the diagnosis, which is why the Wainner cluster is so useful. Its four items are a positive upper limb tension test A, ipsilateral cervical rotation of less than 60 degrees, a positive distraction test and a positive Spurling test. With three of four positive the positive likelihood ratio is about 6; with all four it rises to about 30. The upper limb tension test, with its high sensitivity, is the best single test to rule radiculopathy out.
Reasoning: All four cluster items are positive, and the thumb dermatome, wrist extensor weakness and brachioradialis reflex localize the lesion to the C6 root, most often from a C5 to C6 disc. This is a radiculopathy without red flags or myelopathy, and conservative care with directional preference, traction or gentle mobilization is reasonable, with neurologic re-examination at each visit. Progressive weakness, or a new bilateral or long tract sign, changes the plan to urgent MRI and referral. Repeating Spurling at every visit to "see if it is still positive" adds nothing and only provokes her.
Myelopathy
Cervical spondylotic myelopathy is the most common cause of spinal cord dysfunction in older adults and is easy to miss because neck pain may be minimal. Clues are clumsy hands (difficulty with buttons and handwriting), a broad based or spastic gait, generalized rather than dermatomal numbness, and later bladder urgency. Lhermitte sign, an electric sensation down the spine or into the limbs on neck flexion, points to the cord itself: myelopathy, multiple sclerosis, or less commonly tumor or radiation injury. Long tract signs include Hoffmann sign (flicking the distal phalanx of the middle finger produces thumb and index flexion), the inverted supinator sign (tapping the brachioradialis tendon produces finger flexion with a reduced brachioradialis response, implying a C5 to C6 cord lesion), hyperreflexia below the level, clonus and a Babinski sign. A clinical cluster (gait deviation, positive Hoffmann, inverted supinator sign, positive Babinski and age over 45) gives a positive likelihood ratio of about 30 when three of five are positive, while one or fewer positive helps rule it out. Myelopathy is a reason to refer for MRI and surgical opinion and a contraindication to high velocity cervical thrust.
Upper cervical instability and cervical artery dysfunction
Ligamentous laxity at C1 to C2 is a concern in rheumatoid arthritis, Down syndrome, after upper cervical trauma, and with some congenital anomalies such as os odontoideum. Symptoms include a sense that the head is "heavy" or needs holding, occipital pain, paresthesia of the lips or face, and myelopathic signs. The Sharp Purser test is performed seated with slight neck flexion: the examiner stabilizes the C2 spinous process and presses the forehead posteriorly. A sliding sensation or relief of symptoms as the atlas reduces is positive (specificity about 0.96). Alar ligament stress tests feel for immediate C2 spinous process movement with side bending or rotation; delayed movement suggests laxity. These tests should be gentle, and a positive or suspicious finding means flexion and extension radiographs or MRI before treatment, not repeated testing.
Cervical artery dysfunction (vertebral or internal carotid artery dissection) usually presents with unusual, severe neck pain or headache that the patient calls new and different, sometimes after minor trauma, followed hours to days later by ischemic symptoms. The vertebrobasilar warning signs are remembered as the 5 Ds and 3 Ns: dizziness, diplopia, dysarthria, dysphagia, drop attacks, nausea, nystagmus and numbness (often facial or perioral), plus ataxia. Internal carotid dissection may add Horner syndrome, pulsatile tinnitus or cranial nerve palsies. Traditional positional tests (George, DeKleyn, Maigne, Hautant, Underburg) hold the neck in extension and rotation while watching for nystagmus or symptoms. They have poor sensitivity and do not predict who will be harmed, so a negative positional test never clears a patient. Screening rests on the history and a neurologic examination, including cranial nerves, coordination and blood pressure in both arms. A suspected dissection is an emergency referral.
Reasoning: Bilateral hand symptoms, gait disturbance, Lhermitte sign and hyperreflexia with Hoffmann describe cervical spondylotic myelopathy, not a pinched nerve. The next step is referral for cervical MRI and a spine surgery opinion. Do not perform rotational thrust manipulation or provocative compression testing, and document the long tract signs and the referral. Progressive myelopathy has a poor outcome if decompression is delayed.
Screen the neck for fracture risk, instability, myelopathy and artery dysfunction before provoking it. For arm pain, use the radiculopathy cluster: a negative upper limb tension test argues against radiculopathy, and Spurling with distraction argues for it. Long tract signs or a dissection history mean referral, not treatment.
Section 3Thoracic and rib examination in cases
Motion and rib mechanics
The thoracic spine is stiffened by the rib cage, so its motion is small: commonly cited values are flexion about 20 to 45 degrees, extension 25 to 45 degrees, lateral flexion 20 to 40 degrees and rotation 35 to 50 degrees, with rotation greatest in the upper and middle segments where the facets lie in a near coronal plane. Each typical rib articulates with two vertebral bodies at the costovertebral joint and with a transverse process at the costotransverse joint, so a painful rib and a painful thoracic segment are easily confused. Upper ribs move mainly in a pump handle pattern that raises the sternum anteriorly; lower ribs move in a bucket handle pattern that widens the lateral chest. A rib that stops moving early on inspiration is described as held in exhalation, and one that stops early on exhalation as held in inhalation.
Chest expansion is measured with a tape at the fourth intercostal space (the nipple line in men) from full exhalation to full inspiration. Expansion of less than about 2.5 cm is abnormal and, in a young adult with inflammatory back pain, suggests costovertebral involvement by ankylosing spondylitis. Restricted expansion also occurs with pleural disease, obesity, pain and chronic lung disease, so it is interpreted with the history.
| Test | How it is performed | Positive finding | Suggests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rib springing (anterior to posterior pressure) | Prone; examiner applies gentle posterior to anterior pressure along the angle of each rib | Sharp local pain or abnormal give | Costovertebral or costotransverse dysfunction, rib fracture |
| Rib compression (anterior to posterior or lateral) | Examiner compresses the rib cage away from the painful point | Pain at a distant point on the rib | Rib fracture; pain away from the point of pressure is the classic clue |
| Sternal compression | Supine; downward pressure on the sternum | Lateral chest pain | Rib fracture or costochondral injury |
| Schepelmann | Seated; patient laterally flexes to each side | Pain on the concave side: intercostal neuritis. Pain on the convex side: pleural irritation or intercostal myofascial strain | Separates neural from pleural and myofascial chest wall pain |
| Soto Hall | Supine; examiner stabilizes the sternum and passively flexes the neck | Localized pain in the spine | Posterior ligament, spinous process or vertebral body lesion at that level |
| Spinous percussion | Examiner taps each spinous process with a reflex hammer or finger | Sharp localized pain | Fracture, infection, tumor; nonspecific but a useful red flag screen |
| Beevor sign | Supine patient lifts head and shoulders against resistance | Umbilicus moves upward | Weakness of the lower rectus abdominis: a lesion at about T10 to T12 |
| Adams forward bend and prone extension | Forward bending, then prone trunk lift | Rotational hump; rigid kyphosis that does not correct | Structural scoliosis; Scheuermann disease |
Reasoning: Abrupt onset with a twisting reach, focal tenderness at the costotransverse junction, reproduction on rib springing and pain with deep breathing describe costovertebral or costotransverse joint dysfunction. Painless remote compression and the mechanism argue against fracture. Rib and segmental mobilization or adjustment is appropriate. Had the pain been reproduced away from the point of compression after a fall, a rib fracture would be likely and a chest radiograph would be the next step to exclude pneumothorax.
Thoracic outlet tests
Thoracic outlet syndrome is compression of the brachial plexus, subclavian artery or subclavian vein at one of three sites: the interscalene triangle (anterior scalene in front, middle scalene behind, first rib below), the costoclavicular space between the clavicle and first rib, and the subpectoral space beneath the pectoralis minor near the coracoid. The plexus and subclavian artery pass through the interscalene triangle, while the subclavian vein passes in front of the anterior scalene. About 95 percent of cases are neurogenic, typically affecting the lower trunk (C8 and T1: ulnar side of the hand and forearm, intrinsic hand weakness). Venous cases (about 3 to 5 percent) present with arm swelling and cyanosis, often in a young athlete after overhead exertion (effort thrombosis, Paget Schroetter syndrome). Arterial cases (about 1 percent) present with coldness, pallor or digital ischemia and are often associated with a cervical rib.
| Thoracic outlet test | Position | Space tested | Positive |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adson | Arm slightly abducted and extended, radial pulse monitored; patient extends the neck, rotates the head toward the tested side and holds a deep breath | Interscalene triangle (anterior scalene, cervical rib) | Diminished or absent radial pulse with reproduction of symptoms |
| Reverse Adson (Halstead) | Same, head rotated away from the tested side | Interscalene triangle, middle scalene | Pulse change with symptoms |
| Costoclavicular (Eden, military brace) | Shoulders retracted and depressed, chest out | Costoclavicular space | Pulse change and symptoms |
| Wright hyperabduction | Arm abducted overhead (about 180 degrees) with external rotation | Subpectoral space (pectoralis minor) | Pulse change and symptoms |
| Roos elevated arm stress test (EAST) | Arms abducted 90 degrees and externally rotated, elbows flexed 90 degrees; open and close the hands slowly for 3 minutes | Whole outlet, functional | Inability to continue, heaviness, reproduction of paresthesia; pallor of one hand |
Red flag thoracic pain
Thoracic pain carries a higher pretest probability of serious disease than neck or low back pain. The thoracic spine is the most common site of spinal metastasis (roughly 70 percent of spinal metastases), and many visceral organs refer pain to the interscapular region. Treat thoracic pain as mechanical only when it behaves mechanically: it should change with movement, posture and palpation, and should not be accompanied by systemic or visceral symptoms.
| Presentation | Key clue | Must not miss | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Constant night pain, age over 50, weight loss or prior cancer | Pain not relieved by rest or position, spinous percussion tenderness | Metastasis (breast, lung, prostate, kidney, thyroid), myeloma | Imaging and laboratory work (ESR, CRP, CBC, protein electrophoresis), prompt referral; urgent if cord signs |
| Sudden pain after minor strain in an older woman, long term steroids | Height loss, focal percussion tenderness | Osteoporotic compression fracture | Lateral radiograph, bone density, avoid forceful thrust at the level |
| Interscapular pain with exertion, dyspnea, diaphoresis | Not reproduced by palpation or movement | Myocardial ischemia | Emergency services |
| Sudden tearing pain between the scapulae, hypertension | Arm blood pressure difference over 20 mmHg, pulse deficit | Aortic dissection | Emergency services |
| Pleuritic pain with dyspnea and tachycardia | Recent immobility, leg swelling, oral contraceptives | Pulmonary embolism | Emergency services |
| Burning band of pain in one dermatome, older adult | Hyperesthesia without a rash yet | Herpes zoster | Antiviral therapy within 72 hours of rash; refer |
| Right scapular pain after fatty meals; band pain to the back with vomiting | Right upper quadrant tenderness; epigastric pain, alcohol use | Cholecystitis; pancreatitis | Medical referral, urgent if febrile or vomiting |
| Fever, back pain, injection drug use or diabetes | Severe focal tenderness, rising neurologic deficit | Spinal epidural abscess or discitis | Emergency referral |
| Band like chest wall pain with leg stiffness or bladder change | Hyperreflexia in the legs, sensory level | Thoracic disc herniation or cord tumor (thoracic myelopathy) | Urgent MRI and referral |
Reasoning: Prior cancer, age, night pain unrelieved by rest and focal percussion tenderness make vertebral metastasis the working diagnosis, and hyperreflexia in the legs suggests early cord compression. This is an emergency: same day referral for MRI of the whole spine and oncologic evaluation, because outcome depends on ambulatory status when treatment begins. No manipulation, and do not wait for a plain film to "look first."
Thoracic and rib pain is mechanical when it changes with breathing, movement and focal pressure, and the tests (rib springing, compression, Schepelmann, Soto Hall) help separate joint, rib, neural and pleural sources. Thoracic outlet tests count only when they reproduce symptoms. Because the thoracic region is the commonest site of metastasis and a frequent site of visceral referral, nonmechanical thoracic pain demands a red flag search first.
Section 4Lumbar and pelvic examination in cases
Motion and observation
Typical active lumbar ranges are flexion 40 to 60 degrees, extension 20 to 35 degrees, lateral flexion 15 to 25 degrees and rotation 3 to 18 degrees. Watch the quality of motion as much as its range: a painful arc, a deviation to one side during flexion, a reversal of the lumbopelvic rhythm on returning from flexion (the patient "climbs up the thighs" with the hands, a sign of instability or severe pain), and whether repeated movements centralize or peripheralize symptoms. Pain that centralizes, retreating from the leg toward the spine with repeated movement in one direction, predicts a good outcome with directional preference exercise. The modified Schober test marks the lumbosacral junction (the level of the dimples of Venus) and a point 10 cm above it; an increase of less than 5 cm on full flexion indicates restricted lumbar flexion and is a classic finding in ankylosing spondylitis.
The straight leg raise family and the slump
The sciatic nerve and the L4 to S1 roots glide 2 to 6 mm through the foramina as the hip flexes with the knee straight. A herniated disc tethers the root, so stretch reproduces radicular pain. In the straight leg raise (Lasegue) the examiner lifts the straight leg of the supine patient. Reproduction of the patient's radiating leg pain below the knee between about 30 and 70 degrees is positive. Below 30 degrees there is little root excursion, and pain then suggests acute inflammation, hip or sacroiliac disease, or nonorganic behavior; above 70 degrees the root is fully stretched and pain usually comes from hamstrings, the lumbar joints or the sacroiliac joint. Back pain alone or posterior thigh tightness is not a positive SLR.
| Test | How it is performed | Positive and meaning | Diagnostic value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Straight leg raise | Supine, passive hip flexion with the knee straight | Radiating pain below the knee at 30 to 70 degrees: L5 or S1 root tension, usually disc | Sensitivity about 0.9, specificity about 0.25: a negative SLR helps rule out disc herniation |
| Crossed (well leg) SLR, Fajersztajn | Raise the asymptomatic leg | Pain in the symptomatic leg: large, central or axillary herniation | Specificity about 0.9, sensitivity about 0.3: helps rule in |
| Braggard | From the SLR, lower the leg until pain eases, then dorsiflex the foot | Return of radicular pain: neural tension rather than hamstring | Confirms a positive SLR |
| Bowstring | Lower the leg slightly, flex the knee and press in the popliteal fossa | Radiating pain: sciatic tension | Confirmatory |
| Bechterew | Seated, extend one knee then both | Radicular pain or leaning back to avoid it | Seated SLR equivalent; compare with supine SLR for consistency |
| Slump | Seated; slump the thoracolumbar spine, flex the neck, extend the knee, dorsiflex the ankle; release neck flexion | Reproduced symptoms that ease when the neck is extended | Sensitivity about 0.84, specificity about 0.83; more sensitive than SLR |
| Femoral nerve stretch (prone knee bend) | Prone; knee flexed with hip extended | Anterior thigh pain: L2 to L4 root, upper lumbar disc | Upper lumbar counterpart to the SLR |
| Kemp | Seated or standing; extension with rotation and lateral flexion toward the side, often with axial pressure | Local pain: facet; radiating leg pain: root compression or foraminal stenosis | Sensitive for facet pain but poorly specific |
| Milgram | Supine; lift both straight legs 5 cm and hold 30 seconds | Inability to hold or pain: raised intrathecal pressure or weak abdominals | Low specificity |
| Valsalva and Dejerine triad | Bear down; ask about cough, sneeze and strain | Radiating or spinal pain: space occupying lesion | Supports disc or mass; not diagnostic |
Reasoning: A positive SLR with a positive crossed SLR strongly suggests a disc herniation, and the dorsum of the foot with weak extensor hallucis longus localizes it to the L5 root (usually an L4 to L5 posterolateral disc). Absent bowel, bladder and saddle signs, conservative care is appropriate, with an explicit plan to re-examine strength and to refer urgently if weakness progresses, and immediately if cauda equina symptoms appear. Imaging is not needed unless he fails four to six weeks of care or the deficit worsens.
The sacroiliac joint and the hip
Single sacroiliac tests and static or motion palpation of the joint are unreliable, but a cluster performs well. In the Laslett cluster five provocation tests are used: distraction (anterior gapping, pressure on both ASIS supine), thigh thrust (posterior shear through the femur with the hip flexed to 90 degrees), compression (side lying, pressure down through the iliac crest), sacral thrust (prone, pressure on the sacrum) and Gaenslen (one hip held in full flexion while the other is extended off the table). Three or more positive of five, or two of the first four, gives a sensitivity near 0.9 and specificity near 0.8 for sacroiliac pain. Thigh thrust is the most sensitive single test and distraction the most specific. The cluster is meaningful only when lumbar sources have been reasonably excluded, for example when repeated movements do not centralize the pain. Patrick (FABERE) places the heel on the opposite knee and lowers the flexed, abducted, externally rotated thigh: groin pain implicates the hip, while posterior pain at the joint implicates the sacroiliac joint. Yeoman extends the hip with the knee flexed, prone: sacroiliac pain suggests anterior sacroiliac ligament strain, anterior thigh pain suggests femoral nerve tension, and lumbar pain suggests a lumbar source.
Always screen the hip in "back pain" with buttock or groin pain. Loss of internal rotation is the earliest sign of hip osteoarthritis; groin pain on FADIR (flexion, adduction, internal rotation) suggests femoroacetabular impingement or a labral tear and is very sensitive; pain on the log roll is specific for an intra-articular source; the Thomas test shows hip flexor tightness when the extended thigh lifts off the table; Ely (prone knee flexion that raises the hip) shows rectus femoris tightness; Ober shows iliotibial band tightness. The Trendelenburg sign tests gluteus medius strength.
Nonorganic signs
Waddell signs fall into five categories: superficial or nonanatomic tenderness; simulation tests (low back pain with light axial loading of the head or with passive rotation of the shoulders and pelvis together); distraction (a markedly positive supine SLR but a normal seated SLR during apparent knee examination, the flip test); regional disturbances (giving way or sensory change that follows no root or nerve); and overreaction. Three or more positive categories is significant. The signs indicate psychosocial distress and predict poorer outcome and response to purely physical treatment; they do not prove malingering and do not exclude organic disease. The Hoover test adds evidence about effort: the examiner cups both heels while the supine patient tries to raise the affected leg; a patient who is genuinely trying presses the opposite heel down, and absence of that pressure suggests lack of effort.
Reasoning: Four Waddell categories are positive (tenderness, simulation, distraction, regional; overreaction is also present). This signals significant psychosocial overlay and fear avoidance, often with yellow flags, and predicts a poor response to passive care. It does not mean he is faking, and his real lumbar findings still need a fair neurologic examination. Management shifts toward graded activity, reassurance, active rehabilitation and, if needed, co-management for psychosocial factors; document the findings neutrally.
In the lumbopelvic examination, the SLR and slump detect root tension and a negative SLR helps rule out disc herniation, while a crossed SLR helps rule it in. Clustered sacroiliac provocation tests are useful, single ones are not. Always screen the hip, and read Waddell signs as markers of distress, not proof of deception.
Section 5Palpation and segmental examination
Static and motion palpation
Static palpation is performed with the patient still. It assesses skin temperature and moisture, soft tissue texture and edema, muscle tone (hypertonicity, taut bands and trigger points), tenderness, and bony alignment such as a rotated spinous process or a step off. A myofascial trigger point is a tender nodule in a taut band that reproduces a characteristic referred pain pattern and may give a local twitch response or a jump sign. A palpable step off at L5 on S1, with the spinous process above sitting forward, suggests spondylolisthesis.
Motion palpation assesses movement. Intersegmental range is felt as the patient or examiner moves the spine through flexion, extension, lateral flexion and rotation, and the examiner's contact tracks whether each segment moves as much as its neighbors. Joint play is the small, involuntary accessory movement available in a relaxed joint, and is assessed with gentle springing toward the end of passive range. A fixation (hypomobility) is a segment that lacks normal joint play or end range motion. The examiner notes the direction of restriction, which in chiropractic listings guides the line of drive.
End feel
End feel is the quality of resistance at the end of passive range, as described by Cyriax. Each normal joint has a characteristic end feel, and an end feel in the wrong joint or at the wrong point in range is pathological.
| End feel | What it feels like | Normal example | Abnormal meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bone to bone | Abrupt, hard stop | Elbow extension | Osteophyte, heterotopic bone, malunion |
| Soft tissue approximation | Yielding compression as soft tissues meet | Knee and elbow flexion | Rarely abnormal; may be early with edema or muscle hypertrophy |
| Tissue stretch (capsular, firm) | Firm with slight give | Shoulder external rotation, wrist, hip rotation | Capsular pattern early in range: arthritis, adhesive capsulitis |
| Muscle spasm | Sudden reflex guarding during motion | None | Acute injury, instability, fracture |
| Springy block | Rebound before full range | None | Internal derangement: meniscus tear, loose body |
| Empty | Patient stops movement because of pain before any resistance is felt | None | Acute bursitis, abscess, fracture, neoplasm; a red flag |
Reasoning: An empty end feel means pain limits motion before any mechanical barrier, which points away from capsulitis or a cuff problem toward acute inflammation or a serious lesion. With weight loss, cough and heavy smoking, a superior sulcus (Pancoast) tumor or bone metastasis must be excluded. The next step is a chest radiograph and prompt medical referral, not shoulder mobilization.
Reliability of palpation findings
Palpation is the most chiropractic of all examination skills and the least reliable between examiners, and the board expects you to know the evidence. Reliability is usually expressed with the kappa statistic, where 0 is chance agreement and values above about 0.4 are moderate and above 0.6 substantial. Pain provocation (tenderness on pressure) shows the best interexaminer agreement, typically moderate. Static assessment of soft tissue, and especially of bony position, is poor. Motion palpation for segmental fixation shows interexaminer kappa values near chance in most studies, while the same examiner agrees with himself better (intraexaminer reliability is fair to moderate). Regional range of motion with an inclinometer is reliable. Several practical rules follow: anchor a segmental finding to tenderness, confirm it with a second type of finding at the same level, use the patient's report of familiar pain, and do not stake a diagnosis on a single palpatory impression.
From findings to a segmental diagnosis: PARTS
The PARTS framework organizes the evidence for a segmental dysfunction (the chiropractic subluxation): Pain and tenderness, Asymmetry or misalignment, Range of motion abnormality, Tone, texture and temperature change in the soft tissues, and Special tests (such as provocation or instrumented tests). For third party documentation in the United States, a subluxation demonstrated by physical examination requires at least two of the four PART findings, one of which must be asymmetry or range of motion abnormality. Requiring agreement among several findings at the same level offsets the weakness of any single one.
Reasoning: Tenderness reproducing familiar pain (P), segmental and regional range of motion loss (R) and tone change (T) converge on one level, giving a right C2 to C3 segmental dysfunction with a cervicogenic headache pattern. The convergence matters more than any single finding. Safety screening is reassuring, so manipulation or mobilization with soft tissue work is reasonable; re-examine rotation and tenderness after treatment to confirm that the segment responded.
Palpation gives information no imaging can, but each finding alone is unreliable between examiners. Use end feel to recognize serious pathology (an empty end feel is a red flag), anchor segmental findings to reproducible tenderness, and build the segmental diagnosis from several PARTS findings that agree at one level.
The chapter in one breath
- Observe posture and gait first; a rotational rib hump on the Adams test means structural scoliosis, and a scoliometer reading of about 7 degrees warrants a radiograph.
- Each gait deviation predicts a lesion: Trendelenburg (weak gluteus medius, L5), steppage (weak dorsiflexors, L5 or fibular nerve), spastic (cord), ataxic (cerebellum or dorsal columns).
- In the neck, screen for fracture risk, instability, myelopathy and cervical artery dysfunction before any provocative test.
- Spurling and distraction are specific; the upper limb tension test is sensitive; the Wainner cluster with all four positive strongly rules radiculopathy in.
- Lhermitte, Hoffmann, the inverted supinator sign, hyperreflexia and gait change mean myelopathy: refer for MRI and avoid thrust.
- Positional vertebral artery tests cannot clear a patient; history (the 5 Ds and 3 Ns) and neurologic examination do the screening.
- Rib springing, rib compression, Schepelmann and Soto Hall separate rib, joint, neural and pleural sources; thoracic outlet tests count only if they reproduce symptoms.
- Nonmechanical thoracic pain is a red flag: think metastasis, fracture, cardiac, aortic, pulmonary, zoster and visceral referral.
- A negative SLR helps rule out disc herniation, a crossed SLR helps rule it in, and the slump is more balanced.
- The Laslett cluster (three of five sacroiliac provocation tests) is useful when single tests are not; always screen the hip.
- Waddell signs (three or more categories) mark distress and poor prognosis, not malingering.
- Pain provocation is the most reliable palpatory finding; build segmental diagnoses with PARTS, and treat an empty end feel as a red flag.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Adams forward bend test | Forward flexion while the examiner looks for a rib or lumbar prominence that indicates a structural, rotational curve. |
| Angle of trunk rotation | The scoliometer reading across a rib or lumbar prominence; about 7 degrees or more warrants a radiograph. |
| Antalgic gait | A gait with shortened stance on the painful limb. |
| Trendelenburg sign | Pelvic drop on the swing side during single leg stance, meaning weak hip abductors on the stance side. |
| Steppage gait | High knee lift and foot slap caused by weak ankle dorsiflexors. |
| Upper crossed syndrome | Tight upper trapezius, levator and pectorals with weak deep neck flexors and lower scapular stabilizers. |
| Spurling test | Lateral flexion and extension of the neck with axial pressure; reproduced arm pain suggests root compression. |
| Distraction test | Gentle cervical traction; relief of arm pain suggests foraminal compression. |
| Upper limb tension test | Sequential positioning that tensions the median nerve and roots; highly sensitive for cervical radiculopathy. |
| Wainner cluster | Four cervical findings (tension test, rotation under 60 degrees, distraction, Spurling) that together predict radiculopathy. |
| Lhermitte sign | Electric sensation down the spine or limbs on neck flexion, indicating a cervical cord lesion. |
| Hoffmann sign | Thumb and index flexion when the middle finger tip is flicked; an upper motor neuron sign. |
| Inverted supinator sign | Finger flexion with a reduced brachioradialis response on tapping its tendon; suggests C5 to C6 myelopathy. |
| Sharp Purser test | Posterior pressure on the forehead while stabilizing C2; a sliding reduction suggests atlantoaxial instability. |
| Cervical artery dysfunction | Vertebral or internal carotid artery pathology, especially dissection, that can mimic musculoskeletal neck pain. |
| Schepelmann test | Seated lateral flexion; concave side pain suggests intercostal neuritis, convex side pain pleural or myofascial irritation. |
| Soto Hall test | Passive neck flexion with the sternum stabilized; localized spinal pain suggests a posterior ligament or vertebral lesion. |
| Beevor sign | Upward movement of the umbilicus during a partial sit up, indicating lower abdominal weakness from a T10 to T12 lesion. |
| Roos test | Three minutes of hand opening and closing with arms raised; reproduction of symptoms suggests thoracic outlet syndrome. |
| Straight leg raise | Passive hip flexion with the knee straight; radiating pain below the knee at 30 to 70 degrees suggests root tension. |
| Crossed straight leg raise | Raising the well leg reproduces pain in the affected leg; specific for disc herniation. |
| Slump test | Seated sequential spinal and neural tensioning; symptom change with neck movement indicates neural tension. |
| Laslett cluster | Five sacroiliac provocation tests; three or more positive suggests the joint is the pain source. |
| FABERE (Patrick) test | Flexion, abduction and external rotation of the hip; groin pain implicates the hip, posterior pain the sacroiliac joint. |
| Waddell signs | Five categories of nonorganic findings that indicate psychosocial distress when three or more are present. |
| Hoover test | Monitoring downward heel pressure of the opposite leg as the patient tries to lift the affected leg, to judge effort. |
| Joint play | Small involuntary accessory motion in a relaxed joint, assessed by springing near end range. |
| End feel | The quality of resistance at the end of passive range; empty end feel is a red flag. |
| Kappa statistic | A measure of agreement beyond chance; above about 0.4 is moderate. |
| PARTS | Pain, asymmetry, range of motion, tissue tone and special tests: the findings that support a segmental diagnosis. |
Check yourself
Extremity, Neurologic and Peripheral Vascular Examination
Most extremity and neurologic items on Part III are really localization problems: a patient points to a painful shoulder, a numb hand or a weak foot, and you must decide which tissue, which nerve or which level is responsible, and whether the cause is in the limb, the spine or the blood supply. The tests in this chapter are the tools for that decision. Know how each is done and what it means, but above all know which test to choose next and how much a positive or negative result should change your mind.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Perform and interpret the key shoulder, elbow, wrist and hand tests, and use the impingement and rotator cuff tear clusters.
- Perform and interpret the key hip, knee, ankle and foot tests, including Lachman, McMurray, Thessaly, Thompson and the ligament stress tests.
- Apply the Ottawa ankle and Ottawa knee rules to decide on radiographs.
- Localize a root lesion from dermatomes, myotomes and reflexes, and separate upper from lower motor neuron lesions.
- Screen the cranial nerves and cerebellar function efficiently and recognize the findings that require emergency referral.
- Perform the Allen test, grade pulses and capillary refill, calculate an ankle brachial index, and apply the Wells criteria for deep vein thrombosis.
- Distinguish vascular from neurogenic claudication by history and examination.
- Use sensitivity, specificity and likelihood ratios to choose tests and to judge how far a result moves the probability of disease.
Section 1Upper extremity orthopedic examination in cases
The shoulder
Start every shoulder examination by clearing the neck, because C5 radiculopathy, C5 to C6 facet pain and referred visceral pain (the heart, the diaphragm through C3 to C5, the gallbladder on the right, the spleen on the left) all present as "shoulder pain." Pain that does not change with shoulder movement, or that is reproduced by neck movement, is not from the shoulder. Then compare active and passive range. Loss of both active and passive motion, worst in external rotation, then abduction, then internal rotation (the capsular pattern), indicates adhesive capsulitis or glenohumeral arthritis. Loss of active motion with preserved passive motion indicates a weak or torn rotator cuff or a nerve lesion. A painful arc between about 60 and 120 degrees of abduction suggests subacromial impingement or cuff tendinopathy; pain at the top of the arc, from about 160 to 180 degrees, suggests the acromioclavicular joint.
| Shoulder test | How it is performed | Positive finding | Suggests, and value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Neer impingement | Examiner stabilizes the scapula and passively forward flexes the internally rotated arm | Anterior or lateral shoulder pain | Subacromial impingement; sensitive (about 0.7 to 0.8), not specific |
| Hawkins Kennedy | Shoulder and elbow flexed 90 degrees, examiner forcibly internally rotates | Pain | Impingement under the coracoacromial arch; sensitive, poorly specific |
| Empty can (Jobe) | Arms at 90 degrees in the scapular plane, thumbs down; resist downward pressure | Weakness or pain | Supraspinatus tendinopathy or tear; weakness more meaningful than pain |
| Drop arm | Passively abduct to 90 degrees, ask the patient to lower slowly | Arm drops or cannot be lowered smoothly | Full thickness cuff tear; specificity above 0.9 |
| External rotation lag sign | Elbow flexed 90 degrees; examiner places the arm in near full external rotation and releases | Arm drifts back toward internal rotation | Infraspinatus and supraspinatus tear; highly specific |
| Lift off, belly press, bear hug | Resisted internal rotation from behind the back, against the abdomen, or with the hand on the opposite shoulder | Inability to hold or weakness | Subscapularis tear |
| Speed | Resisted forward flexion with elbow extended and forearm supinated | Pain in the bicipital groove | Biceps tendinopathy or superior labral lesion |
| Yergason | Elbow flexed 90 degrees; resisted supination and external rotation | Groove pain or tendon snapping out of the groove | Biceps tendinopathy, transverse humeral ligament tear |
| O'Brien active compression | Arm flexed 90 degrees and adducted 10 to 15 degrees, thumb down; resist, then repeat palm up | Deep pain thumb down relieved palm up | SLAP lesion (pain on top of the shoulder suggests the AC joint) |
| Apprehension and relocation | Supine, arm abducted 90 degrees and externally rotated; then posterior pressure on the humeral head | Apprehension that eases with relocation pressure | Anterior glenohumeral instability; relocation adds specificity |
| Sulcus sign | Downward traction on the relaxed arm | A gap below the acromion | Inferior or multidirectional instability |
| Cross body adduction | Passive horizontal adduction across the chest | Pain at the AC joint | Acromioclavicular arthritis or sprain |
Clusters outperform single shoulder tests. For subacromial impingement, a positive Hawkins Kennedy, a painful arc and weak resisted external rotation together give a positive likelihood ratio of about 10. For a full thickness rotator cuff tear, a painful arc, a positive drop arm and weak external rotation together, especially over age 60, make a tear very likely. A traumatic cuff tear with marked weakness in an active patient is a reason for early orthopedic referral, because repair results are best within weeks.
Reasoning: Preserved passive with lost active elevation, a positive drop arm and an external rotation lag sign after trauma in a 64 year old make a full thickness rotator cuff tear (supraspinatus and infraspinatus) highly likely. The next step is imaging (ultrasound or MRI) and prompt orthopedic referral for possible repair; the alternative explanations, axillary or suprascapular nerve injury and C5 radiculopathy, are excluded by normal sensation, reflexes and neck examination. Do not label this "impingement" and treat it for months.
The elbow
Lateral elbow pain in a person who grips repeatedly is usually lateral epicondylalgia (tendinopathy of the extensor carpi radialis brevis origin). It is reproduced by Cozen test (resisted wrist extension with a fist, elbow extended, forearm pronated), Mill test (passive wrist flexion with elbow extended and forearm pronated), and Maudsley test (resisted middle finger extension). Medial epicondylalgia is reproduced by resisted wrist flexion and pronation, or passive wrist extension with the elbow extended. Ligaments are tested with valgus stress at about 20 to 30 degrees of flexion for the ulnar collateral ligament (throwing athletes) and varus stress for the lateral collateral ligament. The ulnar nerve is assessed with a Tinel sign in the cubital tunnel and the elbow flexion test (full elbow flexion with wrist extension for one to three minutes reproduces ulnar side paresthesia). Lateral elbow pain that also produces aching in the dorsal forearm and weakness of finger extension without sensory loss suggests the posterior interosseous nerve (radial tunnel).
The wrist and hand
| Test | How it is performed | Positive finding | Suggests, and value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phalen | Wrists held in full flexion, dorsums pressed together, for 60 seconds | Paresthesia in the thumb, index, middle and radial ring fingers | Carpal tunnel syndrome; sensitivity about 0.68, specificity about 0.73 |
| Tinel at the wrist | Tapping over the carpal tunnel | Tingling in the median distribution | Carpal tunnel syndrome; specificity higher than sensitivity |
| Carpal compression (Durkan) | Thumb pressure over the carpal tunnel for 30 seconds | Median paresthesia | Carpal tunnel syndrome; among the most sensitive bedside tests |
| Finkelstein (Eichhoff variant) | Thumb folded into the palm, wrist ulnarly deviated | Pain over the radial styloid | De Quervain tenosynovitis (abductor pollicis longus, extensor pollicis brevis) |
| Froment | Patient grips paper between thumb and index finger as it is pulled | Thumb IP joint flexes to hold the paper | Ulnar nerve palsy: weak adductor pollicis replaced by flexor pollicis longus |
| Snuffbox tenderness and scaphoid compression | Palpation in the anatomic snuffbox; axial thumb loading | Pain | Scaphoid fracture until proven otherwise |
| Watson scaphoid shift | Pressure on the volar scaphoid while the wrist moves from ulnar to radial deviation | Painful clunk | Scapholunate instability |
| Bunnell Littler | PIP flexion tested with the MCP extended, then flexed | PIP flexion limited with MCP extended but improved with MCP flexed | Intrinsic muscle tightness (versus capsular tightness if unchanged) |
Reasoning: Nocturnal median paresthesia relieved by shaking (the flick sign) with positive provocative tests indicates carpal tunnel syndrome. Sparing of the thenar skin is a useful clue: the palmar cutaneous branch of the median nerve leaves before the tunnel, so thenar sensory loss suggests a more proximal lesion. Normal reflexes and a negative neck examination argue against C6 radiculopathy. Conservative care with neutral night splinting, ergonomic changes and nerve gliding is appropriate; thenar atrophy or constant numbness would call for nerve conduction studies and referral.
Clear the neck and the viscera before blaming the shoulder. Compare active with passive range to separate capsular, contractile and neural problems, then use selective and clustered tests: drop arm and the external rotation lag sign for cuff tears, Hawkins with a painful arc for impingement, Phalen and compression for carpal tunnel, Finkelstein for de Quervain, and snuffbox tenderness as a scaphoid fracture until proven otherwise.
Section 2Lower extremity orthopedic examination in cases
The hip
Hip joint pain is felt mainly in the groin and anterior thigh and may refer to the knee, so a child or older adult with "knee pain" and a normal knee needs a hip examination. Lateral hip pain with tenderness over the greater trochanter that is worse lying on that side suggests greater trochanteric pain syndrome (gluteus medius and minimus tendinopathy, with or without bursitis). Buttock pain is more often lumbar, sacroiliac or gluteal than intra-articular. The hip tests most worth knowing were introduced in Chapter 3: loss of internal rotation as the earliest sign of osteoarthritis; FADIR for impingement and labral tears (sensitive, so a negative result helps exclude); the log roll, which is specific for intra-articular pathology because it moves only the joint; FABERE; the Thomas, Ely and Ober tests for flexor, rectus femoris and iliotibial band tightness; and the Trendelenburg sign. Craig test estimates femoral anteversion by rotating the prone hip until the greater trochanter is most lateral; increased anteversion produces in-toeing. The piriformis or FAIR test (flexion, adduction, internal rotation in side lying) reproduces buttock pain in piriformis syndrome.
Reasoning: Knee pain with a normal knee in an overweight early adolescent and obligatory external rotation with hip flexion describe slipped capital femoral epiphysis. Order AP and frog leg lateral pelvis radiographs (or urgent referral) and keep him non weight bearing on crutches: further slip risks avascular necrosis. Do not manipulate the hip or send him off with knee exercises. In a 4 to 8 year old boy with a painless limp and limited abduction and internal rotation, think Legg Calve Perthes disease instead.
The knee
The mechanism usually tells you which structure is injured: a noncontact pivot with a pop and rapid swelling (hemarthrosis within two hours) is the classic anterior cruciate tear; a blow to the lateral knee stresses the medial collateral ligament; a dashboard injury or fall onto the flexed knee drives the tibia backward and tears the posterior cruciate; twisting on a loaded, flexed knee tears a meniscus, which swells more slowly over 6 to 24 hours and may lock or catch. Check for effusion first with the bulge (sweep) test for small effusions and patellar ballottement for large ones.
| Knee test | How it is performed | Positive finding | Suggests, and value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lachman | Knee flexed 20 to 30 degrees; stabilize the femur and draw the tibia forward | Increased anterior translation with a soft or absent end point | ACL tear; the best clinical test (sensitivity about 0.85, specificity about 0.94) |
| Anterior drawer | Knee flexed 90 degrees, foot stabilized; pull the tibia forward | Increased anterior translation | ACL tear; less sensitive in acute injury because of hamstring guarding and effusion |
| Pivot shift | Valgus and internal rotation applied as the knee moves from extension into flexion | Clunk as the subluxed lateral tibial plateau reduces at about 30 degrees | ACL tear; very specific (about 0.98) but hard to perform in an awake patient |
| Posterior drawer and posterior sag (Godfrey) | Knee flexed 90 degrees, push the tibia back; or observe the tibial step off with hips and knees flexed | Posterior translation, loss of the normal tibial step | PCL tear; posterior drawer is highly accurate |
| Valgus stress | Valgus force at 0 and at 30 degrees of flexion | Medial gapping or pain | MCL sprain at 30 degrees; gapping at full extension adds cruciate or capsular injury |
| Varus stress | Varus force at 0 and 30 degrees | Lateral gapping or pain | LCL and posterolateral corner injury |
| McMurray | From full flexion, rotate the tibia and extend the knee with varus or valgus stress | Painful click along the joint line | Meniscal tear; specific (about 0.77 to 0.9) but not sensitive |
| Thessaly | Single leg stance with the knee flexed 20 degrees; patient rotates the body three times | Joint line pain or catching | Meniscal tear; good combined accuracy |
| Apley compression and distraction | Prone, knee flexed 90 degrees; rotate with axial compression, then with distraction | Pain with compression: meniscus; pain with distraction: ligament | Separates meniscal from ligamentous injury |
| Joint line tenderness | Palpate the medial and lateral joint lines | Focal tenderness | Meniscal tear; sensitive, poorly specific |
| Patellar apprehension | Lateral pressure on the patella with the knee in slight flexion | Apprehension or quadriceps contraction | Lateral patellar instability or prior dislocation |
| Patellar grind (Clarke) | Press the patella distally and ask for a quadriceps contraction | Retropatellar pain | Patellofemoral pain or chondromalacia; many false positives |
| Noble compression | Pressure over the lateral femoral condyle as the knee extends from 90 degrees | Lateral pain near 30 degrees | Iliotibial band friction syndrome |
The Ottawa knee rule calls for knee radiographs after acute injury if any one of the following is present: age 55 or older, isolated tenderness of the patella, tenderness of the fibular head, inability to flex the knee to 90 degrees, or inability to bear weight for four steps both immediately and in the examination room (limping steps count as bearing weight).
Reasoning: Noncontact pivot, a pop and rapid hemarthrosis followed by a positive Lachman make an ACL tear very likely. She meets none of the Ottawa knee criteria, so radiographs are not required for fracture, but an MRI and orthopedic referral are appropriate because the ACL tear and its associated meniscal injury influence the decision about reconstruction in a pivoting athlete. Meanwhile, control swelling, restore extension and quadriceps activation.
The ankle and foot
The common inversion sprain injures the anterior talofibular ligament first, then the calcaneofibular ligament. The anterior drawer of the ankle (pull the heel forward with the tibia stabilized, in slight plantar flexion) tests the ATFL, and the talar tilt (inversion stress in neutral) tests the CFL. A high ankle sprain of the distal tibiofibular syndesmosis follows external rotation of the foot, is painful above the joint and recovers slowly; it is reproduced by the squeeze test (compressing the tibia and fibula at midcalf produces distal pain) and the external rotation (Kleiger) test. The Thompson test squeezes the calf of the prone patient: absence of plantar flexion means an Achilles tendon rupture (sensitivity about 0.96, specificity about 0.93), often in a middle aged recreational athlete who felt as if kicked in the heel, sometimes after a fluoroquinolone. Morton neuroma (usually the third web space) gives burning forefoot pain reproduced by squeezing the metatarsal heads, sometimes with a click (Mulder sign). Plantar fasciitis produces first step heel pain with tenderness at the medial calcaneal tubercle, reproduced by passive great toe extension (windlass test). Tarsal tunnel syndrome gives a Tinel sign behind the medial malleolus with burning in the sole.
Reasoning: Tenderness over the ATFL with no Ottawa criteria and the ability to bear weight means a lateral ankle sprain (ATFL, grade I to II) without a need for radiographs. A negative squeeze test argues against syndesmotic injury. Management is early protected weight bearing, functional bracing and progressive balance training. Had he been tender at the base of the fifth metatarsal, a foot series would be needed to exclude an avulsion or Jones fracture.
In the lower limb, let the mechanism suggest the structure, then confirm with the best test for it: Lachman for the ACL, posterior drawer for the PCL, valgus stress at 30 degrees for the MCL, McMurray and Thessaly for the meniscus, the anterior drawer and talar tilt for the lateral ankle ligaments, the squeeze test for the syndesmosis and Thompson for the Achilles. Use the Ottawa rules to decide on radiographs, and examine the hip in any child with knee pain.
Section 3Neurologic screening in cases
Root level screening
A neurologic screen of the limbs tests each root three ways: a dermatome (the skin supplied by one root), a myotome (a muscle group supplied mainly by one root) and a deep tendon reflex. Agreement of all three at one level localizes a radiculopathy; disagreement suggests a peripheral nerve, a plexus or a central lesion. Because adjacent dermatomes overlap, sensory loss from a single root is often patchy; motor and reflex findings are more objective.
| Root | Key sensory area | Key motor test | Reflex |
|---|---|---|---|
| C5 | Lateral upper arm (over the deltoid) | Shoulder abduction, elbow flexion | Biceps |
| C6 | Lateral forearm, thumb and index finger | Wrist extension, elbow flexion | Brachioradialis |
| C7 | Middle finger | Elbow extension, wrist flexion, finger extension | Triceps |
| C8 | Ring and little fingers, medial forearm | Finger flexion, thumb extension | None reliable |
| T1 | Medial arm | Finger abduction (interossei) | None |
| L2 to L3 | Anterior and medial thigh | Hip flexion (L2), knee extension and hip adduction (L3) | Patellar contributes (L3) |
| L4 | Medial leg and medial malleolus | Ankle dorsiflexion (tibialis anterior), knee extension | Patellar |
| L5 | Lateral leg, dorsum of foot, great toe | Great toe extension, hip abduction, foot inversion | Medial hamstring (inconsistent) |
| S1 | Lateral foot, little toe, sole | Plantar flexion, foot eversion, hip extension | Achilles |
Muscle strength is graded 0 (no contraction), 1 (flicker), 2 (full range with gravity eliminated), 3 (full range against gravity), 4 (against some resistance) and 5 (normal). Reflexes are graded 0 (absent), 1+ (diminished), 2+ (normal), 3+ (brisk, possibly with spread) and 4+ (with clonus). Diminished reflexes on one side point to a root or peripheral nerve; symmetrically diminished reflexes may be normal or reflect a peripheral neuropathy (ankles first); brisk reflexes with spread, sustained clonus (more than three beats) or pathologic reflexes indicate an upper motor neuron lesion. Reinforcement (the Jendrassik maneuver, pulling clasped hands apart) helps bring out a hard to elicit reflex.
Upper versus lower motor neuron lesions
The upper motor neuron runs from the motor cortex through the internal capsule and brainstem, crosses at the pyramidal decussation of the medulla and descends in the lateral corticospinal tract. The lower motor neuron begins at the anterior horn cell and travels through the root, plexus and peripheral nerve to the neuromuscular junction. A lesion above the anterior horn releases the spinal reflex arc from cortical inhibition; a lesion at or below it interrupts the arc itself.
Pathologic reflexes are the bedside markers of an upper motor neuron lesion. The Babinski sign is extension of the great toe with fanning of the other toes when the lateral sole is stroked from heel to forefoot; it is normal in infants up to about 12 to 24 months. Oppenheim (stroking down the tibial crest) and Chaddock (stroking around the lateral malleolus) elicit the same response. In the upper limb, Hoffmann sign is the equivalent. Superficial reflexes are lost in upper motor neuron lesions and with damage to their own segments: the abdominal reflexes (T8 to T12), the cremasteric reflex (L1 to L2) and the anal wink (S2 to S4).
Cranial nerves and the cerebellum
| Nerve | Quick screen | Abnormal finding and meaning |
|---|---|---|
| I Olfactory | Identify a familiar smell, each nostril | Anosmia after head trauma (cribriform plate), frontal tumor, early Parkinson disease |
| II Optic | Acuity, visual fields by confrontation, pupillary light reflex, fundus | Field cut (stroke, pituitary tumor: bitemporal hemianopia), papilledema (raised intracranial pressure) |
| III, IV, VI | Follow a target in an H pattern; pupils | III: eye down and out, ptosis, dilated pupil (aneurysm until proven otherwise); IV: vertical diplopia, head tilt; VI: failure of abduction |
| V Trigeminal | Facial sensation in three divisions, jaw clench, corneal reflex | Sensory loss, weak masseter, jaw deviating toward the weak side |
| VII Facial | Raise eyebrows, close eyes tightly, smile | Whole half face weak including forehead: peripheral (Bell palsy); forehead spared: central (stroke) |
| VIII Vestibulocochlear | Finger rub or whisper, Weber and Rinne, nystagmus | Sensorineural loss (acoustic neuroma if unilateral and progressive), vertigo |
| IX, X | Say "ah", gag reflex, voice | Uvula deviates away from the weak side, hoarseness, dysphagia |
| XI Accessory | Shrug and turn the head against resistance | Weak trapezius or sternocleidomastoid (often iatrogenic after neck node surgery) |
| XII Hypoglossal | Protrude the tongue | Tongue deviates toward the weak side, with atrophy and fasciculation in LMN lesions |
Cerebellar function is screened with finger to nose and heel to shin (dysmetria and intention tremor), rapid alternating movements (dysdiadochokinesia), tandem gait and observation for nystagmus and scanning speech. Cerebellar signs are ipsilateral to a hemispheric lesion, while midline (vermis) lesions mainly produce truncal and gait ataxia. The Romberg test (feet together, eyes closed) assesses proprioception rather than the cerebellum: a patient who is steady with eyes open but falls with them closed has a dorsal column or large fiber sensory deficit (B12 deficiency, diabetic neuropathy, tabes dorsalis). A patient with cerebellar ataxia is unsteady with eyes open as well.
Reasoning: A facial weakness that spares the forehead is a central (upper motor neuron) facial palsy, and with aphasia and right arm weakness it localizes to the left hemisphere: an acute stroke. Note the time last seen well and call emergency services immediately, because thrombolysis and thrombectomy are time limited. Do not examine or treat the neck. A Bell palsy, by contrast, weakens the whole half of the face including the forehead and produces no limb signs.
Localize with three tools at each root (dermatome, myotome, reflex), then decide whether the lesion is upper or lower motor neuron. Brisk reflexes, clonus, Babinski, Hoffmann and patterned spastic weakness put the lesion in the brain or cord; reduced reflexes, wasting and dermatomal or nerve specific loss put it in the root or nerve. New cranial nerve, cerebellar or central motor signs require emergency referral.
Section 4Peripheral vascular procedures
Pulses, color, temperature and refill
The peripheral vascular examination begins with inspection and touch: compare color, temperature, hair distribution, skin and nail texture, swelling and ulcers side to side. Chronic arterial insufficiency produces cool, pale, shiny, hairless skin, thickened nails and painful ulcers on the toes and pressure points; chronic venous insufficiency produces edema, brown hemosiderin staining, stasis dermatitis and shallow, less painful ulcers above the medial malleolus. Palpate the radial, brachial, femoral, popliteal, dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial pulses and grade them: 0 absent, 1+ diminished, 2+ normal, 3+ bounding (some scales add 4+). The dorsalis pedis is congenitally absent in a minority of people, so an isolated absent dorsalis pedis with a normal posterior tibial pulse is less meaningful than loss of both. Capillary refill after nail bed blanching should be under about 2 seconds (up to 3 seconds is often accepted in adults and the elderly); a prolonged refill suggests poor perfusion, though cold and dehydration slow it too.
| Procedure | How it is performed | Positive finding | Suggests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allen test | Patient makes a tight fist; examiner occludes the radial and ulnar arteries; hand opens (blanched); release one artery and time the flush; repeat for the other | Color fails to return within about 5 to 7 seconds after release | Occlusion or poor flow in the released artery, or an incomplete palmar arch |
| Adson, Wright, costoclavicular, Roos | See Chapter 3; radial pulse monitored in provocative positions | Pulse change with reproduction of symptoms | Thoracic outlet compression (arterial or neurogenic) |
| Arm blood pressure comparison | Pressure taken in both arms | Difference over 15 to 20 mmHg | Subclavian stenosis (subclavian steal), aortic dissection, coarctation |
| Carotid auscultation | Bell over the carotid with the breath held | Bruit | Turbulent flow, possible carotid stenosis; refer for duplex ultrasound if symptomatic or new |
| Buerger test | Supine leg elevated to 45 degrees for 1 to 2 minutes, then patient sits with legs dependent | Pallor on elevation, then slow return of color with dusky red dependent rubor | Severe peripheral arterial disease |
| Venous filling time | After elevation, the leg is lowered; time for the dorsal foot veins to fill | More than about 20 seconds | Arterial insufficiency (rapid filling under 5 seconds suggests venous incompetence) |
| Brodie Trendelenburg | Leg elevated to empty veins, tourniquet at the upper thigh, patient stands | Rapid filling from above on release | Incompetent saphenofemoral valve (varicose veins) |
| Abdominal aortic palpation | Both hands palpate above and left of the umbilicus | Pulsatile mass wider than about 3 cm, expanding laterally | Abdominal aortic aneurysm |
| Ankle brachial index | Doppler systolic pressures at the ankles and arms | 0.90 or less | Peripheral arterial disease |
The ankle brachial index
The ankle brachial index (ABI) is the ratio of the higher systolic pressure at the ankle (dorsalis pedis or posterior tibial, measured with a Doppler probe) to the higher of the two brachial systolic pressures. Each leg has its own ABI. It is the standard office test for peripheral arterial disease, with about 90 percent sensitivity and 95 percent specificity at a cutoff of 0.90. Calcified, noncompressible arteries in diabetes and chronic kidney disease falsely raise the ankle pressure, giving a value above 1.40 that hides disease; a toe brachial index is then used.
Vascular versus neurogenic claudication
Leg pain with walking in an older adult has two common causes, and the distinction is a favorite board item because both patients may also have back pain.
| Feature | Vascular claudication (PAD) | Neurogenic claudication (lumbar stenosis) |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Calf most often (buttock or thigh with aortoiliac disease) | Buttock, thigh and leg, often bilateral, with paresthesia |
| Walking distance | Fixed, reproducible | Variable |
| Relief | Standing still for 1 to 5 minutes | Sitting or bending forward; standing still is not enough |
| Posture | No effect | Worse with extension and standing, better flexed (shopping cart sign) |
| Uphill versus downhill | Uphill worse (more work) | Downhill worse (extension); uphill often easier |
| Stationary bicycle | Provokes pain | Usually tolerated (flexed posture) |
| Pulses and skin | Reduced pulses, trophic changes, bruits | Normal pulses and skin |
| Confirming test | ABI 0.90 or less | MRI showing stenosis in a matching clinical picture |
Reasoning: A fixed walking distance, relief by standing, trophic changes and weak pulses describe vascular claudication; the ABI is 92 divided by 148, or 0.62, confirming moderate peripheral arterial disease. Refer to his physician for cardiovascular risk management (PAD is a coronary disease equivalent), smoking cessation and supervised exercise therapy, and look for an abdominal aortic aneurysm. Rest pain, ulceration or a cold, pulseless limb would need urgent or emergency vascular referral.
Deep vein thrombosis
The classic Homans sign (calf pain on passive dorsiflexion) is neither sensitive nor specific and should not be used to rule DVT in or out. Probability is estimated with the Wells criteria: one point each for active cancer; paralysis, paresis or recent plaster immobilization of the leg; bed rest over 3 days or major surgery within 12 weeks; localized tenderness along the deep veins; swelling of the entire leg; calf circumference more than 3 cm greater than the other side (measured 10 cm below the tibial tuberosity); pitting edema confined to the symptomatic leg; collateral superficial (nonvaricose) veins; and previously documented DVT; minus two points if an alternative diagnosis is at least as likely. A score of 2 or more means DVT is likely and the patient needs same day compression ultrasound; a score below 2 means DVT is unlikely and a negative D-dimer can exclude it. A suspected DVT is never massaged, manipulated or treated with soft tissue work.
Reasoning: Wells points: recent major surgery 1, deep vein tenderness 1, calf swelling over 3 cm 1, unilateral pitting edema 1, for a score of 4: DVT likely. She needs same day referral for compression ultrasound, and emergency care if she develops dyspnea, chest pain or tachycardia suggesting pulmonary embolism. Do not apply soft tissue work or exercise to the calf, and do not rely on a negative Homans sign to reassure her.
Examine the vessels by comparison: color, temperature, pulses and refill side to side, pressures in both arms. Use the ABI to confirm peripheral arterial disease (0.90 or less), the history and the bicycle test to separate vascular from neurogenic claudication, and the Wells criteria rather than Homans sign for DVT. Acute ischemia, compartment syndrome, likely DVT and a pulsatile abdominal mass with pain are referral emergencies.
Section 5Putting the NMS exam together
Choose tests by hypothesis
An efficient examination is not a checklist of every eponym in the region. By the end of the history you should hold two or three ranked hypotheses, including at least one that must not be missed. Each test is chosen because its result will change that ranking. The usual sequence is: screen for red flags and safety; observe; take active and passive range of motion and resisted testing to identify the tissue type (contractile, inert or neural); do the neurologic screen if there are limb symptoms; then use a small number of provocative or special tests targeted at the leading hypotheses; palpate last, so that tenderness does not color the earlier findings. Stop when the answer is clear enough to act on.
Sensitivity, specificity and likelihood ratios
Sensitivity is the proportion of people with the condition who test positive; specificity is the proportion without it who test negative. A highly sensitive test rarely misses disease, so a negative result rules it out (SnNout): the negative SLR for disc herniation, the negative upper limb tension test for cervical radiculopathy, the Ottawa rules for fracture. A highly specific test rarely labels healthy people, so a positive result rules disease in (SpPin): the crossed SLR, the drop arm test, the pivot shift, Spurling. Predictive values depend on prevalence and so change from one clinic to another, which is why likelihood ratios are more useful.
The positive likelihood ratio (LR+) equals sensitivity divided by (1 minus specificity); the negative likelihood ratio (LR minus) equals (1 minus sensitivity) divided by specificity. An LR+ above 10 or an LR minus below 0.1 produces a large, often conclusive change in probability; 5 to 10 and 0.1 to 0.2 produce moderate changes; 2 to 5 and 0.2 to 0.5 small changes; values near 1 change nothing. A convenient approximation for pretest probabilities between about 10 and 90 percent: an LR of 2 adds about 15 percentage points, 5 adds about 30 and 10 adds about 45; an LR of 0.5 subtracts about 15, 0.2 about 30 and 0.1 about 45.
From complaint to localized lesion
Localization works by asking where one lesion could explain every finding. Weakness and sensory change confined to one root's territory with a matching reflex change localize to the root. Findings that follow a peripheral nerve's map but cross root boundaries localize to the nerve. Findings in more than one root and nerve in one limb suggest the plexus. Bilateral findings with upper motor neuron signs place the lesion in the cord or brain, and a sensory level on the trunk places it in the cord. Stocking and glove sensory loss with reduced ankle reflexes describes a length dependent polyneuropathy (diabetes, alcohol, B12 deficiency, chemotherapy). Fatigable weakness with ptosis and diplopia and normal sensation points to the neuromuscular junction (myasthenia gravis); symmetric proximal weakness with normal sensation and reflexes points to muscle.
| Presentation | Key clue | Most likely lesion | Must not miss alternative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Numb thumb and index finger | Brachioradialis reflex reduced, wrist extension weak, neck movement reproduces | C6 radiculopathy | Carpal tunnel (normal reflex, positive Phalen), myelopathy |
| Numb little and ring fingers, weak hand | Medial forearm spared, Froment positive, Tinel at elbow | Ulnar neuropathy at the elbow | C8 radiculopathy, Pancoast tumor (thenar and medial forearm involved, Horner syndrome) |
| Wrist drop after sleeping with the arm over a chair | Triceps intact, sensory loss on the dorsal first web space | Radial nerve at the spiral groove | C7 radiculopathy (triceps weak and reflex reduced) |
| Foot drop | Hip abduction and inversion normal, Tinel at fibular head | Common fibular nerve palsy | L5 radiculopathy, motor neuron disease |
| Anterolateral thigh burning, no weakness | Tight belt, obesity, pregnancy; normal reflexes | Meralgia paresthetica (lateral femoral cutaneous nerve) | L2 to L3 radiculopathy, pelvic mass |
| Bilateral leg weakness with brisk reflexes | Sensory level on the trunk, bladder change | Spinal cord compression | Transverse myelitis, metastasis, epidural abscess |
| Ascending symmetric weakness with lost reflexes | Recent viral illness, mild sensory symptoms | Guillain Barre syndrome | Cord compression; respiratory failure is the danger |
| Saddle numbness, bilateral sciatica, urinary retention | Reduced anal tone, absent ankle reflexes | Cauda equina syndrome | None more urgent: emergency MRI and surgery |
Reasoning: Thenar involvement (median, T1) and medial forearm sensory loss (medial antebrachial cutaneous, C8 to T1) place the lesion proximal to the ulnar nerve, at the lower trunk or C8 to T1 roots. Ptosis and miosis on the same side form a Horner syndrome. In a heavy smoker with night pain, this combination is a superior sulcus (Pancoast) tumor until proven otherwise. The next step is a chest radiograph and urgent medical referral, not treatment for cubital tunnel syndrome or thoracic outlet syndrome.
Reasoning: A negative SLR (LR minus about 0.3) and a negative slump, with a normal neurologic examination, make radiculopathy unlikely, and pain above the knee is more consistent with somatic referred pain. Centralization with extension suggests a lumbar discogenic source with a directional preference, and the negative sacroiliac cluster argues against the sacroiliac joint. She has nonspecific mechanical low back pain with an extension preference; management is reassurance, extension based exercise and manual therapy, with no imaging. Every test chosen here either ruled out a serious or more specific diagnosis or guided treatment, which is the point of a targeted examination.
Choose each test because its result can change your ranking of hypotheses. Use sensitive tests to rule out and specific tests to rule in, think in likelihood ratios, and remember that the same result means different things at different pretest probabilities. Localize by asking which single lesion explains every finding, and let the must not miss alternative decide how urgently to act.
The chapter in one breath
- Clear the neck and viscera before blaming the shoulder; compare active and passive range to separate capsular, contractile and neural problems.
- Drop arm and the external rotation lag sign are specific for cuff tears; Hawkins Kennedy with a painful arc and weak external rotation forms the impingement cluster.
- Phalen and carpal compression for carpal tunnel, Finkelstein for de Quervain, Froment for ulnar palsy; snuffbox tenderness is a scaphoid fracture until proven otherwise.
- Lachman is the best ACL test, the posterior drawer the best PCL test; McMurray and Thessaly test the menisci; valgus stress at 30 degrees isolates the MCL.
- The Ottawa ankle and knee rules are highly sensitive: a patient who meets no criterion needs no radiograph.
- Thompson detects Achilles rupture; the squeeze test detects syndesmotic injury; knee pain in an overweight adolescent with obligatory external rotation is SCFE.
- Localize roots with dermatome, myotome and reflex; L5 versus fibular palsy hinges on hip abduction and inversion.
- Upper motor neuron signs (hyperreflexia, clonus, Babinski, Hoffmann) put the lesion in the brain or cord; lower motor neuron signs (flaccidity, wasting, reduced reflexes) put it in the root, nerve or anterior horn.
- A forehead sparing facial palsy is central; with limb or speech signs it is a stroke and an emergency.
- ABI of 0.90 or less confirms peripheral arterial disease; over 1.40 means calcified vessels. Vascular claudication is relieved by standing still, neurogenic by sitting or flexing.
- Use the Wells criteria, not Homans sign, for DVT; a score of 2 or more needs same day ultrasound.
- SnNout and SpPin; think in likelihood ratios and pretest probability, and choose tests that change management.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Capsular pattern | A joint specific pattern of restriction from capsular disease; at the shoulder, external rotation is lost most, then abduction, then internal rotation. |
| Painful arc | Pain through 60 to 120 degrees of abduction (subacromial) or at 160 to 180 degrees (acromioclavicular). |
| Drop arm test | Inability to lower the abducted arm smoothly; specific for a full thickness rotator cuff tear. |
| External rotation lag sign | Drift of the arm out of passive external rotation when released, indicating a posterosuperior cuff tear. |
| O'Brien test | Resisted flexion of the adducted arm, thumb down then palm up; deep pain relieved by supination suggests a SLAP lesion. |
| Cozen test | Resisted wrist extension with a fist; lateral epicondyle pain indicates lateral epicondylalgia. |
| Phalen test | Sustained wrist flexion that reproduces median paresthesia in carpal tunnel syndrome. |
| Finkelstein test | Ulnar deviation with the thumb in the palm; radial styloid pain indicates de Quervain tenosynovitis. |
| Froment sign | Thumb IP flexion when pinching paper, substituting for a weak ulnar innervated adductor pollicis. |
| Lachman test | Anterior tibial translation at 20 to 30 degrees of knee flexion; the most accurate clinical ACL test. |
| Pivot shift | A reduction clunk of the lateral tibial plateau during flexion under valgus; very specific for ACL tear. |
| McMurray test | Tibial rotation with knee extension from full flexion; a painful joint line click suggests a meniscal tear. |
| Thessaly test | Rotation on a single leg with the knee bent 20 degrees; joint line pain suggests a meniscal tear. |
| Ottawa ankle rules | Palpation and weight bearing criteria that identify which ankle and foot injuries need radiographs. |
| Thompson test | Calf squeeze in the prone patient; absent plantar flexion indicates Achilles tendon rupture. |
| Squeeze test | Midcalf compression of tibia and fibula producing distal pain in a syndesmotic (high ankle) sprain. |
| Myotome | The group of muscles supplied mainly by one spinal root. |
| Dermatome | The area of skin supplied by the sensory fibers of one spinal root. |
| Upper motor neuron lesion | A lesion from cortex to corticospinal tract causing spasticity, hyperreflexia and pathologic reflexes. |
| Lower motor neuron lesion | A lesion from anterior horn cell to muscle causing flaccid weakness, wasting and reduced reflexes. |
| Babinski sign | Great toe extension with fanning of the toes on plantar stimulation; abnormal after infancy. |
| Clonus | Rhythmic involuntary contractions on sudden muscle stretch; more than three beats indicates an upper motor neuron lesion. |
| Dysdiadochokinesia | Impaired rapid alternating movements, a sign of cerebellar dysfunction. |
| Romberg test | Standing with feet together and eyes closed; falling indicates loss of proprioception. |
| Allen test | Timed reperfusion of the hand after releasing the radial or ulnar artery to check its patency. |
| Ankle brachial index | Ankle systolic pressure divided by brachial systolic pressure; 0.90 or less indicates peripheral arterial disease. |
| Wells criteria | A point score that estimates the probability of deep vein thrombosis and guides testing. |
| Homans sign | Calf pain on passive dorsiflexion; an unreliable historical sign of DVT. |
| Sensitivity | The proportion of people with a condition who test positive. |
| Specificity | The proportion of people without a condition who test negative. |
| Likelihood ratio | How much a test result multiplies the odds of disease; above 10 or below 0.1 is a large effect. |
| Horner syndrome | Ptosis, miosis and facial anhidrosis from interruption of the sympathetic chain, as in a Pancoast tumor. |
Check yourself
Imaging Decisions, Protection, Positioning and Report Writing
Part III rarely asks you to name a bone; it asks whether this patient needs a film at all, which view will answer the question, how to keep the dose down, what the image shows, and what you should write and recommend next. Imaging decisions are clinical decisions: a film ordered without a reason exposes the patient and finds incidental noise, while a film not ordered in the patient with red flags misses a fracture, tumor or infection. This chapter teaches the reasoning that connects the history to the right study, the right projection and the right report.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Decide when plain radiographs are indicated and when they are not, using red flags, the Canadian C spine rule, NEXUS and the Ottawa rules.
- Apply special cautions for pregnancy, children and repeat imaging, and explain why routine imaging of acute nonspecific low back pain is not recommended.
- Use ALARA, collimation, filtration, distance and technique factors (kVp, mAs, SID, grids) to minimize patient dose while keeping diagnostic quality.
- Choose standard and supplemental views (APOM, obliques, flexion and extension, swimmer's, Ferguson, scaphoid, mortise, tunnel, sunrise) for a given clinical question.
- Recognize normal radiographic anatomy, the cervical lines and measurements, and common normal variants that mimic disease.
- Search a film systematically with ABCS and describe a bone lesion by location, margin (Lodwick), matrix and periosteal reaction.
- Write a radiology report with findings, an impression and specific recommendations, and communicate urgent findings appropriately.
- Select MRI, CT, bone scan, ultrasound or DEXA as the next study and decide how urgently it is needed.
Section 1Indications and contraindications for imaging
The question comes first
Every film should answer a question that will change management. Before ordering, state the question in one line: "Is there a fracture after this fall?", "Is there destructive bone disease in this 68 year old with night pain and weight loss?", "Is there instability after this flexion injury?" If you cannot write the question, or if no possible answer would alter what you do, the film is not indicated. Plain radiographs are excellent for fracture, gross alignment, advanced degeneration, many bone tumors and congenital anomalies. They are poor for disc herniation, nerve root compression, early infection, early metastasis (roughly 30 to 50 percent of trabecular bone must be lost before a lytic lesion shows), ligament injury and soft tissue disease. Knowing these limits is as important as knowing the indications.
Red flags that justify imaging
For spinal pain, current guidelines agree that routine imaging of acute low back pain without red flags is not helpful: findings such as disc degeneration and facet arthrosis are common in people without pain, they do not predict outcome, and early imaging is associated with more procedures, more time off work and no better recovery. Imaging becomes appropriate when the history or examination raises suspicion of serious pathology, or when a patient fails to improve after about 4 to 6 weeks of appropriate care.
| Red flag | Condition suspected | First study and urgency |
|---|---|---|
| Significant trauma, or minor trauma in a patient over 50, with osteoporosis or on long term corticosteroids | Fracture | Radiographs promptly; CT if radiographs are equivocal or high risk; stop manipulation of the region until cleared |
| History of cancer, unexplained weight loss, age over 50, night pain, failure to improve in a month | Metastasis, myeloma | Radiographs plus ESR and CBC; MRI if suspicion remains; history of cancer with new back pain warrants MRI |
| Fever, IV drug use, recent bacteremia or urinary infection, immunosuppression, spinal procedure | Vertebral osteomyelitis, discitis, epidural abscess | MRI with contrast plus CBC, ESR, CRP, blood cultures; same day if neurological signs |
| Saddle anesthesia, urinary retention or incontinence, bilateral sciatica, progressive leg weakness | Cauda equina syndrome | Emergency department for MRI now; do not wait for plain films |
| Progressive or severe motor deficit | Large herniation, tumor, abscess | Urgent MRI and surgical opinion |
| Young adult with inflammatory back pain over 3 months | Axial spondyloarthritis | AP pelvis or sacroiliac view; MRI of sacroiliac joints if films are normal and suspicion persists |
| Pulsatile abdominal mass, tearing back pain, vascular risk factors | Abdominal aortic aneurysm | Ultrasound (stable) or emergency department (pain, hypotension) |
Decision rules for cervical trauma
Two validated rules decide whether an alert, stable adult with neck trauma needs cervical imaging. The Canadian C spine rule asks three questions in sequence. First, is there any high risk factor that mandates imaging: age 65 or older, a dangerous mechanism (fall from 3 feet or 5 stairs or more, axial load to the head as in diving, high speed motor vehicle collision over 100 km/h or with rollover or ejection, motorized recreational vehicle, bicycle collision), or paresthesias in the extremities? If yes, image. Second, is there a low risk factor that allows safe assessment of range of motion: simple rear end collision, sitting position in the emergency department, ambulatory at any time, delayed onset of neck pain, or absence of midline cervical tenderness? If none is present, image. Third, can the patient actively rotate the neck 45 degrees left and right? If yes, no imaging is needed; if not, image. The rule has a sensitivity close to 100 percent for clinically important cervical injury. It does not apply to patients under 16, those with a Glasgow Coma Scale below 15, unstable vital signs, acute paralysis, known vertebral disease or prior cervical surgery.
The NEXUS criteria say imaging is not needed if all five are present: no posterior midline cervical tenderness, no focal neurological deficit, normal alertness, no intoxication, and no painful distracting injury. NEXUS is simpler but somewhat less specific than the Canadian rule. In an emergency setting, CT is now the preferred first study for adults who meet imaging criteria, because it is far more sensitive than plain films for fractures; in the chiropractic office, the decision that matters is that the patient needs imaging before any cervical manipulation, and that a high risk patient is immobilized and sent for it.
Extremity decision rules
The Ottawa ankle rules call for ankle radiographs when there is pain in the malleolar zone plus bone tenderness at the posterior edge or tip of either malleolus (distal 6 cm) or inability to bear weight for four steps both immediately and at examination. Foot films are indicated for midfoot pain plus tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal or the navicular, or the same inability to bear weight. Sensitivity approaches 100 percent, so a negative rule reliably excludes fracture. The Ottawa knee rule calls for films with age 55 or older, isolated patellar tenderness, fibular head tenderness, inability to flex to 90 degrees, or inability to bear weight for four steps.
When imaging is not indicated
- Acute nonspecific low back or neck pain under about 6 weeks with no red flags.
- Routine films to "find subluxations", to establish a baseline for every new patient, or to document progress in an improving patient. Repeat films need a new clinical question.
- Imaging for reassurance alone, or to satisfy an insurer, when the result would not change care.
- Radiographs when the question is a soft tissue one (disc herniation, cord, ligament, tendon) and the next step would be MRI or ultrasound anyway.
Pregnancy and children
Ask every patient of reproductive age about pregnancy and the date of the last menstrual period before any exposure that includes the abdomen or pelvis, and document the answer. Elective imaging is deferred during pregnancy. When imaging is truly needed, the dose of a single lumbar or pelvic series is well below the threshold associated with fetal malformation (commonly taught as about 50 to 100 mGy); a lumbar series delivers a fetal dose on the order of 1 to 4 mGy. The theoretical concern at low doses is a small increase in childhood cancer risk, so the rule is to avoid unnecessary exposure, prefer nonionizing studies (ultrasound, MRI without gadolinium), and never withhold a necessary study. The older "10 day rule" (elective pelvic exposure only in the first 10 days after menses onset) reflects the same principle.
Children are more radiosensitive than adults because their tissues are dividing and they have more years in which a cancer can develop. Their unfused growth plates, ossification centers and normal pseudosubluxation also make films easy to misread. Image children only for specific indications, use the fewest views, collimate tightly and use pediatric technique factors. Scoliosis follow up should use the lowest dose method available, PA projection and the minimum number of films needed to make treatment decisions.
Reasoning: Age 65 or older is a high risk factor under the Canadian C spine rule, so she needs imaging regardless of other findings; range of motion should not be tested and the neck must not be manipulated. Older patients often fracture the dens or the lower cervical spine from low energy falls, and degenerative change can hide fractures on plain film. The correct step is to stop, immobilize if there is concern for instability and refer for CT the same day. Treating first and imaging "if it does not improve" would be wrong.
Image when a red flag, a validated decision rule or failure of appropriate care says the result could change management. Do not image acute nonspecific pain, do not repeat films without a new question, ask about pregnancy before every abdominal or pelvic exposure, and treat children as the most radiosensitive patients you have.
Section 2Patient protection and positioning
ALARA and the three cardinal principles
ALARA means keeping exposure "as low as reasonably achievable" while still producing a diagnostic image. For the operator, the three cardinal principles are time (minimize it), distance (maximize it) and shielding (use it). Distance works through the inverse square law: intensity is proportional to 1 divided by the square of the distance, so doubling the distance from a source reduces exposure to one fourth. The operator stands behind the control booth barrier, never holds a patient during exposure, and wears a dosimeter badge. The main source of operator exposure is scatter from the patient, not the primary beam.
For the patient, dose is reduced mostly by avoiding unnecessary films, then by technique: tight collimation, adequate filtration, appropriate kVp and mAs, fast image receptors, correct positioning on the first attempt (repeats double the dose) and, where regulations require it, shielding.
Collimation, filtration and shielding
- Collimation restricts the beam to the area of interest. It is the single most effective technical way to reduce patient dose, and because less tissue is irradiated it also produces less scatter, which improves contrast. The collimated field must never be larger than the image receptor, and a visible collimation border on all sides is evidence of good practice.
- Filtration (aluminum in the tube housing, at least 2.5 mm aluminum equivalent total for units above 70 kVp) absorbs low energy photons that would be absorbed in skin without contributing to the image. Compensating (wedge or trough) filters even out density across body parts of unequal thickness, for example the cervicothoracic junction or a full spine film.
- Shielding of the gonads, thyroid and breast has traditionally been taught when these organs lie within or near (about 5 cm) the primary beam and the shield will not obscure the anatomy of interest. Current physics guidance has moved away from routine gonadal and fetal shielding, because modern equipment uses automatic exposure control that may increase dose when a shield enters the field, and shields frequently hide pathology and force repeat films. Follow the regulations that apply where you practice; for the exam, know both the traditional rule and the reason it is changing.
Technique factors
| Factor | What it controls | Effect of increasing it | Practical point |
|---|---|---|---|
| kVp (peak kilovoltage) | Beam energy and penetration; contrast scale | More penetration, longer scale (lower) contrast, more scatter, lower skin dose for the same receptor exposure | 15 percent rule: raising kVp 15 percent has the same effect on receptor exposure as doubling mAs |
| mAs (milliamperage times seconds) | Number of photons (quantity); density | Darker film (more receptor exposure), directly proportional increase in patient dose | Use short exposure time with higher mA to reduce motion blur |
| SID (source to image distance) | Magnification and sharpness | Less magnification, sharper image, needs more mAs | 40 inches (100 cm) for most views; 72 inches (180 cm) for lateral cervical, chest and full spine films |
| OID (object to image distance) | Magnification | More magnification and blur | Place the part of interest closest to the receptor |
| Grid | Removes scatter before it reaches the receptor | Better contrast, but more mAs and dose needed | Use for parts thicker than about 10 to 12 cm; extremities are done without a grid |
| Focal spot | Geometric sharpness | Small focal spot gives sharper detail but tolerates less heat | Small spot for extremities and fine detail |
With digital radiography, an underexposed image looks noisy while an overexposed image still looks good because software rescales brightness. This allows dose creep, in which operators drift toward higher exposures without noticing. Watching the exposure index and staying within the manufacturer's target range is the digital version of ALARA.
Standard and supplemental views
Every region has a minimum standard series, and long bones and joints always need at least two views at 90 degrees to each other, because a fracture or dislocation can be invisible in a single plane. For a long bone, include the joints above and below. Supplemental views are added to answer a specific question raised by the history, examination or the standard films.
| Region | Standard series | Supplemental view | Add it when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cervical | AP open mouth (APOM), AP lower cervical, neutral lateral | Obliques | Radicular arm symptoms: shows the intervertebral foramina and uncovertebral spurs |
| Cervical | Flexion and extension laterals | Suspected ligamentous instability, but only after fracture is excluded and in a cooperative patient; often delayed 1 to 2 weeks after trauma because spasm hides instability | |
| Cervical | Swimmer's lateral | C7 and T1 not seen on the neutral lateral because of the shoulders | |
| Cervical | Pillar (articular pillar) view | Suspected lateral mass or pillar fracture | |
| Thoracic | AP and lateral | Swimmer's lateral, rib series | Upper thoracic levels hidden; rib fracture or lesion |
| Lumbar | AP and lateral | L5 to S1 spot (coned) lateral | Lumbosacral disc space or L5 poorly seen on the full lateral |
| Lumbar | Obliques | Suspected spondylolysis: the pars defect appears as a collar on the "Scottie dog" neck | |
| Lumbar and pelvis | AP pelvis | Ferguson (AP with 25 to 30 degree cephalad tilt) | Sacroiliac joints and the L5 to S1 junction seen en face, as in suspected sacroiliitis or transitional segment |
| Shoulder | AP internal and external rotation | Scapular Y, axillary | Trauma or suspected dislocation: shows posterior dislocation that an AP can miss |
| Wrist | PA, lateral, oblique | Scaphoid (PA in ulnar deviation) | Anatomical snuffbox tenderness after a fall on an outstretched hand |
| Knee | AP, lateral | Tunnel (intercondylar), sunrise (skyline, Merchant) | Osteochondritis dissecans, loose bodies; patellofemoral alignment and patellar fracture |
| Ankle | AP, lateral, mortise (15 to 20 degree internal rotation) | Stress views | Mortise shows the joint space and syndesmosis evenly; stress views for ligament instability |
Reasoning: The clinical question is spondylolysis, and the view that best shows a pars defect is the lumbar oblique, but the obliques add dose and many guidelines now favor a lateral plus targeted advanced imaging. Before any exposure that includes her pelvis, the pregnancy question must be resolved: she is late in her cycle, so a pregnancy test comes first, and the films are deferred until it is negative. If imaging is needed during pregnancy, MRI without contrast avoids ionizing radiation. Collimate tightly, use a PA projection where appropriate and avoid unnecessary views.
Patient dose is reduced first by not taking unnecessary films and then by collimation, filtration, proper kVp and mAs, long SID, correct positioning on the first attempt and attention to digital exposure indices. Standard series give two planes at 90 degrees; supplemental views are added only to answer a specific question.
Section 3Normal radiographic anatomy and variants in cases
Why normal comes first
Most misreads on Part III come from two directions: calling a normal variant disease (and frightening or overtreating the patient) or accepting real disease as normal. The protection against both is a confident picture of normal on each standard view, including the lines and measurements that define alignment, and a short list of variants that are known to mimic pathology.
The lateral cervical film
The neutral lateral is the single most informative cervical view. On it, four smooth, roughly parallel curves should be traced: the anterior vertebral line along the front of the bodies, the posterior vertebral line (George's line) along the back of the bodies, which forms the anterior wall of the canal, the spinolaminar line joining the junctions of the laminae with the spinous processes, which forms the posterior wall of the canal, and the posterior spinous line through the spinous tips. A step in any line suggests translation (subluxation, dislocation, spondylolisthesis), and fanning of the spinous processes suggests posterior ligament disruption.
| Measurement on the lateral cervical film | Normal (adult unless stated) | Abnormal means |
|---|---|---|
| Atlantodental interval (ADI) | 3 mm or less adult; 5 mm or less child | Transverse ligament laxity or rupture: trauma, rheumatoid arthritis, Down syndrome, ankylosing spondylitis, retropharyngeal infection in children (Grisel) |
| Retropharyngeal soft tissue at C2 | 7 mm or less | Hematoma (occult fracture), abscess, mass |
| Retrotracheal soft tissue at C6 | 22 mm or less (14 mm in children) | Hematoma, abscess, tumor |
| Sagittal canal diameter (back of body to spinolaminar line), C3 to C7 | About 13 mm or more; below 10 mm is absolute stenosis | Congenital or degenerative stenosis, risk of myelopathy |
| Canal to body ratio (Torg or Pavlov) | 1.0 or more; below 0.8 suggests stenosis | Developmental stenosis; uses a ratio so magnification does not matter |
| Horizontal translation of one body on another | Less than 3.5 mm | Instability (White and Panjabi criterion) |
| Angulation between adjacent segments | Less than 11 degrees more than neighbors | Instability |
The other standard views
- APOM: the dens sits centered between the lateral masses of C1, the lateral masses of C1 line up with the articular pillars of C2, and the joint spaces are symmetric. Bilateral overhang of the C1 lateral masses beyond C2 totaling more than about 7 mm suggests a Jefferson burst fracture with transverse ligament rupture. In young children, physiological overhang (pseudospread of the atlas) is normal.
- AP lower cervical: spinous processes in a straight line (a sudden rotational offset suggests unilateral facet dislocation), uncinate processes and uncovertebral joints visible, pedicles and lateral masses symmetric, trachea midline.
- AP lumbar: paired oval pedicles ("owl's eyes") at every level; the interpediculate distance normally widens gradually from L1 to L5. A missing pedicle ("winking owl" sign) suggests lytic metastasis, while widening of the interpediculate distance suggests an intraspinal mass or burst fracture. Psoas shadows, renal outlines, sacroiliac joints and the hips are reviewed in the same film.
- Lateral lumbar: disc heights increase from L1 to L4 to L5; L5 to S1 is often slightly narrower and that alone is not abnormal. George's line should be continuous. The lumbosacral (Ferguson's sacral base) angle averages about 41 degrees (normal range roughly 26 to 57); the lumbar lordosis is measured from the top of L1 to the sacral base.
- Oblique lumbar: the "Scottie dog": nose (transverse process), eye (pedicle), ear (superior articular process), neck (pars interarticularis), body (lamina), front leg (inferior articular process). A collar on the neck is spondylolysis; a decapitated dog suggests spondylolisthesis.
- Thoracic AP and lateral: pedicles at every level, paraspinal lines close to the spine (a bulging paraspinal line suggests hematoma, abscess or tumor), smooth kyphosis about 20 to 40 degrees, and vertebral body heights equal anteriorly and posteriorly (an anterior height loss over about 20 percent suggests compression fracture).
Variants that mimic disease
| Variant | Appearance | Mimics | How to tell it apart |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pseudosubluxation of C2 on C3 (children under about 8) | Anterior offset of C2 on C3 in flexion | Traumatic subluxation, hangman fracture | Swischuk line from the anterior C1 to C3 spinolaminar junctions passes within about 2 mm of the C2 spinolaminar point |
| Os odontoideum | Smooth, corticated ossicle above a short dens with a wide gap | Type II dens fracture | Fracture line is thin, irregular and not corticated; os is round and well corticated, often with hypertrophied C1 anterior arch. Both may be unstable: flexion and extension views or specialist opinion |
| Mach band over the dens | Thin dark line where an overlapping edge (tongue, teeth, arch) crosses the dens | Dens fracture | Line extends beyond the bone margins; repeat APOM with slight tube or head change makes it move |
| Ponticulus posticus (Kimmerle anomaly) | Bony bridge over the vertebral artery groove on the posterior arch of C1 | Not disease; a common incidental finding | Note it; some authors advise caution with upper cervical rotation, though evidence of harm is limited |
| Limbus bone | Triangular fragment at the anterosuperior corner of a lumbar body | Avulsion or teardrop fracture | Intraosseous disc herniation under a ring apophysis: corticated margins, matching defect, no soft tissue swelling |
| Schmorl node | Rounded endplate depression with sclerotic margin | Lytic lesion, compression fracture | Vertical disc herniation into the body; sharply marginated, sclerotic, often multiple |
| Transitional lumbosacral segment | Enlarged L5 transverse process articulating with sacrum, or a sixth lumbar type segment | Wrong level count, Bertolotti pain | Count from C2 or from the ribs; report the anatomy so levels match surgical and MRI reports |
| Spina bifida occulta | Midline lamina gap, often S1 or L5 | Lytic lesion | Incidental in about 1 in 5 people; no clinical significance alone |
| Bone island (enostosis) | Small dense focus with spiculated "brush border" blending into trabeculae | Blastic metastasis | Usually under 1 cm, stable over time, cold or minimally warm on bone scan |
| Block vertebra | Fused bodies with a rudimentary disc and a waist ("wasp waist") | Healed infection, surgical fusion | The concave waist and often fused posterior elements indicate a congenital failure of segmentation |
| Hahn venous clefts | Horizontal lucent lines in the midportion of the posterior body | Fracture | Midbody location, symmetric, smooth, no displacement |
| Unfused apophyses and accessory ossicles (os acromiale, os trigonum, accessory navicular) | Smooth corticated fragments at typical sites | Fracture | Fractures have sharp, noncorticated edges; variants are often bilateral, so a comparison view helps |
Reasoning: In young children, physiological laxity and horizontally oriented facets allow C2 to glide forward on C3 in flexion. Draw the Swischuk (posterior cervical) line from the spinolaminar junction of C1 to that of C3: if the C2 spinolaminar point lies within about 2 mm of the line, this is pseudosubluxation, not injury. With a benign mechanism, normal examination and a normal Swischuk line, no further imaging is needed. A C2 spinolaminar point 2 mm or more behind the line, or prevertebral swelling, would suggest a true hangman type injury and require CT and referral.
Know what normal looks like on every standard view, trace the four lateral cervical lines and measure the ADI, canal and prevertebral soft tissues on every trauma film. Smooth, corticated, often bilateral findings at typical sites are usually variants; sharp, noncorticated, tender findings with soft tissue swelling are injuries.
Section 4Description and interpretation of images
A systematic search
Satisfaction of search, stopping after the first abnormality, is the classic interpretive error. A fixed sequence prevents it. Begin with the label (name, date, side marker, view), confirm the film is adequate (positioning, exposure, the whole region included), and then follow ABCS:
- A, alignment: the curves and lines described above, translation, rotation, scoliosis, listhesis, joint congruity.
- B, bone: each bone's size, shape, outline (cortex continuity) and density (generalized osteopenia or sclerosis, focal lytic or blastic lesions). Count the pedicles. Check the endplates, posterior elements and the edges of the film.
- C, cartilage (joint spaces): uniform versus nonuniform narrowing, subchondral sclerosis, cysts, osteophytes, erosions, calcification of cartilage (chondrocalcinosis), fusion.
- S, soft tissues: prevertebral swelling, paraspinal lines, psoas shadows, abdominal aorta calcification and diameter, renal and gallbladder stones, lung apices, foreign bodies, soft tissue calcification or gas.
Review "hot spots" deliberately: the dens and C1 to C2 on every cervical film, the lung apices, the abdominal aorta (an aortic wall more than 3 cm apart suggests aneurysm), the hips and sacroiliac joints on lumbar films, and the corners of the image where tumors hide.
Describing a bone lesion
Plain film features remain the best way to judge whether a bone lesion is slow growing (usually benign) or aggressive (malignancy or infection). Age is the most powerful clue: a solitary aggressive lesion under 30 suggests a primary tumor such as osteosarcoma or Ewing sarcoma, while over 40 the leading diagnoses become metastasis and multiple myeloma.
- Location: which bone; axial or appendicular; epiphysis (chondroblastoma, giant cell tumor after physeal closure), metaphysis (osteosarcoma, osteochondroma, nonossifying fibroma), diaphysis (Ewing sarcoma, fibrous dysplasia, myeloma); central, eccentric or cortical; vertebral body versus posterior elements (metastasis destroys the pedicle and body, aneurysmal bone cyst and osteoblastoma favor the posterior elements).
- Size and number: solitary or multiple; multiple lytic lesions over 40 suggest metastasis or myeloma.
- Margin and zone of transition: graded with the Lodwick system (below). A narrow zone of transition means slow growth; a wide one means aggressive growth.
- Matrix: what the lesion produces. Osteoid matrix is cloudlike or ivory dense (osteosarcoma, osteoblastic metastasis); chondroid matrix shows rings and arcs or popcorn calcification (enchondroma, chondrosarcoma); fibrous matrix gives a hazy ground glass density (fibrous dysplasia).
- Periosteal reaction: solid, thick, uninterrupted new bone means a slow process; interrupted reactions (lamellated "onion skin", spiculated "sunburst" or "hair on end", and the Codman triangle where elevated periosteum is broken through) mean an aggressive process.
- Cortical breakthrough and soft tissue mass: both indicate aggression.
| Feature | Favors slow growing (benign) | Favors aggressive (malignant or infection) |
|---|---|---|
| Margin | Geographic, sclerotic rim (Lodwick IA) | Moth eaten or permeative (II, III) |
| Zone of transition | Narrow, sharp | Wide, indistinct |
| Periosteal reaction | None or solid | Lamellated, spiculated, Codman triangle |
| Cortex | Intact, may be thinned and expanded | Destroyed, breached |
| Soft tissue mass | Absent | Present |
| Size and change | Small, stable on comparison films | Large, enlarging over weeks |
| Symptoms | Incidental, painless (except osteoid osteoma, night pain relieved by NSAIDs) | Progressive, night pain, systemic symptoms |
Writing the report
A report is a legal and clinical document that another provider must be able to act on. A standard structure is:
- Identifying data: patient name, date of birth, date of study, facility, referring clinician.
- Clinical history: the question being asked ("fall, midline C6 tenderness, rule out fracture").
- Views obtained and their quality, including limitations ("C7 obscured by shoulders").
- Findings: organized by ABCS, describing what is seen in neutral terms (location, size, margin, matrix, periosteal reaction), including pertinent negatives ("no prevertebral soft tissue swelling") and incidental findings.
- Impression: the conclusion in order of importance: the most significant or most likely diagnosis first, then a short differential, then minor or incidental findings. The impression is what busy readers read, so it must stand on its own.
- Recommendations: specific and actionable: the next study (MRI, CT, bone scan, swimmer's view, follow up films in a stated interval), laboratory tests (CBC, ESR, CRP, SPEP, PSA), referral (orthopedic, oncology, emergency department) and urgency.
Findings that need action within hours, such as an unstable fracture, cord compression, aggressive lesion, aortic aneurysm or free intraperitoneal air, must be communicated directly (by phone or in person) to the responsible clinician or patient, and the communication (time, person, content) documented. Leaving a critical finding in a report that may not be read for days is a standard of care failure.
Reasoning: Age, metaphyseal location around the knee, osteoid (cloudlike) matrix and aggressive periosteal reaction point to osteosarcoma; the differential includes Ewing sarcoma (more often diaphyseal, lamellated reaction, no osteoid matrix) and osteomyelitis. The report impression should state "aggressive bone forming lesion of the distal femoral metaphysis, most consistent with osteosarcoma" and recommend MRI of the entire femur and urgent orthopedic oncology referral within days, communicated directly to the family. Do not attribute the pain to a sports strain, and do not have a local biopsy done outside the treating sarcoma center, because a poorly placed biopsy can compromise limb salvage.
Search every film the same way (label, adequacy, alignment, bone, cartilage, soft tissue, hot spots), describe lesions by location, margin, matrix, periosteal reaction and soft tissue, and let age guide the differential. The report must end in a clear impression and specific recommendations, and critical findings must be communicated directly and documented.
Section 5Choosing advanced imaging in cases
Match the study to the tissue and the question
Each advanced study sees a different property of tissue. CT measures X-ray attenuation in thin slices and shows cortical bone in fine detail. MRI maps the behavior of hydrogen protons in a magnetic field and shows water, fat and soft tissue contrast, including marrow, discs, nerves, cord and ligaments. A bone scan (technetium 99m methylene diphosphonate) shows osteoblastic activity and blood flow anywhere in the skeleton. Ultrasound shows tendons, muscles, fluid and vessels in real time without radiation. DEXA measures areal bone mineral density. Choosing well means knowing which property answers the question.
| Study | Best for | Limitations and contraindications |
|---|---|---|
| MRI | Disc herniation with radiculopathy, cauda equina and cord compression, infection (discitis, osteomyelitis, epidural abscess), marrow replacement by tumor, occult and stress fractures, ligament, meniscus and cartilage injury, soft tissue masses | Nonconditional pacemakers and defibrillators, cochlear implants, some aneurysm clips, metallic foreign body in the orbit (screen welders with orbit films), claustrophobia; gadolinium contrast avoided when eGFR is below 30 (nephrogenic systemic fibrosis) and in pregnancy |
| CT | Acute spinal and complex fractures, fracture healing and nonunion, pars defects, facet and posterior element detail, bony stenosis, surgical planning; CT myelography when MRI is contraindicated | Higher radiation dose than plain films (a lumbar CT is roughly equal to several hundred chest films); poorer soft tissue contrast; iodinated contrast risks (allergy, kidney injury) |
| Bone scan (Tc 99m MDP), with SPECT | Survey of the whole skeleton for metastasis, stress fracture, osteomyelitis, occult fracture, Paget disease; SPECT localizes active pars defects and facet arthropathy | Very sensitive, not specific (tumor, fracture, infection and arthritis all "light up"); often cold or normal in multiple myeloma and in very aggressive purely lytic lesions; radiation dose |
| Ultrasound | Rotator cuff and other tendon tears, effusions, Baker cyst, soft tissue masses, abdominal aortic aneurysm screening, deep vein thrombosis, dynamic and guided studies | Operator dependent; cannot see through bone; limited for deep structures |
| DEXA | Diagnosing osteoporosis and estimating fracture risk; monitoring therapy (not more often than about every 2 years) | Degenerative spurs, aortic calcification and compression fractures falsely raise lumbar values; it measures density, not bone quality |
| PET CT | Staging known cancer, unknown primary, treatment response | Cost, radiation, not a first line musculoskeletal test |
MRI signal basics for case questions
On T1 weighted images fat is bright and water is dark, so T1 is the anatomy and marrow sequence: normal adult marrow is bright from fat, and a dark marrow on T1 means replacement by tumor, infection or edema. On T2 weighted images water is bright, so cerebrospinal fluid, edema, cysts, a hydrated disc nucleus and inflammation are bright; a dark ("black") disc on T2 is a desiccated, degenerated disc. STIR and fat suppressed T2 sequences darken fat so that edema stands out, which is ideal for stress reactions, acute fractures and sacroiliitis. Gadolinium enhancement highlights vascular or inflamed tissue: it separates scar (enhances) from recurrent disc herniation (does not enhance centrally) after surgery, outlines abscesses and characterizes tumors.
A classic pattern contrast: in vertebral osteomyelitis and discitis the disc itself is destroyed and bright on T2, with adjacent endplates eroded and both vertebral bodies showing edema; in metastasis the disc is typically preserved while the body and pedicle are replaced. "The disc crosses the infection, the tumor respects the disc" is a useful board shortcut.
Timing: when each study becomes positive
Plain films lag behind biology. Osteomyelitis takes about 10 to 14 days to produce radiographic bone destruction; stress fractures may not show periosteal callus for 2 to 3 weeks, and some never do; a lytic metastasis must remove roughly a third to a half of trabecular bone before it is visible; scaphoid waist fractures are missed on initial films in a meaningful minority of patients. MRI and bone scan become positive within a day or two. This is why a normal radiograph does not exclude early infection, stress fracture or metastasis in a patient whose history suggests them.
Deciding the next study and how fast
| Clinical scenario | Next study | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| Saddle anesthesia, urinary retention, bilateral or progressive leg weakness | MRI lumbar spine | Emergency, same day via the emergency department |
| Known cancer with new spinal pain, especially with neurological signs | MRI whole spine | Same day if neurological deficit (metastatic cord compression); within days otherwise |
| Fever, raised CRP, focal spinal pain | MRI with gadolinium plus blood cultures | Urgent, within 24 hours; emergency if neurological signs |
| Radicular pain without red flags or progressive deficit | No imaging initially; MRI if not improving after about 6 weeks and the patient is a candidate for injection or surgery | Elective |
| Snuffbox tenderness, normal initial scaphoid films | Thumb spica immobilization, then repeat films in 10 to 14 days, or MRI now | Within days; untreated scaphoid fractures risk avascular necrosis and nonunion |
| Runner with focal tibial or metatarsal pain, normal films | MRI (bone scan if MRI unavailable) | Within 1 to 2 weeks; femoral neck stress fracture is urgent because it can displace |
| Suspected rotator cuff tear with weakness | Ultrasound or MRI | Within weeks; sooner for acute traumatic tear in a younger patient (repair works best early) |
| Bone pain, anemia, high ESR, hypercalcemia in an older adult | Serum and urine protein electrophoresis, skeletal survey or low dose whole body CT, MRI | Urgent; bone scan may be falsely normal in myeloma |
| Woman 65 or older, man 70 or older, or younger with risk factors or a fragility fracture | DEXA of the hip and lumbar spine | Routine |
| Pulsatile abdominal mass or male smoker 65 to 75 | Abdominal ultrasound | Routine screening; emergency department if painful or hypotensive |
DEXA interpretation
The T score compares the patient with a young adult of the same sex at peak bone mass: minus 1.0 or higher is normal, between minus 1.0 and minus 2.5 is low bone mass (osteopenia), and minus 2.5 or lower is osteoporosis. A fragility fracture of the hip or spine establishes osteoporosis regardless of the T score. The Z score compares the patient with people of the same age and sex and is used for premenopausal women, men under 50 and children; a Z score of minus 2.0 or lower is "below the expected range for age" and should prompt a search for a secondary cause (steroids, hyperparathyroidism, celiac disease, hypogonadism, myeloma). The FRAX tool combines bone density with clinical risk factors to estimate 10 year fracture probability.
Reasoning: Saddle anesthesia, new urinary hesitancy and bilateral radicular symptoms indicate cauda equina syndrome, most often from a large central disc herniation. This is a surgical emergency: outcome depends on decompression before complete retention develops, ideally within 48 hours of onset and the sooner the better. Send him to the emergency department now for MRI and surgical evaluation, call ahead, and document. Do not manipulate, do not order plain films first and do not schedule an outpatient MRI for next week.
Reasoning: A cancer history plus night pain is a strong red flag, and radiographs miss metastases until much of the trabecular bone is gone. The negative film does not lower suspicion enough. The next study is MRI of the whole spine (it shows marrow replacement and any epidural extension), with CBC, ESR, calcium and alkaline phosphatase, and prompt communication with her oncologist. Should she develop leg weakness, numbness or bladder change before the MRI, she needs same day emergency imaging for metastatic cord compression.
Choose MRI for soft tissue, marrow, nerve and early infection; CT for bony detail and complex fracture; bone scan for a sensitive skeletal survey (except myeloma); ultrasound for tendons, vessels and fluid without radiation; DEXA for bone density. Plain films lag one to three weeks behind disease, so a normal film does not end the workup when the history is worrying, and urgency is set by neurological status.
The chapter in one breath
- Image only when the answer could change management: red flags, validated rules or failure of about 4 to 6 weeks of care; do not image acute nonspecific spinal pain.
- The Canadian C spine rule images any patient 65 or older, with a dangerous mechanism or limb paresthesias; otherwise a low risk factor plus active 45 degree rotation each way clears the neck. NEXUS uses five criteria.
- Ask about pregnancy before abdominal or pelvic exposure, prefer nonionizing studies when pregnant, and remember that children are the most radiosensitive patients.
- ALARA: avoid unnecessary films, then use tight collimation, filtration, appropriate kVp and mAs, long SID, correct first attempt positioning and attention to digital exposure index.
- Standard series give two views at 90 degrees; supplemental views (obliques, swimmer's, flexion and extension, Ferguson, scaphoid, mortise, tunnel, sunrise, Y and axillary) answer specific questions.
- On the lateral cervical film trace the four lines and measure the ADI (3 mm adult, 5 mm child), prevertebral soft tissue (7 mm at C2, 22 mm at C6) and canal diameter.
- Corticated, smooth, bilateral findings are usually variants; know pseudosubluxation, os odontoideum, limbus bone, Schmorl node, bone island, block vertebra and transitional segments.
- Search with ABCS plus hot spots to avoid satisfaction of search.
- Describe lesions by location, margin (Lodwick), zone of transition, matrix and periosteal reaction; let age guide the differential.
- A report has findings, an impression and specific recommendations; critical findings are communicated directly and documented.
- MRI for soft tissue, marrow and early infection, CT for bone detail, bone scan as a sensitive survey (cold in myeloma), ultrasound for tendon and vessel, DEXA for density (T score minus 2.5 or lower is osteoporosis).
- Cauda equina and metastatic cord compression need emergency MRI the same day.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| ALARA | As low as reasonably achievable: the principle of using the smallest radiation exposure that still answers the clinical question. |
| Inverse square law | Radiation intensity falls with the square of the distance from the source, so doubling distance cuts exposure to one quarter. |
| Collimation | Restricting the X-ray beam to the area of interest; the most effective technical way to reduce patient dose and scatter. |
| Filtration | Metal (usually aluminum) in the beam that removes low energy photons which would only add skin dose. |
| kVp | Peak kilovoltage; controls beam penetration and the contrast scale of the image. |
| mAs | Tube current multiplied by exposure time; controls the quantity of photons, image density and patient dose. |
| SID | Source to image distance; longer distances reduce magnification, as in the 72 inch lateral cervical film. |
| Grid | A device of lead strips between patient and receptor that absorbs scatter; used for body parts thicker than about 10 to 12 cm. |
| Dose creep | The drift toward higher exposures in digital radiography because overexposed images still look acceptable. |
| Canadian C spine rule | A three step decision rule for imaging alert, stable adults after neck trauma, based on high risk factors, low risk factors and active rotation. |
| NEXUS criteria | Five findings (no midline tenderness, no focal deficit, normal alertness, no intoxication, no distracting injury) that together make cervical imaging unnecessary. |
| Ottawa ankle rules | Criteria based on malleolar or midfoot bone tenderness and weight bearing ability that identify which ankle injuries need films. |
| APOM | AP open mouth view, showing the dens, the lateral masses of C1 and the C1 to C2 joints. |
| Swimmer's lateral | A lateral view with one arm raised to show C7 and T1 through the shoulder shadows. |
| Ferguson view | An AP lumbosacral view angled 25 to 30 degrees toward the head to show the sacroiliac joints and the L5 to S1 junction. |
| Atlantodental interval | The space between the anterior arch of atlas and the dens; over 3 mm in adults (5 mm in children) indicates transverse ligament insufficiency. |
| George's line | The line along the posterior vertebral body margins; a step indicates anterior or posterior translation. |
| Spinolaminar line | The line joining the junctions of the laminae and spinous processes; forms the posterior border of the canal. |
| Pseudosubluxation | Normal anterior gliding of C2 on C3 in young children, separated from injury with the Swischuk line. |
| Os odontoideum | A smooth, corticated ossicle separate from a shortened dens; it mimics a type II dens fracture and may be unstable. |
| Limbus bone | A triangular corner fragment caused by disc material herniating under the ring apophysis; mimics a fracture. |
| Bone island | Enostosis: a small focus of compact bone with a spiculated edge that can mimic a blastic metastasis. |
| Satisfaction of search | The error of ending the search after finding one abnormality and missing a second. |
| Zone of transition | The border between a lesion and normal bone; narrow suggests slow growth, wide suggests aggression. |
| Lodwick classification | Grading of lytic margins from geographic with sclerosis (IA) to moth eaten (II) and permeative (III). |
| Matrix | The mineralized material a tumor produces: osteoid (cloudlike), chondroid (rings and arcs) or fibrous (ground glass). |
| Codman triangle | A triangle of new bone at the edge of a lesion where the elevated periosteum is broken through; a sign of aggressive growth. |
| Impression | The concluding section of a report giving the most important diagnosis and a short differential. |
| STIR | An MRI sequence that suppresses fat so edema, stress reactions and inflammation appear bright. |
| SPECT | Single photon emission CT; a three dimensional bone scan that localizes activity, as in an active pars defect. |
| T score | Bone density compared with a young adult reference; minus 2.5 or lower defines osteoporosis. |
| Z score | Bone density compared with age and sex matched peers; used for premenopausal women, younger men and children. |
Check yourself
Clinical Laboratory and Special Studies in Cases
A laboratory value means nothing until it is attached to a patient: a sedimentation rate of 85 mm/h is a curiosity in a healthy 30 year old, and a reason for same week referral in a 74 year old with new headache and jaw pain. Part III tests whether you know which test to order for a given question, what pattern of results points to which disease, and what you do next when a result is dangerous. This chapter works through urinalysis, hematology, serology, chemistries, stool and joint fluid, electrophysiologic studies and the statistics that decide whether a test is worth ordering at all.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Interpret urinalysis dipstick and microscopic findings, including casts and crystals, and link them to kidney, urinary tract and systemic disease.
- Read a CBC, classify anemia by MCV, and recognize leukocytosis, leukopenia, platelet disorders and coagulation results that matter before manipulation.
- Use ESR, CRP, RF, anti CCP, ANA and HLA B27 in the right clinical setting and know their limits.
- Interpret calcium, alkaline phosphatase, uric acid, PSA, glucose, renal and liver panels in musculoskeletal and systemic cases.
- Choose and interpret stool tests for occult blood, infection and inflammation, and classify synovial fluid by cell count and crystals.
- Recognize normal ECG intervals and dangerous rhythms, and know when EEG is indicated.
- Predict EMG and nerve conduction findings in radiculopathy, entrapment, plexopathy, polyneuropathy and myopathy.
- Calculate and apply sensitivity, specificity, predictive values and likelihood ratios, and weigh cost and harm when ordering.
Section 1Urinalysis and hematology in cases
The dipstick
A routine urinalysis has three parts: physical (color, clarity, specific gravity), chemical (the dipstick) and microscopic (sediment). It is cheap, fast and screens for kidney disease, urinary infection, diabetes, liver and hemolytic disease, and it is the first test for flank pain that might be renal rather than spinal.
| Dipstick result | Normal | What a positive suggests | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specific gravity | 1.005 to 1.030 | High: dehydration, glucosuria, contrast; fixed near 1.010: chronic kidney disease (isosthenuria); low: diabetes insipidus, overhydration | Correlate with BUN, creatinine, glucose |
| pH | 4.5 to 8 (usually about 6) | Alkaline: urease producing infection (Proteus), vegetarian diet; acid: high protein diet, acidosis | Persistent alkaline urine with stones suggests struvite |
| Protein | Negative or trace | Glomerular disease (nephrotic over 3.5 g per day), diabetes, hypertension, fever or exercise (transient), orthostatic proteinuria in adolescents; dipstick detects albumin, not light chains | Repeat; urine albumin to creatinine ratio; in an older adult with back pain, check for myeloma light chains with electrophoresis |
| Glucose | Negative | Blood glucose above the renal threshold (about 180 mg/dL): diabetes; SGLT2 inhibitors; pregnancy | Fasting glucose or HbA1c |
| Ketones | Negative | Diabetic ketoacidosis, starvation, very low carbohydrate diet, prolonged vomiting | Glucose and clinical state; ketones with high glucose and illness is an emergency |
| Blood | Negative | Hematuria (stone, infection, tumor, glomerulonephritis), or hemoglobin or myoglobin (dipstick positive but few red cells on microscopy) | Microscopy; CK if myoglobin suspected (rhabdomyolysis) |
| Bilirubin | Negative | Conjugated hyperbilirubinemia: hepatitis, biliary obstruction | Liver panel |
| Urobilinogen | Small amount | Increased: hemolysis, hepatocellular disease; absent: complete biliary obstruction | Liver panel, CBC, reticulocytes |
| Nitrite | Negative | Gram negative bacteria (Enterobacterales such as E. coli) converting nitrate; very specific for infection but insensitive | Culture if symptomatic, pregnant or complicated |
| Leukocyte esterase | Negative | Pyuria: infection, interstitial nephritis, stones | Combined with nitrite, supports urinary tract infection |
Microscopy: casts and crystals
Casts form in the renal tubules from Tamm Horsfall protein, so a cast localizes disease to the kidney itself. Red cell casts mean glomerulonephritis. White cell casts mean pyelonephritis or interstitial nephritis (they distinguish upper from lower urinary tract infection). Fatty casts and oval fat bodies ("Maltese cross" under polarized light) go with nephrotic syndrome. Muddy brown granular casts indicate acute tubular necrosis. Waxy casts and broad casts mean advanced chronic kidney disease. Hyaline casts are nonspecific and can follow exercise, fever or dehydration.
Crystals help in stone disease: calcium oxalate (envelope or dumbbell shaped) in the most common stones and in ethylene glycol poisoning; uric acid (rhomboid, yellow brown) with gout, high cell turnover and acid urine; struvite or magnesium ammonium phosphate ("coffin lid") with urease producing infection and staghorn calculi; cystine (hexagonal) in the inherited disorder cystinuria.
The complete blood count
| CBC component | Typical adult reference range | Key interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Hemoglobin | Men about 13.5 to 17.5 g/dL; women about 12.0 to 15.5 g/dL | Below range: anemia; above range: polycythemia (smoking, altitude, polycythemia vera, dehydration) |
| Hematocrit | Men about 41 to 53 percent; women about 36 to 46 percent | Roughly three times the hemoglobin |
| MCV | 80 to 100 fL | Classifies anemia as microcytic, normocytic or macrocytic |
| RDW | About 11.5 to 14.5 percent | High in iron deficiency and mixed deficiencies; normal in thalassemia trait |
| Reticulocyte count | About 0.5 to 2.5 percent | High: marrow responding (hemolysis, bleeding); low: production failure |
| White cell count | 4,500 to 11,000 per µL | Differential tells the cause |
| Platelets | 150,000 to 450,000 per µL | Bleeding risk rises below about 50,000; spontaneous bleeding below about 10,000 to 20,000 |
Classifying anemia
The MCV divides anemia into three groups, and each group has a short list. In microcytic anemia (MCV below 80), iron deficiency is most common; in an adult man or a postmenopausal woman, iron deficiency means gastrointestinal blood loss (often colon cancer) until proven otherwise, and in a premenopausal woman heavy menses is the usual cause. Iron studies separate the causes: iron deficiency shows low ferritin (the single best test; below about 30 ng/mL is diagnostic in most settings), high TIBC and high RDW; anemia of chronic disease shows normal or high ferritin with low TIBC; thalassemia trait shows normal iron, a very low MCV out of proportion to mild anemia, a normal or high red cell count (Mentzer index MCV divided by RBC below 13) and target cells. Lead poisoning and sideroblastic anemia are rarer causes, with basophilic stippling and ringed sideroblasts.
In macrocytic anemia (MCV above 100), the megaloblastic causes are vitamin B12 and folate deficiency, recognized by hypersegmented neutrophils (6 or more lobes). B12 deficiency (pernicious anemia, metformin, long term proton pump inhibitors, vegan diet, gastric or ileal surgery) causes subacute combined degeneration: loss of vibration and position sense, ataxia and upper motor neuron signs, sometimes before anemia appears; methylmalonic acid and homocysteine are both elevated, whereas folate deficiency raises only homocysteine. Nonmegaloblastic macrocytosis comes from alcohol, liver disease, hypothyroidism, reticulocytosis and medications.
In normocytic anemia (80 to 100), the reticulocyte count decides the direction. High reticulocytes indicate blood loss or hemolysis (raised LDH and indirect bilirubin, low haptoglobin, schistocytes or spherocytes on smear). Low reticulocytes indicate underproduction: anemia of chronic disease, chronic kidney disease (low erythropoietin), early iron deficiency, or marrow infiltration by leukemia, myeloma or metastatic cancer, especially when other cell lines are also low.
White cells and platelets
| Finding | Common causes | When it is urgent |
|---|---|---|
| Neutrophilia with left shift (bands) | Bacterial infection, inflammation, corticosteroids, stress, smoking | With fever and spinal pain: suspect osteomyelitis or abscess |
| Lymphocytosis | Viral infection, pertussis; atypical lymphocytes in infectious mononucleosis; CLL in an older adult | Persistent absolute lymphocytosis in an older adult: hematology referral |
| Eosinophilia | Allergy and asthma, drug reactions, parasites, adrenal insufficiency, vasculitis, some cancers | Very high counts or organ symptoms |
| Neutropenia (ANC below 1,500) | Chemotherapy, drugs, viral infection, marrow failure | ANC below 500 with fever is a medical emergency |
| Blasts on the smear, or very high white count with anemia and low platelets | Acute leukemia | Same day referral |
| Thrombocytopenia | Immune thrombocytopenia, drugs (heparin), alcohol, liver disease with splenic sequestration, DIC, marrow failure | Below 50,000: avoid forceful manual therapy; with petechiae, bleeding or other low cell lines: urgent referral |
| Thrombocytosis | Reactive (iron deficiency, inflammation, after splenectomy) or myeloproliferative disorders | Very high persistent counts |
| Prolonged PT and INR | Warfarin, liver disease, vitamin K deficiency (extrinsic pathway) | INR well above the patient's therapeutic range, or any bleeding |
| Prolonged aPTT | Unfractionated heparin, hemophilia, lupus anticoagulant (intrinsic pathway) | Bleeding, hemarthrosis |
For a chiropractor these results matter directly: patients on anticoagulants or with thrombocytopenia bruise and bleed more easily, so high velocity and deep soft tissue techniques are modified or avoided, and any unexplained bruising, petechiae, gum bleeding or hemarthrosis is a reason to check a CBC and coagulation profile rather than treat.
Reasoning: Microcytic anemia with low ferritin and high RDW is iron deficiency. In an older man the cause is gastrointestinal blood loss until proven otherwise, and right sided colon cancer often bleeds occultly with no change in bowel habit. The next step is referral to his physician for colonoscopy (and often upper endoscopy), not iron supplements and spinal care alone. His back pain should be reconsidered as well, because metastatic disease or a retroperitoneal process can present this way.
The urinalysis localizes disease: casts mean kidney, nitrite and esterase mean infection, and blood without red cells means pigment. The CBC is read by pattern: MCV classifies anemia, the reticulocyte count separates loss from failure, ferritin settles iron deficiency, and two or more abnormal cell lines or blasts suggest marrow disease that needs urgent referral.
Section 2Serology and blood chemistries in cases
Inflammatory markers: ESR and CRP
The erythrocyte sedimentation rate (Westergren method) measures how far red cells fall in an hour; acute phase proteins, mainly fibrinogen and immunoglobulins, neutralize the negative surface charge of red cells so they stack (rouleaux) and settle faster. A common rule of thumb for the upper limit is age divided by 2 for men and age plus 10, divided by 2, for women. ESR rises slowly over days, falls slowly over weeks, and is raised by anemia, pregnancy, age and kidney disease; it is lowered by polycythemia, sickle cells and very high white counts. An ESR above 100 mm/h narrows the field to a few causes: infection (osteomyelitis, endocarditis), multiple myeloma and other malignancy, and giant cell arteritis or polymyalgia rheumatica.
C reactive protein is made by the liver under the influence of interleukin 6. It rises within 6 to 8 hours, peaks at about 48 hours and falls quickly when inflammation resolves, so it tracks response to treatment of infection better than ESR. A standard CRP below about 10 mg/L (1 mg/dL) is usually considered normal; high sensitivity CRP is a separate cardiovascular risk test with much lower cutoffs. Both ESR and CRP are nonspecific: their main value in a back pain patient is as a screen that, when normal, makes infection and many cancers less likely, and when high, demands an explanation.
Autoantibodies and HLA B27
| Test | Best used for | Performance and pitfalls |
|---|---|---|
| Rheumatoid factor (IgM against IgG Fc) | Supporting rheumatoid arthritis | Sensitivity about 70 to 80 percent; poor specificity: positive in Sjögren syndrome, hepatitis C, endocarditis, chronic infection and up to about 1 in 4 healthy elderly people |
| Anti CCP (anti citrullinated peptide) | Confirming rheumatoid arthritis, often early | Similar sensitivity to RF, specificity about 95 percent; predicts erosive disease; may precede symptoms |
| ANA (antinuclear antibody) | Screening for systemic lupus erythematosus and other connective tissue diseases | Sensitivity about 95 percent or more for SLE, so a negative ANA nearly excludes it; low specificity: low titers common in healthy people, especially older women |
| Anti dsDNA, anti Smith | Confirming SLE | Highly specific; anti dsDNA tracks lupus nephritis activity |
| Anti histone | Drug induced lupus (hydralazine, procainamide, isoniazid) | Disease improves when the drug is stopped |
| Anti Ro (SS A) and anti La (SS B) | Sjögren syndrome; neonatal lupus risk | Ro antibodies in pregnancy can cause congenital heart block |
| Anti centromere; anti Scl 70 (topoisomerase) | Limited scleroderma (CREST); diffuse systemic sclerosis | Scl 70 carries risk of lung fibrosis |
| HLA B27 | Supporting axial spondyloarthritis in a patient with inflammatory back pain | Present in about 90 percent of white patients with ankylosing spondylitis but also in about 6 to 8 percent of the general population, most of whom never develop disease; useless as a screening test |
The rule for autoantibodies is that they are ordered to confirm a disease the clinical picture already suggests, not to screen people with nonspecific aches. An ANA ordered for fatigue and diffuse pain without objective findings will be positive in a meaningful number of healthy people and usually leads to more testing and anxiety rather than a diagnosis. Seronegative spondyloarthropathies (ankylosing spondylitis, psoriatic, reactive and enteropathic arthritis) are "seronegative" because RF and anti CCP are negative; HLA B27 and imaging are the relevant tests.
Uric acid
Urate saturates body fluids at about 6.8 mg/dL. Hyperuricemia is far more common than gout and is not treated by itself in an asymptomatic patient. During an acute gout flare the serum urate can be normal (urate shifts into crystals and inflammatory cytokines increase excretion), so a normal level does not exclude gout; the diagnostic test is crystals in joint fluid. Causes of high urate include underexcretion (kidney disease, thiazide and loop diuretics, low dose aspirin, alcohol, especially beer), overproduction (myeloproliferative disease, tumor lysis, psoriasis) and diet (purine rich meat and seafood, fructose sweetened drinks).
Calcium, phosphorus, alkaline phosphatase and the bone pattern
Serum calcium (about 8.5 to 10.5 mg/dL) should be interpreted with albumin, because about 40 percent is protein bound: corrected calcium = measured calcium + 0.8 x (4.0 minus albumin). Hypercalcemia in outpatients is usually primary hyperparathyroidism (high or inappropriately normal PTH); in sick or hospitalized patients it is usually malignancy (PTH suppressed: PTH related peptide from squamous cancers, lytic bone metastasis, myeloma). Symptoms follow "stones, bones, abdominal groans and psychic moans": kidney stones, bone pain, constipation and abdominal pain, fatigue, confusion and depression, plus polyuria.
Alkaline phosphatase (about 40 to 130 U/L in adults) comes mainly from liver and bone. A raised ALP with a raised GGT points to the liver (cholestasis); a raised ALP with a normal GGT points to bone, where it reflects osteoblast activity: growth in adolescents, healing fracture, Paget disease (often very high), osteoblastic metastasis (prostate, breast), osteomalacia and hyperparathyroidism. A bone specific ALP or ALP isoenzymes can confirm the source. ALP is typically normal in multiple myeloma, because myeloma suppresses osteoblasts.
PSA, glucose, kidney and liver tests
- PSA: a prostate specific (not cancer specific) protein. A level above about 4 ng/mL has traditionally prompted evaluation, with age adjusted ranges also in use. It rises with prostate cancer, benign prostatic hyperplasia, prostatitis, urinary retention, recent ejaculation and instrumentation. Screening men 55 to 69 is an individual decision after shared discussion. In a man with back pain and an osteoblastic lesion or a raised ALP, PSA is a targeted diagnostic test, not screening.
- Glucose: diabetes is diagnosed by fasting plasma glucose 126 mg/dL or higher, HbA1c 6.5 percent or higher, a 2 hour oral glucose tolerance value of 200 mg/dL or higher, or a random glucose of 200 mg/dL or higher with classic symptoms. Prediabetes is a fasting glucose of 100 to 125 mg/dL or HbA1c of 5.7 to 6.4 percent. Diabetes matters musculoskeletally because of adhesive capsulitis, peripheral neuropathy, Charcot joints, diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis and infection risk.
- Kidney panel: BUN (about 7 to 20 mg/dL) and creatinine (about 0.6 to 1.2 mg/dL), with eGFR calculated from creatinine, age and sex. A BUN to creatinine ratio above 20 suggests prerenal azotemia (dehydration, heart failure, GI bleeding). Chronic NSAID use, dehydration and diuretics can all injure the kidney; an eGFR below about 30 changes the choice of anti inflammatory drug and contrast agent.
- Liver panel: ALT is more liver specific than AST; AST to ALT ratio above 2 suggests alcoholic liver disease; very high aminotransferases (in the thousands) suggest acute viral, toxic (acetaminophen) or ischemic hepatitis. A cholestatic pattern raises ALP, GGT and conjugated bilirubin. Low albumin and a prolonged PT indicate reduced synthetic function.
- Creatine kinase: raised in muscle injury, inflammatory myopathy (polymyositis, dermatomyositis), statin myopathy, hypothyroidism and rhabdomyolysis (very high CK with dark urine that is dipstick positive for blood but shows few red cells).
- TSH: the first test for thyroid function; hypothyroidism causes myalgia, carpal tunnel syndrome, fatigue and raised CK.
Reasoning: Hypercalcemia, renal insufficiency, anemia and bone pain (the CRAB features) with a very high ESR point strongly to multiple myeloma. The normal ALP fits, since osteoblasts are suppressed, and the negative dipstick protein does not reassure because the dipstick misses light chains. Order serum protein electrophoresis with immunofixation and serum free light chains, and refer promptly to his physician or hematology; imaging should be a skeletal survey, low dose whole body CT or MRI rather than a bone scan. Avoid spinal manipulation until his skeleton has been assessed, because myeloma weakens vertebrae and pathological fractures are common.
Reasoning: This is inflammatory back pain, and the laboratory results raise the probability of axial spondyloarthritis but do not prove it, since HLA B27 is common in healthy people and CRP is raised in only some patients. The next step is imaging of the sacroiliac joints (AP pelvis; MRI with STIR if films are normal) and rheumatology referral for consideration of disease modifying therapy. Exercise based care fits well, but forceful manipulation of a fused or osteoporotic spine later in the disease carries fracture risk.
ESR and CRP are sensitive but nonspecific screens; autoantibodies and HLA B27 confirm a suspected disease and should not be used to screen vague pain. Calcium, phosphorus, ALP and PTH form patterns that separate the metabolic bone diseases, and the pattern of high calcium, high ESR, anemia, kidney injury and normal ALP should always suggest myeloma.
Section 3Stool analysis and joint fluid analysis
Occult blood and colorectal cancer screening
Stool tests appear on Part III mainly through colorectal cancer screening, iron deficiency anemia and inflammatory bowel disease that travels with spondyloarthritis. Average risk adults are screened from age 45 to 75. Options include colonoscopy every 10 years, an annual fecal immunochemical test (FIT), a multitarget stool DNA test with FIT every 1 to 3 years, or CT colonography or flexible sigmoidoscopy every 5 years. Any positive stool test requires a follow up colonoscopy; repeating the stool test is not acceptable.
| Stool test | Principle | Strengths and pitfalls |
|---|---|---|
| Guaiac FOBT | Detects the peroxidase activity of heme | False positives from red meat, some raw vegetables (horseradish, turnip) and upper GI bleeding from NSAIDs or aspirin; vitamin C causes false negatives; needs three samples and dietary restriction |
| FIT | Antibody to human globin | No dietary restriction; globin is digested in the upper gut, so FIT is more specific for lower GI (colorectal) bleeding; one sample |
| Stool DNA with FIT | Detects tumor DNA markers plus hemoglobin | More sensitive than FIT for cancer, less specific, more expensive |
| Fecal leukocytes or lactoferrin | White cells shed by inflamed mucosa | Positive in invasive bacterial diarrhea (Shigella, Salmonella, Campylobacter, Clostridioides difficile) and in inflammatory bowel disease |
| Fecal calprotectin | Neutrophil protein in stool | Separates inflammatory bowel disease (high) from irritable bowel syndrome (normal); used to monitor IBD activity |
| Stool culture, C. difficile toxin or PCR, ova and parasites, Giardia antigen | Identify the infecting organism | Indicated for bloody diarrhea, fever, severe or prolonged illness, recent antibiotics (C. difficile), travel or day care exposure (Giardia) |
| Fecal fat (qualitative Sudan stain or 72 hour quantitative) and fecal elastase | Fat malabsorption; pancreatic enzyme output | Steatorrhea over 7 g per day; low elastase in chronic pancreatitis and cystic fibrosis |
Two connections with the musculoskeletal system deserve emphasis. First, reactive arthritis follows enteric infection with Salmonella, Shigella, Campylobacter or Yersinia (and genitourinary Chlamydia) by 1 to 4 weeks, often in HLA B27 positive people, with asymmetric lower limb arthritis, enthesitis, conjunctivitis and urethritis. Second, about 1 in 5 patients with Crohn disease or ulcerative colitis has an enteropathic arthritis: peripheral arthritis that tracks bowel activity, or sacroiliitis and spondylitis that run independently of it.
Reasoning: Inflammatory back pain with bowel symptoms, weight loss and probable anterior uveitis suggests enteropathic spondyloarthritis with underlying inflammatory bowel disease. A fecal calprotectin is the appropriate first stool test: a high value supports IBD and justifies referral for colonoscopy, while a normal value points away from it. She also needs ophthalmology review of the eye and rheumatology evaluation of the spine. Treating this as mechanical back pain and attributing the bowel symptoms to stress would miss both diagnoses.
Synovial fluid analysis
Aspiration of an effusion (arthrocentesis) is the single most informative test for an acutely swollen joint, and for an acute monoarthritis it is mandatory, because septic arthritis destroys cartilage within days and has a meaningful mortality. Fluid is sent for cell count and differential, crystal examination under compensated polarized light, Gram stain and culture. Glucose, protein and LDH add little. Normal synovial fluid is clear, pale yellow, viscous (forms a long "string") and contains fewer than about 200 white cells per µL.
| Class | Appearance | WBC per µL | Neutrophils | Typical causes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normal | Clear, viscous | Under 200 | Under 25 percent | None |
| I, noninflammatory | Clear yellow, viscous | 200 to 2,000 | Under 25 percent | Osteoarthritis, trauma, osteonecrosis, neuropathic joint |
| II, inflammatory | Cloudy, low viscosity | 2,000 to about 50,000 (may reach 75,000 or more) | Over 50 percent | Rheumatoid arthritis, gout, CPPD, reactive and psoriatic arthritis, SLE |
| III, septic | Purulent, opaque | Usually over 50,000, often over 100,000 | Over 75 to 90 percent | Bacterial infection (S. aureus most common; N. gonorrhoeae in sexually active young adults) |
| IV, hemorrhagic | Bloody or xanthochromic | Variable | Variable | Trauma (ligament tear, fracture: fat droplets suggest an intra articular fracture), hemophilia, anticoagulation, pigmented villonodular synovitis, Charcot joint |
Crystal examination uses a red compensator. Monosodium urate crystals in gout are needle shaped and strongly negatively birefringent (yellow when aligned parallel to the slow axis of the compensator, blue when perpendicular). Calcium pyrophosphate crystals in pseudogout (CPPD disease) are rhomboid or rod shaped and weakly positively birefringent (blue when parallel). Calcium hydroxyapatite crystals are too small to see without special stains. Crystals and infection can coexist, so a fluid with crystals and a very high count is still cultured and the patient may need antibiotics until results return.
Gram stain is positive in only about half of septic joints, so a negative stain never excludes infection; culture of synovial fluid is positive in most nongonococcal cases. In gonococcal arthritis synovial cultures are often negative; the diagnosis is made by nucleic acid testing of urethral, cervical, rectal and pharyngeal specimens and blood cultures, in a young adult with migratory polyarthralgia, tenosynovitis and pustular skin lesions.
Reasoning: A count in this range with over 90 percent neutrophils and fever must be treated as septic arthritis until culture results return, even though crystals are present and the Gram stain is negative. The crystals show he has CPPD disease, but crystals and infection coexist. He needs same day medical care for blood cultures, intravenous antibiotics and joint drainage. Manual therapy to the knee, or reassurance that it is "another gout attack," would be dangerous.
A positive stool blood test means colonoscopy, fecal calprotectin separates inflammatory from functional bowel disease, and enteric infection or IBD can drive spondyloarthritis. An acute monoarthritis needs aspiration for cell count, crystals, Gram stain and culture; counts above about 50,000 with a neutrophil majority are septic until proven otherwise, and crystals do not exclude infection.
Section 4Electrophysiologic recordings
ECG basics
The electrocardiogram records the summed electrical activity of the heart from 12 viewpoints (six limb leads in the frontal plane and six precordial leads in the horizontal plane). Standard paper runs at 25 mm per second, so one small (1 mm) box is 0.04 s and one large (5 mm) box is 0.20 s; vertically, 10 mm equals 1 mV. For a regular rhythm, heart rate is 300 divided by the number of large boxes between consecutive R waves (1 box 300, 2 boxes 150, 3 boxes 100, 4 boxes 75, 5 boxes 60, 6 boxes 50). For an irregular rhythm, count the QRS complexes in a 10 second strip and multiply by 6.
The P wave is atrial depolarization; the PR interval (start of P to start of QRS, normally 0.12 to 0.20 s) is mostly delay in the AV node; the QRS complex is ventricular depolarization (normally under 0.12 s, usually under 0.10); the ST segment should be at the baseline and represents the plateau of ventricular action potentials; the T wave is ventricular repolarization; the QT interval, corrected for rate (QTc), is normally under about 0.44 s in men and 0.46 s in women. A systematic read covers rate, rhythm, axis, intervals, P wave and QRS morphology, ST segments and T waves.
Dangerous patterns
| Pattern | ECG clue | What it means and what you do |
|---|---|---|
| Ventricular fibrillation | Chaotic irregular baseline, no identifiable QRS | Cardiac arrest: call emergency services, start CPR, use an AED immediately |
| Ventricular tachycardia | Wide (0.12 s or more), regular QRS at 100 to 250 per minute | Pulseless: CPR and AED; with a pulse: emergency transfer |
| ST elevation myocardial infarction | ST elevation in two contiguous leads: II, III, aVF (inferior, right coronary); V1 to V4 (anterior, left anterior descending); I, aVL, V5, V6 (lateral, circumflex) | Emergency services immediately; aspirin if not contraindicated |
| Third degree (complete) heart block | P waves and QRS complexes independent, slow escape rhythm | Syncope risk: emergency referral for pacing |
| Mobitz II second degree block | Constant PR, then a P wave suddenly not conducted | Can progress to complete block: urgent referral |
| Mobitz I (Wenckebach) | PR lengthens progressively until a beat drops | Usually benign (athletes, vagal tone, AV nodal drugs) |
| Atrial fibrillation | Irregularly irregular rhythm, no distinct P waves, fibrillatory baseline | Stroke risk; new or rapid AF needs medical evaluation; most patients are anticoagulated |
| Atrial flutter | "Sawtooth" flutter waves at about 300 per minute, often 2:1 block (ventricular rate about 150) | Medical evaluation; same stroke concerns as AF |
| Wolff Parkinson White pattern | Short PR (under 0.12 s), delta wave slurring the QRS upstroke | Accessory pathway; risk of rapid arrhythmia; cardiology referral |
| Long QT | QTc over about 0.50 s | Risk of torsades de pointes and sudden death; review drugs (some antibiotics, antipsychotics, antiemetics) and electrolytes |
| Hyperkalemia | Peaked T waves, then wide QRS and loss of P waves | Life threatening; emergency care, especially in kidney disease |
| Hypokalemia | Flattened T waves, U waves | Diuretics, vomiting; muscle weakness and cramps |
EEG
The electroencephalogram records cortical electrical activity from scalp electrodes. Its main indications are suspected seizures and epilepsy classification (interictal spikes and sharp waves; generalized 3 Hz spike and wave in childhood absence epilepsy), unexplained altered consciousness or encephalopathy (diffuse slowing, triphasic waves in hepatic encephalopathy), suspected nonconvulsive status epilepticus, sleep disorders (as part of polysomnography) and confirmation of brain death in some protocols. A normal interictal EEG does not exclude epilepsy, since a single routine study captures abnormalities in only about half of people with the disorder; sleep deprivation and repeated or prolonged recordings raise the yield. EEG has no role in the routine evaluation of headache, dizziness without loss of consciousness, or syncope that is clearly vasovagal.
Nerve conduction studies and needle EMG
Electrodiagnosis is an extension of the neurological examination. Nerve conduction studies stimulate a nerve and record either a sensory nerve action potential (SNAP) or a compound muscle action potential (CMAP), measuring latency, amplitude and conduction velocity. Normal velocities are roughly 50 m/s or faster in the arms and 40 m/s or faster in the legs. Demyelination slows conduction, prolongs distal latencies and F waves and can produce conduction block, while amplitudes are relatively preserved. Axonal loss reduces amplitude with near normal velocity. Needle EMG samples muscle at rest and during contraction: fibrillation potentials and positive sharp waves at rest indicate denervation (or active myopathy); large, long duration, polyphasic motor units with reduced recruitment indicate chronic denervation with reinnervation; small, short, polyphasic units with early recruitment indicate myopathy.
The location of the lesion relative to the dorsal root ganglion is the key to radiculopathy. The sensory cell body sits in the DRG within or just outside the foramen. A root lesion (disc, foraminal stenosis) is proximal to the DRG, so the sensory axon remains connected to its cell body and the SNAP is normal even when the patient has numbness. Plexus and peripheral nerve lesions are distal to the DRG and reduce the SNAP. Timing matters too: fibrillations appear in paraspinal muscles after about 1 to 2 weeks and in limb muscles after about 3 to 6 weeks, so EMG done in the first 2 to 3 weeks after onset can be falsely normal. The ideal time to study a suspected radiculopathy is about 3 weeks or later.
| Disorder | Nerve conduction | Needle EMG |
|---|---|---|
| Radiculopathy (for example C7 or L5) | SNAPs normal; CMAPs normal or reduced if severe axonal loss; H reflex prolonged or absent in S1 radiculopathy | Denervation in two or more muscles of the same myotome supplied by different nerves, plus the paraspinals |
| Carpal tunnel syndrome | Prolonged median distal sensory latency first, then distal motor latency; focal slowing across the wrist; reduced amplitudes when severe | Denervation in abductor pollicis brevis only when severe; normal in forearm median muscles and paraspinals |
| Ulnar neuropathy at the elbow | Slowing of ulnar motor conduction across the elbow (drop of over 10 m/s); reduced ulnar SNAP to the little finger | Denervation in first dorsal interosseous and possibly flexor carpi ulnaris |
| Fibular (peroneal) neuropathy at the fibular head | Conduction block or slowing across the fibular head; reduced superficial fibular SNAP | Tibialis anterior affected, tibialis posterior (tibial nerve, L5) and paraspinals spared; distinguishes it from L5 radiculopathy |
| Brachial plexopathy | Reduced SNAPs in the affected distribution | Denervation across several nerves sharing a trunk or cord; paraspinals spared |
| Diabetic polyneuropathy | Length dependent, mainly axonal: sural SNAP reduced or absent first; mild slowing | Distal denervation in the feet |
| Guillain Barré syndrome (AIDP) | Demyelinating: prolonged or absent F waves early, conduction block, slowed velocities; "sural sparing" pattern | Reduced recruitment; denervation later if axonal damage |
| Myopathy (polymyositis, statin) | Usually normal | Small, short, polyphasic units with early recruitment; fibrillations in inflammatory myopathy |
| Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis | Sensory studies normal, motor amplitudes reduced | Widespread active and chronic denervation in several regions, fasciculations |
Reasoning: The MRI findings are common at her age and may be incidental; the night symptoms and Phalen sign favor carpal tunnel syndrome, but a "double crush" (root plus wrist) is possible. Nerve conduction studies and EMG answer the question: prolonged median distal sensory latency with slowing across the wrist confirms carpal tunnel syndrome, while normal median SNAPs with denervation in C6 or C7 muscles and paraspinals would point to the neck. The result decides whether care is directed at the wrist, the neck or both, and severe findings (thenar denervation) justify surgical referral.
Reasoning: This is atrial fibrillation with rapid ventricular response. He is hemodynamically stable, so this is not a cardiac arrest scenario, but new AF carries stroke risk and needs prompt medical assessment for rate control and anticoagulation, the same day. If he develops chest pain, hypotension, confusion or breathlessness, call emergency services. Stop treatment, monitor him, and do not send him home to "see his doctor next week."
Know the paper (0.04 s and 0.20 s boxes), the normal intervals and the patterns that need emergency help: VF, VT, STEMI, complete or Mobitz II block, hyperkalemia and long QT; AF needs prompt medical care for stroke prevention. EEG is for seizures and altered consciousness. In electrodiagnosis, normal SNAPs with myotomal and paraspinal denervation mean radiculopathy, and studies are most useful about 3 weeks after onset.
Section 5Ordering and interpreting tests wisely
Start with the question and the pretest probability
Every test should answer a specific question, and its result should be able to change what you do. The value of a result depends as much on the pretest probability (how likely the disease was before testing, from prevalence, history and examination) as on the test itself. A positive result for a rare disease in a low risk patient is more often a false positive than a true one; a negative result in a high risk patient may not lower the probability enough to stop.
Sensitivity, specificity and predictive values
- Sensitivity = true positives divided by all who have the disease: how often the test is positive in disease. A highly sensitive test, when negative, rules the disease out (SnNout).
- Specificity = true negatives divided by all who do not have the disease: how often the test is negative in health. A highly specific test, when positive, rules the disease in (SpPin).
- Positive predictive value = true positives divided by all positives: the chance a positive result is right. Negative predictive value = true negatives divided by all negatives. Predictive values change with prevalence: as prevalence falls, PPV falls and NPV rises, even though sensitivity and specificity stay the same.
- Likelihood ratios combine sensitivity and specificity and do not depend on prevalence. LR+ = sensitivity divided by (1 minus specificity); LR minus = (1 minus sensitivity) divided by specificity. Multiply the pretest odds by the LR to get the posttest odds.
| Likelihood ratio | Effect on probability | Approximate change from a moderate pretest probability |
|---|---|---|
| Above 10 | Large increase; often rules in | About plus 45 percentage points |
| 5 to 10 | Moderate increase | About plus 30 to 45 points |
| 2 to 5 | Small increase | About plus 15 to 30 points |
| 1 | No change; the test is useless | None |
| 0.2 to 0.5 | Small decrease | About minus 15 to 30 points |
| 0.1 to 0.2 | Moderate decrease | About minus 30 to 45 points |
| Below 0.1 | Large decrease; often rules out | About minus 45 points |
Applied examples from earlier chapters: the straight leg raise is sensitive (about 90 percent) but not specific for lumbar disc herniation, so a negative SLR helps rule it out while a positive SLR proves little; the crossed SLR is specific (about 90 percent) but insensitive, so a positive crossed SLR strongly supports herniation. An ESR of 20 mm/h or more has moderate sensitivity for cancer as a cause of back pain, but because cancer causes well under 1 percent of back pain in primary care, a raised ESR alone produces many false positives; it is most useful combined with clinical red flags.
Serial and parallel testing
Testing in series (a sensitive screening test first, then a specific confirmatory test only in those who screen positive) maximizes specificity and limits cost: ANA then anti dsDNA; FIT then colonoscopy; ESR and radiographs then MRI. Testing in parallel (several tests at once, any positive counts) maximizes sensitivity and speed and suits urgent situations such as the hot joint (cell count, crystals, Gram stain and culture together) or suspected spinal infection (CBC, ESR, CRP and blood cultures together).
Which test answers which question
| Clinical question | Best first tests | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Is this back pain inflammatory or malignant? | CBC, ESR or CRP; then targeted imaging; SPEP if myeloma possible; PSA in men with blastic lesions | Broad "arthritis panels" without a specific question |
| Is this swollen joint infected or crystal driven? | Synovial fluid cell count, crystals, Gram stain, culture | Serum uric acid alone |
| Is this polyarthritis rheumatoid? | Anti CCP and RF, CRP, hand and foot films | ANA alone |
| Could this be lupus? | ANA first; if positive, anti dsDNA, anti Smith, complement, urinalysis | ANA in patients without objective features |
| Is this fatigue organic? | CBC, metabolic panel, TSH, ferritin, glucose or HbA1c | Wide panels of rare tests |
| Is this numbness root, nerve or polyneuropathy? | Neurological exam; then NCS and EMG at 3 weeks or later; glucose, HbA1c, B12, TSH for neuropathy | Repeated MRI for distal symptoms |
| Is this flank pain renal? | Urinalysis, creatinine; ultrasound or CT for stones | Lumbar radiographs alone |
| Is this anemia from blood loss? | Ferritin, reticulocytes, FIT or colonoscopy as indicated | Starting iron without finding the source |
Cost and harm
Tests are not free of harm. False positives lead to further tests, procedures and anxiety (a cascade); incidental findings ("incidentalomas") lead to follow up imaging and sometimes to surgery that offers no benefit; labeling a patient with a disease marker they do not need to know about can change how they behave; radiation and contrast carry their own risks; and money spent on low value testing is unavailable for useful care. Normal ranges are set to include 95 percent of healthy people, so in a panel of 20 independent tests, a healthy person has roughly a 64 percent chance of at least one "abnormal" result. Order the test that answers the question, interpret it in light of the pretest probability, and act on the result.
Reasoning: With normal inflammatory markers and no objective features, her pretest probability of systemic autoimmune disease is low. An ANA has low specificity, so a positive result here would most likely be false and lead to a cascade of further testing and worry, while a negative result would add little. The wiser plan is to explain this, screen for depression and sleep disorders, consider fibromyalgia (a clinical diagnosis), and reserve autoantibody testing for the appearance of objective signs such as synovitis, rash, cytopenias or proteinuria.
Reasoning: LR minus = (1 minus 0.85) divided by 0.60 = 0.25. Pretest odds are 1 (50 percent); posttest odds are 0.25, which is a probability of 0.25 divided by 1.25, or 20 percent. The negative result lowers the probability meaningfully but does not exclude herniation, so if the patient later develops progressive weakness or red flags, MRI is still appropriate. LR+ would be 0.85 divided by 0.40, about 2.1, so a positive result would only modestly raise the probability, to about 68 percent.
Order a test only when its result could change management, and read it against the pretest probability. Sensitive tests rule out when negative, specific tests rule in when positive, likelihood ratios convert pretest odds to posttest odds, and low prevalence makes positive results unreliable. Every test carries cost and potential harm through false positives and cascades.
The chapter in one breath
- Casts localize urinary disease to the kidney: red cell casts glomerulonephritis, white cell casts pyelonephritis, muddy brown casts ATN, waxy casts chronic kidney disease.
- Nitrite and leukocyte esterase suggest urinary infection; dipstick blood without red cells suggests hemoglobin or myoglobin; the dipstick misses light chains.
- Classify anemia by MCV; ferritin is the best test for iron deficiency, and iron deficiency in a man or postmenopausal woman means colonoscopy.
- B12 deficiency causes macrocytosis with neurological signs (raised methylmalonic acid); two abnormal cell lines or blasts mean urgent hematology referral.
- ESR and CRP are sensitive, nonspecific screens; ESR over 100 suggests infection, myeloma, malignancy or giant cell arteritis.
- Anti CCP is specific for rheumatoid arthritis, a negative ANA nearly excludes lupus, and HLA B27 only supports spondyloarthritis in inflammatory back pain.
- High calcium, anemia, kidney injury, high ESR and normal ALP suggest myeloma; very high ALP with normal calcium suggests Paget disease; osteoporosis has normal chemistries.
- A positive FIT requires colonoscopy; fecal calprotectin separates IBD from IBS; enteric infection and IBD can cause spondyloarthritis.
- Synovial WBC over about 50,000 with neutrophil predominance is septic until proven otherwise; urate needles are negatively birefringent, CPPD rhomboids weakly positive; crystals do not exclude infection.
- ECG: small box 0.04 s, PR 0.12 to 0.20 s, QRS under 0.12 s; VF, VT, STEMI, complete heart block and hyperkalemia are emergencies; new AF needs same day medical care.
- In radiculopathy, SNAPs are normal and denervation appears in the myotome and paraspinals after about 3 weeks; entrapment shows focal slowing.
- SnNout and SpPin; LR+ = sens / (1 minus spec); low prevalence lowers PPV; every test carries cost and cascade risk.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Specific gravity | A measure of urine concentration; fixed near 1.010 suggests the kidney can no longer concentrate or dilute. |
| Urinary cast | A cylinder of protein and cells molded in a renal tubule; its presence localizes disease to the kidney. |
| Leukocyte esterase | An enzyme from white cells detected on the dipstick; indicates pyuria. |
| Nitrite test | Dipstick test for bacteria that convert nitrate to nitrite; specific but insensitive for urinary infection. |
| Myoglobinuria | Muscle pigment in urine after muscle breakdown; dipstick positive for blood with few red cells. |
| MCV | Mean corpuscular volume; the average red cell size used to classify anemia. |
| RDW | Red cell distribution width; a measure of variation in red cell size, high in iron deficiency. |
| Ferritin | The storage form of iron; low ferritin is the most specific test for iron deficiency, but it rises with inflammation. |
| Reticulocyte count | The percentage of young red cells; shows whether the marrow is responding to anemia. |
| Hypersegmented neutrophil | A neutrophil with six or more nuclear lobes; a sign of B12 or folate deficiency. |
| Left shift | An increase in immature neutrophils (bands) in the blood, typical of bacterial infection. |
| INR | International normalized ratio; a standardized prothrombin time used to monitor warfarin. |
| ESR | Erythrocyte sedimentation rate; a slow moving, nonspecific marker of inflammation. |
| CRP | C reactive protein; a fast moving acute phase protein made by the liver in response to interleukin 6. |
| Anti CCP | Antibody to cyclic citrullinated peptide; a highly specific marker for rheumatoid arthritis. |
| ANA | Antinuclear antibody; a sensitive but nonspecific screen for lupus and related diseases. |
| HLA B27 | A class I histocompatibility antigen associated with ankylosing spondylitis and other spondyloarthropathies. |
| Alkaline phosphatase | An enzyme from liver and osteoblasts; raised in cholestasis and in bone forming disease. |
| M protein | A monoclonal immunoglobulin seen as a spike on protein electrophoresis, characteristic of myeloma. |
| PSA | Prostate specific antigen; raised by cancer, hyperplasia, prostatitis and instrumentation. |
| FIT | Fecal immunochemical test; detects human globin in stool and screens for colorectal cancer. |
| Fecal calprotectin | A neutrophil protein in stool that is raised in inflammatory bowel disease. |
| Arthrocentesis | Needle aspiration of fluid from a joint for diagnosis or relief. |
| Birefringence | The property of crystals that makes them appear bright and colored under polarized light. |
| QTc | The QT interval corrected for heart rate; prolongation predisposes to torsades de pointes. |
| Delta wave | A slurred QRS upstroke caused by early ventricular activation through an accessory pathway. |
| SNAP | Sensory nerve action potential; normal in root lesions because they are proximal to the dorsal root ganglion. |
| CMAP | Compound muscle action potential; the summed response of a muscle to stimulation of its motor nerve. |
| Fibrillation potential | Spontaneous discharge of a single denervated muscle fiber seen on needle EMG. |
| Sensitivity | The proportion of people with a disease who test positive. |
| Specificity | The proportion of people without a disease who test negative. |
| Likelihood ratio | How much a test result changes the odds of disease, independent of prevalence. |
| Pretest probability | The estimated chance of disease before a test, based on prevalence, history and examination. |
Check yourself
Clinical Impression I: Musculoskeletal and Neurologic Presentations
Diagnosis or clinical impression is the single heaviest content area on Part III, and nearly every case in the other areas ends with the same silent question: what does this patient have? This chapter teaches you to read a musculoskeletal or neurologic vignette the way an experienced clinician does, by spotting the one or two clues that separate a common mechanical problem from its dangerous look alike, naming the most likely diagnosis, and knowing which alternative must not be missed and how fast to act on it.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Separate mechanical neck pain, cervical radiculopathy and cervical myelopathy by history and examination, and grade a whiplash injury.
- Classify headache as tension type, migraine, cervicogenic or cluster, and recognize the red flag headache and cervical artery dissection.
- Distinguish rib and costovertebral dysfunction from compression fracture, herpes zoster and cardiac, pulmonary and gastrointestinal chest pain.
- Assign low back cases to nonspecific mechanical pain, disc herniation, central stenosis, spondylolisthesis, sacroiliac pain or inflammatory back pain.
- Recognize cauda equina syndrome and the vascular and visceral mimics of back pain, including abdominal aortic aneurysm and vascular claudication.
- Name the most likely shoulder, elbow, wrist, hip, knee and ankle diagnosis from the age, mechanism and key examination clue, and apply the Ottawa rules.
- Localize weakness to upper motor neuron, lower motor neuron, root, plexus, peripheral nerve, junction or muscle.
- Recognize peripheral neuropathy, common entrapments, multiple sclerosis, stroke and TIA and Parkinson disease in a case.
- Sort dizziness into BPPV, vestibular neuritis, Meniere disease and central vertigo, using Dix Hallpike and the HINTS examination.
Section 1Neck pain and headache presentations
Reading a neck pain vignette
Part III neck cases are built around three questions. First, is this local mechanical pain, pain from a nerve root, or a disorder of the spinal cord? Second, is there a red flag (trauma with instability risk, cancer, infection, inflammatory disease, vascular injury)? Third, does the headache, if present, come from the neck or from somewhere more dangerous? The examination items in the vignette are chosen to answer those questions, so read them as deliberately placed clues.
Mechanical neck pain (nonspecific neck pain, facet or myofascial dysfunction, sprain or strain) is the most common answer. It is pain in the posterior neck, sometimes into the upper trapezius or interscapular area, that changes with posture and movement, eases with rest, and is accompanied by restricted, painful segmental motion and local tenderness. The neurologic examination is normal. Facet pain tends to be unilateral, worse with extension and rotation toward the painful side, with referral in predictable maps (C2 to C3 to the suboccipital area, C5 to C6 to the base of the neck and upper trapezius, C6 to C7 to the scapula). Arm symptoms, when present, are vague and do not follow a dermatome.
Cervical radiculopathy is irritation or compression of a nerve root, most often by a posterolateral disc herniation in younger patients and by uncovertebral and facet osteophytes narrowing the intervertebral foramen in older ones. The pattern is arm pain that is often worse than the neck pain, following a dermatome, with paresthesia, and sometimes a myotomal weakness and a reduced reflex. Relief with the hand placed on top of the head (shoulder abduction relief sign) is a classic clue. Because cervical roots exit above the vertebra of the same number, a C5 to C6 disc affects the C6 root. C6 and C7 are the most commonly affected roots.
| Root | Usual level | Sensory loss | Weakness | Reflex |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C5 | C4 to C5 | Lateral arm (deltoid patch) | Deltoid, biceps (shoulder abduction, elbow flexion) | Biceps |
| C6 | C5 to C6 | Lateral forearm, thumb and index finger | Wrist extensors, biceps | Brachioradialis |
| C7 | C6 to C7 | Middle finger | Triceps, wrist flexors, finger extensors | Triceps |
| C8 | C7 to T1 | Ring and little fingers, medial forearm | Finger flexors, hand intrinsics | None reliable |
| T1 | T1 to T2 | Medial arm | Finger abduction (interossei) | None |
The examination cluster that best supports radiculopathy is the one described by Wainner: a positive upper limb tension test A (median nerve bias), cervical rotation toward the affected side of less than 60 degrees, a positive distraction test and a positive Spurling test. When three of the four are positive, the probability of radiculopathy rises substantially; when all four are positive, the positive likelihood ratio is about 30. The ULTT A alone has high sensitivity (around 0.97) and is good for ruling out, whereas Spurling has high specificity (around 0.9) and is good for ruling in.
Cervical spondylotic myelopathy is compression of the cord, usually by a combination of disc bulge, osteophytes and a buckled ligamentum flavum in a congenitally narrow canal, typically in patients over 50. It is the classic must not miss diagnosis disguised as neck stiffness. The patient describes clumsy hands (dropping things, difficulty with buttons and handwriting), numb hands that do not follow a dermatome, and an unsteady, broad based gait; neck pain may be mild or absent. Signs are upper motor neuron signs: hyperreflexia, a positive Hoffmann sign, inverted brachioradialis reflex, sustained clonus, a Babinski sign, and difficulty with tandem gait. Lhermitte sign (electric sensation down the spine with neck flexion) may be present. Cook's clinical prediction rule uses five items: gait deviation, positive Hoffmann, inverted supinator sign, positive Babinski and age over 45; three or more positive strongly rules in myelopathy. The management consequence is important: high velocity cervical manipulation is contraindicated, MRI is indicated, and the patient is referred for a spine surgical opinion, urgently if deficits are progressing.
Whiplash associated disorders
Acceleration and deceleration injuries are graded with the Quebec Task Force scale, and the grade drives both imaging and management decisions.
| Grade | Findings | Impression and next step |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | No neck complaint, no signs | No injury; reassure |
| I | Neck pain, stiffness or tenderness only; no physical signs | Minor soft tissue injury; activity, early return to normal function |
| II | Neck complaint plus musculoskeletal signs (reduced range of motion, point tenderness) | Sprain or strain; conservative care including manual therapy and exercise |
| III | Neck complaint plus neurologic signs (reduced reflexes, weakness, sensory deficit) | Radicular injury; neurologic monitoring, consider advanced imaging and co management |
| IV | Neck complaint plus fracture or dislocation | Immobilize and refer to emergency care |
Whether a trauma patient needs radiographs before any treatment is decided with the Canadian C spine rule. Any high risk factor (age 65 or older, a dangerous mechanism such as a fall from 3 feet or five stairs, an axial load, a high speed or rollover collision, or extremity paresthesias) mandates imaging. If no high risk factor is present, a low risk factor (simple rear end collision, sitting position in the emergency department, ambulatory at any time, delayed onset of neck pain, or absence of midline tenderness) allows the clinician to test active rotation; if the patient can rotate 45 degrees to each side, imaging is not required. The rule has a sensitivity close to 100 percent for clinically important injury.
Headache: primary types
Most headaches in a chiropractic office are primary headaches, and the board expects you to name them from their features.
| Type | Key clues | Most likely mechanism | Chiropractic relevance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tension type | Bilateral, pressing or band like, mild to moderate, not aggravated by routine activity, no nausea; pericranial tenderness | Central sensitization with pericranial muscle tenderness | Most common headache; manual therapy, exercise, ergonomics, stress management |
| Migraine without aura | Unilateral, pulsating, moderate to severe, 4 to 72 hours, worse with activity, nausea, photophobia and phonophobia | Trigeminovascular activation, CGRP release | Identify triggers, co manage; spinal manipulation has modest evidence |
| Migraine with aura | Fully reversible visual (zigzag scintillating scotoma) or sensory aura developing over 5 or more minutes and lasting under 60 minutes, then headache | Cortical spreading depression | Aura that is first ever, prolonged or motor needs workup to exclude TIA |
| Cluster | Strictly unilateral orbital or temporal pain, severe, 15 to 180 minutes, often nightly; ipsilateral tearing, rhinorrhea, ptosis, miosis; restless; more often men | Trigeminal autonomic reflex, hypothalamic | Refer for medical treatment (oxygen, triptan); not a manual therapy problem |
| Cervicogenic | Unilateral, side locked, starts in the neck and spreads to the frontotemporal area, provoked by neck movement or posture, reduced cervical range of motion, positive flexion rotation test | Convergence of upper cervical (C1 to C3) afferents with trigeminal nucleus in the trigeminocervical nucleus | Best evidence for spinal manipulation and deep neck flexor training |
The flexion rotation test is performed supine with the neck fully flexed to isolate C1 to C2, then rotated passively to each side. Normal rotation is about 44 degrees each way; a reduction to about 32 degrees or less, or a difference of more than 10 degrees between sides, supports C1 to C2 dysfunction and cervicogenic headache.
Red flag headaches and cervical artery dissection
The SNOOP mnemonic organizes the danger signs: Systemic symptoms or disease (fever, weight loss, cancer, immunosuppression), Neurologic signs or symptoms (confusion, focal deficit, papilledema), Onset sudden (thunderclap, peak within a minute), Older age at onset (new headache after 50), and Pattern change (progressive, positional, triggered by Valsalva, exertion or sex, worse on waking). Each flag points to specific diagnoses.
| Presentation | Key clue | Most likely diagnosis | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Worst headache of life, peak within seconds, possible neck stiffness | Thunderclap onset | Subarachnoid hemorrhage | Emergency (911); noncontrast CT |
| Headache, fever, neck stiffness, rash | Kernig and Brudzinski signs | Meningitis | Emergency |
| Age over 50, temporal headache, jaw claudication, scalp tenderness, visual blurring | Tender, nodular temporal artery; ESR often over 50 | Giant cell arteritis | Same day referral; risk of permanent blindness |
| Progressive morning headache with vomiting, worse with cough or stooping | Papilledema, focal signs | Space occupying lesion | Urgent imaging and referral |
| Young adult with unusual neck pain and headache after minor neck strain | Horner syndrome, dizziness, visual or speech change | Cervical artery dissection | Emergency; no manipulation |
Cervical artery dissection is a tear of the intima of the vertebral or internal carotid artery, allowing an intramural hematoma that can narrow the lumen or send emboli. Its incidence is low (about 2 to 3 per 100,000 per year), but its early symptom is neck pain and headache, which is why patients with an evolving dissection seek chiropractic care. The board expects you to recognize it before treatment. Vertebral artery dissection causes unilateral posterior neck and occipital pain, often described as unlike any previous pain, followed (sometimes days later) by posterior circulation ischemia: the 5 Ds and 3 Ns (dizziness, diplopia, dysarthria, dysphagia, drop attacks; nausea, numbness, nystagmus) plus ataxia. Internal carotid dissection causes anterolateral neck, face or periorbital pain, an ipsilateral partial Horner syndrome (ptosis and miosis without anhidrosis, because facial sweating fibers travel with the external carotid), pulsatile tinnitus, and later anterior circulation signs (hemiparesis, aphasia, monocular vision loss). Risk factors include recent minor trauma, connective tissue disease, migraine, recent infection and hypertension.
Current understanding is that a dissection already in progress explains most cases in which stroke follows a visit. Premanipulative positional tests (such as the George or DeKleyn tests) have poor sensitivity and do not reliably detect at risk patients; the protection is a careful history for the dissection pattern, a cranial nerve and cerebellar screen, and blood pressure. If the clues are present, the impression is suspected dissection, manipulation is withheld and the patient goes to the emergency department.
Reasoning: The key clues are a new, unusual unilateral posterior neck and occipital pain after trivial rotation, followed by transient posterior circulation symptoms (dysarthria, imbalance) and an ipsilateral cerebellar sign. The impression is suspected vertebral artery dissection with posterior circulation ischemia. The next step is emergency department transfer by ambulance, without manipulation and without provocative positional testing. Do not attribute the symptoms to her tension headache history or treat the neck pain as mechanical; a dissection in progress is exactly the patient who presents to a chiropractor first.
Reasoning: Nondermatomal hand clumsiness with gait ataxia and upper motor neuron signs is cervical spondylotic myelopathy. The reduced biceps reflex with brisk reflexes below suggests compression around C5 to C6. Order or refer for MRI and a spine surgical consultation; avoid high velocity cervical manipulation. Calling this mechanical neck pain or carpal tunnel syndrome is the trap.
Neck cases sort into mechanical pain (normal neurologic exam), radiculopathy (one level of lower motor neuron findings) and myelopathy (upper motor neuron findings below the lesion). Headaches sort into primary types and cervicogenic headache only after the SNOOP screen is clear. A new, unusual neck pain with neurologic symptoms in a young adult is dissection until proven otherwise.
Section 2Thoracic and chest wall presentations
The central question: wall or viscus?
Thoracic pain cases test one skill above all others: telling pain that comes from the spine, ribs and chest wall from pain that comes from the heart, lungs, aorta, esophagus, stomach or gallbladder. Viscera share segmental innervation with the thoracic dermatomes, so visceral pain is felt in the body wall. The clue is not the location but the behavior: musculoskeletal pain is reproduced by movement, posture, palpation and joint loading, while visceral pain is linked to exertion, eating, breathing in a nonmechanical way, or comes with autonomic and systemic symptoms. Remember that palpation tenderness does not exclude a myocardial infarction; about 1 in 7 patients with acute coronary syndrome has some chest wall tenderness, so the whole picture matters.
Musculoskeletal thoracic diagnoses
Thoracic segmental and costovertebral dysfunction causes sharp, localized paraspinal or interscapular pain, often after a twisting or lifting movement or a night of awkward sleep. It may wrap partway around the chest along the rib, and it catches with deep inspiration, coughing, rotation or lying on the affected side. There is tenderness over the costotransverse joint, painful rib springing and restricted segmental motion.
Costochondritis causes anterior chest wall pain with tenderness at multiple costochondral junctions (usually the second to fifth), without swelling, in an adult; it is a diagnosis of exclusion in anyone with cardiac risk. Tietze syndrome is similar but with visible swelling, typically at a single upper costal cartilage (second or third) in a younger patient. Slipping rib syndrome involves the hypermobile 8th to 10th ribs, with a clicking or popping sensation and a positive hooking maneuver. Intercostal muscle strain follows coughing or a sudden twist and is focal.
Thoracic disc herniation is uncommon and usually at T8 to T12. It may cause band like radicular pain around the chest or abdomen, or, because the thoracic canal is narrow and the cord has a watershed blood supply, a myelopathy with leg spasticity, a sensory level and bladder symptoms. Any sensory level on the trunk is a cord problem and needs MRI.
Osteoporotic compression fracture is the classic must not miss musculoskeletal diagnosis in an older patient. The vignette typically describes a woman over 65, or a patient of any age on long term corticosteroids, with sudden midthoracic or thoracolumbar pain after minimal trauma (bending, lifting a grocery bag, sneezing, stepping off a curb), severe pain on standing and walking that eases lying down, and percussion tenderness over a spinous process. Height loss of more than 4 cm (or more than 2 cm in a year) and a fixed kyphosis suggest prior fractures. The next step is radiographs; a wedge with an intact posterior cortex is a stable fracture that can be managed conservatively with modification of care, whereas posterior cortex involvement, neurologic signs or a fracture above T7 in an older patient raises concern for a pathologic fracture from metastasis or myeloma. Spinal manipulation of the fractured segment is contraindicated.
Herpes zoster (shingles) is reactivation of varicella zoster virus in a dorsal root ganglion. Its trap is the prodrome: for 2 to 5 days the patient has burning, stabbing or itching unilateral pain in a thoracic dermatome before any rash, which looks like a rib or a radicular problem. Clues are the strictly unilateral band that stops at the midline, allodynia (pain to light touch of clothing), age over 50 or immunosuppression, and sometimes malaise. Then a cluster of vesicles on an erythematous base appears in the dermatome. Antiviral therapy works best within 72 hours of rash onset, so refer promptly; ophthalmic zoster (vesicles on the tip of the nose, Hutchinson sign) is an eye emergency. Postherpetic neuralgia is pain persisting 90 days or more after the rash.
| Finding | What it suggests | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Pain reproduced by rib springing and rotation, normal vitals | Costovertebral or segmental dysfunction | Conservative care, reassess |
| Point percussion tenderness, older patient, minor trauma, pain worse upright | Compression fracture | Radiographs, no manipulation at the level, bone health workup |
| Unilateral dermatomal burning with allodynia, no rash yet | Prodromal herpes zoster | Re examine daily; refer as soon as vesicles appear |
| Sensory level on the trunk, spastic legs | Thoracic myelopathy (disc, tumor, abscess) | Urgent MRI and referral |
| Pain with exertion, relieved by rest, diaphoresis | Myocardial ischemia | Emergency services |
| Pleuritic pain with dyspnea and tachycardia | Pulmonary embolism, pneumothorax, pneumonia | Emergency or same day referral |
| Burning retrosternal pain after meals, worse lying flat | Gastroesophageal reflux | Medical co management; exclude cardiac first |
Visceral mimics
Acute coronary syndrome (unstable angina and myocardial infarction) produces pressure, tightness or heaviness behind the sternum, often radiating to the left arm, jaw or between the scapulae, provoked by exertion or emotion and accompanied by dyspnea, diaphoresis, nausea or lightheadedness. Women, older adults and people with diabetes more often present with atypical symptoms: dyspnea, fatigue, epigastric discomfort or interscapular pain alone. Stable angina lasts a few minutes and resolves with rest or nitroglycerin; pain at rest or lasting more than 15 to 20 minutes is an emergency. The chiropractor's job is to recognize the pattern, call emergency services, keep the patient at rest, and (absent allergy or bleeding risk) aspirin may be advised per local protocol.
Aortic dissection causes sudden, tearing or ripping chest pain radiating to the interscapular back, at maximum intensity at onset, in a patient with hypertension, Marfan syndrome or a bicuspid aortic valve. Clues are a blood pressure difference of more than 20 mm Hg between arms, a pulse deficit, a new diastolic murmur of aortic regurgitation, or neurologic deficits. It is an emergency.
Pulmonary embolism presents with sudden pleuritic chest pain, dyspnea, tachycardia, sometimes hemoptysis, in a patient with risk factors: recent surgery or immobilization, long travel, pregnancy or estrogen use, cancer, or a swollen painful calf. Spontaneous pneumothorax occurs in a tall thin young man or a patient with emphysema: sudden unilateral pleuritic pain, dyspnea, reduced breath sounds and hyperresonance on the affected side. Pneumonia and pleurisy give pleuritic pain with fever, cough and crackles or a friction rub. A Pancoast tumor at the lung apex produces shoulder and medial arm pain (C8 to T1), hand intrinsic weakness and Horner syndrome in a smoker; it is often first treated as a thoracic outlet or cervical problem.
Reasoning: Exertional interscapular discomfort that settles with rest, in a man with diabetes and hypertension, is angina or an evolving acute coronary syndrome with atypical location. Mild tenderness does not change that. The next step is emergency evaluation today, not a thoracic adjustment. Do not let the shoveling story anchor you to a mechanical diagnosis.
Reasoning: Unilateral dermatomal burning with allodynia before a rash in an older adult is the herpes zoster prodrome; the vesicles confirm it. Refer the same day for antiviral therapy, ideally within 72 hours of rash onset, and counsel that the lesions are contagious to people who have not had chickenpox. Manipulation of the segment would not be harmful in itself, but treating it as a rib problem delays the treatment that reduces the risk of postherpetic neuralgia.
Thoracic and chest pain is musculoskeletal when it behaves mechanically and the patient is otherwise well. Exertional, pleuritic, tearing or meal related pain, abnormal vitals and systemic symptoms point to the heart, aorta, lungs or gut and need referral by urgency. Compression fracture and the shingles prodrome are the two mechanical looking traps.
Section 3Low back and pelvic presentations
Triage first
About 90 percent of low back pain is nonspecific mechanical pain, roughly 5 to 10 percent is radicular, and only 1 to 2 percent is serious pathology (fracture, cancer, infection, cauda equina syndrome, inflammatory disease, aneurysm or visceral disease). Board vignettes over represent the last group, so read every low back case for its red flags before you name a mechanical diagnosis.
| Presentation | Key clue | Most likely diagnosis | Must not miss alternative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acute back pain after lifting, worse with sitting and flexion, normal neuro exam | Mechanical behavior, no leg dominance | Nonspecific mechanical low back pain | Fracture in an older or steroid treated patient |
| Leg pain below the knee worse than back pain, positive SLR at 30 to 70 degrees | Dermatomal pain, tension sign | Disc herniation with radiculopathy | Cauda equina syndrome |
| Over 60, legs ache and tire with walking or standing, relieved by sitting or leaning on a cart | Flexion relief, positional | Central lumbar stenosis | Vascular claudication |
| Teen athlete with extension pain, gymnast or lineman | Pain with one leg extension, hamstring tightness | Spondylolysis or isthmic spondylolisthesis | Osteoid osteoma (night pain relieved by NSAIDs) |
| Buttock pain below L5, no pain above, worse rising or climbing stairs | Fortin finger point at the PSIS, positive provocation cluster | Sacroiliac joint pain | Sacroiliitis of spondyloarthritis |
| Under 40, insidious, morning stiffness over 30 minutes, better with exercise | Night pain in the second half of the night, alternating buttock pain | Axial spondyloarthritis | Infection or tumor if systemic signs |
| Older smoker, deep boring back pain unaffected by position, pulsatile abdominal mass | Nonmechanical pain, vascular risk | Abdominal aortic aneurysm | Rupture (emergency) |
Disc herniation and radiculopathy
Lumbar disc herniation peaks in the 30s to 50s and about 95 percent occur at L4 to L5 or L5 to S1. A posterolateral herniation compresses the traversing root (the lower number): an L4 to L5 disc affects L5, and an L5 to S1 disc affects S1. A far lateral (foraminal) herniation compresses the exiting root (the upper number), so an L4 to L5 far lateral disc affects L4. Pain is worse with sitting, bending, coughing and sneezing (raised intradiscal and intrathecal pressure), and the patient may lean away from the side of the lesion (antalgic list).
| Root | Pain and sensory change | Weakness | Reflex | Functional test |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| L4 | Anterior thigh, medial leg and medial malleolus | Tibialis anterior (dorsiflexion and inversion), quadriceps | Patellar | Heel walk, squat and rise |
| L5 | Lateral leg and dorsum of the foot, web of the great toe | Extensor hallucis longus, gluteus medius, foot eversion is spared or mild | None reliable (medial hamstring) | Heel walk, great toe extension |
| S1 | Posterior calf, lateral foot and little toe, sole | Gastrocnemius and soleus, peroneals, gluteus maximus | Achilles | Toe walk, repeated single leg heel raises |
The straight leg raise is positive when it reproduces leg pain below the knee between about 30 and 70 degrees. It is sensitive (about 0.9) but not specific; the crossed SLR (raising the well leg reproduces pain in the affected leg) is highly specific (about 0.9) and suggests a large or sequestered fragment. The slump test is slightly more sensitive. A positive femoral nerve stretch (prone knee bend) points to L2 to L4 roots. Centralization of symptoms with repeated movements predicts a good prognosis.
Cauda equina syndrome
Cauda equina syndrome is compression of multiple lumbosacral roots below the conus, usually by a large central L4 to L5 or L5 to S1 disc herniation, and less commonly by tumor, abscess, hematoma or severe stenosis. The clues are saddle anesthesia (perineum, buttocks, inner thighs), urinary retention with overflow incontinence (the most consistent finding, about 90 percent), fecal incontinence or reduced anal tone, sexual dysfunction, and bilateral or alternating sciatica with progressive leg weakness and reduced ankle reflexes. Back pain alone with any new bladder or perineal change is enough to act. This is a surgical emergency: send the patient to the emergency department for same day MRI, because outcomes are best when decompression occurs within about 48 hours, before retention is established. Conus medullaris syndrome (T12 to L1) causes more symmetric, early sphincter dysfunction with mixed upper and lower motor neuron signs and less pain.
Stenosis, spondylolisthesis and the sacroiliac joint
Central lumbar stenosis results from disc bulge, facet hypertrophy and ligamentum flavum thickening, usually at L4 to L5, in patients over 60. Its hallmark is neurogenic claudication: bilateral buttock and leg aching, heaviness or numbness provoked by standing and walking (extension) and relieved by sitting or flexion (the shopping cart sign). The best history items are relief with sitting and absence of pain when seated; a wide based gait and a positive Romberg add specificity. Lateral recess and foraminal stenosis give unilateral radicular pain with similar positional behavior.
| Feature | Neurogenic claudication (stenosis) | Vascular claudication (peripheral artery disease) |
|---|---|---|
| Provoked by | Standing or walking, any extended posture | Walking a fixed distance (exercise) |
| Relieved by | Sitting or bending forward, takes minutes | Standing still, within 1 to 2 minutes |
| Uphill and cycling | Uphill (flexed) and cycling tolerated | Uphill and cycling worsen pain |
| Location | Buttock and thigh, dermatomal or diffuse | Calf most often (aortoiliac disease: buttock and thigh) |
| Pulses and skin | Normal | Reduced pulses, shiny hairless skin, ABI under 0.9 |
Spondylolisthesis is forward slippage of one vertebra on the one below. Isthmic spondylolisthesis follows a pars interarticularis fracture (spondylolysis), almost always at L5 on S1, in adolescents who repetitively hyperextend (gymnasts, divers, football linemen, cricket bowlers). Degenerative spondylolisthesis is due to facet arthrosis with an intact pars, occurs typically at L4 on L5, is more common in women over 50, and often causes stenosis. Clues are extension pain, hamstring tightness, and a palpable step off (above the slipped level in isthmic slips, because the posterior arch stays behind; at the slipped level in degenerative slips). The Meyerding grade (I under 25 percent, II 25 to 50, III 50 to 75, IV 75 to 100, V spondyloptosis) is discussed with imaging.
Sacroiliac joint pain is felt below L5 over the PSIS and buttock, sometimes into the posterior thigh, rarely below the knee. No single test is reliable, but the Laslett cluster (distraction, compression, thigh thrust, sacral thrust, Gaenslen) is useful: three or more positive of the five gives a positive likelihood ratio of about 4, especially when centralization is absent. Pregnancy and the postpartum period, leg length difference, and trauma (falls onto the buttock) are typical stories.
Inflammatory back pain and the mimics
Inflammatory back pain (ASAS criteria) is chronic back pain beginning before age 40, insidious in onset, improving with exercise but not with rest, with pain at night that improves on getting up; four of these five features give a sensitivity of about 77 percent and specificity of about 92 percent. Supporting clues are alternating buttock pain, enthesitis (heel), uveitis, psoriasis, inflammatory bowel disease, a family history, a good response to NSAIDs, raised CRP and HLA B27. The spondyloarthropathies are covered in Chapter 8; the impression step here is to recognize the pattern and refer for rheumatologic evaluation rather than treating it as mechanical pain for months.
Visceral and vascular causes of back pain are nonmechanical: pain that does not change with position or activity, night pain, colicky pain, and pain with systemic symptoms. Abdominal aortic aneurysm (men over 65, smokers, hypertension, family history) may cause deep back, flank or abdominal pain and a pulsatile, expansile mass above the umbilicus; a widened aortic shadow or curvilinear calcification on a lateral lumbar film is a clue. A symptomatic or tender aneurysm, or pain with hypotension and syncope, means rupture or impending rupture: call emergency services. An asymptomatic aneurysm of 3.0 to 5.4 cm is referred for surveillance; 5.5 cm or more, or growth over 1 cm per year, is referred for repair. Avoid forceful lumbar manipulation and deep abdominal work in known aneurysm. Renal colic (writhing, colicky flank pain radiating to the groin with hematuria), pyelonephritis (fever, flank pain, costovertebral angle tenderness), pancreatitis, and gynecologic or prostate disease are discussed with visceral referral in Chapter 8.
Reasoning: Saddle anesthesia and urinary retention with bilateral reflex loss are cauda equina syndrome, most likely from a large central L5 to S1 disc herniation. The next step is immediate emergency department referral for MRI and surgical decompression. Do not manipulate, do not wait for the next visit, and do not attribute retention to pain medication.
Reasoning: Relief with standing still, intolerance of cycling, faint pulses and trophic skin changes indicate vascular claudication from peripheral artery disease, not neurogenic claudication. Measure or refer for an ankle brachial index (under 0.9 confirms disease), and refer to the primary care provider for vascular risk management. Ask about abdominal pulsation, since aneurysm shares the same risk factors.
Name the low back diagnosis from its behavior: flexion sensitive back pain (mechanical), leg dominant dermatomal pain with tension signs (herniation), extension sensitive leg pain relieved by sitting (stenosis), adolescent extension pain (spondylolysis), buttock pain below L5 with a positive provocation cluster (sacroiliac), and young onset morning stiffness better with exercise (inflammatory). Saddle anesthesia or retention is cauda equina, and nonmechanical pain with vascular risk is an aneurysm until proven otherwise.
Section 4Extremity presentations
How extremity vignettes are built
Extremity cases almost always give you three things: the patient's age, the mechanism (overuse, a specific traumatic event, or insidious onset), and one discriminating examination finding. Combine them and the diagnosis usually falls out. Always ask two further questions: could this be referred from the spine or a viscus (neck for shoulder pain, hip for knee pain, heart or diaphragm for left shoulder pain), and does it need imaging before treatment?
| Region | Case clues | Most likely diagnosis | Do not miss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shoulder | 40 to 60, overhead work, painful arc 60 to 120 degrees, pain with resisted abduction, positive Hawkins and Neer | Rotator cuff tendinopathy or subacromial pain | Cervical radiculopathy (C5), referred cardiac or diaphragmatic pain |
| Shoulder | Over 60, fall, cannot lift the arm, positive drop arm and external rotation lag | Full thickness rotator cuff tear | Fracture or dislocation; refer for imaging |
| Shoulder | 40 to 60, often diabetic or hypothyroid, global loss of passive motion, external rotation lost most (capsular pattern) | Adhesive capsulitis | Posterior dislocation (locked internal rotation), osteoarthritis |
| Shoulder | Young athlete, sense of slipping with abduction and external rotation, positive apprehension and relocation | Anterior glenohumeral instability | Labral (Bankart) or Hill Sachs lesion |
| Elbow | 35 to 55, gripping, pain at lateral epicondyle, positive Cozen and Mill tests | Lateral elbow tendinopathy (tennis elbow) | Radial tunnel syndrome, C6 radiculopathy |
| Elbow | Medial epicondyle pain with resisted wrist flexion and pronation; young thrower with medial pain and valgus laxity | Medial epicondylalgia; ulnar collateral ligament sprain | Ulnar neuropathy (cubital tunnel) |
| Wrist and hand | New mother or repetitive thumb use, radial styloid pain, positive Finkelstein | De Quervain tenosynovitis | Scaphoid fracture, first CMC arthritis |
| Wrist and hand | Fall on outstretched hand, anatomical snuffbox tenderness, normal initial film | Scaphoid fracture until proven otherwise | Avascular necrosis of the proximal pole; immobilize and re image |
| Wrist and hand | Night paresthesia of thumb to radial ring finger, shaking hand relieves it, positive Phalen, Durkan and Tinel | Carpal tunnel syndrome | C6 to C7 radiculopathy, double crush, hypothyroidism, pregnancy, diabetes |
| Hip | Over 50, groin pain, morning stiffness under 1 hour, loss of internal rotation | Hip osteoarthritis | Avascular necrosis (steroids, alcohol), occult femoral neck fracture |
| Hip | Middle aged woman, lateral hip pain lying on that side, tender greater trochanter, pain with single leg stance | Greater trochanteric pain syndrome (gluteal tendinopathy) | L5 radiculopathy, hip joint disease |
| Hip | Young athlete, groin pain with flexion, adduction and internal rotation (FADIR), clicking | Femoroacetabular impingement or labral tear | Femoral neck stress fracture (runner, female athlete triad) |
| Knee | Pivot with a pop, swelling within 2 hours, positive Lachman | Anterior cruciate ligament tear | Associated meniscus and MCL injury; fracture (Ottawa) |
| Knee | Twisting on a flexed knee, delayed swelling, joint line tenderness, locking, positive Thessaly and McMurray | Meniscal tear | Loose body, osteochondritis dissecans |
| Knee | Adolescent or young runner, anterior knee pain with stairs, squatting and prolonged sitting | Patellofemoral pain syndrome | Slipped capital femoral epiphysis referring to the knee |
| Ankle and foot | Inversion injury, lateral swelling, tender ATFL, positive anterior drawer | Lateral ankle sprain | Fracture (apply Ottawa), high ankle sprain, fifth metatarsal fracture |
| Ankle and foot | First steps in the morning stab at the medial heel, eases then returns | Plantar fasciopathy | Calcaneal stress fracture, tarsal tunnel, enthesitis of spondyloarthritis |
| Ankle and foot | Sudden "kick" in the calf during a lunge, positive Thompson | Achilles tendon rupture | Calf DVT; refer the same day for orthopedic care |
Rules that decide imaging
The Ottawa ankle rules call for ankle radiographs when there is pain in the malleolar zone and any of: bone tenderness along the distal 6 cm of the posterior edge or tip of the lateral malleolus, bone tenderness along the distal 6 cm of the posterior edge or tip of the medial malleolus, or inability to bear weight for four steps both immediately and in the office. Foot radiographs are needed for midfoot pain with tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal or the navicular, or inability to bear weight. Sensitivity is close to 100 percent, so a negative rule safely avoids imaging. The Ottawa knee rule calls for a film after acute knee injury in a patient aged 55 or older, with isolated patellar tenderness, fibular head tenderness, inability to flex to 90 degrees, or inability to bear weight for four steps.
Reasoning: Snuffbox tenderness after a fall on an outstretched hand is a scaphoid fracture until proven otherwise; up to a fifth are not visible on initial films. Immobilize in a thumb spica splint and obtain repeat radiographs with a scaphoid view in 10 to 14 days, or MRI now. Do not adjust the wrist or reassure him because the first film was normal; a missed waist or proximal pole fracture risks nonunion and avascular necrosis.
Extremity diagnosis is age plus mechanism plus one discriminating finding. Before treatment, decide whether the complaint is referred from the spine or a viscus and whether a decision rule (Ottawa ankle, foot or knee) or a fracture prone mechanism such as a fall on the outstretched hand calls for imaging.
Section 5Neurologic presentations
Localize first, then name
Neurologic vignettes reward the habit of localizing the lesion before guessing a disease. Weakness, sensory change and reflexes together place the problem in the brain, cord, root, plexus, peripheral nerve, neuromuscular junction or muscle.
| Site | Pattern | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Upper motor neuron (brain, cord) | Weakness of a region or one side, spasticity, hyperreflexia, Babinski, little early atrophy | Stroke, multiple sclerosis, myelopathy |
| Nerve root | One myotome, one dermatome, one reflex, with spinal pain | Disc herniation, foraminal stenosis |
| Peripheral nerve | Muscles and skin of one nerve, Tinel at the site, reflex reduced if the nerve carries it | Carpal tunnel, peroneal palsy |
| Polyneuropathy | Symmetric, distal, length dependent stocking and glove loss, ankle reflexes lost first | Diabetes, B12 deficiency, alcohol |
| Neuromuscular junction | Fatigable weakness, ptosis and diplopia, normal sensation and reflexes | Myasthenia gravis |
| Muscle | Symmetric proximal weakness, normal sensation, reflexes preserved until late, raised CK | Polymyositis, statin myopathy |
| Mixed upper and lower motor neuron | Fasciculations and atrophy plus brisk reflexes, no sensory loss | Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis |
Peripheral neuropathy and entrapment
Diabetic polyneuropathy is the most common neuropathy: symmetric burning or numbness starting in the toes, loss of vibration (128 Hz tuning fork) and of 10 g monofilament sensation, and absent ankle reflexes. Loss of protective sensation means daily foot inspection and podiatry referral because of ulcer risk. Other causes to name from clues are vitamin B12 deficiency (vegan diet, metformin, proton pump inhibitors, gastric surgery, pernicious anemia; posterior column loss with a positive Romberg and macrocytosis), alcohol, hypothyroidism, chemotherapy, and Guillain Barre syndrome, which is an ascending symmetric weakness with areflexia over days, often 1 to 3 weeks after a diarrheal or respiratory illness. Guillain Barre is an emergency because of respiratory failure.
Common entrapments are median nerve at the carpal tunnel (thenar weakness, sensory loss on the radial three and a half digits sparing the thenar eminence, because the palmar cutaneous branch passes above the tunnel), ulnar nerve at the cubital tunnel (little and ulnar ring finger numbness including the dorsal hand, interossei weakness, Froment sign) or at Guyon canal (dorsal ulnar hand spared), radial nerve at the spiral groove (wrist drop, "Saturday night palsy," triceps spared), common peroneal at the fibular head (foot drop with weak eversion, sensory loss on the dorsum, from leg crossing or rapid weight loss), and the lateral femoral cutaneous nerve at the inguinal ligament (meralgia paresthetica: burning anterolateral thigh with no weakness, tight belts, obesity, pregnancy). Distinguish peroneal palsy from L5 radiculopathy: L5 also weakens inversion (tibialis posterior) and hip abduction, and often brings back pain.
Multiple sclerosis, stroke and TIA, Parkinson disease
Multiple sclerosis is a demyelinating disease of the central nervous system, usually in women aged 20 to 40. Episodes are separated in time and space: optic neuritis (painful monocular vision loss with pain on eye movement), internuclear ophthalmoplegia, transverse myelitis, sensory loss, Lhermitte sign, fatigue, and the Uhthoff phenomenon (worsening with heat such as a hot shower). Examination shows upper motor neuron signs. Refer for MRI (periventricular, juxtacortical, infratentorial and cord lesions) and neurology.
Stroke is sudden focal deficit: face droop, arm drift, speech change (BE FAST: balance, eyes, face, arm, speech, time). Middle cerebral artery strokes affect the face and arm more than the leg, with aphasia if dominant; anterior cerebral artery strokes affect the leg; posterior circulation strokes cause vertigo, ataxia, diplopia, dysarthria and crossed signs (ipsilateral face, contralateral body, as in Wallenberg lateral medullary syndrome). Thrombolysis is time limited, so call emergency services and note the time last known well. A TIA resolves, usually within an hour, without infarction; it is a warning, with stroke risk highest in the first 48 hours, so it needs same day emergency evaluation. Amaurosis fugax (a curtain over one eye for minutes) is a carotid TIA.
Parkinson disease is loss of dopaminergic neurons in the substantia nigra, usually after 60. The cardinal signs are bradykinesia plus rest tremor (4 to 6 Hz pill rolling, reduced with action), rigidity (cogwheel or lead pipe) and later postural instability. Early clues include asymmetric onset, micrographia, hypomimia (masked face), reduced arm swing, a soft voice, constipation, loss of smell and REM sleep behavior disorder. The gait is shuffling and festinating with en bloc turning and freezing. Contrast essential tremor: a bilateral action and postural tremor, often familial, improved by alcohol, with head or voice involvement and no bradykinesia. Patients with Parkinson disease are at high risk for falls and osteoporotic fractures.
Vertigo and dizziness
Start by asking what "dizzy" means (spinning vertigo, presyncope, disequilibrium) and then sort by timing and trigger.
| Timing and trigger | Key clues | Most likely diagnosis | Test or next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seconds, triggered by rolling over, looking up or lying down | Latency of a few seconds, fatigable torsional upbeating nystagmus | BPPV (posterior canal in most) | Dix Hallpike, then Epley canalith repositioning |
| Episodes of 20 minutes to 12 hours | Fluctuating low frequency hearing loss, tinnitus, aural fullness | Meniere disease | Audiology and ENT referral |
| Continuous for days after a viral illness | Horizontal nystagmus beating away from the lesion, positive head impulse test, can walk, hearing normal | Vestibular neuritis (labyrinthitis if hearing lost) | HINTS to exclude stroke; vestibular rehabilitation |
| Continuous, sudden, vascular risk factors | Normal head impulse, direction changing nystagmus, skew deviation, cannot stand, other brainstem signs | Posterior circulation stroke | Emergency |
| Lightheaded on standing | BP drop of 20 systolic or 10 diastolic within 3 minutes | Orthostatic hypotension | Medication review, medical referral |
The Dix Hallpike test takes the seated patient quickly into supine with the head turned 45 degrees to one side and extended about 20 degrees over the table edge; a positive test is vertigo with upbeating torsional nystagmus toward the lower ear after a short latency, lasting under a minute and fatiguing on repetition. The HINTS examination (Head Impulse, Nystagmus, Test of Skew) is used in continuous vertigo: an abnormal head impulse, unidirectional nystagmus and no skew is reassuring (peripheral), while a normal head impulse, direction changing nystagmus or a skew deviation (any one "INFARCT" finding) suggests stroke, with sensitivity higher than early MRI.
Reasoning: Foot drop with weak eversion but normal inversion and hip abduction, a normal reflex and a positive Tinel at the fibular head points to common peroneal neuropathy, not L5 radiculopathy. Advise him to stop leg crossing, protect the fibular head, consider an ankle foot orthosis, and refer for electrodiagnostic testing if there is no improvement in a few weeks. Treating the lumbar spine alone would miss the lesion.
Reasoning: Continuous vertigo with direction changing nystagmus, a normal head impulse and skew deviation is a central (INFARCT) pattern, most likely a posterior circulation stroke in a patient with an embolic source. Call emergency services and record the time last known well. Do not diagnose vestibular neuritis and do not perform positional maneuvers.
Localize before naming: upper or lower motor neuron, root, nerve, junction or muscle. Symmetric distal sensory loss is polyneuropathy; a single nerve's territory with Tinel is entrapment; relapsing central signs in a young woman suggest MS; sudden focal deficit is stroke or TIA; bradykinesia with rest tremor is Parkinson disease. For vertigo, timing and the HINTS exam separate benign peripheral causes from stroke.
The chapter in one breath
- Mechanical neck pain has a normal neurologic exam; radiculopathy gives one level of lower motor neuron signs; myelopathy gives clumsy hands, gait ataxia and upper motor neuron signs and contraindicates high velocity cervical manipulation.
- The Wainner cluster (ULTT A, rotation under 60 degrees, distraction, Spurling) supports cervical radiculopathy; the Canadian C spine rule decides trauma imaging.
- Clear the SNOOP red flags before naming tension type, migraine, cluster or cervicogenic headache (side locked, neck provoked, positive flexion rotation test).
- New, unusual neck pain with headache plus Horner syndrome or posterior circulation signs is cervical artery dissection: no manipulation, emergency referral.
- Thoracic pain that is exertional, pleuritic, tearing or meal related, or accompanied by abnormal vitals, is visceral until proven otherwise; palpation tenderness does not exclude ischemia.
- Compression fracture (older patient, minor trauma, percussion tenderness) and the zoster prodrome (dermatomal burning with allodynia before the rash) are mechanical looking traps.
- Posterolateral lumbar discs hit the traversing root; far lateral discs hit the exiting root; crossed SLR is the specific sign.
- Cauda equina syndrome (saddle anesthesia, urinary retention, bilateral deficits) is a same day surgical emergency.
- Neurogenic claudication is relieved by sitting and flexion; vascular claudication is relieved by standing still and comes with poor pulses.
- Inflammatory back pain starts before 40, is insidious, and improves with exercise, not rest; nonmechanical back pain with vascular risk raises abdominal aortic aneurysm.
- Extremity diagnosis is age plus mechanism plus one discriminating sign; the Ottawa rules and snuffbox tenderness decide imaging.
- In vertigo, brief positional spells are BPPV; continuous vertigo needs HINTS, where a normal head impulse, changing nystagmus or skew means stroke.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Allodynia | Pain from a stimulus that is normally painless, such as clothing on the skin. |
| Cauda equina syndrome | Compression of several lumbosacral roots causing saddle anesthesia, sphincter dysfunction and leg deficits. |
| Cervical artery dissection | An intimal tear of the vertebral or internal carotid artery that can cause stroke. |
| Cervicogenic headache | Headache referred from upper cervical structures through the trigeminocervical nucleus. |
| Crossed straight leg raise | Raising the unaffected leg reproduces sciatica in the affected leg; specific for disc herniation. |
| Dix Hallpike test | Rapid positioning test that provokes nystagmus and vertigo in posterior canal BPPV. |
| Exiting root | The nerve root leaving through the foramen at a given level, affected by far lateral discs. |
| Flexion rotation test | Passive rotation with full cervical flexion to isolate C1 to C2 motion. |
| HINTS examination | Head impulse, nystagmus and skew testing to separate peripheral from central vertigo. |
| Hoffmann sign | Thumb and index flexion when the middle fingernail is flicked, an upper motor neuron sign. |
| Horner syndrome | Ptosis, miosis and sometimes anhidrosis from interruption of the sympathetic chain. |
| Inflammatory back pain | Insidious back pain before 40 that improves with exercise and not with rest. |
| Isthmic spondylolisthesis | Forward slip of a vertebra due to a pars interarticularis defect, usually L5. |
| Lhermitte sign | An electric sensation down the spine on neck flexion, seen in cord lesions such as MS. |
| Myelopathy | Dysfunction of the spinal cord, producing upper motor neuron signs below the lesion. |
| Neurogenic claudication | Leg pain with standing and walking from stenosis, relieved by sitting or flexion. |
| Ottawa ankle rules | A decision rule that identifies which ankle and midfoot injuries need radiographs. |
| Radiculopathy | Dysfunction of a nerve root, with dermatomal, myotomal and reflex change. |
| Saddle anesthesia | Loss of sensation over the perineum, buttocks and inner thighs. |
| Skew deviation | Vertical misalignment of the eyes from a brainstem lesion. |
| SNOOP | Mnemonic for headache red flags: systemic, neurologic, onset sudden, older, pattern change. |
| Traversing root | The root that crosses a disc to exit one level lower, affected by posterolateral discs. |
| Vascular claudication | Exercise induced leg pain from arterial insufficiency, relieved by standing still. |
Check yourself
Clinical Impression II: Systemic, Visceral and Special Population Presentations
The patients who are harmed in practice are rarely the ones with an unusual mechanical problem; they are the ones whose cancer, infection, inflammatory disease or visceral disorder was treated as back pain for too long. This chapter teaches the systemic, visceral and special population presentations that Part III uses to test whether you can see past the musculoskeletal surface, and then shows how to pull history, examination, imaging and laboratory findings together into a defensible primary and secondary diagnosis.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Recognize rheumatoid arthritis, the spondyloarthropathies, gout and polymyalgia rheumatica from joint distribution, stiffness pattern and laboratory clues.
- Separate fibromyalgia, hypothyroid myopathy, diabetic musculoskeletal syndromes and osteoporosis from mechanical pain.
- Identify the case clues of metastatic bone disease, multiple myeloma and the common primary bone tumors.
- Recognize vertebral osteomyelitis, discitis and spinal epidural abscess and refer with the right urgency.
- Map visceral referral from the heart, aorta, kidney, gallbladder, pancreas, pelvic organs and prostate to the back and shoulder.
- Distinguish growing pains from pediatric pathology, and recognize scoliosis, SCFE and Legg Calve Perthes disease.
- Assess falls and fragility fractures in older adults and the red flags of pregnancy related pain.
- Build a clinical impression with a primary diagnosis, secondary diagnoses and a ranked differential, and handle extended matching style items.
Section 1Inflammatory, metabolic and systemic disease presenting as musculoskeletal pain
Inflammatory versus mechanical
The first discrimination in any joint or spine case is whether the pain is inflammatory or mechanical. Inflammatory pain is worst after rest, with morning stiffness longer than 30 to 60 minutes, eases with activity, may wake the patient in the second half of the night, and comes with soft tissue swelling, warmth and sometimes systemic features (fatigue, low grade fever, weight loss) and raised ESR or CRP. Mechanical pain worsens with use, stiffness after rest lasts minutes (gelling), and swelling, when present, is bony. The second discrimination is the pattern: how many joints (mono, oligo or polyarticular), which joints, symmetric or not, and whether the spine and entheses are involved.
The inflammatory arthritides
Rheumatoid arthritis is a symmetric, small joint polyarthritis (MCP, PIP, wrist, MTP) that spares the DIP joints and the thoracolumbar spine, with morning stiffness over an hour, fatigue, and in established disease ulnar deviation, swan neck and boutonniere deformities and rheumatoid nodules. It is three times more common in women, peaking at 30 to 50. Rheumatoid factor is positive in about 70 to 80 percent, but anti CCP antibody is more specific (about 95 percent). The chiropractic must know is atlantoaxial instability: synovitis erodes the transverse ligament and dens, so an anterior atlantodental interval over 3 mm in an adult on a flexion film is abnormal, and patients may report occipital pain, Lhermitte sign or myelopathic signs. Rotational and high velocity upper cervical manipulation is contraindicated in active RA until instability is excluded.
The seronegative spondyloarthropathies share HLA B27 association, sacroiliitis, enthesitis, asymmetric large joint oligoarthritis, anterior uveitis, and negative rheumatoid factor.
| Disease | Case clues | Key findings | Impression note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ankylosing spondylitis | Man under 40, inflammatory back pain, reduced chest expansion (under 2.5 cm), alternating buttock pain, heel pain, painful red eye | Bilateral symmetric sacroiliitis, marginal syndesmophytes, positive Schober (under 5 cm increase), HLA B27 in about 90 percent | Fused spine is fracture prone: new pain after minor trauma needs imaging |
| Psoriatic arthritis | Psoriasis (scalp, umbilicus, gluteal cleft), nail pitting, sausage digit | DIP erosions, pencil in cup, asymmetric sacroiliitis, nonmarginal syndesmophytes | Skin disease may follow joint disease in about 15 percent |
| Reactive arthritis | Young adult 1 to 4 weeks after urethritis (Chlamydia) or diarrhea (Salmonella, Shigella, Campylobacter, Yersinia) | Asymmetric lower limb arthritis, conjunctivitis, urethritis, heel enthesitis, keratoderma blennorrhagicum | Treat or refer the triggering infection |
| Enteropathic arthritis | Crohn disease or ulcerative colitis, diarrhea with blood or weight loss | Peripheral arthritis tracking bowel activity; axial disease independent of it | Co manage with gastroenterology |
Gout is urate crystal arthritis: a sudden, exquisitely painful, red, hot, swollen joint, classically the first MTP (podagra), often overnight after alcohol, a large meat or seafood meal, dehydration, or starting a thiazide or loop diuretic. Risk factors are male sex, obesity, metabolic syndrome, chronic kidney disease and low dose aspirin. Serum urate may be normal during an attack. The definitive test is joint aspiration showing negatively birefringent needle shaped crystals. Chronic tophaceous gout causes punched out periarticular erosions with overhanging edges. Pseudogout (calcium pyrophosphate deposition) affects the knee and wrist of older adults, with chondrocalcinosis on films and positively birefringent rhomboid crystals. The must not miss alternative for a hot single joint is septic arthritis: fever, inability to bear weight or move the joint, and immunosuppression or a recent joint injection. A hot joint is septic until aspirated.
Polymyalgia rheumatica and fibromyalgia
Polymyalgia rheumatica occurs almost exclusively after 50 (mean around 70), more often in women. It causes bilateral aching and marked morning stiffness of the shoulder and hip girdles and neck, with difficulty rising from a chair, getting out of bed or combing the hair. Strength is normal when tested (pain limits it), CK is normal, and the ESR is high (often over 40, frequently over 50 mm per hour) with a raised CRP. The response to low dose prednisone is dramatic within days. About 15 to 20 percent also have giant cell arteritis, so ask every patient about new headache, jaw claudication, scalp tenderness and visual change.
Fibromyalgia is a central pain sensitization disorder: widespread pain for three months or more (both sides, above and below the waist, and axial), with fatigue, unrefreshing sleep and cognitive symptoms ("fibro fog"), often with irritable bowel, headache and mood disorder. Current criteria use a widespread pain index and symptom severity score rather than tender points. Laboratory tests are normal, which is the point: the impression of fibromyalgia requires that hypothyroidism, polymyalgia, inflammatory arthritis, vitamin D deficiency and statin myopathy have been considered. Management emphasizes graded aerobic exercise, sleep hygiene and education.
Metabolic and endocrine causes
| Condition | Musculoskeletal presentation | Clues and tests |
|---|---|---|
| Hypothyroidism | Proximal myalgia and stiffness, carpal tunnel syndrome, slow relaxing reflexes, fatigue | Cold intolerance, weight gain, constipation, dry skin; raised TSH, low free T4, mildly raised CK |
| Diabetes mellitus | Adhesive capsulitis, trigger finger, Dupuytren contracture, carpal tunnel, diabetic cheiroarthropathy (prayer sign), DISH, neuropathic (Charcot) foot | Polyuria, thirst; fasting glucose 126 or more, HbA1c 6.5 percent or more |
| Osteoporosis | Silent until fracture: vertebral compression, hip, distal radius; height loss, kyphosis | DXA T score of minus 2.5 or lower, or a fragility fracture; check vitamin D, calcium, secondary causes |
| Osteomalacia | Diffuse bone pain and tenderness, proximal weakness, waddling gait | Low vitamin D, low or normal calcium and phosphate, raised alkaline phosphatase, Looser zones |
| Hyperparathyroidism | Bone pain, "stones, bones, groans and psychiatric overtones" | Raised calcium and PTH, subperiosteal resorption of the radial middle phalanges |
| Paget disease | Over 55, deep bone pain, enlarging skull or bowed tibia, hearing loss | Markedly raised alkaline phosphatase with normal calcium; thickened cortex and coarse trabeculae |
Osteoporosis risk factors that appear in vignettes are female sex, age over 65, low body weight, smoking, excess alcohol, early menopause, family history of hip fracture, long term glucocorticoids (5 mg prednisone daily for three months or more), aromatase inhibitors, anticonvulsants, hyperthyroidism and rheumatoid arthritis. A T score between minus 1.0 and minus 2.5 is osteopenia. In osteoporosis, use low force techniques and avoid high velocity thrust to the thoracic spine and ribs.
Reasoning: Bilateral girdle pain with prolonged morning stiffness, normal strength, normal CK and a high ESR after age 50 is polymyalgia rheumatica; normal CK excludes a myositis. The new temporal headache raises concern for coexisting giant cell arteritis, which makes this a same day referral (vision is at risk) rather than routine. Do not label her as fibromyalgia or rotator cuff disease.
Ask whether pain is inflammatory or mechanical, then read the pattern: symmetric small joints with DIP sparing (RA), axial disease with enthesitis and uveitis (spondyloarthropathy), a hot first MTP (gout), girdle stiffness with a high ESR after 50 (PMR), widespread pain with normal labs (fibromyalgia). Systemic disease changes technique: RA threatens C1 to C2 stability, and osteoporosis and ankylosing spondylitis make bone fragile.
Section 2Neoplastic and infectious presentations
The pattern of serious spinal pathology
Tumor and infection share a recognizable history, and the board builds cases around it. Pain is constant and progressive, not relieved (or even worsened) by lying down, worse at night, and unresponsive to rest, positioning and a few weeks of conservative care. Systemic clues include unexplained weight loss, fatigue, fever, night sweats and malaise. The patient's history supplies the risk: a prior cancer, age over 50, immunosuppression, intravenous drug use, diabetes, a recent infection or procedure. The strongest single predictor of spinal malignancy is a previous history of cancer, which raises the probability many times over. Bone tenderness to percussion over a spinous process and failure to improve within about four to six weeks complete the picture.
Metastatic disease and myeloma
Metastases are by far the most common malignant lesion of bone in adults. The primaries that metastasize to bone are remembered as "PB KTL" (lead kettle): Prostate, Breast, Kidney, Thyroid and Lung. Breast and prostate account for most; lung metastases appear early and in smokers; renal and thyroid lesions are typically lytic and expansile. Prostate metastases are usually blastic (sclerotic, "ivory vertebra" possible), breast may be lytic, blastic or mixed. Metastases reach the spine through the arterial supply and the valveless Batson venous plexus, which explains the predilection for the vertebral bodies and pedicles of the thoracic and lumbar spine and the pelvis. The classic radiographic sign is the absent pedicle ("winking owl") on the AP view, because the pedicle is destroyed; vertebral body collapse with preserved disc height distinguishes tumor from infection, which destroys the disc first. Radiographs miss lesions until 30 to 50 percent of the trabecular bone is gone, so a normal film does not exclude metastasis; MRI or bone scan is the next step when suspicion is high.
Metastatic spinal cord compression is an oncologic emergency. It occurs in about 5 to 10 percent of patients with cancer; it may be the first presentation of an unknown primary. Back pain (often band like, worse lying flat or at night) precedes neurologic deficits by weeks. New weakness, sensory level, gait change or sphincter disturbance in a patient with cancer and back pain requires same day MRI of the whole spine and urgent oncology referral; ambulatory status at diagnosis is the main predictor of outcome.
Multiple myeloma is a malignant plasma cell proliferation, typically after 60, more common in Black patients. Remember CRAB: hyperCalcemia (thirst, constipation, confusion), Renal insufficiency, Anemia (fatigue, normocytic) and Bone lesions (back pain, punched out lytic lesions, pathologic compression fractures, diffuse osteopenia). Recurrent infections are common. The ESR is markedly raised, with rouleaux on the smear; serum protein electrophoresis shows an M spike, and urine may contain Bence Jones protein. Bone scan is often falsely negative because the lesions are purely lytic with little osteoblastic response, so a skeletal survey or whole body low dose CT or MRI is used.
Primary bone tumors
Primary bone tumors are rare, so the board tests them through age, location and a single classic clue.
| Tumor | Typical age | Location | Case clue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Osteoid osteoma | 10 to 30 | Femur, tibia, posterior elements of the spine | Night pain relieved by aspirin or NSAIDs; painful scoliosis concave to the lesion; small lucent nidus with dense sclerosis |
| Osteoblastoma | 10 to 30 | Spinal posterior elements | Larger than 1.5 to 2 cm, less NSAID response |
| Osteosarcoma | 10 to 25 (second peak in Paget disease) | Metaphysis around the knee | Painful swelling, sunburst periosteal reaction, Codman triangle |
| Ewing sarcoma | 5 to 20 | Diaphysis of long bones, pelvis | Fever and raised ESR mimic infection; onion skin periosteal reaction |
| Chondrosarcoma | Over 40 | Pelvis, proximal femur, shoulder | Ring and arc chondroid calcification, endosteal scalloping |
| Giant cell tumor | 20 to 40, after physeal closure | Epiphysis to subarticular bone, distal femur, proximal tibia, sacrum | Eccentric lytic "soap bubble" lesion without a sclerotic rim |
| Hemangioma | Any adult | Vertebral body | Usually incidental; vertical striations ("corduroy"), "polka dot" on axial CT |
| Chordoma | 40 to 60 | Sacrum and clivus | Midline destructive sacral mass, constipation, sacral pain |
Spinal infection
Vertebral osteomyelitis and discitis in adults usually arise by hematogenous spread from a urinary, skin, dental or endocarditis source, or after spinal procedures. Staphylococcus aureus is the most common organism; gram negative rods follow urinary infection, Pseudomonas is associated with intravenous drug use, Salmonella with sickle cell disease, and Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Pott disease) with immigrants from endemic regions, causing a gibbus deformity, paraspinal cold abscess and relative disc sparing. The adult disc is avascular, so infection seeds the endplate and spreads to the disc and adjacent vertebra. The presentation is progressive, severe, constant back pain, often with exquisite percussion tenderness and muscle spasm; fever is present in only about half. ESR and CRP are almost always raised (CRP is the most sensitive marker and the one used to follow treatment). Radiographs lag by two to four weeks; MRI is the test of choice. In children, discitis presents as refusal to walk, sit or bend, with a lordosis loss.
Spinal epidural abscess is the emergency form. The classic triad of back pain, fever and neurologic deficit is present in only a minority at first, so suspicion must come from risk factors: diabetes, intravenous drug use, alcoholism, recent spinal injection or surgery, an indwelling catheter or a distant infection. The usual sequence is back pain, then radicular pain, then weakness and sphincter loss, then paralysis, sometimes within hours. Any patient with back pain, a raised CRP or fever and a risk factor needs same day emergency evaluation and MRI with gadolinium.
Reasoning: Night pain, weight loss, a cancer history and percussion tenderness point to vertebral metastasis; the new leg weakness, brisk reflexes and sensory level mean metastatic spinal cord compression. This is an emergency: same day whole spine MRI and oncology or emergency referral. Do not order a routine plain film and wait, and do not manipulate the thoracic spine.
Reasoning: A diabetic patient with a recent skin infection, constant night pain, low grade fever, focal spinal tenderness and a very high CRP has vertebral osteomyelitis or a spinal epidural abscess until proven otherwise; normal films are expected early. Refer the same day for MRI with contrast and blood cultures. A normal neurologic examination is not reassuring, because deficits can appear within hours.
Constant, progressive, nonmechanical night pain with systemic symptoms and a risk factor (cancer history, age over 50, immunosuppression, diabetes, IV drug use, recent infection or procedure) means tumor or infection. Normal radiographs do not exclude either. New neurologic signs turn the referral into an emergency: cord compression and epidural abscess are measured in hours.
Section 3Visceral referral patterns in cases
Why viscera hurt in the back and shoulder
Visceral afferents travel with sympathetic nerves into the dorsal horn at the spinal segments that supplied the organ in the embryo, and they converge on the same dorsal horn neurons as somatic afferents from skin and muscle. The brain, more used to signals from the body wall, projects the pain to the corresponding dermatomes and myotomes. That is viscerosomatic convergence, and it explains why the heart (T1 to T5) refers to the chest, left arm and interscapular area, and why the gallbladder (T7 to T9 and the right phrenic nerve) refers to the right scapula. The diaphragm is a special case: its central part is innervated by the phrenic nerve (C3 to C5), so irritation of its undersurface by blood, pus or an inflamed organ refers pain to the shoulder tip (the C4 dermatome). Visceral disease can also cause reflex paraspinal muscle guarding and segmental tenderness (viscerosomatic reflex), which is why tenderness alone cannot tell you the source.
Organ by organ
| Organ | Where pain is felt | Case clues that betray the viscus | Urgency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heart | Retrosternal, left arm, jaw, interscapular, epigastric | Exertional, diaphoresis, dyspnea, risk factors; women and diabetics atypical | Emergency |
| Thoracic aorta (dissection) | Tearing chest pain to the interscapular back | Maximal at onset, arm BP difference over 20 mm Hg, pulse deficit | Emergency |
| Abdominal aorta (aneurysm) | Deep low back, flank, abdomen, groin | Older male smoker, pulsatile expansile mass, pain unchanged by movement | Emergency if symptomatic |
| Kidney and ureter | Flank and costovertebral angle, radiating to groin and testis or labia | Colicky, writhing (stone); fever, dysuria, CVA tenderness (pyelonephritis); hematuria | Same day; emergency if fever with obstruction |
| Gallbladder | Right upper quadrant, right scapula, right shoulder | After fatty meals, nausea; Murphy sign (inspiration stops on RUQ palpation), fever in cholecystitis; jaundice in obstruction | Same day to urgent |
| Pancreas | Epigastric boring pain through to the midback (T10 to L1 band) | Alcohol or gallstones, vomiting, relief leaning forward, raised lipase; weight loss and painless jaundice in cancer | Emergency in acute pancreatitis |
| Stomach and duodenum | Epigastric; posterior duodenal ulcer to the midback | Meal related, NSAID use, black stools; sudden severe pain with rigid abdomen in perforation | Emergency if bleeding or perforated |
| Spleen | Left upper quadrant and left shoulder tip (Kehr sign) | Trauma, recent mononucleosis in an athlete | Emergency |
| Uterus and ovaries | Low back, sacrum, lower abdomen | Cyclic pain (endometriosis, dysmenorrhea); missed period, vaginal bleeding, shoulder tip pain (ectopic pregnancy); fever and discharge (pelvic inflammatory disease) | Emergency for ectopic or torsion |
| Prostate | Sacrum, perineum, low back | Urinary hesitancy, nocturia, weak stream; fever and tender gland (prostatitis); older man with bone pain and raised PSA (cancer) | Urgent if fever or bone lesion |
| Colon and rectum | Sacrum, lower abdomen | Change in bowel habit, blood, anemia, weight loss over 50 | Urgent |
Screening questions that unmask visceral pain
Musculoskeletal pain has a mechanical signature; visceral pain has a systemic signature. When the examination fails to reproduce the complaint, or the pain does not behave mechanically, run a focused review of systems for the organ systems that share the segment. Useful questions include: Does eating, bowel movement or urination change the pain? Is there fever, sweats or weight loss? Any change in urine color or stream, blood in the stool or urine, or black stools? Shortness of breath or pain with exertion? Any vaginal bleeding, discharge or missed period? Any relationship to the menstrual cycle? Examination maneuvers that help include palpation of the abdominal aorta (a width over 3 cm is abnormal), Murphy sign, costovertebral angle percussion (Murphy punch), and testing for peritoneal irritation (rebound tenderness, McBurney point tenderness, psoas sign and obturator sign). A positive psoas sign (pain with resisted hip flexion or passive hip extension) can come from appendicitis, psoas abscess or a retroperitoneal process and mimics hip or lumbar pain.
Reasoning: Postprandial right scapular pain that movement does not reproduce, with nausea, fever and a positive Murphy sign, is acute cholecystitis. Right scapular referral occurs through T7 to T9 and, with diaphragmatic irritation, the phrenic nerve. Refer for same day medical evaluation with ultrasound. Treating the thoracic spine would miss an evolving surgical problem.
Reasoning: Colicky flank to groin pain with restlessness and hematuria is renal colic from a ureteral stone. Refer the same day for imaging and analgesia; refer emergently if fever develops, which suggests an infected obstructed kidney. A mechanical back problem would leave him lying still in a position of comfort.
Viscera refer pain to the dermatomes of their segments, and the diaphragm to the shoulder tip through C3 to C5. A complaint that the examination cannot reproduce, or that is tied to meals, urination, bowel habit, menses or exertion, needs a review of systems and a visceral examination. The location suggests the organ; the systemic signs set the urgency.
Section 4Pediatric, geriatric and pregnant patient presentations
Children: growing pains or pathology?
Musculoskeletal complaints in children are common, and most are benign. Growing pains affect children aged about 3 to 12: bilateral, intermittent, deep aching in the thighs, calves or behind the knees, in the evening or night, relieved by massage, with a completely normal child by morning, a normal examination, no limp and no joint swelling. Anything that breaks this pattern is not growing pains. Red flags in a child are unilateral pain, pain in a joint (rather than between joints), a limp or refusal to bear weight, morning stiffness, swelling, fever, weight loss, night pain that wakes the child, pain that persists in the day, bruising or pallor, and back pain in a child under about 10 (a structural or serious cause is more likely than in adults).
| Presentation in a child | Key clue | Most likely diagnosis | Must not miss and next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Limping toddler, no fever, recent minor fall | Tenderness of the distal tibia | Toddler's fracture (spiral tibial) | Abuse if the story does not fit; radiographs |
| 3 to 10 years, acute hip pain and limp after a viral illness, afebrile, able to bear weight | Mild loss of hip rotation | Transient synovitis | Septic arthritis (Kocher criteria); same day evaluation |
| Febrile child refuses to bear weight | Fever over 38.5 °C, ESR over 40, WBC over 12,000 | Septic arthritis of the hip | Emergency aspiration |
| 4 to 8 year old boy, painless or mild limp, knee or groin ache | Loss of internal rotation and abduction | Legg Calve Perthes disease | Radiographs, orthopedic referral |
| Overweight adolescent, 10 to 16, knee or thigh pain, out toed gait | Obligatory external rotation with hip flexion | Slipped capital femoral epiphysis | Stop weight bearing, urgent orthopedic referral |
| Active preteen with anterior knee pain at the tibial tubercle | Tender, prominent tubercle | Osgood Schlatter disease | Tumor if night pain or unilateral swelling |
| Child with bone pain, pallor, bruising, fever | Abnormal blood count | Acute leukemia | Same day blood count and referral |
| Teen with painful scoliosis and night pain relieved by NSAIDs | Rapid onset, rigid curve | Osteoid osteoma | Imaging; painful scoliosis is never idiopathic |
Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) is displacement of the femoral head off the neck through the physis, posteriorly and medially, during the adolescent growth spurt. It is most common in overweight boys aged 10 to 16, and is bilateral in about 20 to 40 percent; endocrine disorders (hypothyroidism, growth hormone deficiency) should be considered when it occurs outside the usual age range. The trap is that pain is often referred to the knee or thigh through the obturator nerve. On examination the hip falls into external rotation as it is flexed (Drehmann sign), with limited internal rotation. On the AP film, Klein line along the superior femoral neck fails to intersect the femoral head; the frog leg lateral is more sensitive for early slips. An unstable slip (cannot bear weight) has a high risk of avascular necrosis. Management is urgent orthopedic referral and non weight bearing on crutches; never manipulate the hip.
Legg Calve Perthes disease is idiopathic avascular necrosis of the femoral head in children aged about 4 to 8, four to five times more common in boys, often small for age. It presents with an insidious, mostly painless limp or activity related groin, thigh or knee pain, and loss of hip internal rotation and abduction. Early radiographs may be normal or show a small dense epiphysis and a subchondral fracture line (crescent sign); later, fragmentation and flattening appear. Prognosis is better in younger children (under 6) with less head involvement. Refer to pediatric orthopedics.
Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis is a lateral curvature of 10 degrees or more (Cobb angle) with vertebral rotation, without a known cause, appearing at 10 years or older; it is usually a right thoracic curve and progresses most during the growth spurt, more often in girls. Screening uses the Adams forward bend test with a scoliometer (7 degrees or more of trunk rotation suggests a curve of about 20 degrees and warrants a radiograph). Risk of progression is highest with a large curve in a skeletally immature patient (Risser 0 to 1, premenarchal). Typical management thresholds are observation under 25 degrees, bracing for 25 to 40 (or 45) degrees in a growing child, and surgical referral beyond about 45 to 50 degrees. Red flags that suggest a secondary cause (tumor, syrinx, tethered cord) are pain, a left thoracic curve, rapid progression, abnormal neurologic findings or abdominal reflexes, and onset before 10.
Older adults: falls and fractures
In older adults, the important impressions are fragility fracture, the cause of the fall, and atypical presentations of serious disease. A fall is a symptom: ask whether it was a trip (mechanical), a faint or near faint (syncope from arrhythmia, orthostatic hypotension, medications), dizziness, or leg weakness, and look for polypharmacy (sedatives, antihypertensives, more than four medications), visual impairment, cognitive impairment, neuropathy, Parkinson disease and fear of falling. Screening tools include the Timed Up and Go (more than about 12 seconds suggests increased fall risk) and the 30 second chair stand.
A hip fracture after a fall presents with groin or thigh pain, inability to bear weight, and a shortened, externally rotated leg in displaced fractures; an impacted femoral neck fracture may allow walking and present only as groin pain, so pain on axial loading or log roll after a fall needs films (and MRI if films are normal). Distal radius (Colles) fractures and vertebral compression fractures are the other sentinel fragility fractures; any of them should prompt osteoporosis evaluation. Older adults also present atypically: myocardial infarction with dyspnea or confusion alone, infection without fever, and appendicitis or cholecystitis with little tenderness. New back pain after 50, new headache after 50 and unexplained weight loss carry more weight in this group.
Pregnancy
Low back and pelvic girdle pain affect about half of pregnant patients. Pregnancy related lumbar pain is above the sacrum and behaves mechanically. Pelvic girdle pain is felt between the posterior iliac crest and the gluteal fold, near the sacroiliac joints, or at the pubic symphysis, and is aggravated by walking, stairs, turning in bed and standing on one leg; the active straight leg raise and the posterior pelvic pain provocation (thigh thrust) tests help confirm it. Relaxin and estrogen increase ligament laxity, the center of mass moves forward, and lumbar lordosis increases. Symphysis pubis dysfunction causes anterior pelvic pain with a waddling gait. Carpal tunnel syndrome and meralgia paresthetica are also common from fluid retention and weight gain.
Technique is adapted (pregnancy pillows or drop sections, side lying positions, avoiding prolonged supine positioning after about 20 weeks because of aortocaval compression, and avoiding abdominal pressure), but the impression step is about red flags.
| Red flag in pregnancy | Concern | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Vaginal bleeding or fluid leakage | Placental abruption or previa, ruptured membranes, miscarriage | Emergency obstetric care |
| Rhythmic low back pain or cramping before 37 weeks | Preterm labor | Emergency obstetric care |
| Severe headache, visual disturbance, right upper quadrant or epigastric pain, swelling of face and hands, BP 140/90 or higher after 20 weeks | Preeclampsia, HELLP syndrome | Emergency obstetric care |
| Unilateral calf swelling and pain, or sudden dyspnea and chest pain | Deep vein thrombosis, pulmonary embolism (pregnancy raises risk four to five times) | Emergency |
| Flank pain with fever and dysuria | Pyelonephritis (more common in pregnancy) | Same day medical referral |
| Reduced fetal movement | Fetal distress | Same day obstetric assessment |
| Saddle anesthesia or bladder change | Cauda equina syndrome | Emergency |
Reasoning: Knee pain with a normal knee, obesity, age 12, and the Drehmann sign point to slipped capital femoral epiphysis, with pain referred along the obturator nerve. Obtain AP and frog leg lateral pelvic radiographs (Klein line), keep him non weight bearing on crutches, and refer urgently to orthopedics. Do not adjust the hip or pelvis, and examine the right hip too.
Reasoning: New headache, visual symptoms and edema with BP over 140/90 after 20 weeks are signs of preeclampsia with severe features, which can progress to eclampsia, HELLP or stroke. The impression has changed from pregnancy related pelvic girdle pain to an obstetric emergency: send her for emergency obstetric evaluation now. Do not continue the planned treatment visit.
Special populations change the probabilities. In children, unilateral pain, limp, fever, night pain and joint signs exclude growing pains; match hip disorders to age, and remember that hip disease refers to the knee. In older adults, treat a fall as a symptom and a low trauma fracture as osteoporosis until proven otherwise. In pregnancy, mechanical pelvic girdle pain is common, but bleeding, preterm contractions, preeclampsia and thrombosis are emergencies.
Section 5Synthesizing the clinical impression
From data to a working diagnosis
A clinical impression is not a single label; it is a ranked judgment built from probabilities. Experienced clinicians generate two to four hypotheses within the first minutes of the history, then use the rest of the encounter to test them. Part III mirrors that process: the stem gives demographics and a chief complaint (which set the pretest probability), the history and examination add or subtract weight, and imaging and laboratory findings confirm or redirect. The skill being tested is how to weigh each piece.
- Frame the problem. Age, sex, chief complaint, duration (acute under 6 weeks, subacute 6 to 12, chronic over 12) and mechanism.
- Screen for danger first. Red flags for fracture, cancer, infection, cauda equina or myelopathy, vascular emergency and visceral disease. If one is strongly present, the impression is that condition and the next step is referral at the right urgency.
- Generate the differential. The most likely diagnosis, the must not miss alternative, and one or two others.
- Test it with the examination. Use tests whose results change probability: a highly sensitive test that is negative rules out (SnNout), a highly specific test that is positive rules in (SpPin). Clusters outperform single tests.
- Add imaging and labs only when they would change management. Interpret them against the clinical picture; incidental degenerative findings are common in asymptomatic people.
- State the impression. Primary diagnosis, secondary diagnoses, complicating factors, and the plan or referral that follows.
Weighing evidence
Diagnostic accuracy can be expressed as likelihood ratios. A positive likelihood ratio (sensitivity divided by 1 minus specificity) above 10 produces a large increase in probability, 5 to 10 a moderate increase, and 2 to 5 a small one; a negative likelihood ratio below 0.1 produces a large decrease. A test with an LR near 1 changes nothing and should not drive a decision. Because a test's predictive value depends on prevalence, the same positive Spurling test means much more in a patient whose history already suggests radiculopathy than in a patient with nonspecific neck pain.
| Type of data | Strengths | Common trap |
|---|---|---|
| History | Establishes most diagnoses; reveals red flags and visceral patterns | Anchoring on the patient's own explanation ("I lifted a box") |
| Physical and orthopedic examination | Localizes the tissue and level; neurologic signs are objective | Over reading a single positive test with poor specificity |
| Imaging | Confirms fracture, instability, tumor, infection, structural anomalies | Treating incidental degeneration (disc bulges in a third of 20 year olds, most 60 year olds) as the diagnosis |
| Laboratory tests | ESR and CRP for inflammation and infection, CBC, calcium, alkaline phosphatase, PSA, SPEP, HLA B27, RF and anti CCP | Ordering autoantibodies without a matching clinical picture (positive ANA in healthy people) |
| Response to care | Expected improvement confirms a mechanical diagnosis | Continuing the same care when the patient is not improving |
Cognitive errors are as dangerous as gaps in knowledge. Anchoring fixes on the first impression; premature closure stops thinking once a plausible diagnosis is found; availability bias favors what was seen recently; confirmation bias collects only supporting evidence. Two habits protect against them: always name the must not miss alternative, and treat failure to improve as new data.
Primary and secondary diagnoses
The primary diagnosis is the condition that best explains the chief complaint and that care is directed at. Secondary diagnoses are additional conditions that are present and relevant: a coexisting problem (myofascial pain with a radiculopathy), a complicating factor that changes prognosis or technique (osteoporosis, diabetes, anticoagulation, obesity, depression or fear avoidance), or a related finding (a transitional segment). Order matters for documentation and coding: the condition being treated is listed first, followed by those that affect care. When a red flag condition is suspected, the impression states it as suspected and the plan is referral; you do not need to prove it before acting.
Extended matching items
In extended matching style, a single long option list (often 10 to 20 diagnoses) is followed by several short vignettes; each vignette is matched to the best option, and options can be used once, more than once or not at all. Because every option is plausible for something, these items reward discriminating clues over general recognition. A good approach: read the vignette and name the answer before scanning the list; identify the one feature that rules out the near neighbors (age, laterality, timing, a specific sign or lab); and do not eliminate an option because you used it already.
| Vignette (options: lumbar stenosis, disc herniation, AAA, ankylosing spondylitis, metastasis, osteomyelitis, compression fracture, sacroiliac dysfunction, renal colic, cauda equina) | Discriminating clue | Best match |
|---|---|---|
| Man, 26, two years of back pain and stiffness each morning for an hour, better after a workout, reduced chest expansion | Young onset, improves with exercise | Ankylosing spondylitis |
| Woman, 79, on prednisone, sudden thoracolumbar pain after lifting a laundry basket, percussion tender at T12 | Minor trauma, steroids, age | Compression fracture |
| Man, 70, smoker, constant deep back pain unchanged by movement, pulsatile mass | Nonmechanical pain, pulsatile mass | AAA |
| Woman, 58, breast cancer five years ago, night pain, weight loss | Cancer history, night pain | Metastasis |
| Man, 40, acute back pain with bilateral sciatica and new urinary retention | Sphincter change | Cauda equina |
| Man, 73, leg aching after five minutes of standing, relieved by sitting, normal pulses | Positional, flexion relief | Lumbar stenosis |
Reasoning: The red flag screen is negative. The best explanation of the chief complaint is a right S1 radiculopathy, most likely from an L5 to S1 disc herniation: dermatomal pain, positive SLR in the 30 to 70 degree range, reduced Achilles reflex and plantar flexion weakness. That is the primary diagnosis. Secondary diagnoses are osteoporosis (changes technique: avoid high force thrust, especially to the thoracic spine and ribs), poorly controlled diabetes (slower healing, possible coexisting polyneuropathy that can blunt the ankle reflex bilaterally, so compare sides) and high fear avoidance beliefs (predicts chronicity; address with education and graded activity). Monitor the neurologic deficit, measure function with the Oswestry index, and refer for MRI and a surgical opinion if weakness progresses, or emergently if cauda equina signs appear. The disc narrowing on the film supports but does not prove the impression.
Reasoning: Failure to improve is new data, and the labs point to multiple myeloma: CRAB features (hypercalcemia, renal impairment, anemia and a lytic bone lesion) with a very high ESR. The impression changes from mechanical back pain to suspected myeloma with a lytic L2 lesion at risk of pathologic fracture. Stop manipulation, and refer promptly to the primary care physician or hematology for serum protein electrophoresis, free light chains and a skeletal survey. This is the classic premature closure error the board wants you to recognize.
Build the impression in order: frame the problem, screen for danger, generate a differential with a must not miss alternative, test it with discriminating examination findings and only the imaging and labs that change management, then state a primary diagnosis, relevant secondary diagnoses and the plan. Failure to improve is a finding that reopens the differential.
The chapter in one breath
- First decide inflammatory versus mechanical: prolonged morning stiffness, improvement with use, swelling and raised ESR or CRP mean inflammation.
- Rheumatoid arthritis is symmetric small joint disease that spares the DIP joints, with anti CCP as the specific test and atlantoaxial instability as the chiropractic hazard.
- The spondyloarthropathies share HLA B27, sacroiliitis, enthesitis and uveitis; gout is a hot first MTP with negatively birefringent crystals, and a hot joint is septic until aspirated.
- Polymyalgia rheumatica is girdle stiffness after 50 with normal strength and a high ESR; always ask about giant cell arteritis.
- Fibromyalgia is widespread pain with normal tests after other causes are excluded; hypothyroidism, diabetes and osteoporosis each have characteristic musculoskeletal faces.
- Constant night pain, weight loss and a cancer history suggest metastasis (PB KTL); myeloma is CRAB with an M spike; tumor spares the disc, infection crosses it.
- Epidural abscess and metastatic cord compression are emergencies whose neurologic signs can appear within hours.
- Viscera refer to their segmental dermatomes and the diaphragm to the shoulder tip; pain tied to meals, urination, menses or exertion is visceral.
- Growing pains are bilateral, nocturnal and leave a normal child by morning; SCFE (teen, knee pain, Drehmann sign) and Perthes (boy 4 to 8, painless limp) must be matched to age.
- In older adults a fall is a symptom and a low trauma fracture means osteoporosis; in pregnancy, bleeding, preterm contractions, preeclampsia and thrombosis are emergencies.
- State a primary diagnosis, relevant secondary diagnoses and a must not miss alternative; use likelihood ratios and clusters, and treat failure to improve as new data.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Anchoring | A reasoning error in which the clinician stays fixed on the first impression despite new evidence. |
| Anti CCP antibody | Antibody to cyclic citrullinated peptide; the most specific blood test for rheumatoid arthritis. |
| Batson plexus | Valveless vertebral venous network that lets pelvic and abdominal tumors and infections reach the spine. |
| CRAB | Hypercalcemia, renal insufficiency, anemia and bone lesions; the features of multiple myeloma. |
| Crescent sign | A subchondral lucent line in the femoral head indicating collapse from avascular necrosis. |
| Dactylitis | Swelling of a whole digit ("sausage digit"), typical of psoriatic and reactive arthritis. |
| Discitis | Infection of the intervertebral disc space, usually with the adjacent endplates. |
| Drehmann sign | Obligatory external rotation of the hip as it is flexed, seen in slipped capital femoral epiphysis. |
| Enthesitis | Inflammation where a tendon or ligament attaches to bone, a hallmark of spondyloarthropathy. |
| Extended matching item | A question format with one long option list and several vignettes, each matched to the best option. |
| Fragility fracture | A fracture from a fall from standing height or less, indicating reduced bone strength. |
| Kehr sign | Left shoulder tip pain from diaphragmatic irritation by blood, classically a ruptured spleen. |
| Klein line | A line along the superior femoral neck on an AP film that should intersect the femoral head; it misses in SCFE. |
| Likelihood ratio | How much a test result changes the odds of a diagnosis; above 10 or below 0.1 is strong. |
| M spike | A monoclonal protein peak on serum protein electrophoresis, typical of myeloma. |
| Murphy sign | Arrest of inspiration during palpation under the right costal margin, suggesting cholecystitis. |
| Pelvic girdle pain | Pregnancy related pain over the sacroiliac joints or symphysis, provoked by weight bearing and turning. |
| Preeclampsia | New hypertension after 20 weeks of pregnancy with proteinuria or organ involvement. |
| Premature closure | Accepting a diagnosis before it has been fully verified, so alternatives are not considered. |
| Pretest probability | The likelihood of a diagnosis before a test, based on prevalence and the history. |
| Primary diagnosis | The condition that best explains the chief complaint and toward which care is directed. |
| Secondary diagnosis | A coexisting or complicating condition that is relevant to prognosis or management. |
| Spinal epidural abscess | Pus in the epidural space that can compress the cord or cauda equina within hours. |
| Viscerosomatic convergence | Visceral and somatic afferents sharing dorsal horn neurons, so organ pain is felt in the body wall. |
| Winking owl sign | Absence of one pedicle on an AP spine film, usually from a lytic metastasis. |
Check yourself
Chiropractic Technique Decisions
Technique questions on Part III are rarely about how to set up a single adjustment. They ask whether this patient should be adjusted at all, which region and procedure fit the findings, how the procedure must change for a fragile, anticoagulated, pregnant or very young patient, and what to do when something goes wrong on the table. This chapter teaches the decision behind the thrust: screening, selection, line of drive, consent and the response to an adverse event.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Separate absolute from relative contraindications to manipulation and decide, case by case, whether to proceed, modify or refer.
- Modify care for osteoporosis, anticoagulation, inflammatory arthritis, pregnancy and pediatric patients.
- Choose among diversified, Gonstead, Thompson drop, flexion distraction, instrument assisted, SOT blocking and mobilization by region, finding, size and tolerance.
- Grade mobilization with the Maitland scale and explain where a manipulation (grade V) acts.
- Select extremity procedures for the shoulder, elbow, wrist, hip, knee, ankle and foot from the restricted motion and the injury history, after fracture rules are cleared.
- Apply coupled motion, facet plane orientation and the convex concave rule to choose a line of drive.
- Read and write segmental listings in Gonstead and motion palpation terms, including pelvic PI and AS ilium listings.
- Screen for cervical artery dissection, recognize an evolving stroke on the table, and activate emergency care.
- Obtain valid informed consent and document a procedure so that it is defensible and reproducible.
Section 1Indications and contraindications in the case
The indication comes first
Manipulation and mobilization are indicated for mechanical joint dysfunction: pain and restricted or aberrant motion that change with position and load, with examination findings that localize to a segment or joint (tenderness, altered end feel, restricted joint play, reproduction of the familiar pain). The best supported indications are mechanical low back and neck pain and cervicogenic headache. A Part III item often hides the real question in the indication: if the pain is constant, unchanged by movement and present at night, the problem is probably not mechanical, and the right answer is further workup, not a technique.
The decision on the day of the visit has three outcomes. Proceed when the complaint is mechanical and no contraindication applies. Modify when a relative contraindication changes how much force, which direction or which region is safe. Do not manipulate and refer when an absolute contraindication or a red flag is present. A contraindication is local or general: a metastatic deposit in T8 forbids thrusting at T8 but may still allow gentle care of an ankle, whereas a suspected vertebral artery dissection or cauda equina syndrome stops all manual care and changes the visit into an urgent referral.
Absolute and relative contraindications
An absolute contraindication means that high velocity thrust at that region carries a risk that no benefit can justify. A relative contraindication means that the risk is raised but can be managed by changing force, leverage, direction, position or technique, or by obtaining more information first. Thrust is dangerous where bone may break (fracture, tumor, infection, severe osteoporosis), where ligaments no longer hold the joint (instability), where a vessel or the cord is already damaged (dissection, aneurysm, myelopathy) and where bleeding cannot be controlled.
| Category | Absolute at the involved region | Relative (modify, monitor or clarify first) |
|---|---|---|
| Bone integrity | Acute fracture; primary or metastatic tumor; osteomyelitis or discitis; severe osteoporosis with prior fragility fracture at that region | Osteopenia or osteoporosis without fracture; healed fracture; long term corticosteroid use |
| Stability | Dislocation; ligamentous instability (atlantoaxial instability in rheumatoid arthritis or Down syndrome, odontoid hypoplasia or os odontoideum); unstable spondylolisthesis | Stable spondylolisthesis; hypermobility syndromes such as Ehlers Danlos; segments adjacent to a fusion |
| Neural | Cauda equina syndrome; cord compression with myelopathy; rapidly progressive neurological deficit | Disc herniation with stable radiculopathy (choose technique and direction carefully) |
| Vascular | Suspected cervical artery dissection or stroke in evolution; large or symptomatic abdominal aortic aneurysm (lumbar thrust) | Anticoagulation; atherosclerotic risk factors; small known aneurysm under surveillance |
| Inflammatory and systemic | Acute inflammatory arthritis flare at the segment; ankylosed (fused) segments in ankylosing spondylitis | Inflammatory arthritis in remission; diabetes with neuropathy; pregnancy |
| Bleeding | Hemophilia or other uncontrolled bleeding disorder; supratherapeutic INR with bruising | Stable warfarin or direct oral anticoagulant therapy; thrombocytopenia |
| Behavioral | Refusal or withdrawal of consent | Psychological dependence on manipulation; symptom magnification; failure to improve after a fair trial |
Osteoporosis
Osteoporosis is defined on DXA by a T score of −2.5 or lower, or clinically by any fragility fracture of the spine or hip. Stem risk factors include postmenopausal age, low body weight, smoking, alcohol excess, long term corticosteroids (5 mg prednisone or more for 3 months or longer), rheumatoid arthritis and a prior fragility fracture. Vertebral compression fractures are the most common osteoporotic fracture and many are painless; a new one typically causes sudden midthoracic or thoracolumbar pain after trivial loading (lifting a grocery bag, a cough, bending).
Modifications follow from the fracture mechanism. Osteoporotic vertebrae fail in flexion and axial compression, and ribs fail under prone posteroanterior load. Avoid prone thoracic thrusts with body weight, rib springing and forced rotation; avoid flexion based exercise such as sit ups and toe touching. Prefer instrument assisted adjusting, drop table assistance with the tension set light, gentle mobilization, supine or seated set ups with minimal leverage, soft tissue work and extension biased postural exercise.
Reasoning: The key clue is the trivial load in a patient with two strong risk factors and point tenderness on percussion; this is a compression fracture until proved otherwise. Obtain lateral thoracic radiographs (and refer for MRI if films are negative but suspicion stays high, since MRI shows marrow edema in an acute fracture). No thrust at the fracture level and no prone posteroanterior pressure. If a stable fracture is confirmed, care is supportive: pain control through her physician, gentle mobilization elsewhere, extension biased postural work and fall prevention, and coordination of bone health treatment. If she had progressive leg weakness, that would mean retropulsion and an emergency.
Anticoagulation and bleeding risk
Patients on warfarin (target INR usually 2 to 3, up to 3.5 for some mechanical valves), direct oral anticoagulants (apixaban, rivaroxaban, dabigatran, edoxaban) or dual antiplatelet therapy bleed more easily into muscle, epidural space and joints. Ask about recent INR values, dose changes, easy bruising and bleeding. Spontaneous bruising, an INR above the therapeutic range or new bleeding symptoms make thrust inappropriate and call for contact with the prescriber. With stable therapy, use low force procedures, avoid sustained deep pressure and aggressive soft tissue techniques such as instrument scraping, and educate the patient to report new bruising or severe new pain, which in the spine can mean an epidural hematoma (sudden severe back pain followed by rapidly progressive weakness).
Inflammatory arthritis
In rheumatoid arthritis, pannus and ligamentous laxity at C1 and C2 cause atlantoaxial instability, which may be silent. Before upper cervical manipulation in any patient with long standing rheumatoid arthritis, review a lateral cervical radiograph with flexion and extension views. The atlantodental interval (ADI) is normally no more than 3 mm in adults and 5 mm in children; a larger ADI, or symptoms such as occipital pain with myelopathic signs, makes upper cervical thrust absolutely contraindicated. In ankylosing spondylitis, the fused "bamboo" spine is rigid and brittle: it fractures with minimal force, often through the ankylosed disc space, and an unrecognized fracture can produce cord injury. Thrust on fused segments is contraindicated; mobile segments, the hips and soft tissues can be treated gently, and extension exercise and breathing exercise are central. During an acute flare of any inflammatory arthropathy the inflamed joint should not be thrust upon.
Down syndrome carries a risk of atlantoaxial instability from ligamentous laxity and odontoid anomalies, and the same rule applies: screen with history (neck pain, torticollis, change in gait, loss of bladder control) and imaging before considering upper cervical thrust, and prefer low force methods.
Pregnancy
Relaxin and estrogen increase ligamentous laxity, the center of gravity moves forward, lumbar lordosis increases and the sacroiliac joints and pubic symphysis take more stress. Manipulation is generally safe in an uncomplicated pregnancy when technique is modified: use pelvic or pregnancy cushions or a table with an abdominal drop so there is no pressure on the abdomen when prone; after about 20 weeks avoid prolonged supine positioning, which compresses the inferior vena cava (supine hypotensive syndrome) and should be relieved by turning her onto her left side; use side posture with minimal rotation; reduce force because joints are lax.
The red flags matter more than the technique: vaginal bleeding, leakage of fluid, regular painful contractions before term, severe abdominal pain, decreased fetal movement, and signs of preeclampsia (blood pressure of 140/90 or higher after 20 weeks, severe headache, visual disturbance, right upper quadrant pain, sudden edema of the face and hands). Any of these means same day obstetric referral; severe features need emergency care. Early pregnancy with unilateral pelvic pain and spotting suggests ectopic pregnancy, an emergency.
Reasoning: Her back pain is not the problem. New hypertension after 20 weeks with headache and visual disturbance is preeclampsia with severe features, which can progress to eclamptic seizures, placental abruption or HELLP syndrome. Do not adjust; arrange immediate transfer to labor and delivery or emergency care and document the readings and the referral. Back pain alone with normal blood pressure would have been treated with modified side posture or a pelvic adjustment on a pregnancy table.
Children and infants
Children are not small adults. Their joints are more mobile, growth plates are vulnerable, and they cannot reliably report red flag symptoms. Forces must be scaled down dramatically: fingertip pressure for infants, low force or instrument methods for young children, and full thrust only in older adolescents. Serious pediatric mimics include leukemia (bone pain, fatigue, bruising, pallor), osteomyelitis and septic arthritis (fever, refusal to bear weight), slipped capital femoral epiphysis (an overweight adolescent with knee pain), Legg Calvé Perthes disease (a 4 to 8 year old boy with a limp), spondylolysis in young athletes, and nonaccidental trauma (injuries inconsistent with the history, multiple bruises in different stages, posterior rib fractures). Back pain in a child under 10 is uncommon and should be investigated, particularly night pain relieved by aspirin or NSAIDs, which suggests osteoid osteoma.
Decide first whether the complaint is mechanical, then whether anything makes thrust at that region unsafe. Absolute contraindications forbid thrust at the region and red flags demand referral; relative contraindications are answered by changing force, position and technique. Osteoporosis, anticoagulation, rheumatoid and ankylosing arthritis, pregnancy and childhood each have a predictable injury mechanism, and the modification is the one that avoids it.
Section 2Spinal adjustive technique selection
What the choice depends on
No single technique is best for every patient. Part III items reward choosing a procedure that fits five variables: the region (upper cervical, lower cervical, thoracic, ribs, lumbar, sacroiliac), the finding (restricted segment, disc lesion, stenosis, facet irritation, muscle guarding), the patient's size and build relative to the doctor, the patient's tolerance and preference (fear of the cavitation sound, acute pain that makes positioning impossible), and any relative contraindication. Evidence supports manipulation and mobilization in general more than any named system, so the board rewards safe, logical selection.
The main systems
| Technique | How it works | Best suited to |
|---|---|---|
| Diversified (HVLA) | Manual high velocity, low amplitude thrust after taking up joint slack, directed along the facet plane; often produces cavitation | Most mechanical restrictions in all regions, average sized and tolerant patients |
| Gonstead | Specific contact on the spinous or mammillary process, listings derived from static and motion palpation, instrumentation (heat reading) and full spine radiographs; uses side posture, knee chest and cervical chair | Specific segmental work guided by radiographs, disc patients (avoids excessive rotation) |
| Thompson terminal point (drop) | Segmental drop pieces on the table are cocked; the doctor gives a quick thrust that drops the section a short distance, so the table decelerates the patient and less force is needed | Pelvic and lumbar work, larger patients, patients who dislike rotation; leg length checks used for analysis |
| Flexion distraction (Cox) | Patient prone on a table whose caudal section flexes and distracts; the doctor stabilizes the spinous process above the target while the section moves in slow, gentle cycles | Disc herniation with radiculopathy, central and lateral stenosis, facet syndrome, spondylolisthesis, postsurgical and older patients |
| Instrument assisted (Activator type) | Spring loaded hand held instrument gives a very fast, low force impulse; analysis by leg length reactivity in many protocols | Osteoporosis, children, anxious patients, anticoagulated patients, acute pain, extremities |
| Sacro occipital technique (SOT) | Pelvic blocks under the prone or supine patient use body weight to correct pelvic distortions; patients are classified into Category I, II or III | Sacroiliac and pelvic dysfunction, pregnancy (supine blocking), patients who cannot tolerate thrust |
| Upper cervical specific (toggle recoil, atlas orthogonal, NUCCA) | Precise, low amplitude correction of atlas or axis misalignment calculated from specialized radiographs | Upper cervical dysfunction in patients wanting minimal force |
| Mobilization and muscle energy | Graded oscillations (Maitland) or patient's isometric contraction against resistance followed by movement to a new barrier | Acute pain, apprehension, osteoporosis, before or after thrust |
Mobilization grades and the barrier concept
Joint motion has three zones. Active range ends at the physiological barrier, passive range (joint play) continues to the elastic barrier, and the paraphysiological space lies just beyond the elastic barrier and before the anatomical barrier, where ligaments and bone stop motion. Cavitation occurs when the joint is taken quickly into the paraphysiological space and synovial pressure falls; passing the anatomical barrier causes injury. Maitland grades describe mobilization by amplitude and where in the range the movement occurs.
Choosing by region
Upper cervical (occiput to C2): motion is mostly flexion and extension at the occipitoatlantal joint and rotation at the atlantoaxial joint. Use low amplitude, carefully localized procedures with minimal rotation, and always clear instability and vascular history first. Lower cervical (C3 to C7): rotary and lateral break set ups follow the facet plane, which faces up and back at about 45 degrees; keep end range rotation and extension modest and localize with lateral flexion. Supine set ups allow the doctor to monitor the patient's face. Thoracic: prone posteroanterior thrusts (bilateral thenar, crossed bilateral pisiform, hypothenar to transverse process), the supine anterior thoracic (patient's arms crossed, doctor's hand under the segment, body drop through the patient's elbows), and seated or standing lifts for the upper thoracics. Ribs: costovertebral and costotransverse contacts with a gentle impulse; avoid in osteoporosis. Lumbar: side posture (lumbar roll) with contact on the spinous (push or pull) or mammillary process, using rotation to lock segments above and below; flexion distraction; drop table. Sacroiliac and pelvis: side posture ilium and sacral moves, drop table, SOT blocking.
The key safety idea in lumbar side posture is localization by locking: flexing the upper leg and rotating the trunk to bring tension to the target segment so the thrust acts there and does not spread into adjacent levels. In an acute disc herniation, side posture with heavy rotation and flexion may increase intradiscal stress, so many clinicians begin with flexion distraction or prone extension biased mobilization and progress to gentle side posture once leg pain centralizes.
Size, tolerance and preference
For a patient much larger than the doctor, drop pieces, flexion distraction and instruments replace long lever side posture. A patient who braces against the cavitation sound needs low force or mobilization, and preference is a legitimate reason to choose; fused levels are not thrust, and segments adjacent to a fusion are treated gently.
Reasoning: This is a left S1 radiculopathy from an L5 to S1 disc herniation with a protective list, and no cauda equina signs. Flexion distraction at L5 to S1, with the force kept below the level that increases leg pain, is the logical first technique; prone extension biased work can be added if leg pain centralizes. Heavy rotational side posture thrust is avoided in the acute stage. Reassess neurological signs each visit; progressive motor loss, bilateral symptoms or saddle numbness would mean emergency referral.
Choose the technique that fits the region, the finding, the patient's size and tolerance and any relative contraindication. High velocity thrust remains the default for an uncomplicated restriction; flexion distraction suits disc and stenosis, instruments and drop tables lower force, and mobilization grades I to IV fill the space between rest and thrust. A grade V thrust passes the elastic barrier but never the anatomical one.
Section 3Extremity adjustive technique
Principles that apply to every joint
Extremity manipulation follows the same sequence as spinal work: establish a mechanical indication, clear fracture, dislocation, infection, tumor and instability, then identify the restricted motion and choose the glide that restores it. Joint play (the small accessory motions such as glides, distraction and spin that a patient cannot produce voluntarily) is assessed with the joint in its loose packed (resting) position, where the capsule is most lax. Manipulation is usually delivered from loose packed toward the restricted direction; the close packed position (maximal congruence, capsule taut) is used for stability testing and avoided for mobilization. When the whole capsule is involved, motion is lost in the joint's capsular pattern, which points to arthritis or capsulitis rather than a single ligament or muscle problem.
Capsular patterns worth knowing: glenohumeral, external rotation then abduction then internal rotation; hip, internal rotation, flexion and abduction; knee and elbow, flexion more than extension; talocrural, plantar flexion more than dorsiflexion; first MTP, extension more than flexion.
Shoulder
The glenohumeral joint is a convex humeral head on a shallow concave glenoid, so the humeral head glides opposite to the direction the shaft moves (Section 4). Restricted abduction is treated with inferior glide; restricted flexion and internal rotation with posterior glide; restricted extension and external rotation with anterior glide, which is avoided in a patient with anterior instability or a history of anterior dislocation. In adhesive capsulitis (frozen shoulder, most common in women aged 40 to 60 and in diabetics), passive external rotation is lost first and most; the freezing phase is painful and calls for gentle grade I and II mobilization, while the frozen and thawing phases tolerate end range grade III and IV glides and long axis distraction. Acute acromioclavicular separations of grade III or higher are not manipulated.
Before treating a painful shoulder, consider what does not belong in a chiropractic office: a proximal humerus fracture in an older patient after a fall, an unreduced posterior dislocation (arm locked in internal rotation, often after a seizure or electric shock), a full thickness rotator cuff tear with a positive drop arm test and true weakness, and referred pain from the heart, the lung apex (Pancoast tumor with Horner syndrome), the diaphragm and gallbladder (right shoulder), the spleen (left shoulder, Kehr sign) or a cervical radiculopathy.
Elbow and forearm
The elbow comprises the humeroulnar hinge, the radiohumeral joint and the proximal radioulnar joint, which share one capsule. Common procedures are humeroulnar long axis distraction, medial and lateral gapping (often written as ulnar adduction or abduction listings) and radial head glides. Restricted pronation and supination often reflect a radial head that will not glide: a posterior radial head listing is common after a fall on the outstretched hand with pronation, while an anterior radial head is associated with forceful supination.
Radial head subluxation (pulled elbow, nursemaid's elbow) is the classic pediatric extremity question: a child of 1 to 4 years whose arm was pulled while extended and pronated, who then holds the arm slightly flexed and pronated against the body and refuses to use it, with no swelling or deformity. The annular ligament has slipped over the radial head. Reduction by hyperpronation (slightly more successful) or by supination followed by full flexion with the thumb over the radial head usually produces a click and return of use within minutes. If there was a fall, swelling, bruising or point tenderness, obtain radiographs first; a supracondylar fracture (posterior fat pad sign, risk to the brachial artery and median nerve) must not be manipulated.
Wrist and hand
At the radiocarpal joint the convex proximal carpal row moves on the concave radius, so a restriction of wrist flexion is treated with a dorsal glide of the carpals and a restriction of extension with a volar glide. Individual carpals are mobilized with a thumb contact on the displaced bone; after a fall on the outstretched, extended wrist the lunate classically shifts volarly (anterior) and the capitate dorsally.
Two wrist injuries must never be adjusted. A scaphoid fracture follows a fall on an outstretched hand with tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox; initial radiographs can be negative, so the wrist is immobilized in a thumb spica and imaged again in 10 to 14 days (or by MRI), because a missed fracture can progress to avascular necrosis of the proximal pole and nonunion. A lunate or perilunate dislocation shows the "spilled teacup" lunate on the lateral film and may compress the median nerve; it needs urgent orthopedic reduction.
Hip
The femoral head is convex in the concave acetabulum, so restricted flexion and internal rotation call for a posterior glide and restricted extension and external rotation an anterior glide. Long axis distraction (traction through the leg with gentle oscillation or a thrust, the hip in its resting position) is the workhorse for hip osteoarthritis, in which manual therapy combined with exercise improves pain and function; hip osteoarthritis presents in older adults with groin pain, morning stiffness under an hour and loss of internal rotation.
Do not manipulate a hip until the dangerous diagnoses are cleared: slipped capital femoral epiphysis (overweight adolescent, groin, thigh or knee pain, obligatory external rotation with hip flexion, frog leg lateral film), avascular necrosis (corticosteroids, alcohol, sickle cell disease), a femoral neck stress fracture in a runner (groin pain with impact, especially in a female athlete with low energy availability; tension side fractures on the superior neck are surgical emergencies) and a septic joint (fever, refusal to bear weight).
Knee
The concave tibial plateau moves on the convex femoral condyles, so in open chain the tibia glides in the same direction as the leg moves: an anterior tibial glide restores extension and a posterior tibial glide restores flexion. The proximal tibiofibular joint is mobilized anteriorly or posteriorly (a posterior fibular head listing is common after ankle inversion sprains, because inversion pulls the fibula downward and alters fibular mechanics); because the common fibular nerve winds around the fibular neck, contact is broad and force moderate. The patella is mobilized in superior, inferior, medial and lateral directions; inferior patellar glide is required for knee flexion and is often restricted after immobilization.
Apply the Ottawa knee rule after acute trauma: radiographs are needed if the patient is 55 or older, has isolated patellar tenderness, has tenderness at the fibular head, cannot flex to 90 degrees, or cannot bear weight for four steps both immediately and at examination. A locked knee (cannot fully extend) after a twist suggests a displaced bucket handle meniscal tear and needs orthopedic referral, not manipulation.
Ankle and foot
At the talocrural joint the convex talus rolls within the concave mortise, so restricted dorsiflexion is treated with a posterior glide of the talus (or long axis distraction with a thrust), and restricted plantar flexion with an anterior glide. After a lateral (inversion) ankle sprain, the talus commonly remains anteriorly displaced and dorsiflexion stays limited for weeks, which impairs squatting, stair descent and running; posterior talar glide plus calf flexibility and balance training speeds recovery. The subtalar joint is mobilized into inversion and eversion with calcaneal contacts. Cuboid syndrome produces lateral midfoot pain after an inversion sprain or repetitive plantar flexion (dancers); the cuboid is displaced plantarly and is treated with the cuboid whip or a cuboid squeeze, a thrust that moves it dorsally. The navicular is mobilized dorsally, and the first metatarsophalangeal joint is mobilized with a dorsal glide of the proximal phalanx to restore extension in hallux limitus.
Clear fracture with the Ottawa ankle and foot rules, which have sensitivity close to 100 percent for significant fractures: ankle films are needed for pain in the malleolar zone with bone tenderness at the posterior edge or tip of either malleolus (the distal 6 cm) or inability to bear weight for four steps both immediately and at examination; foot films for midfoot pain with tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal or the navicular, or the same weight bearing failure. Also exclude a high ankle (syndesmotic) sprain (pain with the squeeze or external rotation test), a Maisonneuve fracture (proximal fibular fracture with medial ankle injury) and an Achilles rupture (positive Thompson squeeze test).
| Finding | What it suggests | Procedure that fits | Must exclude first |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lost glenohumeral abduction and external rotation, capsular pattern | Adhesive capsulitis or glenohumeral arthritis | Inferior and anterior glides, long axis distraction, grades matched to irritability | Posterior dislocation, fracture, referred visceral pain |
| Child holding arm pronated after a pull | Radial head subluxation | Hyperpronation or supination with flexion | Supracondylar fracture if fall, swelling or bruising |
| Limited wrist extension after a fall, volar tenderness over lunate | Volar lunate subluxation | Dorsal directed carpal mobilization, volar radiocarpal glide | Scaphoid fracture (snuffbox), lunate dislocation |
| Groin pain, loss of hip internal rotation, age 60 | Hip osteoarthritis | Long axis distraction, posterior glide, exercise | Avascular necrosis, femoral neck stress fracture, referred lumbar pain |
| Lateral knee pain after an ankle sprain, fibular head tender | Proximal tibiofibular dysfunction | Fibular head mobilization with broad contact | Fibular fracture (Ottawa, Maisonneuve), peroneal nerve injury |
| Limited dorsiflexion weeks after an inversion sprain | Anterior talus, posterior capsule stiffness | Posterior talar glide, distraction thrust, calf stretching | Fracture (Ottawa), syndesmotic sprain, osteochondral lesion of the talus |
| Lateral midfoot pain after inversion, painful push off | Cuboid syndrome | Cuboid whip or squeeze | Fifth metatarsal base fracture, stress fracture |
Reasoning: The key clue is loss of dorsiflexion with a stable ankle after a healed sprain, which points to anterior talar positioning and posterior capsular stiffness rather than instability. Fracture rules were satisfied when he walked in without bone tenderness. Treat with posterior talar glide or a long axis distraction thrust, fibular head and subtalar mobilization as indicated, calf stretching, and progressive balance and agility training to reduce the high recurrence risk. Anterior glide would be the wrong direction.
Extremity technique is chosen by the restricted motion and the shape of the joint surfaces, applied from the loose packed position, after fractures, dislocations and serious hip and knee disease are excluded. Inferior glide restores shoulder abduction, posterior talar glide restores dorsiflexion, anterior tibial glide restores knee extension, and the cuboid whip treats cuboid syndrome; the pulled elbow of a toddler is reduced, not adjusted.
Section 4Skeletal biomechanics applied to technique
Why biomechanics decides the thrust
A thrust is effective and safe when it moves a restricted joint in a direction its surfaces allow with no more force than needed. Facet orientation, coupled motion and arthrokinematics (the convex concave rule) supply the direction; listings record what was found and corrected.
Facet planes and the line of drive
Facet orientation is described by two angles: the angle to the transverse (horizontal) plane, seen from the side, and the angle to the coronal (frontal) plane, seen from above. The orientation determines the motions each region favors and therefore the line of drive, which should run along the facet plane so the joint surfaces glide rather than jam.
| Region | Facet orientation | Motion favored | Practical line of drive |
|---|---|---|---|
| Atlanto-occipital | Concave atlas facets cupping convex occipital condyles | Flexion and extension (the "yes" joint), about 20 to 25 degrees total | Low amplitude, minimal rotation; localize precisely |
| Atlantoaxial | Nearly horizontal, biconvex facets around the dens | Rotation (the "no" joint), about 40 to 45 degrees each way, roughly half of all cervical rotation | Rotation biased set up with minimal extension; vertebral artery loops here, so screening matters |
| C3 to C7 | About 45 degrees to the transverse plane, facing up and back (close to coronal) | Flexion and extension, lateral flexion and rotation coupled to the same side | Along the 45 degree plane: posterior to anterior and inferior to superior, toward the opposite eye in a rotary set up |
| T1 to T12 | About 60 degrees to the transverse plane and 20 degrees to the coronal plane, facing back, up and slightly out | Rotation and lateral flexion (limited by the rib cage); flexion and extension limited | Posterior to anterior with a slight inferior to superior component, following the shingled facets |
| L1 to L4 | About 90 degrees to the transverse plane and 45 degrees to the coronal plane, facing medially and laterally (sagittal) | Flexion and extension; rotation limited to 1 or 2 degrees per segment | Side posture with rotation to gap the facets; posterior to anterior through the spinous or mammillary process |
| L5 to S1 | More coronal than the upper lumbar facets | More rotation than upper lumbar levels; resists forward shear of L5 | Side posture or drop; respect spondylolisthesis and the pars |
Coupled motion
Coupling is the consistent association of one motion with another about a different axis. In the lower cervical spine (C2 to C7), lateral flexion is coupled with rotation to the same side: bending to the right turns the vertebral bodies to the right and the spinous processes to the left. A cervical set up therefore combines lateral flexion with rotation rather than relying on excessive rotation. In the upper cervical spine, lateral flexion at the occipitoatlantal joint is coupled with slight rotation to the opposite side, and rotation at C1 and C2 is accompanied by slight vertical translation as the biconvex facets ride over each other.
In the thoracic spine coupling is variable; the upper thoracics behave like the cervical spine (same side), while mid and lower patterns differ between individuals and with posture. In the lumbar spine coupling is small and inconsistent between studies; the commonly taught pattern is that in neutral, lateral flexion is accompanied by rotation of the vertebral bodies to the opposite side (bodies toward the convexity), while in flexion the coupling may become same side. The osteopathic summary is Fryette's laws:
- Type I (neutral mechanics): with the spine in neutral, side bending and rotation occur to opposite sides, across a group of vertebrae. This is the pattern of a scoliotic curve: the bodies rotate toward the convexity and the spinous processes toward the concavity.
- Type II (nonneutral mechanics): with the spine flexed or extended, side bending and rotation occur to the same side, at a single segment. Isolated segmental restrictions follow this pattern.
- Type III: introducing motion in one plane reduces available motion in the other planes. This is the basis of locking: flexion and rotation are used to tighten the segments above and below so the thrust acts only at the target.
Joint play and end feel
Joint play is examined passively at the end of active range and in the resting position: the clinician stabilizes one bone and moves the other through small glides and distraction. Restricted, painful joint play at a segment that reproduces the complaint is the main indication for adjusting it. The quality of resistance at end range, the end feel, adds information.
| End feel | What it feels like | Normal example | When abnormal, it suggests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bone to bone | Abrupt, hard stop | Elbow extension | Osteophyte, myositis ossificans, malunion (if early) |
| Soft tissue approximation | Soft compression of tissue | Knee or elbow flexion | Swelling or bulk (if early) |
| Tissue stretch | Firm, slightly elastic resistance | Most joints at end range (shoulder external rotation) | Capsular or ligamentous shortening if it occurs early |
| Muscle spasm | Sudden guarding that stops motion | Not normal | Acute injury, instability, inflammation |
| Capsular | Hard, early tissue stretch in a capsular pattern | Not normal | Arthritis, adhesive capsulitis |
| Springy block | Rebound before end range | Not normal | Internal derangement such as a meniscal tear or loose body |
| Empty | Pain stops motion before any resistance is felt | Not normal | Serious pathology: fracture, tumor, abscess, acute bursitis; do not manipulate |
The convex concave rule
Joint surfaces move by rolling (new points on one surface meet new points on the other), gliding (one point slides across new points) and spinning (rotation about a fixed axis). When a convex surface moves on a fixed concave surface, it rolls in the direction of the bone's movement but glides in the opposite direction; otherwise the head would roll off the socket. When a concave surface moves on a fixed convex surface, roll and glide occur in the same direction. Mobilization restores the glide component, so the rule tells you which direction to push.
Segmental listings
A listing records the position or motion fault of a segment so the doctor can choose a contact and line of drive and so another clinician can understand the record. Two families are tested. Static (positional) listings, used in Gonstead and many diversified systems, describe where the vertebra has moved relative to the one below. Motion (fixation) listings, from motion palpation, describe which motion is restricted, for example "T6 restricted in right rotation" or "L4 to L5 left lateral flexion fixation." Both must be readable.
In the Gonstead system a lumbar or thoracic listing usually starts with P (the vertebral body has moved posterior), followed by R or L (the side toward which the spinous process has rotated) and then S or I, which describes lateral flexion (the disc wedge) on the side of spinous rotation. A PRS listing means posterior body, spinous rotated right, and the right side superior (disc wedge open on the right); it is corrected with a contact on the right side of the spinous and a line of drive posterior to anterior, right to left and superior to inferior. A PLI listing is posterior, spinous left, left side inferior.
Atlas listings describe its laterality and the position of the anterior tubercle: ASR (anterior superior right) means the atlas has shifted right and its anterior arch is superior; the classic atlas listings combine A or P, S or I, and R or L. Pelvic listings describe the innominate (ilium) relative to the sacrum:
| Listing | Ilium position | Typical findings | Correction (side posture, conceptually) |
|---|---|---|---|
| PI (posterior inferior) | Ilium rotated posteriorly; PSIS posterior and inferior | Apparent short leg on that side; iliac crest lower; PSIS prominent and low | Contact PSIS, line of drive posterior to anterior and inferior to superior |
| AS (anterior superior) | Ilium rotated anteriorly; PSIS anterior and superior | Apparent long leg on that side; PSIS higher and less prominent | Contact ischial tuberosity, line of drive posterior to anterior and inferior to superior (rotating the ilium back) |
| IN (internal) | Ilium rotated internally about a vertical axis: ASIS medial, PSIS lateral | PSIS farther from the sacral midline; usually combined with AS (ASIn) | Contact lateral aspect of the PSIS, drive lateral to medial |
| EX (external) | Ilium rotated externally: ASIS lateral, PSIS medial | PSIS closer to the sacral midline; usually combined with PI (PIEx) | Contact medial aspect of the PSIS, drive medial to lateral |
| Sacral base posterior (P-L or P-R) | Sacrum rotated so one side of the base is posterior | Deeper sulcus on the opposite side, prominent base on the listed side | Contact sacral base on the posterior side, drive posterior to anterior |
Reasoning: The pattern fits a right PI ilium (apparent short leg, low prominent PSIS) with sacroiliac fixation. In side posture with the right side up, contact the right PSIS and drive posterior to anterior and inferior to superior to rotate the ilium anteriorly; drop table on the PSIS is an alternative. Apparent leg length is unreliable on its own; the decision rests on the whole examination.
Facet planes decide which motions a region favors and therefore the line of drive; coupled motion and Fryette's laws explain how to lock segments and why scoliotic bodies rotate toward the convexity. End feel separates normal stiffness from danger, and an empty end feel stops manipulation. The convex concave rule gives the direction of every extremity glide, and listings record the fault in static (PRS, PI, ASR) or motion (restricted right rotation) terms.
Section 5Safety, consent and adverse events
Screening before cervical manipulation
Serious adverse events after cervical manipulation are rare, and the most feared is stroke from cervical artery dissection (vertebral or internal carotid). Population studies show that patients with vertebrobasilar stroke are about as likely to have seen a primary care physician as a chiropractor beforehand, suggesting that many dissections are already under way and cause the pain that brings the patient in; the clinician must recognize one before treating it as mechanical neck pain.
Screening relies on history, not provocative positioning tests. Rotation and extension tests (such as the DeKleyn, Hautant, George and Maigne tests) have poor sensitivity and cannot clear a patient; a negative test does not make thrust safe. Ask about:
- Pain character: sudden, severe, unusual neck pain or headache, especially "worst ever" or different from previous episodes, often unilateral and occipital (vertebral) or anterolateral neck, face and eye (carotid).
- Recent trauma, even minor (sports, a sudden head turn, a fall, a motor vehicle collision) in the preceding days or weeks.
- Posterior circulation symptoms, the classic "5 Ds and 3 Ns": dizziness, diplopia, dysarthria, dysphagia, drop attacks, nausea, numbness (often facial or perioral) and nystagmus, plus ataxia.
- Carotid signs: ipsilateral Horner syndrome (ptosis, miosis), pulsatile tinnitus, transient monocular vision loss, contralateral weakness or speech disturbance.
- Risk factors: connective tissue disorders (Ehlers Danlos, Marfan, fibromuscular dysplasia), recent infection, migraine with aura, uncontrolled hypertension, prior dissection.
Also screen for upper cervical instability (rheumatoid arthritis, Down syndrome, recent trauma, steroid use; symptoms such as a sensation of the head being heavy, lump in the throat, bilateral paresthesia) and for myelopathy (clumsy hands, gait change, Hoffmann sign, hyperreflexia), both of which forbid cervical thrust until imaging and specialist assessment.
Adverse events: expected and serious
| Event | Frequency and timing | Recognition | Response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local soreness, stiffness, mild headache, fatigue | Common (roughly a third to a half of patients), begins within hours, resolves in 24 to 48 hours | Mild, local, improving | Warn in advance; ice or heat, gentle movement; adjust force next visit |
| Vasovagal syncope | Uncommon; anxious or fasting patients | Pallor, sweating, lightheadedness, brief loss of consciousness | Lay supine with legs raised, check pulse and breathing; recovery should be rapid and complete |
| Rib fracture | Rare; osteoporotic patients, prone thoracic thrust | Sharp pain with breathing or coughing, point tenderness | Radiographs, rib films; consider pneumothorax if breathless |
| Worsened disc herniation, cauda equina syndrome | Very rare | New or worse leg pain, weakness, saddle anesthesia, urinary retention | Cauda equina is an emergency: same day emergency imaging and surgical referral |
| Cervical artery dissection or stroke | Very rare | Dizziness, nystagmus, ataxia, dysarthria, visual loss, Horner sign, hemiparesis | Stop, supine, emergency services, monitor, document (Figure 9.6) |
Reasoning: The history alone (sudden, unusual, unilateral occipital pain after minor trauma) should have stopped cervical manipulation; the new posterior circulation signs indicate a vertebral artery dissection with brainstem ischemia. Do not adjust. Keep her lying down, call emergency services, note the time symptoms began, monitor vital signs and level of consciousness, give nothing by mouth and stay with her. Document the history, findings, times and actions in detail. Sitting her up "to see if it passes" or performing provocative tests would be wrong.
Informed consent
Consent is a process, not a signature. A valid consent requires a competent patient (or a parent or legal guardian for a minor, or a legally authorized representative), voluntary agreement and adequate disclosure of: the diagnosis or clinical impression, the nature and purpose of the proposed procedure, its material risks (common minor ones and rare serious ones, including stroke for cervical manipulation), the expected benefits, reasonable alternatives including no treatment, and the likely consequences of declining. Most jurisdictions judge disclosure by the reasonable patient standard: what a reasonable person in the patient's position would want to know. The patient must have the chance to ask questions and may withdraw consent at any time, including on the table. Consent should be renewed when the plan changes, for example when a new region or a new procedure is added. Use a trained interpreter when needed.
Documenting the procedure
The record must let another clinician reproduce the visit and let a reviewer judge necessity. Use a SOAP structure. The objective findings that justify a spinal adjustment are often summarized with PART: Pain and tenderness, Asymmetry or misalignment, Range of motion abnormality and Tissue tone, texture and temperature change; two of the four, one of which must be asymmetry or range of motion, are commonly required to document a subluxation for payment purposes. For each procedure record the region and segment, the technique and patient position, the side and line of drive, the patient's immediate response, any adverse event and its management, the advice given, and the plan with goals tied to outcome measures (such as the Neck Disability Index or Oswestry Disability Index). Never alter a record after the fact; corrections are made as dated, initialed addenda with the original left legible.
Safety before cervical manipulation rests on a careful history for sudden unusual pain, recent trauma, posterior circulation and carotid symptoms, instability and myelopathy; provocative tests cannot clear a patient. Minor soreness is common and self limited; stroke and cauda equina syndrome are rare emergencies that require immediate cessation, emergency activation and detailed documentation. Consent discloses risks, benefits and alternatives including no treatment, and the record (SOAP, PART, procedure, response, plan) must make each visit reproducible.
The chapter in one breath
- Every technique question starts with whether the complaint is mechanical; nonmechanical pain and red flags call for workup or referral, not a procedure.
- Absolute contraindications forbid thrust at the involved region (fracture, tumor, infection, instability, dissection, cauda equina, myelopathy); relative ones are answered by modifying force, position and technique.
- Osteoporosis: avoid prone body weight thrust, rib springing, rotation and flexion exercise; image new thoracic pain. Anticoagulation: low force, check INR and bruising.
- Rheumatoid arthritis and Down syndrome: check the ADI (over 3 mm in adults is abnormal) before upper cervical work; ankylosing spondylitis: never thrust fused segments.
- Pregnancy: pregnancy cushions, side posture, left lateral after 20 weeks; bleeding or preeclampsia means obstetric referral.
- Flexion distraction fits disc herniation and stenosis; instruments and drop tables lower force; mobilization grades I and II relieve pain, III and IV restore motion, and V is a thrust past the elastic barrier.
- Extremity glides follow the convex concave rule: convex on concave glides opposite, concave on convex glides the same way.
- Clear fractures first: Ottawa ankle, foot and knee rules, the anatomical snuffbox, and a toddler's pulled elbow only after a fall is excluded.
- Cervical facets lie at about 45 degrees, thoracic at 60 degrees and lumbar near 90 degrees to the transverse plane; lower cervical lateral flexion and rotation couple to the same side.
- Gonstead listings (PRS, PLI, PI, AS, ASR) record position; motion palpation listings record the restricted direction. A PI ilium gives an apparent short leg.
- Cervical artery dissection is screened by history; positional tests cannot clear a patient. New neurological signs on the table mean stop, supine, emergency services, time of onset, monitor, document.
- Valid informed consent covers risks, benefits, alternatives and no treatment; records follow SOAP with PART findings and the patient's response.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Absolute contraindication | A condition in which thrust at the involved region should never be performed because the risk outweighs any benefit. |
| Relative contraindication | A condition that raises risk but allows care if force, position or technique is modified. |
| Atlantodental interval (ADI) | The distance between the anterior arch of the atlas and the dens on a lateral film; over 3 mm in adults or 5 mm in children indicates instability. |
| High velocity, low amplitude thrust | A fast, short manual impulse delivered at the end of passive range to move a joint into the paraphysiological space. |
| Flexion distraction | A table based technique that flexes and distracts lumbar segments gently, used for disc lesions, stenosis and facet pain. |
| Instrument assisted adjusting | A spring loaded hand held device that delivers a very fast, low force impulse. |
| Maitland grades | A five level scale of mobilization by amplitude and position in the range; grade V is manipulation. |
| Paraphysiological space | The small zone between the elastic barrier and the anatomical barrier where cavitation occurs. |
| Capsular pattern | The characteristic proportional loss of motion when the whole joint capsule is involved, as in arthritis or adhesive capsulitis. |
| End feel | The quality of resistance felt at the end of passive range; an empty end feel suggests serious pathology. |
| Convex concave rule | A convex surface moving on a concave one glides opposite to its roll; a concave surface moving on a convex one glides the same way. |
| Coupled motion | The consistent occurrence of one motion with another about a different axis, such as same side rotation with lateral flexion in the lower cervical spine. |
| Fryette's laws | Rules of spinal coupling: neutral side bending and rotation to opposite sides (type I), nonneutral to the same side (type II), and motion in one plane limiting others (type III). |
| PI ilium | An ilium rotated posteriorly and inferiorly on the sacrum, associated with an apparent short leg on that side. |
| Radial head subluxation | Slippage of the annular ligament over the radial head in a young child after a pull on the extended, pronated arm. |
| Cuboid syndrome | Lateral midfoot pain from plantar displacement of the cuboid, treated with a dorsally directed thrust such as the cuboid whip. |
| Cervical artery dissection | A tear in the wall of the vertebral or internal carotid artery that can cause neck pain, headache and stroke. |
| 5 Ds and 3 Ns | Posterior circulation warning symptoms: dizziness, diplopia, dysarthria, dysphagia, drop attacks, nausea, numbness and nystagmus. |
| Informed consent | A competent patient's voluntary agreement after disclosure of the procedure, its material risks, benefits and alternatives, including no treatment. |
| PART | Documentation criteria for subluxation: pain, asymmetry, range of motion abnormality and tissue change. |
Check yourself
Supportive Interventions
Adjustments rarely work alone. Part III asks which modality fits the stage of an injury and which one must never be used on this patient, what diet or supplement advice is safe and when it needs a dietitian or physician, how to dose and progress exercise, how to change the desk, the lift and the pillow that keep provoking the pain, and how to help a patient stop smoking or start moving. This chapter teaches the supportive side of the treatment plan, where good choices speed recovery and poor ones cause burns, interactions and relapse.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Choose cryotherapy, superficial heat, therapeutic ultrasound, electrical stimulation, traction and laser by tissue, depth and stage, with correct parameters.
- Recognize the contraindications that rule each modality out, especially pacemakers, malignancy, pregnancy, impaired sensation and thrombosis.
- Give safe nutrition advice on anti inflammatory eating, evidence based supplements, bone health and weight management, and spot drug and supplement interactions.
- Know when to refer to a dietitian or physician, including unintended weight loss, eating disorders and toxicity.
- Match the phases of rehabilitation to the phases of tissue healing and dose exercise for strength, endurance and flexibility.
- Apply McKenzie classification, directional preference and centralization, and prescribe spinal stabilization exercise.
- Teach lifting, workstation and sleep posture principles and plan a graded return to work.
- Prescribe exercise with the FITT principle and screen for pre participation risk.
- Use the 5 As, stages of change and motivational interviewing for smoking, alcohol, sleep and stress counseling.
Section 1Physiotherapy modalities
Choosing a modality
A modality is chosen by three questions: what tissue is the target and how deep is it, what stage is the tissue in (acute inflammation, repair or remodeling), and what does this patient have that forbids it. Modalities are adjuncts. They reduce pain and swelling, prepare tissue for movement and help muscles fire, but on their own they do not restore function; a plan that uses only passive modalities for weeks is poor care and a common board distractor. The universal precautions are impaired sensation (the patient cannot report a burn), impaired circulation, malignancy in the treatment area, active infection, deep vein thrombosis, broken or radiation damaged skin, and an inability to communicate.
Cryotherapy
Cold causes vasoconstriction, slows cellular metabolism and secondary hypoxic injury, slows nerve conduction (raising the pain threshold) and reduces muscle spasm. It is the modality of choice in the acute stage, roughly the first 48 to 72 hours, and after exercise that flares a joint. Ice packs are applied for 15 to 20 minutes with a thin barrier, ice massage for 5 to 10 minutes over a small area, and cold baths for 10 to 15 minutes. The patient feels a predictable sequence: cold, burning, aching, numbness; numbness marks the end point. Current sports medicine teaching (the POLICE and PEACE and LOVE frameworks) emphasizes protection, optimal loading, compression and elevation, and uses ice for short term pain relief rather than for long periods.
Contraindications are conditions in which cold causes a harmful response: Raynaud phenomenon, cold urticaria, cryoglobulinemia, paroxysmal cold hemoglobinuria and peripheral vascular disease, plus impaired sensation. Use care over superficial nerves, because prolonged ice over the common fibular nerve at the fibular neck or the ulnar nerve at the elbow can cause a temporary neuropraxia (foot drop or hand numbness), and in uncontrolled hypertension, because cold raises blood pressure.
Superficial heat
Heat increases blood flow, metabolism and collagen extensibility and reduces muscle guarding, so it fits subacute and chronic stiffness and is ideal just before stretching or mobilization. Moist hot packs (stored at about 70 to 75 °C, 160 to 170 °F) are wrapped in six to eight layers of toweling and applied for about 20 minutes; they heat to a depth of about 1 to 2 cm. Paraffin baths (about 52 to 54 °C, 126 to 130 °F) suit the irregular joints of the hands and feet in osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis outside a flare, using the dip and wrap method. Check the skin at 5 minutes. Do not heat acutely inflamed or bleeding tissue, areas of impaired sensation or circulation, a known malignancy, a DVT, or the abdomen and low back in pregnancy, and never let a patient lie on a hot pack, which concentrates heat and causes burns.
Therapeutic ultrasound
Ultrasound uses a piezoelectric crystal to produce high frequency sound waves. The frequency sets the depth: 1 MHz penetrates about 2.5 to 5 cm for deep tissue such as the hip capsule or deep lumbar muscle, and 3 MHz is absorbed in the superficial 1 to 2 cm (patellar tendon, lateral epicondyle, plantar fascia) and heats about three times faster. Continuous output (100 percent duty cycle) produces thermal effects; pulsed output (commonly 20 percent duty cycle) produces mainly nonthermal effects (acoustic streaming and stable cavitation) thought to aid healing in subacute tissue. Typical intensities are 0.5 to 2.5 W/cm2, the treatment area should be no more than about twice the effective radiating area of the sound head, the head is kept moving with coupling gel, and treatments last 5 to 10 minutes. Evidence for ultrasound in most musculoskeletal pain is weak; it is best used to warm tissue before stretching or for specific tendon problems. Phonophoresis uses ultrasound to drive a topical medication into tissue.
Ultrasound must not be applied over the pregnant uterus, the eyes, the testes, a malignancy, a cardiac pacemaker, the spinal cord after laminectomy, a DVT or thrombophlebitis, an active infection, ischemic tissue, or a joint replacement fixed with methyl methacrylate cement or high density plastic, which heat rapidly. Open growth plates in children are a precaution. Metal implants are not a contraindication: metal conducts heat away and does not heat selectively, though the reflected energy warrants lower intensity.
Electrical stimulation
| Current | Typical parameters | Mechanism and use |
|---|---|---|
| Conventional (high rate) TENS | 80 to 150 Hz, short pulse (50 to 100 µs), comfortable sensory level | Gate control at the dorsal horn; fast onset, short carryover; acute and chronic pain |
| Acupuncture like (low rate) TENS | 2 to 10 Hz, long pulse, strong visible contractions | Endogenous opioid release; slower onset, longer relief; chronic pain |
| Interferential current (IFC) | Two medium frequency carriers near 4,000 Hz differing by 1 to 150 Hz | The beat frequency forms where they cross, deep in tissue, with low skin resistance; pain and edema |
| Russian stimulation and NMES | 2,500 Hz carrier in 50 bursts per second, about 10 s on and 50 s off | Muscle strengthening and reeducation (quadriceps after ACL reconstruction or knee surgery) |
| High volt pulsed current | Twin peak monophasic pulses over 100 V | Edema reduction and wound healing; polarity can be chosen |
| Iontophoresis | Continuous direct current, dose 40 to 80 mA·min | Drives charged drugs: dexamethasone from the negative electrode, lidocaine from the positive |
Contraindications to electrical stimulation are demand pacemakers and implanted defibrillators, placement over the carotid sinus (hypotension, bradycardia), across the chest or over the heart, over the anterior neck (laryngeal spasm), over the pregnant uterus and low back in pregnancy, over a DVT, over a malignancy, transcranially in epilepsy, and over damaged skin or areas without sensation.
Traction
Mechanical traction separates vertebral bodies and facets, widens the foramina, stretches soft tissues and may reduce disc pressure. It is used for radiculopathy and foraminal narrowing, more convincingly in the cervical spine (combined with exercise and manual therapy) than in the lumbar spine. Cervical traction starts at about 10 to 15 lb to relax tissues; about 20 to 30 lb (roughly 7 to 10 percent of body weight or more) is needed for vertebral separation, with the neck in 20 to 30 degrees of flexion to open the lower cervical foramina and closer to neutral for upper levels. A halter that pulls through the chin loads the temporomandibular joints, so an occipital wedge device is preferred. Lumbar traction needs about 25 percent of body weight just to overcome friction (a split table removes most of it) and about 50 percent of body weight to separate vertebrae. Contraindications include acute strain or sprain, instability (rheumatoid arthritis, Down syndrome, recent fracture), tumor, infection, severe osteoporosis, cord compression, vertebral artery disease, pregnancy (lumbar) and claustrophobia; uncontrolled hypertension and hiatal hernia (with a lumbar harness) are precautions.
Laser and other modalities
Low level laser therapy (photobiomodulation) uses red to near infrared light, roughly 600 to 1,000 nm, dosed in joules per square centimeter, for tendinopathy, neck pain, osteoarthritis and wound healing. Protective eyewear for patient and doctor is mandatory, and laser is not used over the eyes, a malignancy, the thyroid, the pregnant uterus or tissue treated with photosensitizing drugs. Shortwave diathermy heats large deep areas but is contraindicated with metal implants, pacemakers, pregnancy and wet dressings. Kinesiology taping, compression and bracing are low risk adjuncts.
| Patient feature | Avoid | Safer choice |
|---|---|---|
| Demand pacemaker or implanted defibrillator | Electrical stimulation, diathermy, ultrasound over the device | Heat or cold, manual therapy, exercise |
| Pregnancy | Ultrasound, electrical stimulation or diathermy over the abdomen and low back; lumbar traction; deep heat | Cold, gentle superficial heat away from the abdomen, exercise, support belts |
| Raynaud phenomenon or cold urticaria | Cryotherapy | Superficial heat if sensation intact |
| Known cancer in the area | Heat, ultrasound, electrical stimulation, laser, diathermy over the tumor | Education, gentle exercise, coordinated care |
| Diabetic neuropathy of the feet | Any thermal modality on insensate skin | Exercise, manual therapy, close skin checks |
| Rheumatoid arthritis with atlantoaxial instability | Cervical traction | Isometric exercise, superficial heat outside flares |
Reasoning: A demand pacemaker is a contraindication to electrical stimulation (and to diathermy, and ultrasound over the device), because the current can inhibit or trigger the pacemaker. Explain why and offer moist heat with a towel barrier and skin checks, gentle manual therapy and deep neck flexor and scapular exercise. His foot neuropathy is irrelevant to neck treatment but would forbid thermal agents on the feet.
Reasoning: Ottawa rules are negative, so no radiograph is needed. In the acute stage, heat increases blood flow and edema; instead use protection, compression, elevation and short bouts of ice (15 to 20 minutes) for pain, with early protected weight bearing and range of motion (optimal loading). Heat can be introduced once swelling stabilizes, typically after 48 to 72 hours.
Choose the modality by depth, stage and contraindications: ice for the acute stage, heat for stiffness, ultrasound at 1 MHz for deep and 3 MHz for shallow targets, TENS for pain, NMES for strength, traction for radiculopathy and laser at red to near infrared wavelengths. Pacemakers, pregnancy, malignancy, thrombosis, impaired sensation and circulation are the recurring contraindications, and modalities support but never replace active care.
Section 2Nutrition and diet counseling
Scope and the first questions
Chiropractors routinely give general nutrition guidance: healthy eating patterns, adequate protein, calcium and vitamin D, weight management and supplement safety, within the limits set by state law. Medical nutrition therapy for disease (renal diets, diabetes meal planning with insulin, eating disorders, tube feeding, severe food allergy, pregnancy with complications) belongs to a registered dietitian working with the physician. A useful nutrition history asks what the patient actually eats in a typical day, alcohol intake, recent weight change, appetite, chewing and swallowing problems, restrictive diets (vegan, ketogenic), every supplement and over the counter product, and every prescription drug, because interactions are the most dangerous part of supplement advice.
Anti inflammatory eating
Chronic low grade inflammation, measured by markers such as C reactive protein, rises with central obesity, refined carbohydrates, sugar sweetened drinks, ultra processed foods and a high ratio of omega 6 to omega 3 fatty acids. The eating pattern with the strongest evidence for lowering inflammatory markers and cardiovascular risk is the Mediterranean diet: vegetables, fruit, legumes, whole grains, nuts and seeds, extra virgin olive oil as the main fat, fish two or more times a week, modest dairy and poultry, and little red or processed meat. The DASH diet is similar and lowers blood pressure. Present these as patterns rather than single "anti inflammatory foods": the benefit comes from the whole diet and from the weight loss and exercise that often accompany it.
Supplements: what the evidence supports
| Supplement | Reasonable use and evidence | Cautions |
|---|---|---|
| Vitamin D | Correct documented deficiency; supports bone health and fall risk reduction in deficient older adults | Toxicity causes hypercalcemia; adult upper limit 4,000 IU a day without monitoring |
| Calcium | Fill the gap between dietary intake and the requirement (1,000 to 1,200 mg a day total) | Excess raises kidney stone risk; separate from thyroid hormone, iron and quinolone or tetracycline antibiotics by about 4 hours |
| Omega 3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) | About 2.5 to 3 g a day modestly reduces joint pain and stiffness in rheumatoid arthritis; lowers triglycerides | Fishy aftertaste; additive bleeding risk at high doses with anticoagulants |
| Glucosamine and chondroitin | Mixed results in knee osteoarthritis; large trials show little benefit over placebo overall | Glucosamine is shellfish derived in many products; may slightly raise INR with warfarin |
| Curcumin (turmeric extract) | Small benefit for osteoarthritis pain in short trials | Poor absorption; antiplatelet effect; rare liver injury |
| Creatine | With resistance training, improves strength and lean mass, including in older adults with sarcopenia | Avoid in kidney disease; water weight gain |
| Protein (food or supplement) | Older adults need about 1.0 to 1.2 g/kg a day, athletes 1.2 to 2.0 g/kg, to build and keep muscle | Advanced kidney disease needs a supervised plan |
| Vitamin B12 | Treats deficiency in vegans, older adults, and patients on metformin or long term acid suppression | Untreated deficiency causes neuropathy and subacute combined degeneration |
Interactions and toxicity
The highest risk patient is the one on warfarin. Vitamin K (leafy greens, some multivitamins) lowers the INR and the anticoagulant effect; fish oil at high dose, ginkgo, garlic, ginger, vitamin E, dong quai and high dose turmeric add to bleeding risk. Advise consistency in vitamin K intake rather than avoidance, and tell the patient to check any new supplement with the prescriber. St. John's wort induces hepatic enzymes (CYP3A4) and drug transporters, reducing the effect of warfarin, oral contraceptives, cyclosporine and many other drugs, and causes serotonin syndrome with SSRIs. Red yeast rice contains a natural statin (monacolin K, identical to lovastatin) and can cause myopathy, especially with a prescribed statin. Licorice causes hypokalemia and hypertension; kava can injure the liver.
Fat soluble vitamins accumulate. Vitamin A excess causes liver injury, raised intracranial pressure, bone loss and birth defects, so pregnant women must avoid high dose retinol. Vitamin D excess causes hypercalcemia (kidney stones, bone pain, abdominal pain, confusion, polyuria). Among water soluble vitamins, vitamin B6 above about 100 mg a day for months causes a sensory neuropathy, and high dose niacin causes flushing and liver injury.
Bone health
Bone mass peaks around age 30 and is lost faster after menopause. The nutritional basis is adequate calcium (1,000 mg a day for adults, 1,200 mg for women over 50 and men over 70, preferably from food), adequate vitamin D (600 IU a day to age 70 and 800 IU after, with a serum 25 hydroxyvitamin D below 20 ng/mL usually treated as deficient), adequate protein, and limits on alcohol (no more than about two drinks a day) and smoking. Calcium carbonate needs stomach acid and should be taken with meals; calcium citrate is absorbed without acid and suits patients on proton pump inhibitors or with achlorhydria. Doses above 500 mg are absorbed better when split. Add weight bearing and progressive resistance exercise, balance training and fall proofing at home. Screening DXA is recommended for women 65 and older and for younger postmenopausal women with risk factors; a T score of −2.5 or lower, or a fragility fracture, needs physician referral for pharmacotherapy.
Reasoning: Long term proton pump inhibitor use reduces acid dependent calcium absorption and is linked to fracture risk, so calcium citrate is the better form, aiming for about 1,200 mg a day from food plus supplement, split into doses of 500 mg or less. Ask her physician to check 25 hydroxyvitamin D and to review whether the PPI is still needed. She has osteopenia, not osteoporosis, but her fracture risk (for example by FRAX) should be calculated by her physician. Add resistance and balance training and assess fall risk.
Weight management
Excess weight raises load on the knees and hips (each kilogram of body weight adds roughly three to four kilograms of force across the knee during walking), increases low back pain risk and worsens recovery. Classify with body mass index and waist circumference, because abdominal fat carries most of the metabolic risk.
Weight loss of 5 to 10 percent improves blood pressure, glucose control and osteoarthritis pain. A daily deficit of about 500 to 750 kcal produces loss of roughly 0.5 to 0.75 kg (1 to 1.5 lb) a week; very low calorie diets below about 800 kcal a day need medical supervision. Combine dietary change with 150 to 300 minutes a week of moderate activity (more, about 250 to 300 minutes, helps maintain loss), resistance training to protect lean mass, sleep and stress management. Medications such as GLP 1 receptor agonists are considered for a BMI of 30 or more, or 27 or more with comorbidity, and bariatric surgery for a BMI of 40 or more, or 35 or more with comorbidity; both are physician decisions.
When to refer
| Finding | What it may mean | Refer to |
|---|---|---|
| Unintended weight loss over 5 percent in 6 to 12 months | Cancer, hyperthyroidism, diabetes, malabsorption, depression | Physician, promptly |
| Low BMI, amenorrhea, bradycardia, lanugo, knuckle calluses (Russell sign), parotid swelling | Anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa | Physician and eating disorder team |
| Athlete with stress fracture, low energy intake, menstrual disturbance | Relative energy deficiency in sport (female athlete triad) | Sports physician and dietitian |
| Bloating, diarrhea, iron deficiency anemia, dermatitis herpetiformis | Celiac disease | Physician for serology before gluten is removed |
| Numb feet, poor balance, glossitis, macrocytosis in a vegan or metformin user | Vitamin B12 deficiency | Physician for testing and replacement |
| Diabetes, chronic kidney disease, pregnancy, dysphagia | Need for medical nutrition therapy | Registered dietitian with the physician |
Reasoning: Each product can increase bleeding risk or raise the INR, and new bruising suggests over anticoagulation. He should stop the ginkgo and add nothing new until his prescriber has checked his INR; send a brief note to the prescriber. Offer evidence based measures for knee osteoarthritis instead: weight loss if overweight, quadriceps and hip strengthening, walking or cycling, and education. Do not use deep soft tissue techniques until his bruising is explained.
Teach eating patterns (Mediterranean, DASH) rather than miracle foods, recommend supplements only where evidence supports them (vitamin D and calcium to fill gaps, omega 3 for rheumatoid arthritis, creatine with training, B12 for deficiency), and always check for interactions, especially with warfarin. Know the calcium and vitamin D targets, the BMI and waist thresholds, the 5 to 10 percent weight loss goal, and the findings that send a patient to a physician or dietitian.
Section 3Corrective exercise and rehabilitation
Healing phases drive rehabilitation phases
Soft tissue heals in three overlapping phases, and each rehabilitation phase is matched to what the tissue can tolerate. In the inflammatory phase (roughly the first 3 to 6 days) platelets, neutrophils and macrophages clear debris and release growth factors; the tissue is weak, and the goals are protection, pain and swelling control and gentle motion. In the proliferative (repair) phase (from about day 3 to week 3 to 6) fibroblasts lay down disorganized type III collagen and new capillaries; this young scar needs controlled, progressive loading to align its fibers. In the remodeling (maturation) phase (from about week 3 to a year or more) type III collagen is replaced by stronger type I collagen aligned along lines of stress; tensile strength rises slowly and never quite reaches that of uninjured tissue. Tendons and ligaments, with poor blood supply, heal more slowly than muscle; bone heals in about 6 to 12 weeks in adults.
| Phase | Goals | Typical interventions | Criteria to progress |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acute (protection) | Limit further injury, control pain and edema, maintain motion elsewhere | Relative rest, ice, compression, gentle pain free range of motion, isometrics, adjustments or mobilization as tolerated, advice to stay active | Pain and swelling settling, pain free range improving |
| Subacute (repair) | Restore full range and joint play, re-establish motor control | Stretching, mobilization, stabilization (low load motor control), proprioceptive training, light resistance | Near full range, good control, minimal pain with daily activities |
| Functional (remodeling) | Strength, endurance, power, task specific skills, prevention | Progressive resistance, plyometrics and agility, work or sport simulation, home program | Strength about 90 percent of the other side, passing functional tests, confidence |
Spinal stabilization and motor control
After an episode of low back pain the lumbar multifidus shows rapid, segmental atrophy on the painful side that does not recover spontaneously, and the transversus abdominis fires late, before rather than with limb movement. Stabilization training retrains these deep muscles first (abdominal drawing in or bracing, multifidus swelling in prone or quadruped) and then integrates them into the global muscles and daily tasks. A widely used and well tolerated core program is the McGill "big three": the modified curl up, the side bridge and the bird dog, which build endurance while keeping spinal load and motion low. Endurance, not maximal strength, is the main deficit in chronic back pain, so holds of about 8 to 10 seconds repeated in descending pyramids are typical. In the neck, the deep neck flexors (longus colli and capitis) are trained with the craniocervical flexion (chin nod) exercise, guided by a pressure biofeedback cuff, together with the lower trapezius and serratus anterior.
Muscle imbalance patterns help choose exercises. The upper crossed syndrome combines tight upper trapezius, levator scapulae and pectorals with weak deep neck flexors, lower trapezius and serratus anterior, producing forward head posture, rounded shoulders and scapular winging. The lower crossed syndrome combines tight hip flexors and lumbar erector spinae with weak abdominals and gluteus maximus, producing anterior pelvic tilt and increased lordosis. Treatment stretches the tight group and strengthens the inhibited group.
McKenzie mechanical diagnosis and therapy
The McKenzie method classifies spinal pain by its response to repeated end range movements and sustained positions. Centralization, the retreat of referred symptoms from distal to proximal toward the spine during repeated movement in one direction, predicts a good prognosis and identifies the directional preference that guides the home program. Peripheralization, spread of symptoms further down the limb, means that direction should be avoided for now.
| McKenzie syndrome | Clinical picture | Response to repeated movement | Management |
|---|---|---|---|
| Derangement (most common) | Pain often referred, may be variable, with a lateral shift or obstructed movement | Rapid change: centralization and restored range in one direction, worsening in the opposite | Repeated movement in the directional preference (most often extension), correction of lateral shift, postural education |
| Dysfunction | Intermittent pain only at end range of a shortened structure, no referred pain distal to the knee (except adherent nerve root) | Pain produced at end range, not worse afterward, no rapid change | Regular remodeling stretch into the painful end range over weeks |
| Postural syndrome | Young, sedentary; local pain only after prolonged static loading, normal examination | No pain with movement; relieved by changing posture | Postural correction and education |
Reasoning: The thigh pain centralized with extension and peripheralized with flexion, so this is a derangement with an extension directional preference. Prescribe repeated prone press ups every 2 to 3 hours, avoidance of prolonged slumped sitting with a lumbar roll for support, and progression to standing extension and stabilization once symptoms are central. Centralization predicts a favorable outcome; if leg pain worsened or neurological deficits appeared, the plan would change and imaging or referral would be considered.
Stretching
Static stretching held for about 30 seconds, two to four repetitions, at least two to three days a week improves flexibility; longer holds add little for most adults, though older adults may benefit from up to 60 seconds. Proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation (PNF) techniques such as contract relax and hold relax use an isometric contraction of the target muscle (or the antagonist) before the stretch and produce the largest short term gains. Ballistic stretching (bouncing) is avoided in rehabilitation. Before sport, a dynamic warm up is preferred, because long static holds immediately before power activity can briefly reduce force output. Neural mobilization (sliders and tensioners) moves a nerve through its bed for patients with neural mechanosensitivity, such as a positive slump test.
Dosage and progression
| Goal | Load | Repetitions and sets | Rest and frequency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Muscular endurance | Below about 50 percent of 1 repetition maximum (1RM) | 15 to 25 repetitions, 1 to 3 sets | Short rest (under 1 minute); 2 to 3 days a week |
| Hypertrophy and general strength (novice) | About 60 to 70 percent of 1RM | 8 to 12 repetitions, 1 to 3 sets | 1 to 2 minutes; 2 to 3 nonconsecutive days a week |
| Maximal strength (trained) | About 80 percent of 1RM or more | Up to 6 repetitions, 2 to 6 sets | 2 to 3 minutes |
| Power | Light to moderate, moved fast | 3 to 6 repetitions | Full recovery between sets |
The overload and specificity (SAID) principles mean that tissues adapt to the demands placed on them, so the program must progress and resemble the target task. A practical progression rule: when the patient can complete one or two repetitions beyond the target on two consecutive sessions, raise the load by about 2 to 10 percent. Progress in a logical order: pain free range of motion, isometric, isotonic, then functional and plyometric; stable to unstable surfaces; slow to fast; single plane to multiplane. Tendinopathy responds to heavy slow resistance or eccentric loading, with pain during exercise allowed up to about 3 to 5 out of 10 if it settles by the next morning. For patients with fear avoidance, graded activity (quota based increases) and graded exposure to feared movements beat waiting for pain to disappear.
Reasoning: She is in the remodeling phase with persistent deficits in strength and proprioception, the main risk factors for recurrent sprain and chronic instability. Continue progressive calf and peroneal strengthening, single leg balance on firm then unstable surfaces, hopping and cutting drills, and return to practice in stages when hop tests and heel raises reach about 90 percent of the other side. A brace or tape for the first season reduces recurrence.
Rehabilitation follows healing: protect in the inflammatory phase, restore motion and motor control with controlled loading in the repair phase, and build strength, endurance and task specific skill during remodeling. Retrain multifidus, transversus abdominis and deep neck flexors, use directional preference and centralization to guide McKenzie exercise, hold static stretches about 30 seconds, and progress load by measurable criteria rather than by the calendar alone.
Section 4Body mechanics, ergonomics and patient education
Why the environment matters
Many mechanical complaints are maintained by what the patient does for eight hours a day: the desk, the vehicle, the lift, the phone and the pillow. Correcting these loads is often the difference between a patient who improves for a day after each adjustment and one who stays better. Education should be specific, demonstrated and checked: the patient performs the lift or sets up the workstation in front of the clinician, and the plan is written down.
Lifting and handling
Spinal load during lifting depends mostly on the horizontal distance of the load from the spine, because the extensor muscles work through a short lever and must generate many times the load's weight. Teach the patient to keep the load close, face it squarely, use a wide base with one foot slightly forward, hip hinge with the spine near neutral (the squat lift for low objects, the golfer's lift for light items), brace the abdominal wall, lift smoothly without jerking, and turn with the feet rather than twisting the trunk. Combined flexion and rotation under load is the classic disc injury mechanism. Avoid heavy or repeated lumbar flexion in the first hour after rising, when the discs are most hydrated and the posterior annulus most vulnerable. In the workplace, the NIOSH lifting equation starts from a load constant of 23 kg (51 lb) under ideal conditions and reduces it for distance, height, travel, asymmetry, frequency and grip; loads above the recommended limit call for mechanical aids or team lifts.
The computer workstation
The goal is a neutral, supported posture that the patient changes frequently. Adjust the chair first (feet flat, thighs roughly horizontal, lumbar support at the belt line, armrests that do not hike the shoulders), then the desk or keyboard to elbow height, then the monitor: directly in front, about an arm's length away, top at or slightly below eye level. Wearers of progressive lenses need the monitor lower to avoid tipping the head back. Laptops need an external keyboard and a raised screen for prolonged use. Phones and tablets held low drive the head into flexion, which multiplies the load on the cervical extensors; raise the device instead. The most important prescription is movement: a change of position every 30 to 60 minutes, short standing or walking breaks, and for eye strain the 20 20 20 habit (every 20 minutes look at something about 20 feet away for 20 seconds). Sit to stand desks help when they increase position changes, not when standing simply replaces sitting for hours.
Reasoning: The picture is mechanical neck pain with cervicogenic headache maintained by sustained flexion and upper crossed imbalance. Along with cervical and thoracic manipulation, prescribe an external keyboard and mouse at elbow height, a laptop stand or monitor lowered slightly for her progressive lenses, a chair with lumbar support, breaks every 30 to 45 minutes, deep neck flexor and lower trapezius training and pectoral stretching. Recheck her actual setup with a photograph at the next visit.
Sleep posture and self care
For neck pain, a pillow that keeps the cervical spine in line with the thoracic spine (higher for side sleepers with broad shoulders, lower for back sleepers) is the key; prone sleeping forces the neck into end range rotation for hours and is discouraged. Side lying with a pillow between the knees keeps the pelvis level and reduces lumbar rotation; supine sleepers with back pain often benefit from a pillow under the knees, which flattens the lumbar curve slightly. A medium firm mattress is generally better than a very firm one for chronic low back pain. Patients with stenosis prefer curled side lying, while those with an extension directional preference often tolerate prone lying.
A written self care plan gives the patient control between visits: how to use ice or heat, the two or three exercises that matter most, how to modify activity without stopping it, how to pace (break tasks into blocks with rest), and what warning signs mean they should call. For acute low back pain, staying active leads to faster recovery than bed rest, which is no longer recommended beyond a day or two for severe pain. Reassurance that most acute back pain improves substantially within 6 weeks, delivered with a plan rather than a vague "it will get better," reduces fear avoidance and disability.
Return to work
The longer a worker is off, the lower the chance of returning: after about 12 weeks away, the likelihood of ever returning to that job falls sharply. Early, graded return with modified duty (lifting limits, alternating sitting and standing, reduced hours) produces better outcomes than waiting to be pain free. Communicate restrictions in functional terms (no lifting over 10 kg, change position every 30 minutes, no repeated overhead work for 2 weeks) rather than "no work." Screen for yellow flags (fear avoidance beliefs, catastrophizing, low mood, job dissatisfaction, poor expectations of recovery, compensation disputes) and blue and black flags (perceptions of the workplace and system obstacles), which predict chronicity better than imaging findings. A functional capacity evaluation measures what a patient can safely do and guides restrictions; work conditioning rebuilds general strength and endurance, and work hardening adds simulated job tasks and behavioral support in an interdisciplinary program.
| Situation | Advice that helps | Common mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Acute low back pain without red flags | Stay active, short walks, modified duties, reassurance with a plan | Prolonged bed rest and time off "until it stops hurting" |
| Warehouse worker with disc related pain | Hip hinge, load close, pivot with the feet, avoid lifting in the first hour after rising, lifting aids | Telling him only to "bend the knees" |
| Driver with back pain | Seat close enough to keep knees bent, lumbar support, stops every 1 to 2 hours, avoid lifting right after a long drive | Long uninterrupted drives with a reclined seat |
| Office worker with neck pain | Monitor height and distance, external keyboard, breaks every 30 to 60 minutes, exercises | Buying an expensive chair without changing habits |
| Worker off 8 weeks with high fear avoidance | Graded activity, workplace contact, modified duties, address beliefs | More passive treatment and further imaging |
Teach the patient to keep loads close and turn with the feet, set up the workstation around a neutral posture with frequent movement, sleep with the spine aligned and avoid prone sleeping for neck pain, and follow a written self care plan. Return to work early and gradually with function based restrictions, screen yellow flags, and use functional capacity evaluation, work conditioning and work hardening for the patient who is not progressing.
Section 5Wellness and lifestyle counseling
Exercise prescription
Adults should accumulate 150 to 300 minutes a week of moderate aerobic activity or 75 to 150 minutes of vigorous activity (or an equivalent mix), plus muscle strengthening of all major muscle groups on 2 or more days a week; older adults add balance training, and any activity is better than none. Prescriptions follow FITT-VP: frequency, intensity, time, type, volume and progression. Intensity can be set by the talk test (moderate: can talk but not sing), by the Borg rating of perceived exertion (about 12 to 13 on the 6 to 20 scale for moderate, 14 to 17 for vigorous), or by heart rate. Age predicted maximum heart rate is about 220 minus age; the Karvonen method sets target heart rate as resting rate plus a percentage (40 to 59 percent for moderate, 60 to 89 percent for vigorous) of the heart rate reserve (maximum minus resting). Beta blockers blunt the heart rate response, so these patients should use perceived exertion.
Pre participation screening uses three questions: does the person exercise regularly now, do they have known cardiovascular, metabolic or renal disease, and do they have signs or symptoms of such disease (exertional chest discomfort, unusual breathlessness, syncope, palpitations, claudication, ankle edema). A person with symptoms should stop and obtain medical clearance before any exercise. A person with known disease and no symptoms who is inactive should get clearance before starting; one already active can continue moderate exercise. Healthy asymptomatic people can start light to moderate exercise and progress gradually without clearance.
Reasoning: Exertional chest tightness relieved by rest is stable angina until proved otherwise, and he has known metabolic disease. He needs medical evaluation (and probably exercise testing) before any exercise program; it would be wrong to start a walking program "gently" first. If cleared, begin with moderate walking or cycling using perceived exertion, add resistance training twice a week, and progress gradually. Chest pain at rest, or lasting more than a few minutes, would mean emergency services now.
Tobacco
Smoking impairs disc nutrition, slows bone and soft tissue healing, raises the risk of spinal fusion nonunion and osteoporosis, and is associated with low back pain, in addition to its cardiovascular and cancer risks. Every visit is an opportunity to use the 5 As: Ask about tobacco use, Advise quitting clearly and personally ("stopping smoking is the most important thing you can do for your back and your heart"), Assess willingness to quit, Assist with a plan (quit date, removing triggers, telephone quitline, referral for pharmacotherapy such as nicotine replacement, varenicline or bupropion, which together with counseling roughly doubles success), and Arrange follow up. For a patient not ready to quit, use the 5 Rs: relevance, risks, rewards, roadblocks and repetition. Brief advice from a clinician, even under 3 minutes, measurably increases quit rates.
Alcohol
A US standard drink contains about 14 g of alcohol (12 oz of beer, 5 oz of wine, 1.5 oz of spirits). Low risk limits commonly cited are no more than 2 drinks a day for men and 1 for women, and less is better. Screen with the AUDIT-C or a single question ("How many times in the past year have you had 5 or more drinks in a day [4 for women]?") or CAGE (cut down, annoyed, guilty, eye opener; two or more positives suggest a problem). Heavy drinking causes falls and fractures, osteoporosis, neuropathy, myopathy, gout and avascular necrosis of the femoral head, and interacts dangerously with sedatives and acetaminophen. Patients with dependence must not stop abruptly without medical supervision because alcohol withdrawal can cause seizures and delirium tremens; refer to a physician.
Sleep and stress
Adults need 7 or more hours of sleep a night; poor sleep lowers pain thresholds and predicts persistence of musculoskeletal pain. Sleep hygiene advice includes a consistent wake time, a dark, cool, quiet bedroom, no screens for about an hour before bed, limiting caffeine after midday and alcohol in the evening, and getting out of bed after 20 minutes awake. Chronic insomnia is best treated with cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia. Loud snoring, witnessed apneas, daytime sleepiness, a large neck and hypertension suggest obstructive sleep apnea (screen with STOP-BANG) and need referral for a sleep study.
Chronic stress raises sympathetic tone and cortisol and amplifies pain and muscle tension. Useful tools are regular exercise, diaphragmatic breathing, progressive muscle relaxation, mindfulness practice and social connection. Screen mood with the PHQ-2 (little interest or pleasure in doing things; feeling down, depressed or hopeless over the last 2 weeks), followed by the PHQ-9 when positive. Any patient who expresses hopelessness or thoughts of self harm must be asked directly about suicidal intent and, if at risk, connected to crisis services (in the US, the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) or emergency care the same day.
Behavior change
Advice changes behavior only when it matches the patient's readiness. The transtheoretical model (stages of change) describes that readiness, and the clinician's task changes at each stage.
Motivational interviewing is a collaborative style that helps the patient voice their own reasons to change. Its core skills are OARS: open questions, affirmations, reflective listening and summaries. The clinician listens for and strengthens change talk (desire, ability, reasons and need, then commitment), avoids arguing (which produces resistance), and respects autonomy. Once the patient is ready, goals are written as SMART goals (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time bound), for example "walk 20 minutes after dinner on Monday, Wednesday and Friday for the next 2 weeks." Self efficacy, the confidence that one can do the behavior (from social cognitive theory), is built with small early successes. The health belief model adds that people act when they believe they are susceptible, the problem is serious, the action works and the barriers are manageable.
| Patient says | Stage | Best response |
|---|---|---|
| "I don't see why my smoking matters for my back." | Precontemplation | Brief, personal information and permission to revisit; no pressure |
| "I know I should walk more, but I'm so tired after work." | Contemplation | Reflect both sides, explore pros and cons, elicit change talk |
| "I'm going to start the gym on the first of the month." | Preparation | Build a SMART plan, anticipate barriers |
| "I've walked every day for 6 weeks." | Action | Affirm, problem solve setbacks, progress the plan |
| "I've kept it up for a year, but the holidays worry me." | Maintenance | Relapse prevention, plan for high risk situations |
Reasoning: He is in contemplation: he sees reasons to quit but is ambivalent. Use motivational interviewing rather than a lecture: reflect his ambivalence ("smoking helps you cope with stress, and you're also worried about your heart after what happened to your father"), ask what quitting would mean for him, and explore other ways to manage stress at work. If he moves toward preparation, assist with a quit date, quitline referral and a physician visit for pharmacotherapy, and arrange follow up at his next visit.
Prescribe exercise with FITT-VP toward 150 to 300 minutes of moderate activity and strength training twice weekly, after screening for cardiovascular symptoms. Use the 5 As for tobacco, AUDIT-C or CAGE for alcohol, sleep hygiene and STOP-BANG for sleep, and PHQ-2 for mood with urgent action on suicidal thoughts. Match counseling to the stage of change, using motivational interviewing for ambivalence and SMART goals for action.
The chapter in one breath
- Ice for the acute stage (15 to 20 minutes), heat for subacute stiffness; cold is contraindicated in Raynaud phenomenon, cold urticaria and cryoglobulinemia.
- Ultrasound: 1 MHz deep, 3 MHz superficial, continuous thermal, pulsed nonthermal; never over the pregnant uterus, eyes, malignancy, pacemaker or DVT.
- TENS high rate for gate control, low rate for endorphins; NMES for strength; electrical stimulation is contraindicated with demand pacemakers and over the carotid sinus.
- Traction needs about 20 to 30 lb to separate cervical and about half of body weight to separate lumbar vertebrae; avoid with instability, tumor and infection.
- Recommend the Mediterranean pattern; supplements with evidence include vitamin D and calcium to fill gaps, omega 3 for rheumatoid arthritis, creatine with training and B12 for deficiency.
- Warfarin interacts with vitamin K, ginkgo, fish oil, garlic, vitamin E and St. John's wort; calcium citrate suits patients on acid suppression.
- BMI thresholds 18.5, 25, 30, 35, 40; a 5 to 10 percent weight loss improves osteoarthritis pain, blood pressure and glucose.
- Rehabilitation phases follow healing: protect, restore motion and motor control, then build strength and function.
- Centralization identifies the directional preference; peripheralization means avoid that direction.
- Keep loads close, hip hinge, turn with the feet; set the monitor at arm's length with the top at eye level; move every 30 to 60 minutes.
- Stay active and return to work early with modified duty; yellow flags predict chronic disability.
- Exercise target 150 to 300 minutes moderate plus strength twice weekly; use the 5 As, stages of change and motivational interviewing.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Cryotherapy | Therapeutic use of cold to reduce pain, metabolism, swelling and spasm, mainly in the acute stage. |
| Cold urticaria | Hives and swelling triggered by cold exposure; a contraindication to cryotherapy. |
| Duty cycle | The percentage of time an ultrasound or electrical device is actually emitting energy during treatment. |
| Effective radiating area | The part of an ultrasound sound head that produces energy; the treatment area should be about twice this size. |
| Phonophoresis | Use of ultrasound to drive a topical medication through the skin. |
| Iontophoresis | Use of direct current to drive a charged drug into tissue, placing the drug under the electrode of the same charge. |
| Gate control theory | The idea that large fiber sensory input at the dorsal horn inhibits transmission of pain signals, the basis of high rate TENS. |
| Interferential current | Two medium frequency currents crossing in tissue to create a low frequency beat at depth with little skin discomfort. |
| Photobiomodulation | Low level laser or LED therapy with red to near infrared light intended to reduce pain and aid tissue repair. |
| Mediterranean diet | An eating pattern rich in vegetables, fruit, legumes, whole grains, nuts, olive oil and fish, with little red or processed meat. |
| Calcium citrate | A calcium salt absorbed without stomach acid, preferred for patients on acid suppression. |
| Relative energy deficiency in sport | Impaired physiological function from low energy availability, including menstrual and bone health effects (the female athlete triad). |
| Body mass index | Weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared; 25 or more is overweight and 30 or more is obese. |
| Remodeling phase | The final healing phase in which type III collagen is replaced by stronger, aligned type I collagen. |
| Centralization | Retreat of referred pain toward the spine with repeated movement in one direction, a favorable prognostic sign. |
| Directional preference | The movement direction that reduces or centralizes symptoms and restores range of motion. |
| Derangement | The McKenzie syndrome in which symptoms change rapidly with repeated movement and often centralize. |
| Upper crossed syndrome | Tight upper trapezius, levator scapulae and pectorals with weak deep neck flexors, lower trapezius and serratus anterior. |
| PNF stretching | Proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation techniques that combine an isometric contraction with a stretch to gain range. |
| One repetition maximum | The greatest load that can be lifted once with good form, used to set training intensity. |
| NIOSH lifting equation | A workplace tool that starts from 23 kg (51 lb) and lowers the recommended weight limit for poor lifting conditions. |
| Work hardening | An interdisciplinary program that uses simulated job tasks and behavioral support to prepare a worker to return. |
| Karvonen method | Target heart rate calculated as resting heart rate plus a chosen percentage of heart rate reserve. |
| 5 As | Brief tobacco intervention steps: ask, advise, assess, assist, arrange. |
| Motivational interviewing | A collaborative counseling style that resolves ambivalence by eliciting the patient's own reasons for change. |
Check yourself
Case Management
Case management carries more weight on Part III than any domain except diagnosis, because it asks the question every patient eventually poses: what happens now? Knowing the diagnosis is only the start; the board wants to see that you can set measurable goals, choose a sensible frequency and duration of care, recognize when a patient is not responding, refer at the right speed to the right person, and leave a record that would satisfy a reviewer, an insurer or a court. This chapter turns those decisions into a repeatable process and then walks through multi visit cases that test the next best step.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Write a treatment plan with a working diagnosis, SMART goals, frequency, duration, re-examination date and discharge criteria.
- Estimate prognosis from natural history, complicating factors, yellow flags and risk tools such as the STarT Back screening tool.
- Choose and interpret outcome measures (NPRS, Oswestry, Neck Disability Index, PSFS) using the minimal clinically important difference.
- Schedule re-examinations and decide what to do when a patient improves, plateaus or worsens, including recognition of maximum medical improvement.
- Sort referrals into emergency, urgent, prompt and routine categories and name the right receiving clinician for each.
- Write a focused referral letter and run co-management with physicians, therapists and mental health providers.
- Document care in SOAP format, obtain valid informed consent using the PARQ elements, and correct records properly.
- Apply coding basics: ICD-10-CM diagnosis codes, CPT procedure codes for manipulation, evaluation and therapy, and the common modifiers.
- Work multi visit scenarios to the next best step in management.
Section 1Treatment plans and prognosis
What a treatment plan must contain
A treatment plan is a written contract between your findings and your actions. It flows directly from the assessment: if the diagnosis is acute mechanical low back pain without radiculopathy, the plan addresses pain control, restoring motion and returning the patient to work, and it predicts how long that should take. Reviewers judge a plan by whether a stranger reading it could tell what you intended to do, why, for how long, and how you would know whether it was working. A complete plan contains:
- Working diagnosis with the primary condition and any secondary or complicating diagnoses (for example, lumbar sprain, segmental dysfunction L4 and L5, and a history of two prior episodes).
- Baseline measures: pain intensity, a validated functional questionnaire, objective findings such as range of motion or a straight leg raise angle, and the patient's own functional limits (cannot sit more than 20 minutes, cannot lift a 15 kg box).
- Goals, both short term (two to four weeks) and long term (by discharge), written so they can be measured.
- Interventions: the techniques, regions, supportive care, exercise and education you will use, with any precautions or modifications.
- Frequency and duration: visits per week and the total trial period before formal re-examination.
- Re-examination date and the outcome measures you will repeat.
- Discharge criteria and the conditions that would prompt referral (for example, any new neurological deficit).
- Home care: activity advice, exercises, ergonomic changes and what to do if symptoms flare.
Goals that can be measured
Goals should be SMART: specific, measurable, achievable, relevant to the patient's life, and time bound. "Decrease pain" is not a goal; "reduce average pain from 7/10 to 3/10 or less and Oswestry score from 46% to below 20% within six weeks, so the patient can return to full duty as a warehouse worker" is. Functional goals are more persuasive than pain goals because pain is volatile and insurers pay for restored function. Tie each goal to an activity the patient cares about (sitting through a school day, lifting a grandchild, driving 90 minutes to work). The Patient Specific Functional Scale (PSFS) formalizes this: the patient names three to five activities they struggle with and rates each from 0 (unable) to 10 (normal).
Phases of care
Care is usually described in phases that overlap rather than switch on a fixed date. Intensity is highest early and tapers as the patient improves, while the balance shifts from passive treatment to active care and self-management.
| Phase | Primary aim | Typical content | Typical frequency | Moves on when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Relief (acute) | Reduce pain and inflammation, protect healing tissue, restore some motion | Manipulation or mobilization as tolerated, cryotherapy, activity modification (stay active, avoid bed rest), reassurance, simple exercises | 2 to 3 visits per week for 1 to 2 weeks | Pain falling, patient able to perform daily activities with less guarding |
| Corrective and rehabilitative (subacute) | Restore range of motion, strength, endurance and motor control | Manipulation, progressive exercise, stabilization, ergonomic and lifting retraining | 1 to 2 visits per week for 2 to 6 weeks | Functional goals largely met, patient independent with home program |
| Self-management and discharge | Independence, prevention of recurrence | Home program, graded return to full activity, education on flare management | Tapering to every 2 to 4 weeks, then discharge | Goals met or maximum medical improvement reached |
| Supportive care | Maintain function in a patient who has reached MMI but regresses when care is withdrawn | Periodic manipulation plus continued home program | Individualized (often monthly) | Documented regression with withdrawal justifies continuing; otherwise discharge |
| Wellness or maintenance | Health promotion with no current clinical problem | Elective periodic care | Patient choice | Not medically necessary care; not billable to most payers as treatment |
Frequency and duration
There is no single correct schedule, but the commonly taught evidence informed pattern for an uncomplicated acute spinal episode is a trial of care of about two to four weeks (often 6 to 12 visits) followed by a formal re-examination. Consensus guidelines for chiropractic practice describe a reasonable trial as up to two weeks of care at the intensity you choose; if there is no meaningful response after two trials (roughly four weeks), the plan must change: different technique, added active care, further testing or referral. Most uncomplicated acute low back pain episodes resolve or largely resolve within 6 to 8 weeks; continuing passive care beyond about 12 weeks without documented functional gains is hard to justify. Frequency should be decided by the clinical picture, not by a fixed package sold in advance; prepaid long term plans for acute conditions are viewed critically by boards and payers.
Prognosis and the factors that change it
Prognosis is a prediction of how much recovery to expect and how fast. Start from natural history: about 60 to 70% of people with acute low back pain improve substantially within six weeks and most within 12 weeks, but recurrence within a year is common (often quoted at about half). Acute neck pain behaves similarly, though about half of whiplash patients still report some symptoms a year later. Then adjust for the factors below.
| Factor type | Examples that worsen prognosis | Management response |
|---|---|---|
| Clinical severity | High baseline pain and disability, radiating pain below the knee or elbow, neurological deficit, widespread pain | Longer trial, closer neurological monitoring, earlier imaging if deficits progress |
| History | Multiple prior episodes, symptom duration over 3 months, delay of more than about a week before care, prior spinal surgery | Emphasize active care and self-management; set realistic timeline |
| Structural and medical | Spondylolisthesis, stenosis, scoliosis, osteoporosis, inflammatory arthritis, diabetes, obesity, smoking, deconditioning | Modify technique and force; co-manage the medical condition |
| Psychosocial (yellow flags) | Fear avoidance, catastrophizing, depression or anxiety, belief that pain means harm, passive coping, poor job satisfaction | Education, graded activity, cognitive approaches, referral for psychological care when high risk |
| Work and legal (blue and black flags) | Heavy physical work without modified duty, conflict with employer, pending litigation or compensation disputes | Early communication with employer about modified duty, careful objective documentation |
Two tools help put numbers on this. The STarT Back Screening Tool (nine items) stratifies low back pain patients into low, medium and high risk of persistent disability. Low risk patients need advice, reassurance and minimal treatment; medium risk patients benefit from physical treatment such as manipulation and exercise; high risk patients need physical treatment combined with psychologically informed care. The Örebro Musculoskeletal Pain Questionnaire does a similar job and predicts work absence. A third tool predicts who responds to a specific treatment: the lumbar manipulation clinical prediction rule identifies patients likely to improve rapidly with lumbopelvic manipulation when at least four of five criteria are present (symptoms under 16 days, no symptoms distal to the knee, Fear Avoidance Beliefs Questionnaire work subscale under 19, at least one hypomobile lumbar segment, and at least one hip with more than 35 degrees of internal rotation). The original study reported a positive likelihood ratio of about 24 when four or more were present, although later validation has been less striking.
Outcome measures and meaningful change
An outcome measure is useful only if you know how much change matters. The minimal clinically important difference (MCID) is the smallest change the patient would notice as a real improvement; a change smaller than the instrument's measurement error is noise. Commonly taught values are below.
| Measure | What it captures | Scoring | Commonly taught MCID |
|---|---|---|---|
| Numeric Pain Rating Scale (NPRS) | Pain intensity | 0 to 10 | About 2 points or 30% |
| Visual Analog Scale (VAS) | Pain intensity on a 100 mm line | 0 to 100 mm | About 15 to 20 mm |
| Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) | Low back related disability, 10 sections | 0 to 100% | About 10 percentage points or 30% |
| Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire | Low back related disability, 24 yes or no items | 0 to 24 | About 3 to 5 points |
| Neck Disability Index (NDI) | Neck related disability, 10 sections | 0 to 50 (or 0 to 100%) | About 5 to 7 points (10 to 14%) |
| Patient Specific Functional Scale (PSFS) | Patient chosen activities | 0 to 10 average | About 2 points average |
| Fear Avoidance Beliefs Questionnaire (FABQ) | Fear of activity and work | Work subscale 0 to 42 | Work score over 34 predicts poor return to work |
| Headache Disability Index | Headache related disability | 0 to 100 | About 16 points |
Use at least one pain measure and one region specific functional measure at baseline and at every re-examination. Objective findings such as range of motion, straight leg raise angle, grip strength or a timed functional task supplement but do not replace the questionnaires, because reviewers and the board expect validated patient reported outcomes.
Setting expectations
Patients who understand the expected course do better and are less likely to see normal fluctuation as failure. At the report of findings explain the diagnosis in plain words, the expected time to meaningful improvement, the possibility of brief post treatment soreness, the patient's own role (exercises, activity, sleep, ergonomics), what would trigger a change of plan, and the warning signs that require immediate contact. Hurt does not equal harm is a useful message for most mechanical pain. Avoid language that creates fragility ("your spine is out", "your disc is degenerated") and avoid promising cures or fixed outcomes.
Reasoning: She meets all five criteria of the lumbar manipulation prediction rule and is low risk on STarT Back, so prognosis is favorable. A reasonable plan is lumbopelvic manipulation with a short course of care (for example two visits per week for two weeks), advice to stay active, and simple home exercises, with re-examination at two to four weeks using NPRS and ODI. Goals: NPRS 2/10 or less and ODI under 15% within four weeks. Do not sell a 36 visit package, order imaging, or advise bed rest; none is supported for an uncomplicated case with an excellent prognosis.
A treatment plan converts the diagnosis into measurable goals, a defined frequency and duration, a re-examination date and discharge criteria. Prognosis begins with natural history and is adjusted for severity, prior episodes, structural or medical complications and yellow flags; validated outcome measures interpreted against their MCID tell you whether the plan is working.
Section 2Case follow up and review
Daily reassessment versus formal re-examination
Every visit includes a brief reassessment: how the patient responded to the last treatment, any new symptoms, and a few targeted findings (pain rating, key range of motion, the tests that were positive at baseline, palpation of the treated segments). This visit to visit check guides the day's treatment and is the first place a deterioration or a new red flag is detected. A formal re-examination is more complete. It repeats the outcome questionnaires, the relevant orthopedic and neurological tests and the objective measures from the initial examination, compares them to baseline and to the written goals, and ends with a documented decision about the plan.
When to re-examine
- At the end of each trial of care, commonly every 2 to 4 weeks, or about every 12 visits or 30 days, whichever comes first.
- When the patient reports a new complaint or a new injury (a new region must have its own history, examination and diagnosis before it is treated).
- When symptoms worsen or change character, or when any new neurological symptom appears.
- Before discharge, before a change to supportive care, and before releasing a patient back to full work duty.
- When a third party requests it (insurer, attorney, employer), or after a long gap in care.
Interpreting change
Compare each repeated measure to its MCID. A patient whose ODI falls from 44% to 30% and whose NPRS falls from 7 to 4 has improved meaningfully on both; one whose ODI falls from 44% to 40% has not, even if she feels "a bit better". Look at function as well as pain: a patient whose pain is unchanged but who has returned to work and doubled her walking tolerance is improving. Patterns of change also matter. Rapid early improvement predicts a good final outcome. Improvement that lasts only a few hours after each visit and then returns to baseline suggests the passive treatment is providing temporary relief without addressing the drivers, so active care or another approach is needed.
| Finding at re-examination | What it suggests | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Pain and function both improved past MCID, goals partly met | Correct diagnosis, effective plan | Continue, reduce frequency, progress exercise, set a discharge date |
| All goals met, patient independent with home program | Episode resolved | Discharge with written home program and instructions for recurrence |
| Temporary relief after each visit, no sustained change | Passive care not addressing the driver; possible wrong diagnosis | Change approach, add active care, reassess diagnosis |
| No meaningful change after two trials of 2 weeks each | Wrong diagnosis, wrong treatment, poor adherence, psychosocial barriers or a condition outside chiropractic scope | Reassess, consider imaging or labs, co-manage or refer; do not simply continue |
| Improvement stopped at a stable level below goals despite changes | Maximum medical improvement | Rate permanent impairment if required, discharge or move to supportive care with justification |
| Brief flare after a known strain, then return toward prior level | Exacerbation of a known condition | Short increase in care, review activity and home program |
| New or progressive weakness, reflex loss or sensory loss | Progressive radiculopathy or other neurological disease | Advanced imaging and urgent specialist referral; emergency if cauda equina or myelopathy signs |
| New nonmechanical pain, fever, weight loss, night pain | Possible infection, neoplasm or visceral disease | Stop manipulation of the region, labs and imaging, refer promptly |
The plateau
A plateau is the most common management problem on the exam. The patient is not worse, but has stopped improving or never improved enough. Work through the causes before changing anything:
- Is the diagnosis right? Re-take the history and repeat the examination. Hip osteoarthritis, sacroiliac joint pain, a visceral source, early inflammatory spondyloarthritis, peripheral entrapment neuropathy or a missed red flag may be masquerading as mechanical spinal pain.
- Is the treatment right? Consider a different technique (for example, flexion distraction for a disc patient who did not tolerate side posture), adding mobilization, soft tissue work or a directional preference exercise program, and moving from passive to active care.
- Is the patient doing the plan? Check attendance, home exercise adherence, workstation, sleep, lifting habits and activity level.
- Are yellow flags blocking recovery? Repeat the STarT Back or FABQ; high scores call for psychologically informed care and, often, referral.
- Does the patient need something else? Imaging, labs, a medical evaluation, physical therapy, pain management, or a surgical opinion.
If none of these produces progress, the patient has either reached maximum medical improvement or needs care outside your office. Continuing the same treatment indefinitely without measurable benefit is the classic wrong answer.
Maximum medical improvement and supportive care
Maximum medical improvement (MMI) is the point at which further significant recovery is not expected with continued treatment, although symptoms may persist. It is the trigger for impairment rating in personal injury and workers' compensation cases, commonly using the AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment. MMI does not mean the patient is pain free. Some patients at MMI repeatedly lose ground when care is withdrawn; for them, supportive care at the lowest effective frequency may be justified, provided you document the regression after withdrawal and the response to resumed care. Purely elective maintenance care aimed at prevention or wellness is legitimate but is not medically necessary treatment, and most payers, Medicare among them, do not cover it; when a Medicare patient chooses it, an Advance Beneficiary Notice is signed beforehand.
Missed visits, noncompliance and discharge
Document missed appointments and the reason, and document when you contacted the patient. If a patient stops attending without explanation, a short letter or call noting that care was discontinued, summarizing the status and advising follow up protects both parties. A provider may discharge a noncompliant or abusive patient, but must give reasonable notice, offer help finding another provider and remain available for emergencies during the transition; ending care without notice when the patient still needs treatment can constitute abandonment. Every discharge note records the final outcome measures, the goals met and not met, the home program, and the conditions under which the patient should return.
Reasoning: Neither measure reached its MCID after two trials, so this is a plateau. The new history (inflammatory pattern back pain in a man under 45) changes the working diagnosis; axial spondyloarthritis must be excluded. The next step is to order pelvic radiographs with a sacroiliac view and labs (HLA-B27, ESR, CRP) and refer to a rheumatologist, while continuing gentle mobilization and exercise. Do not simply increase visit frequency or add another passive modality.
Reasoning: A new, significant motor deficit (foot drop) during care is progressive radiculopathy. Stop lumbar manipulation, order MRI, and refer to a spine surgeon urgently (same day contact, seen within days). If saddle anesthesia, urinary retention or bilateral symptoms were present, this would be suspected cauda equina syndrome and an emergency department referral now. Document the deficit, the time and the referral.
Reassess briefly every visit and formally every 2 to 4 weeks or about 12 visits, and whenever something new happens. Improvement past the MCID earns tapering and discharge; a plateau forces you to recheck the diagnosis, the treatment, adherence and yellow flags before changing course or referring; worsening or a new deficit triggers a red flag screen and referral at the right speed.
Section 3Referral and co-management
Why and when to refer
Referral is part of chiropractic care, not a failure of it. A chiropractor refers when the patient has, or may have, a condition outside the scope of chiropractic management; when a condition inside the scope is not responding; when the patient needs a service you do not provide (medication, injection, surgery, psychotherapy, supervised rehabilitation); when a second opinion would help the patient or protect the plan; and when the patient asks. The board tests two separate judgments in every referral item: to whom and how fast. Getting the speciality right but the urgency wrong (sending suspected cauda equina syndrome to a routine neurosurgery appointment) is still the wrong answer.
Matching the problem to the receiving clinician
| Presentation | Key clue | Refer to | Urgency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saddle anesthesia, urinary retention or incontinence, bilateral leg symptoms | Cauda equina syndrome | Emergency department (MRI, spine surgery) | Emergency |
| Sudden severe neck pain or headache with dizziness, diplopia, dysarthria, dysphagia, drop attacks, ataxia, nystagmus | Cervical artery dissection or posterior circulation stroke | Emergency services | Emergency |
| Back pain with a pulsatile abdominal mass, hypotension, age over 60, smoker | Abdominal aortic aneurysm | Emergency services if painful; vascular surgery if an incidental finding | Emergency or prompt |
| Progressive foot drop or quadriceps weakness | Progressive radiculopathy | Spine surgeon (with MRI) | Urgent |
| Hand clumsiness, gait change, Hoffmann sign, hyperreflexia | Cervical myelopathy | Spine surgeon or neurologist, MRI | Urgent; emergency if rapid |
| Back pain with fever, IV drug use, recent infection, immunosuppression | Vertebral osteomyelitis or epidural abscess | Emergency department or physician same day | Urgent to emergency |
| New temporal headache over age 50, jaw claudication, scalp tenderness, visual change | Giant cell arteritis | Physician same day (ESR, CRP, steroids) | Urgent |
| Calf pain, swelling, warmth after surgery or immobilization | Deep venous thrombosis | Physician or emergency department for duplex ultrasound | Urgent, same day |
| History of cancer, weight loss, night pain | Metastatic disease | Primary physician or oncologist with imaging | Urgent if deficit, otherwise prompt |
| Young adult, inflammatory back pain, uveitis | Axial spondyloarthritis | Rheumatologist | Prompt |
| Symmetric small joint swelling of hands, morning stiffness over an hour | Rheumatoid arthritis | Rheumatologist | Prompt |
| Chronic pain with high fear avoidance, depression | Psychosocial barriers to recovery | Psychologist (cognitive behavioral therapy), with ongoing chiropractic care | Routine |
| Failed conservative care for radicular pain, no progressive deficit | Candidate for injection or surgical opinion | Physiatrist, pain management or spine surgeon | Routine |
Handling an emergency in the office
For a true emergency, call emergency medical services, stay with the patient, monitor vital signs and airway, and do not let the patient drive. Do not manipulate. Send a brief written summary with the patient or call it to the receiving department, then document the findings, the time, who was contacted and what was said. For an urgent referral, telephone the receiving clinician or department rather than relying on a letter, confirm that an appointment has been made, and follow up the same day or next morning to confirm the patient was seen.
The referral letter
A useful referral letter is short, specific and asks a question. Busy specialists read the first lines and the question; put the important things there.
- Patient identifiers: name, date of birth, contact details, and the patient's consent to share records.
- Reason for referral and urgency: the specific question ("Please evaluate for inflammatory sacroiliitis" or "Please assess for surgical decompression; progressive L5 weakness over 48 hours").
- Relevant history: onset, course, red flags present or absent, past history, medications.
- Key examination findings, positive and pertinent negative, with numbers (reflex grades, motor grades, straight leg raise angle).
- Investigations: imaging and laboratory results with copies attached.
- Treatment rendered and response, including outcome scores.
- Your plan: whether you will continue to treat (co-management), modify care, or suspend care pending their opinion.
- Your contact information and a request for a report back.
Under the federal privacy rule, health information may be shared with another provider for treatment purposes without a separate written authorization, but many offices obtain a signed release as good practice, and state law or the type of information (substance use treatment records, some mental health records) can require more. Share only what the receiving clinician needs.
Co-management
Co-management means two or more clinicians treat the same patient for the same episode with defined roles. Common arrangements: the chiropractor provides manipulation and exercise while the primary physician manages medication and comorbidities; physical therapy provides supervised strengthening while the chiropractor treats joint dysfunction; a pain specialist provides an epidural steroid injection for radicular pain and the chiropractor continues with mechanical and functional care; a psychologist addresses fear avoidance and depression while chiropractic care continues. Good co-management requires a shared diagnosis, clear roles, exchange of progress notes and an agreed point for reassessment. Questions about prescription drugs go to the prescriber: a chiropractor may discuss potential effects and interactions but should not tell a patient to stop or change a prescribed medication.
Reasoning: Nonmechanical back pain, a pulsatile abdominal mass, hypotension and tachycardia in an older male smoker means a symptomatic or leaking abdominal aortic aneurysm until proven otherwise. Call emergency medical services now, keep the patient lying still, do not let him drive, and do not manipulate or apply deep abdominal pressure. A routine vascular surgery referral or an outpatient ultrasound order is the wrong level of urgency; that would be appropriate only for a painless incidental aneurysm found on a lumbar film.
Every referral decision has two parts: the right destination and the right speed. Emergencies go to emergency services now, urgent problems are telephoned and seen within a day or two, and prompt and routine referrals follow with a focused letter that asks a specific question. Co-management keeps the chiropractor involved with defined roles, and a declined referral is documented as informed refusal.
Section 4Clinical documentation and informed consent
The purpose of the record
The record serves the patient first: it lets you, a covering colleague or a later clinician see what was found, what was done and how the patient responded. It is also the evidence of medical necessity for payers, the basis for any legal defense, and the source for impairment and disability reports. The principle that governs reviewers and courts is simple: if it was not documented, it was not done. The record must also be consistent with the bill; a charge for a five region manipulation needs documented findings in five regions.
The initial examination record
The first visit record holds the full history (chief complaint, present illness, past, family and social history, review of systems), the examination (vital signs, observation, palpation, range of motion, orthopedic and neurological tests, and any other systems examined), the results of any imaging or labs, the working diagnosis and differential, the treatment plan with goals, the informed consent, and baseline outcome measures. For Medicare patients, a subluxation must be shown either by an x-ray or by the physical examination findings summarized as PART: Pain or tenderness, Asymmetry or misalignment, Range of motion abnormality, and Tissue or tone changes. Two of the four are required, and one of them must be asymmetry or range of motion abnormality. The level of subluxation must be named specifically, and Medicare covers only manual manipulation of the spine to correct it, not the examination by the chiropractor, x-rays taken in the office, or therapies.
The SOAP daily note
- Subjective: the patient's report since the last visit: pain intensity and location, functional changes, response to the last treatment, home program adherence, new symptoms. Use the patient's words for key complaints.
- Objective: what you measured today: findings at the treated segments, range of motion, repeated positive tests, neurological status when relevant, and the outcome scores at re-examinations.
- Assessment: your interpretation: diagnosis, whether the patient is improving, unchanged or worse, progress toward each goal, and any new concern.
- Plan: what you did and what comes next: technique and segments or regions treated, supportive procedures with time for timed codes, home instructions, changes to frequency, next re-examination and any referral.
Records that withstand review
| Practice | Do | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | Complete the note on the day of service; label any late entry as a late entry with the date written | Writing notes days later without labeling them |
| Corrections | Single line through the error so it stays legible, with date, initials and reason; electronic systems keep an audit trail | Erasing, correction fluid, overwriting, deleting, backdating |
| Individualization | Visit specific findings that change as the patient changes | Cloned notes identical from visit to visit |
| Measurability | Numbers: pain scores, degrees, grades, questionnaire scores | "Patient doing better", "tolerated well" as the only entry |
| Consistency | Regions treated match the diagnosis and the bill | Billing more regions or more time than documented |
| Identification | Patient name and date on every page, legible signature and credentials | Unsigned or undated entries, private abbreviations |
| Legal holds | Preserve the record unchanged once a complaint, claim or subpoena is known | Any alteration after notice of a claim (spoliation destroys credibility) |
| Retention | Keep records for the period set by state law (commonly at least 7 years for adults, longer for minors) | Destroying records early or without secure disposal |
Informed consent
Informed consent is a process of communication that ends with a voluntary decision by a competent patient; the signed form is evidence that the process happened, not a substitute for it. A useful memory aid is PARQ: explain the Procedure (and the diagnosis it treats), the Alternatives (including other conservative care, medical care and no treatment, with their risks), the material Risks and expected benefits, and invite Questions. Jurisdictions differ on the standard used to judge disclosure: the reasonable patient (material risk) standard asks what a reasonable patient would want to know to decide, while the professional standard asks what a reasonable practitioner would disclose. Prepare for the patient standard, which is stricter.
- Risks of manipulation to disclose: common, benign and short lived reactions such as local soreness, stiffness, fatigue or headache, occurring in roughly a third to a half of patients and usually settling within 24 to 48 hours; rare serious events such as rib or other fracture in osteoporotic bone, aggravation of a disc herniation, and very rarely cauda equina syndrome after lumbar manipulation; and cervical artery dissection with stroke, which is very rare and whose causal relationship to manipulation has not been established, but which is material because of its severity.
- Who consents: a competent adult for themselves; a parent or legal guardian for a minor (with the child's assent where possible), unless the minor is emancipated or state law allows; a legal guardian or health care agent for an adult lacking capacity.
- When to renew: when the diagnosis changes, when you add a new technique or region, when a significant new risk factor appears (anticoagulation, osteoporosis), and at the start of any new episode.
- Withdrawal: the patient may withdraw consent at any time, including during a procedure.
- Emergencies: consent is implied when a patient cannot consent and delay would cause harm.
Coding basics
Two code sets travel together on every claim. ICD-10-CM codes describe why the patient was treated (the diagnosis). CPT codes describe what was done (the procedures and evaluations). Codes must be supported by the documentation of that visit.
| Code or modifier | Meaning | Documentation point |
|---|---|---|
| 98940, 98941, 98942 | Chiropractic manipulative treatment of 1 to 2, 3 to 4, and 5 spinal regions | Spinal regions: cervical, thoracic, lumbar, sacral, pelvic; findings and treatment documented for each region billed |
| 98943 | Extraspinal manipulation, one or more regions | Extremities, rib cage, head (including TMJ), abdomen |
| 99202 to 99205, 99212 to 99215 | Evaluation and management, new and established patients | Level by medical decision making or total time |
| Modifier 25 | Significant, separately identifiable E/M on the same day as a procedure | Used for the initial exam, formal re-exam or new complaint, not for the routine pre-manipulation check |
| Modifier 59 (or XS) | Distinct procedure, for example 97140 manual therapy to a separate region from the manipulated one | Document the separate region |
| 97110, 97112, 97140, 97530, 97035 | Therapeutic exercise, neuromuscular reeducation, manual therapy, therapeutic activities, ultrasound | Timed in 15 minute units; record minutes |
| AT and GA modifiers (Medicare) | AT: active or corrective treatment; GA: an Advance Beneficiary Notice is on file | Maintenance care is billed without AT and with an ABN |
| M99.01 to M99.05 | Segmental and somatic dysfunction: cervical, thoracic, lumbar, sacral, pelvic | Medicare lists the subluxation code first |
| S13.4XXA, S33.5XXA | Sprain of cervical and of lumbar spine ligaments, initial encounter | Seventh character: A active treatment, D subsequent (healing phase), S sequela |
| M54.16, M54.2, M54.50 | Lumbar radiculopathy, cervicalgia, low back pain unspecified | Prefer the most specific supported code |
Reasoning: A new risk factor that changes the material risk of the procedure (fracture in low density bone) means consent must be revisited. Explain the increased fracture risk, offer alternatives (low force instrument adjusting, mobilization, drop table, exercise), document the discussion and her decision, and modify technique accordingly. Relying on the original signed form, or continuing high force prone thoracic thrusts unchanged, is the wrong answer.
Document every visit in SOAP form with numbers that can be compared over time, an assessment of progress toward goals and a plan that names what was done; correct records only with a visible, dated correction and never alter them after a claim. Consent is a conversation covering procedure, alternatives, material risks and questions, renewed when the plan or the risk changes, and the codes billed must match what the note shows.
Section 5Worked case management scenarios
How Part III asks management questions
Management items usually describe a patient over several visits and stop at a decision point: a re-examination result, a new symptom, a test report, a patient request. The question asks for the next best step. The method is the same each time: (1) decide whether anything in the stem is a red flag that changes the urgency; (2) decide whether the patient is improving, plateaued or worse, using the numbers given; (3) ask whether the working diagnosis still fits; (4) choose the single action that addresses the most important problem first. Distractors are usually steps that are reasonable but premature (advanced imaging before a trial of care), inadequate (continuing unchanged care after a plateau), excessive (surgery referral for uncomplicated pain) or too slow (routine referral of an emergency).
| Decision point in the stem | Most likely correct step | Typical wrong answer |
|---|---|---|
| Acute low back pain, no red flags, first visit | Trial of conservative care, advice to stay active, no imaging | Lumbar radiographs or MRI "to be safe" |
| Improving past MCID at 4 weeks | Reduce frequency, progress active care, plan discharge | Keep the same frequency for the rest of a prepaid plan |
| No meaningful change after two trials | Reassess diagnosis, change approach or refer | Increase frequency or add another passive modality |
| New progressive motor deficit | Stop manipulation of the region, MRI, urgent surgical referral | Continue care and recheck next week |
| Saddle anesthesia or urinary retention | Emergency department now | Order an outpatient MRI |
| Post treatment soreness for a day after the first visit | Reassure, ice, lighter force next visit | Stop care or order imaging |
| Neurological signs suggesting brainstem ischemia during or after a neck visit | Stop, keep patient still, emergency services | Rest in the office and reassess in 30 minutes |
| Imaging reveals an incidental finding needing follow up | Inform the patient, document, refer to the appropriate physician | Ignore because it is unrelated to the complaint |
| Patient at MMI who regresses whenever care stops | Supportive care at the lowest effective frequency with documentation | Indefinite care at the original frequency |
Scenario 1: the disc patient who stalls, then responds
A 42 year old delivery driver has right sided low back and buttock pain for 10 days after lifting. The straight leg raise is positive at 60 degrees for back and buttock pain only, reflexes and strength are normal, and there are no red flags. Baseline ODI is 48% and NPRS 7/10. You begin side posture manipulation three times a week with advice to keep moving.
At the two week re-examination ODI is 44%; at four weeks it is 42%, still short of the 10 point MCID. Repeated movement testing now shows that sustained extension in prone centralizes his buttock pain. Two trials of care have failed, but the examination has produced new information: a directional preference. The next step is to change the plan (flexion distraction and a repeated extension home program), not to refer for surgery and not to continue unchanged side posture care. By week 8 his ODI is 18%.
Reasoning: Bilateral hand symptoms, clumsiness, gait change and new upper motor neuron signs mean myelopathy, not a radiculopathy, and the differential in a young woman includes a large central disc herniation and multiple sclerosis. Stop cervical manipulation, order cervical (and if indicated brain) MRI, and refer urgently to a neurologist or spine surgeon; if deficits are progressing over hours, send her to the emergency department. Document the new findings and the change in plan.
Reasoning: He reached a plateau long ago, and the passive relief pattern plus high fear avoidance shows that psychosocial factors are driving his disability. Continuing weekly manipulation indefinitely is the wrong answer. The next step is a formal re-examination, a frank discussion, a shift to an active, graded exposure program with pain neuroscience education, referral to a psychologist for cognitive behavioral therapy, and coordination with his employer on modified duty. Reduce passive care, and discharge or move to supportive care only if documented regression justifies it.
Scenario 4: the imaging surprise
A 66 year old man with a five year history of mechanical low back pain has lumbar radiographs because of a recent fall. There is no fracture, but there is curvilinear calcification of the abdominal aortic wall with a diameter you estimate at 4.5 cm. He has no abdominal pain and his vital signs are normal. The aneurysm is incidental and asymptomatic, so this is a prompt, not emergency, referral: inform the patient in plain terms, send a letter and the films to his primary physician with a request for abdominal ultrasound and vascular evaluation, document the conversation, and avoid deep abdominal pressure and forceful lumbar rotation while it is evaluated. If he had back or abdominal pain, hypotension or a tender pulsatile mass, it would be an emergency.
Solve management questions in a fixed order: red flags and urgency first, then the direction of change against the MCID, then whether the diagnosis still fits, and finally the single most important action. The right answer tapers care when patients improve, changes the plan or refers when they plateau, and refers at the correct speed when they worsen or show new neurological signs.
The chapter in one breath
- A treatment plan states the diagnosis, baseline measures, SMART goals, interventions, frequency, duration, re-examination date and discharge criteria.
- Care moves from relief to corrective and active care to self-management, with frequency tapering as function improves; a trial of care is about 2 to 4 weeks.
- Prognosis starts with favorable natural history and worsens with severity, prior episodes, delayed care, structural disease and yellow flags; STarT Back stratifies risk.
- Use validated outcome measures (NPRS, ODI, NDI, PSFS) and judge change against the MCID: about 2 points for NPRS and about 10 points for ODI.
- Re-examine every 2 to 4 weeks or about 12 visits, and whenever there is a new complaint, worsening or a new deficit.
- A plateau after two trials demands reassessment of diagnosis, treatment, adherence and psychosocial barriers, then a new plan, referral or discharge at MMI.
- Supportive care requires documented regression on withdrawal; elective maintenance is not medically necessary care and needs an ABN for Medicare patients.
- Every referral has a destination and an urgency: emergency (cauda equina, stroke, symptomatic AAA), urgent (progressive deficit, infection, giant cell arteritis, DVT), prompt and routine.
- A good referral letter asks a specific question and gives findings with numbers; co-management needs shared diagnosis, defined roles and exchange of notes.
- SOAP notes must be timely, individualized, measurable and consistent with the bill; corrections are visible, dated and initialed, and records are never altered after a claim.
- Informed consent covers procedure, alternatives, material risks and questions (PARQ), and is renewed when the plan or risk changes; a refusal is documented as informed refusal.
- ICD-10-CM codes give the reason for care, CPT codes the service (98940 to 98942 spinal CMT, 98943 extraspinal), with modifiers 25, 59, AT and GA used correctly.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Abandonment | Ending the clinician patient relationship without reasonable notice while the patient still needs care; avoided by giving notice, offering referral and covering emergencies. |
| Advance Beneficiary Notice (ABN) | A form a Medicare patient signs before receiving a service likely to be denied, such as maintenance care, accepting financial responsibility. |
| AT modifier | Medicare modifier showing that manipulation was active or corrective treatment rather than maintenance. |
| Blue and black flags | Workplace perceptions (blue) and system or legal factors such as compensation disputes (black) that can delay recovery. |
| Clinical prediction rule | A set of findings that, when present together, predicts a diagnosis or response to a specific treatment. |
| Cloned notes | Daily notes copied unchanged from visit to visit; they fail to show individualized care or medical necessity. |
| Co-management | Shared care of one patient by two or more clinicians with defined roles and exchange of information. |
| CPT code | A procedure code describing the service performed, such as 98941 for manipulation of 3 to 4 spinal regions. |
| Directional preference | A direction of repeated movement or sustained position that reduces or centralizes symptoms, used to guide exercise. |
| Fear Avoidance Beliefs Questionnaire | A questionnaire measuring fear that activity or work will cause harm; high work scores predict delayed return to work. |
| ICD-10-CM code | A diagnosis code giving the reason for the encounter, such as M99.03 for lumbar segmental dysfunction. |
| Informed consent | A competent patient's voluntary agreement to care after disclosure of the procedure, alternatives, material risks and benefits, with a chance to ask questions. |
| Informed refusal | A documented decision by an informed patient to decline a recommended test, treatment or referral. |
| Late entry | A note added after the day of service, clearly labeled with the date it was written. |
| Maintenance care | Elective care for health promotion or prevention without a current clinical problem; not medically necessary treatment. |
| Maximum medical improvement (MMI) | The point at which further significant recovery is not expected with continued treatment, although symptoms may remain. |
| Minimal clinically important difference (MCID) | The smallest change in an outcome score that patients perceive as meaningful. |
| Modifier 25 | CPT modifier for a significant, separately identifiable evaluation and management service on the same day as a procedure. |
| Modifier 59 | CPT modifier identifying a distinct procedure, such as manual therapy to a region not manipulated that day. |
| Neck Disability Index | A 10 section questionnaire scoring neck related disability from 0 to 50. |
| Oswestry Disability Index | A 10 section questionnaire scoring low back related disability from 0 to 100%. |
| PARQ | Memory aid for consent: Procedure, Alternatives, Risks, Questions. |
| PART | Medicare examination criteria for subluxation: Pain, Asymmetry, Range of motion abnormality, Tissue tone change; two required, one being A or R. |
| Patient Specific Functional Scale | An outcome measure in which the patient rates three to five self chosen difficult activities from 0 to 10. |
| Plateau | Failure to improve by a meaningful amount over a defined period of appropriate care. |
| SOAP note | A note format of Subjective, Objective, Assessment and Plan. |
| Spoliation | Destruction or alteration of records relevant to a claim, which damages credibility and can carry legal penalties. |
| STarT Back Screening Tool | A nine item tool that sorts low back pain patients into low, medium or high risk of persistent disability to match treatment. |
| Supportive care | Ongoing care for a patient at MMI who has documented regression when care is withdrawn. |
| Trial of care | A defined period, typically about 2 weeks per trial and up to two trials, after which response is formally judged. |
| Yellow flags | Psychosocial factors such as fear avoidance, catastrophizing and depression that predict chronic pain and disability. |
Check yourself
Image Interpretation I: Arthritic Disorders
Arthritis is the most common thing you will see on a musculoskeletal film, and the interpretation section of Part III expects you to name it from its pattern rather than from a single sign. Each arthritis leaves a signature made of distribution, symmetry, bone density, joint space, erosions and new bone, and reading those features in order separates degenerative from inflammatory and crystal disease. The stakes are practical: the same film that shows a harmless osteophyte may show an unstable atlantoaxial joint in rheumatoid arthritis or a fused, fracture prone spine in ankylosing spondylitis, and those findings change whether and how you treat.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Describe osteoarthritis by site, including nonuniform joint space loss, subchondral sclerosis, osteophytes and subchondral cysts, and grade it with Kellgren and Lawrence.
- Distinguish intervertebral osteochondrosis, spondylosis deformans, facet arthrosis and uncovertebral arthrosis, and recognize DISH and its complications.
- Recognize the hallmarks of rheumatoid arthritis (symmetric proximal distribution, periarticular osteopenia, uniform narrowing, marginal erosions) and measure the atlantodental interval.
- Identify the growth related findings of juvenile idiopathic arthritis, including cervical apophyseal ankylosis.
- Grade sacroiliitis, and tell marginal syndesmophytes from nonmarginal syndesmophytes, osteophytes and flowing DISH ossification.
- Describe the imaging of ankylosing spondylitis, psoriatic, reactive and enteropathic arthritis.
- Recognize gout, CPPD with chondrocalcinosis, hydroxyapatite deposition, hemochromatosis and neuropathic joints.
- Apply a systematic ABCDS approach to any arthritic film and write a report with a sound recommendation.
Section 1Degenerative joint and disc disease
The radiographic language of osteoarthritis
Osteoarthritis (degenerative joint disease) is a failure of articular cartilage followed by a reparative response of the underlying bone. Every radiographic sign follows from that sequence. Cartilage loss is greatest where load is greatest, so the joint space narrows nonuniformly (one compartment more than another). The bone beneath the thinned cartilage takes more stress and becomes dense: subchondral sclerosis, or eburnation when bone rubs on bone. Synovial fluid forced through cracks in the subchondral plate produces subchondral cysts (geodes) with sclerotic margins. At the joint margins, where cartilage meets periosteum, the bone grows outward as osteophytes. Bone density stays normal, erosions are absent, and soft tissue swelling is slight. These features (nonuniform narrowing, sclerosis, osteophytes, cysts, normal density) are the "productive" signature that separates degenerative disease from the "destructive" erosive signature of inflammatory arthritis.
Osteoarthritis by site
| Site | Characteristic pattern | Best view or note |
|---|---|---|
| Knee | Medial femorotibial compartment narrows first, producing varus; osteophytes on femoral and tibial margins and tibial spines; patellofemoral narrowing with patellar osteophytes | Standing (weight bearing) AP or flexed PA (Rosenberg) views show true narrowing; tangential (skyline) view for the patellofemoral joint. Isolated lateral or patellofemoral disease suggests CPPD |
| Hip | Superolateral migration of the femoral head is most common; femoral head and acetabular osteophytes, buttressing (thickening) of the medial femoral neck cortex, acetabular and femoral head cysts | Axial (concentric) migration suggests inflammatory arthritis; medial migration with protrusio suggests RA, Paget disease or osteomalacia |
| Hand | DIP joints (Heberden nodes), PIP joints (Bouchard nodes) and the first carpometacarpal joint; MCP joints usually spared | Erosive OA (middle aged women): central erosions giving a gull wing appearance at PIP and DIP joints, may ankylose |
| Foot | First MTP joint narrowing with dorsal osteophytes (hallux rigidus); hallux valgus with medial bunion | Lateral foot view shows the dorsal spur |
| Shoulder | Acromioclavicular OA common; primary glenohumeral OA uncommon (inferior humeral head osteophyte "goat's beard") | Glenohumeral OA without trauma suggests CPPD, rotator cuff arthropathy or neuropathic joint |
| Sacroiliac | Narrowing, sclerosis and anterior bridging osteophytes at the inferior (synovial) portion; no erosions | Osteophytes overlapping the joint can mimic ankylosis on AP views |
The Kellgren and Lawrence scale grades OA on radiographs: grade 0 none; grade 1 doubtful narrowing and possible osteophyte; grade 2 definite osteophytes and possible narrowing; grade 3 moderate multiple osteophytes, definite narrowing, some sclerosis and possible bone end deformity; grade 4 large osteophytes, marked narrowing, severe sclerosis and definite deformity. Radiographic severity and pain correlate only loosely, so the film describes structure, not symptoms.
Degenerative disease of the spine
The spine has two kinds of joints: the intervertebral disc (an amphiarthrosis, a symphysis) and the paired zygapophyseal (facet) joints, which are synovial. The cervical spine adds the uncovertebral joints (joints of Luschka) from C3 to C7. Each degenerates in its own way, and the vocabulary matters because the board uses the terms precisely.
- Intervertebral osteochondrosis is degeneration of the nucleus pulposus and endplates: disc space narrowing, the vacuum phenomenon (a dark linear nitrogen collection in a fissured disc, which essentially excludes infection), endplate sclerosis and Schmorl nodes. On MRI it shows as a dark (desiccated) disc and Modic endplate changes (type 1 edema, type 2 fatty, type 3 sclerotic).
- Spondylosis deformans is degeneration of the outer annulus fibers (Sharpey fibers): the annulus bulges, pulls on its attachment, and osteophytes form at the anterior and lateral vertebral body margins. They begin a few millimeters from the endplate, project horizontally, then turn vertically toward the disc (claw osteophytes), and may bridge. Disc height may be relatively preserved early.
- Traction spurs are small horizontal osteophytes arising 2 to 3 mm from the endplate margin; they are traditionally taught as a sign of segmental instability.
- Facet arthrosis shows joint space narrowing, sclerosis, hypertrophic articular processes and periarticular osteophytes, best seen on oblique lumbar views and on the lateral view as overlapping density. Hypertrophied facets and a buckled ligamentum flavum narrow the lateral recess and canal (degenerative stenosis).
- Degenerative spondylolisthesis is forward slippage with an intact pars, almost always at L4 on L5, usually Meyerding grade 1, and most often in women over 50 with sagittally oriented facets. Because the whole vertebra slips, the canal narrows (unlike isthmic spondylolisthesis, which leaves the posterior arch behind and widens the canal).
- Uncovertebral arthrosis produces sharpening and hypertrophy of the uncinate processes on the AP lower cervical view and posterolateral osteophytes that narrow the intervertebral foramina, best seen on oblique cervical views. Combined with facet arthrosis it is the usual cause of cervical foraminal stenosis and radiculopathy at C5 to C6 and C6 to C7.
- Baastrup disease (kissing spinous processes) shows contact, sclerosis and flattening of adjacent lumbar spinous processes, often with interspinous bursitis.
Diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH)
DISH (Forestier disease) is a noninflammatory enthesopathy in which ligaments and tendon insertions ossify. The Resnick criteria are: (1) flowing ossification along the anterolateral aspect of at least four contiguous vertebral bodies; (2) relative preservation of disc height without extensive degenerative disc disease; and (3) absence of facet joint ankylosis and of sacroiliac erosion, sclerosis or intra-articular fusion. It is most common in the thoracic spine, on the right side (the descending aorta on the left seems to inhibit it), in men over 50, and is associated with obesity, type 2 diabetes and hypertension. A thin lucent line often separates the ossified ligament from the anterior vertebral body, and the ossification bulges at the disc levels like candle wax. Extraspinal "whiskering" enthesophytes appear at the iliac crests, ischial tuberosities, trochanters, olecranon, patella and calcaneus.
DISH matters clinically for four reasons: dysphagia from bulky anterior cervical ossification; a strong association with ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament (OPLL), which can cause myelopathy; stiffness that turns minor trauma into unstable fractures through the ossified segment (the long lever arm behaves like a fused spine); and postoperative heterotopic ossification after hip arthroplasty.
Describing degenerative findings
A good degenerative report names the joint or level, the specific findings, their severity (mild, moderate, severe), alignment and its effect on canal or foramina. For example: "Moderate disc space narrowing at L5 to S1 with vacuum phenomenon, endplate sclerosis and anterior osteophytes (intervertebral osteochondrosis and spondylosis). Bilateral L4 to L5 facet arthrosis with grade 1 degenerative anterolisthesis of L4." Avoid alarming labels such as "severe degeneration" without clinical context, and remember that degenerative findings are common in asymptomatic adults.
Reasoning: Four or more contiguous levels, preserved discs and normal SI joints define DISH, not ankylosing spondylitis. Report it as DISH, recommend lateral cervical evaluation (or ENT referral) for the dysphagia, and note in the report that the ossified segments are prone to fracture after even minor trauma, so any new pain after a fall needs CT. Avoid high velocity thrusts through the ossified segment; mobilize the adjacent mobile segments and use low force methods.
Degenerative disease is productive: nonuniform narrowing, subchondral sclerosis, osteophytes and cysts with normal bone density and no erosions. In the spine, disc narrowing with vacuum and sclerosis is osteochondrosis, marginal claw osteophytes are spondylosis deformans, uncovertebral and facet arthrosis narrow the foramina, and thick flowing ossification over four levels with tall discs is DISH, a stiff spine that fractures easily.
Section 2Rheumatoid arthritis and juvenile idiopathic arthritis
The rheumatoid signature
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a synovial inflammation. Hypertrophied synovium (pannus) releases enzymes and cytokines that dissolve cartilage evenly and attack bone where synovium touches it directly without a cartilage cover: the bare areas at the joint margins. Increased blood flow and disuse thin the bone around the joint. The radiographic signature follows:
- Distribution: bilateral and symmetric, polyarticular, favoring the MCP joints (especially the second and third), PIP joints, the wrist (with early erosion of the ulnar styloid) and the MTP joints of the feet (the fifth MTP is often the first to erode). The DIP joints are characteristically spared.
- Soft tissue: fusiform, symmetric periarticular swelling, the earliest finding.
- Bone density: periarticular (juxta-articular) osteopenia early, becoming generalized later and worsened by corticosteroids.
- Joint space: uniform, symmetric narrowing because the whole cartilage surface is attacked.
- Erosions: marginal erosions at the bare areas, seen first as loss of the thin white cortical line (dot dash appearance), then as defined notches. No sclerotic margins and no new bone formation.
- Alignment (late): ulnar deviation and volar subluxation at the MCP joints, swan neck and boutonniere deformities, carpal collapse and, sometimes, carpal ankylosis.
| Region | RA finding | How it differs from OA |
|---|---|---|
| Hand and wrist | MCP, PIP and wrist erosions, ulnar styloid erosion, ulnar deviation | OA favors DIP, PIP and first CMC, with osteophytes and no osteopenia |
| Foot | MTP erosions, fifth MTP early, fibular deviation of the toes | OA favors the first MTP with dorsal osteophytes |
| Hip | Bilateral, axial (concentric) migration, protrusio acetabuli | OA: superolateral migration with osteophytes |
| Knee | Uniform narrowing of all three compartments, popliteal (Baker) cyst, valgus late | OA: medial compartment, varus, osteophytes |
| Shoulder | Erosion of the superolateral humeral head and distal clavicle; high riding humeral head with rotator cuff tear | OA: inferior humeral osteophyte, sclerosis |
| Cervical spine | Atlantoaxial instability, dens erosion, cranial settling, subaxial stepladder subluxations, disc narrowing without osteophytes, spinous process erosion | Degenerative disease narrows discs with osteophytes and sclerosis |
The cervical spine in rheumatoid arthritis
The cervical spine is involved in a large proportion of patients with long standing RA, and it is the finding with the most direct effect on chiropractic care. The synovial joints around the dens, and the transverse ligament that holds the dens against the anterior arch of the atlas, are destroyed by pannus.
- Anterior atlantoaxial subluxation is the most common pattern. The atlantodental interval (ADI), measured on the lateral view from the posterior surface of the anterior arch of C1 to the anterior surface of the dens, should be no more than 3 mm in adults (5 mm in children). Instability may be hidden in neutral and appear only in flexion, so flexion and extension laterals are obtained. An ADI over about 9 to 10 mm, or a posterior atlantodental interval (space available for the cord) of 14 mm or less, indicates high risk of cord compression and surgical consultation.
- Vertical subluxation (cranial settling, basilar invagination) occurs when the lateral masses of C1 and C2 collapse and the dens rises toward the foramen magnum. It is assessed with lines such as McGregor's line (hard palate to the lowest point of the occiput; the dens tip should not project more than about 4.5 mm above it) and Chamberlain's line (hard palate to opisthion).
- Dens erosion may leave a thin, pointed or completely resorbed odontoid.
- Subaxial subluxation at several levels gives a stepladder appearance, with disc narrowing and endplate erosion but little osteophyte formation.
Laboratory correlation and report recommendations
Imaging findings suggest RA; the diagnosis rests on the clinical picture with rheumatoid factor (sensitive but not specific), anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide antibodies (anti-CCP, highly specific, about 95%), and ESR and CRP. Radiographs are often normal in the first months, when ultrasound or MRI show synovitis and bone marrow edema earlier. A typical recommendation reads: "Findings consistent with an inflammatory arthropathy in a rheumatoid distribution. Recommend serologic correlation (RF, anti-CCP, ESR, CRP) and rheumatology referral. Flexion and extension lateral cervical views are recommended before cervical manipulation to assess atlantoaxial stability."
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) is arthritis lasting at least six weeks with onset before age 16. Subtypes include oligoarticular (the most common, four or fewer joints, often the knee, with ANA positivity and a high risk of silent uveitis requiring ophthalmic screening), polyarticular (RF negative or RF positive, the latter resembling adult RA), systemic (Still disease, with quotidian fever, rash and organomegaly), enthesitis related arthritis (HLA-B27, the juvenile spondyloarthritis) and psoriatic. Most children are RF negative.
Because the skeleton is still growing, the hallmarks of JIA are growth disturbances produced by chronic hyperemia:
- Epiphyseal overgrowth (ballooned epiphyses) and accelerated maturation, often with limb length discrepancy (a longer limb early from hyperemia; shortening later from premature physeal closure).
- At the knee, a widened intercondylar notch and squared inferior patella; the same findings occur in hemophilic arthropathy, the main differential.
- Periostitis of the phalanges and metacarpals, and brachydactyly from early physeal fusion.
- Joint space loss and erosions appear late because the cartilage is thick in children; ankylosis is more common than in adult RA, especially in the carpus and tarsus.
- In the cervical spine, ankylosis of the apophyseal joints, classically at C2 to C3, with hypoplastic vertebral bodies and discs at the fused levels (bodies small in both height and AP diameter), plus atlantoaxial subluxation. Mandibular underdevelopment (micrognathia) may accompany temporomandibular involvement.
| Finding | What it suggests | Must not miss alternative | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Child with a swollen knee for 8 weeks, ballooned epiphyses, widened notch | Oligoarticular JIA | Hemophilic arthropathy (boy, bleeding history), tuberculous arthritis | Pediatric rheumatology; ophthalmology screen for uveitis; coagulation history |
| Fused C2 to C3 facets with small vertebral bodies in a young adult | Old JIA | Congenital block vertebra (Klippel Feil: waist at the fused disc, no history of arthritis) | Flexion and extension views; avoid thrust at and adjacent to fused levels |
| Single hot joint with fever in a child | Septic arthritis until proven otherwise | Osteomyelitis, leukemia | Emergency referral for aspiration |
Reasoning: The flexion view unmasks atlantoaxial instability from transverse ligament failure, and bilateral hand paresthesia with a positive Hoffmann sign suggests cord compromise. Cervical manipulation is absolutely contraindicated. Advise her to avoid neck flexion, provide a soft collar for comfort if needed, and refer urgently to a spine surgeon with an MRI request; if neurological signs are progressing rapidly, send her to the emergency department. The report should state the measurements in neutral and flexion and recommend MRI and surgical consultation.
RA is bilateral, symmetric and proximal in the hands and feet, with soft tissue swelling, periarticular osteopenia, uniform narrowing and marginal erosions but no new bone. Its most dangerous spinal finding is atlantoaxial instability, judged by an ADI over 3 mm (often only in flexion), which forbids upper cervical manipulation. JIA adds growth disturbance: ballooned epiphyses, a widened notch, squared patella and C2 to C3 apophyseal ankylosis with small vertebral bodies.
Section 3Seronegative spondyloarthropathies
What the group shares
The seronegative spondyloarthropathies (spondyloarthritides) are ankylosing spondylitis, psoriatic arthritis, reactive arthritis and enteropathic arthritis (with Crohn disease or ulcerative colitis). They are "seronegative" because rheumatoid factor is absent, and they share a strong association with HLA-B27, inflammatory back pain, sacroiliitis, peripheral arthritis that favors the lower limb, dactylitis, anterior uveitis and, above all, enthesitis: inflammation where ligaments, tendons and joint capsules attach to bone. Enthesitis explains why these diseases make bone as well as destroy it. Where RA erodes and stops, the spondyloarthropathies erode and then heal with new bone: fluffy periostitis, enthesophytes ("whiskering"), syndesmophytes and eventually ankylosis. Bone density is preserved early (osteoporosis appears late in ankylosing spondylitis from immobility).
Sacroiliitis: views and grading
The sacroiliac joint is the first and most characteristic target. Its lower two thirds are synovial and its upper third is ligamentous. Inflammation begins on the iliac side, where the cartilage is thinner. The sequence on radiographs is: blurring and loss of the white subchondral line; small erosions that make the joint look paradoxically wider (pseudowidening) with a "postage stamp" serrated margin; reactive sclerosis, more on the iliac side; then bridging and complete ankylosis, after which the sclerosis fades and the joint becomes a faint ghost line. The joint is best seen on an AP view angled cephalad (about 15 to 30 degrees, the Ferguson view) or with oblique views; MRI (STIR sequences showing bone marrow edema) detects sacroiliitis years before radiographs and defines nonradiographic axial spondyloarthritis. CT shows erosions well but with substantial radiation.
| New York grade | Radiographic appearance |
|---|---|
| Grade 0 | Normal |
| Grade 1 | Suspicious changes |
| Grade 2 | Minimal abnormality: small localized areas of erosion or sclerosis without change in joint width |
| Grade 3 | Unequivocal abnormality: moderate or advanced sacroiliitis with erosions, sclerosis, widening, narrowing or partial ankylosis |
| Grade 4 | Severe abnormality: total ankylosis |
Under the modified New York criteria, radiographic sacroiliitis counts toward ankylosing spondylitis when it is bilateral grade 2 or higher, or unilateral grade 3 or 4. The distribution of sacroiliitis is itself a diagnostic clue.
| Sacroiliac pattern | Usual causes |
|---|---|
| Bilateral and symmetric | Ankylosing spondylitis, enteropathic arthritis (also hyperparathyroidism, which mimics it with subchondral resorption, and osteitis condensans ilii, which shows triangular iliac sclerosis with a normal joint) |
| Bilateral and asymmetric | Psoriatic arthritis, reactive arthritis |
| Unilateral | Infection (pyogenic, tuberculous; think of IV drug users), gout, or early psoriatic or reactive arthritis. A single inflamed SI joint with fever is septic until proven otherwise |
Ankylosing spondylitis
Ankylosing spondylitis (AS) begins in late adolescence or early adulthood, is more common in men, and over 90% of white patients with AS carry HLA-B27. The radiographic progression is orderly: bilateral symmetric sacroiliitis first, then ascending spinal disease starting at the thoracolumbar and lumbosacral junctions.
- Romanus lesions: erosions at the anterior corners of the vertebral bodies that heal with sclerosis, the shiny corner sign.
- Squaring of the vertebral bodies on the lateral view, as corner erosions and periosteal bone fill in the normal anterior concavity.
- Marginal syndesmophytes: thin, vertical ossification of the outer annulus arising at the body corners, bilateral and symmetric, eventually bridging every level to form the bamboo spine.
- Ossification of the facet capsules and of the interspinous and supraspinous ligaments: three vertical lines on the AP view (trolley track sign), or a single central line (dagger sign).
- Andersson lesion: a destructive spondylodiscitis of the disc and endplates, often from a stress fracture through an otherwise fused segment; it mimics infection.
- Hip disease is common, bilateral and symmetric, with concentric (axial) narrowing and a collar (ring) osteophyte at the head neck junction. Enthesitis produces whiskering at the iliac crests, ischial tuberosities and trochanters, and erosion with spurring at the calcaneus.
- Late osteoporosis of the fused spine sets up the most dangerous complication: the transverse (carrot stick or chalk stick) fracture, usually cervical or cervicothoracic, after minor trauma, unstable because it passes through all three columns, often missed on radiographs, and frequently associated with epidural hematoma and cord injury.
Psoriatic, reactive and enteropathic arthritis
| Feature | Ankylosing spondylitis | Enteropathic | Psoriatic | Reactive |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sacroiliitis | Bilateral, symmetric | Bilateral, symmetric | Bilateral asymmetric or unilateral | Bilateral asymmetric or unilateral |
| Spine | Marginal syndesmophytes, ascending, bamboo spine | Identical to AS | Nonmarginal, bulky, comma shaped, skip levels; cervical involvement common | Nonmarginal, like psoriatic; thoracolumbar |
| Peripheral pattern | Hips and shoulders (root joints) | Large lower limb joints, activity follows the bowel disease | Hands, DIP predominant, ray pattern | Feet, ankles, knees, heels |
| Signature findings | Shiny corner, squaring, trolley track, dagger sign | Same as AS; look for bowel history | Pencil in cup, erosions with adjacent fluffy new bone (mouse ears), sausage digit, ivory phalanx, acro-osteolysis | Fluffy periostitis and erosion at the calcaneal Achilles and plantar fascia insertions, MTP erosions |
| Clinical clue | Young man, inflammatory back pain, uveitis | Crohn disease or ulcerative colitis | Psoriasis, nail pitting (skin disease may follow the arthritis) | Urethritis or diarrhea 1 to 4 weeks earlier (Chlamydia, Salmonella, Shigella, Yersinia, Campylobacter), conjunctivitis |
Psoriatic arthritis keeps normal bone density, which helps separate it from RA in the hand; its erosions start at the margins and extend centrally until the proximal bone tapers to a pencil and the distal base cups around it. Severe disease produces arthritis mutilans with telescoping digits. Reactive arthritis looks like psoriatic arthritis moved to the foot. In enteropathic arthritis, peripheral joint flares track bowel activity, but the spinal and sacroiliac disease progresses independently of it, even after colectomy.
Reasoning: Bilateral grade 2 to 3 sacroiliitis plus shiny corners (Romanus lesions) in a young man with inflammatory back pain and probable uveitis means ankylosing spondylitis. Report the grade and distribution, and recommend HLA-B27, ESR and CRP with rheumatology referral (early biologic therapy changes the course). Exercise based care and mobilization are appropriate while he is evaluated; document his spinal mobility (Schober, chest expansion) as a baseline. Do not label the findings as mechanical sacroiliac dysfunction.
Spondyloarthropathies erode and then make bone, because their target is the enthesis. Sacroiliitis begins on the iliac side and is graded 0 to 4; bilateral symmetric disease suggests AS or enteropathic arthritis, asymmetric disease psoriatic or reactive arthritis, and unilateral disease infection. Thin marginal syndesmophytes mean AS, bulky nonmarginal ones mean psoriatic or reactive arthritis, and the fused spine is fragile.
Section 4Crystal and metabolic arthropathies
Gout
Gout is inflammation caused by monosodium urate crystals, which form when urate exceeds its solubility (about 6.8 mg/dL) in tissue. It affects mostly men over 40 and postmenopausal women, and is promoted by renal underexcretion, diuretics, alcohol (especially beer), purine rich meat and seafood, fructose, obesity and high cell turnover (myeloproliferative disease, chemotherapy). The first attack is usually monoarticular at the first MTP joint (podagra), followed by the midfoot, ankle, knee, olecranon bursa and hand. Serum urate may be normal during an acute attack; the diagnosis is made by aspiration showing needle shaped, negatively birefringent crystals.
Radiographs are normal or show only soft tissue swelling for the first several years. Chronic tophaceous gout then produces a distinctive picture:
- Asymmetric, polyarticular distribution with a lower limb predominance; the first MTP is the classic site.
- Tophi: lumpy, eccentric soft tissue masses, slightly denser than muscle, occasionally calcified.
- Punched out erosions that are juxta-articular or away from the joint, with sclerotic margins and an overhanging edge (the Martel sign), where the cortex is lifted around an adjacent tophus.
- Joint space preserved until late, and bone density normal, both unlike RA.
- Olecranon and prepatellar bursal swelling; dual energy CT can map urate deposits directly.
Calcium pyrophosphate deposition (CPPD)
CPPD disease is caused by rhomboid, weakly positively birefringent calcium pyrophosphate dihydrate crystals. It is mainly a disease of older adults, and when it appears before about 55 it should prompt a search for hyperparathyroidism, hemochromatosis, hypomagnesemia or hypophosphatasia. It presents as asymptomatic chondrocalcinosis, as acute attacks (pseudogout, most often of the knee or wrist), or as a chronic degenerative arthropathy.
- Chondrocalcinosis: calcification of fibrocartilage (knee menisci, the triangular fibrocartilage of the wrist, the pubic symphysis, the acetabular and glenoid labra) and of hyaline cartilage, where it appears as a thin line parallel to the subchondral bone.
- Pyrophosphate arthropathy: looks like OA (narrowing, sclerosis, osteophytes) but in unusual places: the radiocarpal joint, the second and third MCP joints (with hook like osteophytes), isolated patellofemoral disease, the elbow and the glenohumeral joint. Large subchondral cysts and rapid fragmentation are characteristic.
- SLAC wrist (scapholunate advanced collapse): scapholunate dissociation with the capitate migrating proximally between them, a classic CPPD pattern.
- Crowned dens: calcification around the dens on CT, causing acute neck pain and stiffness with fever that can mimic meningitis or giant cell arteritis.
Hydroxyapatite deposition disease (HADD)
Calcium hydroxyapatite deposits in tendons and bursae rather than cartilage. The radiographic sign is a homogeneous, cloudlike, amorphous periarticular calcification without trabeculae. The supraspinatus tendon just above the greater tuberosity is the most common site (calcific tendinitis); others include the gluteal insertions at the greater trochanter and the flexor carpi ulnaris near the pisiform. The acute phase is very painful, and the calcification may become fluffy and then resorb. Longus colli calcific tendinitis deserves special mention: amorphous calcification anterior to C1 and C2 with prevertebral soft tissue swelling produces acute neck pain, stiffness and painful swallowing, and must be distinguished from a retropharyngeal abscess. Milwaukee shoulder is a destructive hydroxyapatite arthropathy of older women with a large effusion and rotator cuff loss.
Hemochromatosis
Iron overload (hereditary HFE mutation, more often expressed in men, or secondary to transfusions) produces an arthropathy that resembles CPPD. Hallmarks: narrowing, subchondral cysts and hook like (drooping) osteophytes on the radial side of the second and third metacarpal heads, with chondrocalcinosis and generalized osteopenia. Unlike CPPD it may also involve the fourth and fifth MCP joints and progresses more uniformly. Recommend iron studies (transferrin saturation over about 45%, ferritin) and physician referral, because early phlebotomy prevents cirrhosis, diabetes and cardiomyopathy even though the arthropathy responds poorly.
Neuropathic (Charcot) joint
Loss of protective pain and position sense allows repeated unrecognized trauma that destroys a joint. The classic radiographic features are the six Ds: Density increased (subchondral sclerosis), Destruction of articular surfaces, Debris (bone fragments), Disorganization, Dislocation and Distension (large effusion). The hypertrophic form shows sclerosis and debris; the atrophic form shows resorption that ends the bone as if surgically amputated, typical of the shoulder in syringomyelia. The site points to the cause.
| Cause | Typical joints | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Diabetes mellitus (most common today) | Midfoot: tarsometatarsal (Lisfranc) and intertarsal joints, ankle, MTP | Glucose control, offloading, podiatry; MRI if infection suspected |
| Syringomyelia | Shoulder, elbow, wrist, cervical spine (upper limb) | Cervical and thoracic MRI, neurology |
| Tabes dorsalis (tertiary syphilis) | Knee, hip, ankle, lumbar spine | Serology, physician referral |
| Spinal cord injury, congenital insensitivity to pain, leprosy, chronic alcohol use | Spine below injury; hands and feet | Treat the cause, protect joints |
In a diabetic foot, the main differential is osteomyelitis; infection favors involvement beside an ulcer and marrow signal away from the joint on MRI, while neuropathic change centers on the joints of the midfoot.
| Crystal or deposit | Crystal shape and birefringence | Key film finding | Classic site |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monosodium urate (gout) | Needle, strongly negative | Punched out erosion with overhanging edge, tophi, preserved joint space | First MTP |
| Calcium pyrophosphate (CPPD) | Rhomboid, weakly positive | Chondrocalcinosis, OA in unusual joints, large cysts | Knee menisci, TFCC, 2nd and 3rd MCP, radiocarpal |
| Hydroxyapatite (HADD) | Too small for light microscopy | Cloudlike periarticular calcification | Supraspinatus, longus colli |
| Iron (hemochromatosis) | Not a crystal arthritis; CPPD often coexists | Hook osteophytes, chondrocalcinosis | 2nd and 3rd MCP |
Reasoning: Punched out erosion with overhanging edge beside a soft tissue tophus, preserved joint space and normal density is chronic tophaceous gout. Report it, and recommend serum urate, renal function and physician referral for urate lowering therapy and review of the diuretic. Avoid manipulating an acutely inflamed joint. If the toe were acutely hot with fever, aspiration would be needed to exclude septic arthritis, which can coexist with gout.
Gout gives punched out erosions with sclerotic rims and overhanging edges, tophi, preserved joint space and normal density; CPPD gives chondrocalcinosis and OA in unusual joints with large cysts; hydroxyapatite gives cloudlike tendon calcification, notably supraspinatus and longus colli; hemochromatosis gives hook osteophytes at the second and third MCPs; and neuropathic joints show the six Ds, with the site pointing to diabetes, syringomyelia or tabes.
Section 5Approach to the arthritic film
A systematic search: ABCDS
Arthritis is diagnosed from a pattern, so read every arthritic film in the same order and write down each feature before naming a disease. The widely taught ABCDS scheme works for any joint.
| Step | Question to ask | What the answer points to |
|---|---|---|
| Alignment | Subluxation, deviation, collapse, instability? | Ulnar deviation, swan neck, atlantoaxial instability (RA, lupus); telescoping (psoriatic mutilans); dislocation (neuropathic) |
| Bone density | Normal, periarticular osteopenia, or diffuse osteopenia? Any productive new bone (periostitis, enthesophytes, syndesmophytes)? | Osteopenia: RA, JIA, septic arthritis, disuse. Normal density with new bone: OA, spondyloarthropathies, gout. Increased density: OA sclerosis, neuropathic joint |
| Cartilage (joint space) | Narrowed or preserved? Uniform or nonuniform? | Nonuniform: OA. Uniform: inflammatory. Preserved until late: gout. Widened: early erosive sacroiliitis, effusion, acromegaly |
| Distribution | Which joints, how many, one side or both, symmetric or not, proximal or distal, axial or peripheral? | The single most useful clue (see Figure 12.5) |
| Soft tissues | Fusiform swelling, lumpy masses, calcification, sausage digit? | Fusiform: inflammatory synovitis. Lumpy, eccentric: tophi. Calcification: CPPD (cartilage), HADD (tendon), scleroderma (subcutaneous) |
| Erosions | Present? Marginal, central, or punched out? Sclerotic rim? | Marginal without rim: RA. Marginal with fluffy new bone: psoriatic, reactive. Central gull wing: erosive OA. Punched out with overhanging edge: gout |
Two summary contrasts organize most of the answers. Productive versus destructive: OA, DISH and the spondyloarthropathies add bone, RA removes it. Symmetric and proximal versus asymmetric and distal: RA is the former; OA (distal rows), psoriatic and reactive arthritis and gout tend toward the latter. Monoarticular disease is its own category: in a single inflamed joint, think first of infection, then crystals and trauma, and remember that septic arthritis destroys cartilage and subchondral bone within days, so a rapidly narrowing single joint with indistinct cortex is an emergency.
| Disease | Distribution | Density | Joint space | Erosions | New bone |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Osteoarthritis | Weight bearing joints, DIP, PIP, first CMC; asymmetric | Normal | Nonuniform loss | None (central in erosive OA) | Osteophytes, sclerosis |
| Rheumatoid arthritis | Bilateral symmetric MCP, PIP, wrist, MTP, C1 to C2 | Periarticular osteopenia | Uniform loss | Marginal, no rim | None |
| Ankylosing spondylitis | SI joints, spine, hips, shoulders; symmetric | Normal early, osteoporotic late | Loss, then ankylosis | SI and vertebral corners | Marginal syndesmophytes, enthesophytes |
| Psoriatic arthritis | DIP, ray, asymmetric; SI asymmetric | Normal | Loss or widening | Marginal progressing to pencil in cup | Fluffy periostitis, nonmarginal syndesmophytes |
| Reactive arthritis | Feet, ankles, knees, heels; SI asymmetric | Normal or periarticular loss early | Loss | Marginal | Calcaneal periostitis, nonmarginal syndesmophytes |
| Gout | First MTP, foot, knee, olecranon; asymmetric | Normal | Preserved until late | Punched out, sclerotic rim, overhanging edge | Overhanging cortex only |
| CPPD | Knee, wrist, 2nd and 3rd MCP, patellofemoral | Normal | Loss, OA like | None; large cysts | Osteophytes, chondrocalcinosis |
| Neuropathic | Midfoot (diabetes), shoulder (syrinx), knee (tabes) | Increased (hypertrophic) or resorbed (atrophic) | Destroyed | Destruction, debris | Sclerosis, fragments |
Writing the report
The imaging report has three parts. Findings describe what is seen, in order, without diagnosis (alignment, density, joint spaces, erosions, new bone, soft tissues, incidental findings). The impression gives the most likely diagnosis and a short differential, in order of likelihood, with any finding that affects safety stated plainly. Recommendations say what should happen next: laboratory tests, further views or advanced imaging, referral, and precautions for care. For arthritic films the recommendation almost always includes laboratory correlation (RF, anti-CCP, ESR, CRP, HLA-B27, uric acid, iron studies, as the pattern suggests), and for the spine it states whether stability views are needed and whether manipulation of a region is contraindicated or should be modified.
| Impression | Typical recommendation |
|---|---|
| Degenerative disc and facet disease without instability | Clinical correlation; no further imaging unless neurological deficit; manipulation not contraindicated |
| Degenerative spondylolisthesis | Flexion and extension views if instability suspected; MRI if neurogenic claudication or deficit |
| DISH | Note fracture risk after trauma (CT for any post traumatic pain); evaluate dysphagia; avoid thrust through ossified segments |
| Rheumatoid pattern | RF, anti-CCP, ESR, CRP; rheumatology referral; cervical flexion and extension views before cervical care |
| Sacroiliitis or syndesmophytes | HLA-B27, ESR, CRP; MRI of SI joints if radiographs equivocal; rheumatology referral; no thrust to fused segments |
| Gout | Serum urate, renal function, aspiration if acute; physician referral |
| Chondrocalcinosis in a patient under 55 | Calcium, PTH, iron studies, magnesium |
| Neuropathic joint | Glucose and HbA1c, or spinal MRI for syrinx, or syphilis serology by site; MRI if infection is a concern |
Worked interpretation cases
Reasoning: Distal and middle row disease with thumb base involvement, normal density and osteophytes is osteoarthritis; the central erosions make it the erosive (inflammatory) variant. The differential is psoriatic arthritis, which erodes marginally with fluffy periostitis rather than centrally with osteophytes. Impression: erosive osteoarthritis of the hand. Recommend clinical correlation; inflammatory markers are usually normal or mildly raised. Hand mobilization and exercise are appropriate.
Reasoning: Chondrocalcinosis in fibrocartilage and hyaline cartilage, plus degenerative change in an unusual compartment with large cysts, is CPPD arthropathy. Differential: primary OA (which would favor the medial compartment) and hemochromatosis. Impression: calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease. Recommend calcium, PTH, magnesium and iron studies, and physician referral if an acute pseudogout attack occurs (aspiration showing rhomboid, weakly positive crystals).
Read every arthritic film in the same order: alignment, bone density, cartilage space, distribution, soft tissues and the character of erosions and new bone. Distribution and density eliminate most alternatives, the combination of features names the disease, and the report finishes with laboratory correlation, the right further imaging and any precaution that changes how the patient may be treated.
The chapter in one breath
- Osteoarthritis is productive: nonuniform narrowing, subchondral sclerosis, osteophytes and cysts with normal density; knee medial compartment, hip superolateral migration, hand DIP, PIP and first CMC.
- In the spine, intervertebral osteochondrosis (narrowing, vacuum, endplate sclerosis) differs from spondylosis deformans (claw osteophytes); uncovertebral and facet arthrosis narrow the foramina, best seen on obliques.
- DISH: flowing ossification over at least four contiguous levels, discs preserved, SI and facets normal; dysphagia, OPLL and fracture after minor trauma are its complications.
- Rheumatoid arthritis is bilateral, symmetric and proximal with fusiform swelling, periarticular osteopenia, uniform narrowing and marginal erosions, and spares the DIP joints.
- An adult ADI over 3 mm (often visible only in flexion) means atlantoaxial instability; upper cervical manipulation is contraindicated and cord signs require urgent referral.
- JIA shows growth disturbance: ballooned epiphyses, widened intercondylar notch, squared patella, and C2 to C3 apophyseal ankylosis with hypoplastic bodies.
- Sacroiliitis starts on the iliac side, is graded 0 to 4, and its distribution points to AS or enteropathic (bilateral symmetric), psoriatic or reactive (asymmetric) or infection (unilateral).
- AS: Romanus lesions, squaring, thin marginal syndesmophytes, bamboo spine, trolley track and dagger signs, Andersson lesion and unstable carrot stick fractures.
- Psoriatic arthritis: DIP and ray pattern, pencil in cup, mouse ears, ivory phalanx, normal density, nonmarginal syndesmophytes; reactive arthritis moves the same pattern to the feet and heels.
- Gout: punched out erosions with sclerotic rims and overhanging edges, tophi, preserved joint space; CPPD: chondrocalcinosis and OA in unusual joints; HADD: cloudlike tendon calcification.
- Hemochromatosis gives hook osteophytes at the 2nd and 3rd MCPs; the neuropathic joint shows the six Ds, with site pointing to diabetes, syringomyelia or tabes.
- Read with ABCDS plus erosions and new bone, and finish every report with laboratory correlation, further imaging and treatment precautions.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Andersson lesion | Destructive inflammatory or stress related lesion of the disc and endplates in ankylosing spondylitis that can mimic infection. |
| Atlantodental interval (ADI) | Distance between the anterior arch of C1 and the dens on the lateral view; normal up to 3 mm in adults and 5 mm in children. |
| Bamboo spine | Continuous vertical bridging of all vertebral levels by marginal syndesmophytes in advanced ankylosing spondylitis. |
| Bare area | The margin of a synovial joint where synovium contacts bone without cartilage cover; the first site of rheumatoid erosion. |
| Chondrocalcinosis | Calcification of hyaline or fibrocartilage, most often due to calcium pyrophosphate deposition. |
| Claw osteophyte | A degenerative vertebral osteophyte that projects horizontally and then curves vertically toward the adjacent body. |
| Dagger sign | A single vertical line of ossified supraspinous and interspinous ligaments on the AP view in ankylosing spondylitis. |
| DISH | Diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis: flowing anterolateral ossification over at least four contiguous vertebrae with preserved discs and normal SI joints. |
| Enthesitis | Inflammation at the attachment of a ligament, tendon or capsule to bone, the central lesion of the spondyloarthropathies. |
| Erosive osteoarthritis | An inflammatory variant of hand OA with central erosions that give a gull wing appearance at the interphalangeal joints. |
| Ferguson view | An AP pelvic or lumbosacral view angled cephalad to show the sacroiliac joints. |
| Gull wing appearance | The outline of an interphalangeal joint in erosive OA, with a central erosion on the proximal side and marginal osteophytes. |
| Hook osteophyte | A beak like osteophyte on the radial side of the second and third metacarpal heads, typical of hemochromatosis and CPPD. |
| Intervertebral osteochondrosis | Degeneration of the nucleus and endplates: disc narrowing, vacuum phenomenon, endplate sclerosis. |
| Ivory phalanx | Diffuse sclerosis of a distal phalanx, characteristic of psoriatic arthritis. |
| Kellgren and Lawrence grade | A 0 to 4 radiographic grading of osteoarthritis based on osteophytes, narrowing, sclerosis and deformity. |
| Marginal erosion | An erosion at the joint margin (bare area), typical of rheumatoid and other inflammatory arthritides. |
| Marginal syndesmophyte | Thin vertical ossification of the outer annulus arising at the vertebral body corner, typical of ankylosing spondylitis and enteropathic arthritis. |
| Nonmarginal syndesmophyte | Bulky, comma shaped paravertebral ossification separated from the body margin, typical of psoriatic and reactive arthritis. |
| Overhanging edge | A lip of cortex projecting over a gouty erosion beside a tophus (Martel sign). |
| Pencil in cup deformity | Tapering of the proximal bone into a point that sits in a widened, cupped distal bone base, seen in psoriatic arthritis. |
| Periarticular osteopenia | Reduced bone density adjacent to a joint from hyperemia and disuse, an early sign of rheumatoid arthritis. |
| Protrusio acetabuli | Medial bulging of the acetabulum into the pelvis beyond the ilioischial line, seen in RA, Paget disease and osteomalacia. |
| Romanus lesion | Erosion of the anterior vertebral body corner that heals with sclerosis (shiny corner sign) in ankylosing spondylitis. |
| Sacroiliitis | Inflammation of the sacroiliac joint, shown radiographically by blurring, erosion, sclerosis and eventual ankylosis. |
| Schmorl node | Herniation of disc material through a vertebral endplate into the body. |
| Six Ds | The features of a neuropathic joint: increased density, destruction, debris, disorganization, dislocation and distension. |
| Squaring | Loss of the normal anterior concavity of the vertebral bodies in ankylosing spondylitis. |
| Tophus | A soft tissue deposit of monosodium urate crystals in chronic gout. |
| Trolley track sign | Three vertical lines of ossified facet capsules and midline ligaments on the AP view in ankylosing spondylitis. |
| Vacuum phenomenon | A dark nitrogen collection within a degenerated disc or joint; it argues against infection. |
Check yourself
Image Interpretation II: Congenital Anomalies, Variants, Scoliosis and Trauma
Half of what you see on a spine or extremity film is not disease at all: it is anatomy that formed a little differently, or a growth center that has not yet fused. The board tests whether you can tell a harmless variant from a fracture, a congenital block from a fused infected segment, and a stable injury from one that needs the emergency department today. This chapter teaches the radiographic hallmarks of congenital anomalies, variants, scoliosis and trauma, and the exact recommendation you would write in the report for each.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Recognize occipitalization, os odontoideum and ponticulus posticus, and say which threaten stability.
- Distinguish a congenital block vertebra from acquired fusion, and identify hemivertebra, butterfly vertebra, spina bifida, transitional segments and cervical rib.
- Separate accessory ossicles and variants from fractures with the corticated margin rule.
- Use Hilgenreiner, Perkins and Shenton lines and the acetabular index to evaluate DDH.
- Measure scoliosis by Cobb, grade the Risser sign, and choose observation, bracing or surgical referral.
- Recognize the major spinal fractures and judge stability with the three column model.
- Grade spondylolisthesis, identify a pars defect, and name key extremity, Salter Harris and stress fractures.
- Apply prevertebral swelling, fat pad and lipohemarthrosis signs, and read flexion and extension views for instability.
Section 1Spinal congenital anomalies and variants
Why anomalies matter on the board and in the office
An anomaly matters clinically when it does one of three things: it makes a segment unstable (os odontoideum, some occipitalizations), it overloads the neighbors (block vertebra, Klippel Feil fusion, transitional segment), or it signals other anomalies elsewhere in the body (hemivertebra with renal and cardiac defects, Klippel Feil with Sprengel deformity and renal agenesis). On the exam, an item showing an upper cervical anomaly almost always asks one of two things: what is it, or what you should do before adjusting. The answer to the second is usually flexion and extension views to assess stability, and modification or avoidance of high velocity rotary thrust at that level.
Anomalies arise from failure of formation (part of a vertebra missing: hemivertebra, butterfly vertebra, pedicle agenesis) or failure of segmentation (two vertebrae fused: block vertebra, occipitalization, unsegmented bar), the same scheme used for congenital scoliosis.
Upper cervical anomalies
Occipitalization (atlanto occipital assimilation) is fusion of the atlas to the occiput. On the lateral film the posterior arch of C1 merges with the occiput with no joint space. The C1 to C2 joint must then provide all upper cervical motion, which promotes late atlantoaxial instability; it is also associated with basilar impression and Chiari malformation. Recommend flexion and extension views, and MRI if there are long tract signs or headache with Valsalva.
Os odontoideum is a smooth, round ossicle above a hypoplastic dens, separated from C2 by a wide gap (most likely an old ununited childhood fracture). The ossicle moves with C1, so the transverse ligament no longer controls C1 on C2. It has smooth, corticated margins and the anterior arch of C1 is often enlarged and rounded from chronic stress. A type II odontoid fracture has a thin, irregular, noncorticated line and a normal sized arch; an ossiculum terminale is a small, stable unfused center at the dens tip. Os odontoideum contraindicates upper cervical thrust; recommend flexion and extension views and surgical referral, urgently if there is myelopathy.
Agenesis of the posterior arch of atlas ranges from a trivial midline cleft to complete absence; the smooth margins and an enlarged C2 spinous process separate it from fracture. Ponticulus posticus (arcuate foramen) is ossification of the oblique atlantooccipital ligament forming a bony ring over the vertebral artery groove of C1, seen in roughly 10 to 15 percent of people; it is a variant, but many clinicians modify upper cervical rotary thrust in its presence, so mention it in the report. Basilar impression (dens tip more than about 7 mm above McGregor line) may accompany occipitalization, Paget disease and rheumatoid arthritis.
Block vertebra and Klippel Feil syndrome
A congenital block vertebra is failure of segmentation of two or more vertebral bodies, most often at C2 to C3 and C5 to C6 in the neck and in the lumbar spine less often. The hallmarks on the lateral film are: a narrow waist at the level of the absent disc (the wasp waist sign), a rudimentary disc space that may persist as a thin sclerotic line, a combined height equal to two vertebrae plus the missing disc, fused facets and often fused spinous processes, and an enlarged intervertebral foramen that is shaped like a keyhole or oval. The segments above and below are hypermobile and degenerate early.
Acquired fusion lacks the waist: surgical fusion shows hardware or graft, ankylosing spondylitis shows syndesmophytes, juvenile idiopathic arthritis fuses facets with small bodies, and healed infection leaves an irregular sclerotic, often kyphotic fusion.
Klippel Feil syndrome is congenital fusion of multiple cervical segments; the classic triad (short neck, low hairline, restricted motion) is present in under half. It is associated with Sprengel deformity (high scapula, sometimes with an omovertebral bone), scoliosis, renal anomalies, heart disease and hearing loss, so renal ultrasound is advised. Never manipulate the fused block and treat the hypermobile adjacent levels gently.
Hemivertebra and butterfly vertebra
A hemivertebra results from failure of formation of one half of the vertebral body. On the AP film it appears as a wedge shaped body with a single pedicle, producing an abrupt lateral angulation, a short sharp scoliosis. A lateral hemivertebra causes scoliosis; a dorsal (posterior) hemivertebra, in which the anterior body fails to form, causes a sharp kyphosis (gibbus) with risk of cord compression. Hemivertebrae may be fully segmented (discs above and below, greatest growth potential), semisegmented, or incarcerated (tucked into the curve, least deforming). The extra or missing pedicle and rib count help confirm the diagnosis.
A butterfly vertebra (sagittal cleft vertebra) results from failure of fusion of the two lateral chondral centers. On the AP film the body is narrowed centrally with two triangular halves pointing toward the midline, and the adjacent end plates of the vertebrae above and below are reciprocally shaped to fill the cleft. On the lateral film it can look like a compression fracture; the AP appearance and the reciprocal deformity of the neighbors settle the question. Butterfly vertebrae are associated with Alagille syndrome and other anomalies but are usually isolated and asymptomatic.
Spina bifida and other posterior element variants
Spina bifida occulta is a midline lucent cleft where the laminae fail to unite, most often at L5 and S1, and is usually insignificant. A hair tuft, dimple or lipoma over it in a child with gait change, foot deformity or bladder symptoms suggests tethered cord and calls for MRI. Spina bifida vera (meningocele, myelomeningocele) is evident at birth with widened interpedicular distances. A knife clasp deformity is an elongated L5 spinous process that drops into an S1 cleft in extension, causing extension pain.
Agenesis of a pedicle must be distinguished from the destroyed pedicle of metastasis (Chapter 14): congenital absence shows a hypertrophied, sclerotic contralateral pedicle. A limbus bone is a corticated triangular ossicle at the anterosuperior corner of a lumbar body, formed when disc material herniates through the ring apophysis before it fuses; it is often mistaken for a teardrop fracture. Unfused apophyses at transverse, spinous or articular process tips also mimic fractures but are smoothly corticated.
Transitional segments
A lumbosacral transitional segment occurs in roughly 10 to 15 percent of people. Sacralization means L5 takes on sacral features (an enlarged transverse process forming a joint with or fusing to the sacral ala); lumbarization means S1 behaves like a lumbar vertebra with a well formed disc below it. The Castellvi classification grades the anomaly: type I is a dysplastic, enlarged transverse process (at least 19 mm tall); type II is a pseudarthrosis (a diarthrodial joint) between the transverse process and the sacrum; type III is complete bony fusion; type IV is type II on one side and type III on the other. Each type may be unilateral (a) or bilateral (b).
A unilateral type II pseudarthrosis can itself cause pain (Bertolotti syndrome), and the disc above a transitional segment degenerates early. The practical point is level counting: state how you counted (from C2 or from the lowest rib bearing vertebra) so advanced imaging and procedures use the same numbering.
Cervical rib
A cervical rib arises from the costal element of C7 (about 0.5 to 1 percent of people, often bilateral). The C7 transverse process points downward, whereas T1 transverse processes point upward and carry the first rib. A complete rib or an invisible fibrous band from an incomplete one can compress the lower trunk of the brachial plexus or the subclavian artery (thoracic outlet syndrome). Correlate with C8 to T1 findings, and refer promptly for vascular studies if there are signs of arterial compromise.
| Anomaly | Best view and hallmark | Main mimic | How to tell them apart |
|---|---|---|---|
| Block vertebra | Lateral: wasp waist, combined height, oval foramen | Fusion from infection or ankylosing spondylitis | Infection: irregular, sclerotic, kyphotic, no waist; AS: syndesmophytes |
| Hemivertebra | AP: wedge with one pedicle, sharp scoliosis | Compression fracture | Fracture keeps both pedicles; hemivertebra changes rib or pedicle count |
| Butterfly vertebra | AP: two triangles, reciprocal neighbors | Compression fracture on lateral | AP view; reciprocal end plate shape above and below |
| Spina bifida occulta | AP: midline lucent cleft at L5 or S1 | Fracture of lamina | Midline, smooth, no trauma history |
| Transitional segment | AP: enlarged L5 transverse process joint or fusion with ala | Miscounted levels | Count from C2 or rib bearing T12; state the method |
| Cervical rib | AP: downward pointing C7 transverse process with rib | Normal first rib | First rib arises from T1 whose transverse process points upward |
Reasoning: The corticated margins and hypertrophied anterior arch point to os odontoideum, a long standing developmental lesion, not a fresh fracture. The key issue is stability, which a neutral film cannot show. Recommend flexion and extension lateral views (or dynamic imaging ordered with medical colleagues) and refer for a spine surgery opinion; any motion of the ossicle with C1 relative to C2 indicates instability. Do not perform upper cervical high velocity thrust. If she had myelopathic signs (hyperreflexia, Hoffmann sign, gait change), referral would be urgent with MRI.
Classify every spinal anomaly as a failure of formation or of segmentation, then ask three questions: is it stable, does it overload neighbors, and does it predict other anomalies? Smooth corticated margins point to development rather than injury. Upper cervical anomalies that compromise the transverse ligament (os odontoideum, Down syndrome, some occipitalizations) demand flexion and extension views before any thrust technique.
Section 2Extraspinal anomalies and variants
The corticated margin rule
The single most useful principle in this section is simple: a developmental ossicle or unfused apophysis has a smooth, rounded, completely corticated margin on all sides, and the parent bone next to it is also corticated and often shaped to receive it. An acute fracture fragment has a sharp, irregular, noncorticated edge on the fracture side, it fits like a jigsaw piece into a defect in the parent bone, and there is usually soft tissue swelling and focal tenderness. Bilateral symmetry also favors a variant; when in doubt, a comparison view of the other side is a cheap and classic answer. An old ununited fracture will eventually corticate, so history matters as well.
Accessory ossicles of the foot and ankle
- Os trigonum: unfused lateral tubercle of the posterior talar process; causes posterior ankle impingement in dancers.
- Accessory navicular: medial to the navicular at the posterior tibial tendon insertion; the most often symptomatic foot ossicle, especially with flatfoot.
- Os peroneum: in the peroneus longus tendon near the cuboid; proximal migration on serial films suggests tendon rupture.
- Os vesalianum: at the base of the fifth metatarsal, rare, with smooth margins. The normal fifth metatarsal apophysis in a child runs parallel to the shaft; a fracture line runs transverse (perpendicular) to the shaft. This is a heavily tested distinction.
- Bipartite medial hallux sesamoid: more common medially and often bilateral; it is smooth, and the two parts together are larger than the opposite sesamoid. A fractured sesamoid has sharp edges and the pieces add up to a normal size.
Other common variants
- Bipartite patella: an unfused ossification center at the superolateral pole, usually bilateral, with smooth sclerotic margins. A transverse patellar fracture is mid patella; a fragment at the inferior pole after trauma is a sleeve fracture or fracture, not a variant.
- Fabella: sesamoid in the lateral gastrocnemius head behind the lateral femoral condyle, not a loose body.
- Os acromiale: unfused acromial apophysis after about age 25, best on the axillary view, linked to impingement.
- Nutrient foramen: a thin oblique lucent line through one cortex of a long bone, angled away from the growing end (toward the elbow in the upper limb, away from the knee in the lower limb). A fracture line usually crosses both cortices.
- Mach band: a perceptual dark line where two densities overlap, classically across the base of the dens from the overlying posterior arch of C1 or the teeth. It extends beyond the bone margins, which a true fracture line does not.
| Finding | Variant features | Fracture features | Next step if unsure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fifth metatarsal base in a child | Apophysis parallel to shaft | Line transverse to shaft | Compare with other foot; examine for focal tenderness |
| Patella fragment | Superolateral, bilateral, smooth | Mid patella or inferior pole, acute effusion | Contralateral view, check extensor function |
| Hallux sesamoid | Medial, bilateral, larger than partner, smooth | Sharp edges, pieces sum to normal size | Contralateral view or MRI |
| Dens base line | Mach band extends beyond bone | Line confined to bone, displacement, swelling | Repeat open mouth view with altered angle, CT |
| Long bone cortex line | Nutrient foramen: one cortex, oblique, predictable direction | Both cortices, focal pain | Second projection |
| Acromion line | Os acromiale on axillary view, often bilateral | Fracture after direct blow, swelling | Axillary view, compare sides |
Developmental dysplasia of the hip
Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) ranges from a shallow acetabulum to frank dislocation. Risk factors are female sex, breech presentation, first born, family history and tight swaddling; the left hip is involved more often. In the newborn, Barlow (adduction with posterior pressure) dislocates an unstable hip and Ortolani (abduction with anterior lift) reduces it with a clunk. After about 3 months these become negative, and the signs are limited abduction, a positive Galeazzi sign and asymmetric thigh folds; a walking child limps. Use ultrasound before the femoral head ossifies (about 4 to 6 months), then an AP pelvis:
Imaging depends on age. Before the femoral head ossifies (about 4 to 6 months), ultrasound is the study of choice. After that, an AP pelvis is used with these lines:
- Hilgenreiner line: a horizontal line through both triradiate cartilages.
- Perkins line: a vertical line through the lateral edge of the acetabular roof, perpendicular to Hilgenreiner line. Together they form quadrants; the femoral head ossification center (or the medial metaphyseal beak if not yet ossified) should lie in the lower inner quadrant. A head in an upper or outer quadrant is subluxated or dislocated.
- Acetabular index: the angle between Hilgenreiner line and a line along the acetabular roof. Normal is about 30 degrees or less at birth, decreasing toward about 20 to 22 degrees by age 2. A value over 30 degrees suggests dysplasia.
- Shenton line: a smooth arc from the inferior border of the superior pubic ramus along the medial femoral neck. A break indicates superior displacement of the femur.
- A smaller, delayed femoral head ossification center on the affected side is another sign.
Residual adult dysplasia shows a shallow acetabulum with a lateral center edge angle under about 20 to 25 degrees and leads to early osteoarthritis. Refer any suspected DDH to pediatric orthopedics promptly; a Pavlik harness works well in the first months.
Reasoning: Negative Ortolani and Barlow tests do not exclude DDH after about 3 months; limited abduction and a positive Galeazzi sign are now the key findings, and the risk factors (female, breech, first born, left side) all fit. At 9 months the femoral head is ossified, so an AP pelvis is appropriate: expect a small left ossification center in the upper outer quadrant, an acetabular index over 30 degrees and a broken Shenton line. Refer promptly to pediatric orthopedics; this is not a case for observation or manipulation, and delay worsens the outcome.
Before calling any extremity fragment a fracture, check the margin, the opposite side and the textbook location of ossicles: corticated, bilateral and typically placed means variant. Know the infant hip lines cold (Hilgenreiner, Perkins, acetabular index, Shenton), remember that Ortolani and Barlow fade after 3 months, and refer any suspected DDH promptly because early treatment works and late treatment often does not.
Section 3Scoliosis
Definitions and classification
Scoliosis is a lateral curvature of the spine of 10 degrees or more measured by the Cobb method on an upright AP or PA film. It is a three dimensional deformity: the vertebrae also rotate, with the bodies turning toward the convexity and the spinous processes toward the concavity, which is why the ribs form a posterior hump on the convex side during the Adams forward bend test. Curves are named for the side of the convexity (a right thoracic curve is convex to the right) and by the apex: cervical (apex C1 to C6), cervicothoracic (C7 to T1), thoracic (T2 to T11), thoracolumbar (T12 to L1), lumbar (L2 to L4) and lumbosacral (L5 to S1).
A structural curve has fixed rotation and does not correct on side bending; a nonstructural (functional) curve is flexible and has a cause outside the spine, such as a leg length inequality, muscle spasm or a painful lesion. A functional curve from leg length difference disappears when the patient sits or when the short leg is lifted. Curves are also called major (largest, most structural) and minor or compensatory.
| Type | Share and features | Radiographic clue | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adolescent idiopathic (age 10 to skeletal maturity) | About 80 percent of structural scoliosis; girls with progressive curves outnumber boys about 7 to 1 | Typically right thoracic, smooth, normal vertebrae | Measure, grade maturity, observe or brace or refer by size |
| Juvenile and infantile idiopathic (under 10) | Higher progression risk; infantile more often left thoracic in boys | Variable curves | Orthopedic referral; MRI often advised |
| Congenital | Failure of formation (hemivertebra), segmentation (unsegmented bar) or both | Abnormal vertebrae, short sharp curve | Orthopedics; screen kidneys and heart; MRI for cord anomalies |
| Neuromuscular | Cerebral palsy, muscular dystrophy, spinal muscular atrophy, myelomeningocele | Long C shaped curve, pelvic obliquity | Manage with medical team |
| Degenerative (de novo adult) | Over 50, lumbar, from asymmetric disc and facet degeneration | Lateral listhesis, osteophytes, apex L2 to L3 | Conservative care; refer if progressive neurological deficit |
| Secondary or symptomatic | Osteoid osteoma, infection, tumor, disc herniation (sciatic scoliosis) | Painful, rigid curve, often atypical | Find the cause; advanced imaging |
Features that make a curve atypical and call for MRI of the neural axis: a left thoracic curve, a short sharp curve, rapid progression, onset under age 10, pain (especially at night), abnormal abdominal reflexes, cavus foot or other neurological signs (syrinx, Chiari, tethered cord, tumor). Painful scoliosis with night pain relieved by NSAIDs suggests osteoid osteoma on the concave side near the apex (Chapter 14).
In congenital scoliosis the worst prognosis is a unilateral unsegmented bar with a contralateral hemivertebra. Because the somites form alongside the kidneys and heart, renal (about 20 to 30 percent), cardiac and intraspinal anomalies are common and must be screened.
Measuring the curve: the Cobb method
The Cobb method is the standard measurement. First identify the end vertebrae: the most tilted vertebrae at the top and bottom of the curve, those whose end plates tilt most toward the concavity. Draw a line along the superior end plate of the upper end vertebra and along the inferior end plate of the lower end vertebra. If the end plates are hard to see, the tops or bottoms of the pedicles may be used. Then draw perpendiculars to those two lines; the angle where the perpendiculars intersect equals the Cobb angle (with large curves you can measure the angle between the end plate lines directly). The measurement error between observers is about 3 to 5 degrees, so a change must exceed about 5 degrees to count as true progression. The apical vertebra is the most horizontal and most laterally displaced vertebra (or disc) in the curve, and it shows the most rotation.
Rotation is graded by the Nash Moe method, by how far the convex side pedicle migrates toward the midline.
Skeletal maturity: the Risser sign
The Risser sign grades ossification of the iliac crest apophysis, which advances from the ASIS posteriorly: 0 none, 1 to 4 by quarters, 5 fused to the ilium (skeletal maturity). Peak growth occurs before Risser 1, near triradiate closure and before menarche.
Predicting progression
Progression risk rises with larger curves, Risser 0 to 1, premenarchal status, female sex and thoracic or double curves: a 20 to 29 degree curve progresses in about two thirds at Risser 0 to 1 versus about one quarter at Risser 2 to 4. After maturity, thoracic curves over about 50 degrees progress about 1 degree a year.
| Cobb angle (skeletally immature) | Usual recommendation | Follow up interval |
|---|---|---|
| Under 10 degrees | Spinal asymmetry, not scoliosis; reassure, recheck clinically | Clinical recheck as growth continues |
| 10 to 25 degrees | Observation; exercise and conservative care may be used; document Risser grade | Every 4 to 6 months with standing film during growth spurt |
| 25 to 40 or 45 degrees with Risser 0 to 2 | Orthopedic referral for bracing (also if a curve over 20 degrees has progressed by more than 5 degrees) | Per orthopedist |
| Over 40 to 50 degrees | Surgical consultation | Per surgeon |
| Any curve with red flags (pain, neurological signs, left thoracic, rapid change) | MRI and referral regardless of size | Prompt |
Bracing (worn roughly 13 or more hours a day) reduces progression to surgical size but does not permanently correct a curve. Chiropractic care may help pain and function but has not been shown to halt progression, so a progressing curve in a growing child calls for referral for bracing assessment. Use PA projection and minimal views to limit radiation in serial films.
Reasoning: This is a typical adolescent idiopathic scoliosis, but the combination of a curve over 25 degrees, Risser 0 and premenarchal status puts her at high risk of progression during the coming growth spurt. Recommend referral to an orthopedic scoliosis specialist for bracing assessment now. Supportive care and exercises can continue alongside, but observation alone or manipulation alone would not be appropriate. If she had night pain, a left thoracic curve or abnormal abdominal reflexes, MRI of the neural axis would be added.
Scoliosis is a curve of 10 degrees or more by Cobb. Measure from the most tilted end plates, add a Risser grade, and decide by size and maturity: observe 10 to 25 degrees, refer for bracing at 25 to 40 degrees in a growing child, refer for surgery over about 45 to 50 degrees. Atypical features (left thoracic, pain, neurological signs, rapid change, young age) call for MRI regardless of size.
Section 4Skeletal trauma
Who needs films after neck trauma
Two validated rules decide whether an alert, stable adult needs cervical imaging. NEXUS clears the neck if there is no posterior midline tenderness, no focal deficit, normal alertness, no intoxication and no distracting injury. The Canadian C spine rule mandates imaging for age 65 or older, a dangerous mechanism (fall from 3 feet or 5 stairs, axial load, high speed or rollover crash, ejection, bicycle collision) or extremity paresthesias, and otherwise requires that the patient can actively rotate 45 degrees each way. In hospitals, CT has replaced plain films for significant trauma; in the office, recognize instability and transfer rather than image and treat.
The three column concept
The Denis three column model divides the thoracolumbar spine into the anterior column (anterior longitudinal ligament, anterior two thirds of the body and annulus), the middle column (posterior third of the body and annulus, posterior longitudinal ligament) and the posterior column (pedicles, facets, laminae, spinous processes and the posterior ligament complex). Injury to two or more columns, and in particular any injury involving the middle column, is considered unstable. Newer systems (TLICS and the AO classification) also weigh neurological status and the integrity of the posterior ligament complex, but the three column model remains the board standard.
Upper cervical fractures
- Jefferson fracture: a burst of the C1 ring from axial load (diving, a blow to the vertex). On the open mouth view the C1 lateral masses overhang C2; a combined overhang over about 7 mm (rule of Spence) implies transverse ligament rupture and instability. An isolated posterior arch fracture from hyperextension is stable but must be separated from a congenital cleft.
- Odontoid (dens) fractures, Anderson and D'Alonzo: type I an avulsion of the tip (rare, usually stable); type II through the base of the dens (the most common and the most prone to nonunion because of poor blood supply, especially in the elderly after a simple fall); type III extending into the body of C2 (better union). Clues on the lateral film include anterior or posterior tilt of the dens, disruption of the Harris ring (the ring of cortex projected over the body of C2, broken in type III) and prevertebral swelling.
- Hangman fracture (traumatic spondylolisthesis of the axis): bilateral fractures through the pars interarticularis of C2 from hyperextension with axial loading, typically a deceleration crash with the chin striking the dashboard. The lateral film shows lucent lines through the C2 pedicles, anterior slip of the C2 body and disruption of the spinolaminar line at C2 (the posterior cervical line of Swischuk helps separate it from pediatric pseudosubluxation). The canal widens, so the cord is often spared.
Lower cervical fractures and dislocations
| Injury | Mechanism | Radiographic hallmark | Stability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clay shoveler fracture | Forced flexion or muscle avulsion | Oblique avulsion of a spinous process, C7 most often (then C6, T1); ghost spinous on AP | Stable |
| Simple wedge compression | Flexion | Anterior body height loss, intact posterior wall | Usually stable |
| Flexion teardrop | Severe flexion with axial load (diving) | Large anteroinferior body fragment, posterior body displaced into canal, facet widening | Highly unstable; anterior cord syndrome |
| Extension teardrop | Hyperextension, often C2 in elderly | Small triangular avulsion of the anteroinferior corner, fragment taller than wide | Stable in flexion, unstable in extension |
| Unilateral facet dislocation | Flexion with rotation | Anterolisthesis about 25 percent of body width; bow tie sign of facets on lateral; rotated spinous on AP | Usually stable but needs reduction |
| Bilateral facet dislocation | Severe flexion | Anterolisthesis 50 percent or more, perched or locked facets | Unstable; high cord injury rate |
A fragment from the anteroinferior corner of a body after trauma is a teardrop fracture until proven otherwise; a corticated triangle at the anterosuperior corner of a lumbar body is a limbus bone. A fused spine (ankylosing spondylitis, DISH) fractures like a long bone after minor trauma; new pain after a fall in such a patient needs CT.
Thoracic and lumbar fractures
- Compression (wedge) fracture: anterior column failure in flexion, with reduced anterior height, an intact posterior wall, a buckled anterior cortex and a dense zone of impaction below the end plate in recent fractures. Height loss over about 50 percent raises concern for posterior ligament injury.
- Burst fracture: anterior and middle column failure from axial load, usually T12 to L2, with posterior height loss, retropulsion and a widened interpedicular distance on AP. All need CT.
- Chance fracture (seatbelt, flexion distraction): a horizontal fracture through spinous process, laminae, pedicles and body at T12 to L2. Up to half have intra abdominal injuries, so send to the emergency department.
- Fracture dislocation: all three columns, translational displacement, highly unstable, high rate of paraplegia.
Osteoporotic versus pathological compression fracture
Favoring osteoporosis: diffuse osteopenia, an intact posterior wall and pedicles, and a level below T6. Favoring malignancy: a destroyed pedicle, a convex posterior wall, a soft tissue mass, a level above T5 and other lytic or blastic lesions (Chapter 14). Recommend MRI and labs when features are atypical.
Pars defects and spondylolisthesis
Spondylolysis is a pars interarticularis defect, usually a fatigue fracture, in about 5 to 6 percent of people and more in athletes who hyperextend (gymnasts, linemen, fast bowlers); L5 accounts for about 85 to 90 percent. On the oblique view the posterior elements form the Scotty dog (nose transverse process, eye pedicle, neck pars, ear superior facet, front leg inferior facet, body lamina); a defect is a collar, and a slip decapitates the dog. Early stress reactions need SPECT, CT or MRI.
Spondylolisthesis is forward slip of one vertebra on the one below. Wiltse types: I dysplastic, II isthmic (pars defect), III degenerative (facet arthrosis, typically L4 to L5 in women over 50, intact pars, rarely beyond grade I), IV traumatic, V pathological and VI iatrogenic. Meyerding grading uses quarters of the lower end plate: I up to 25 percent, II to 50, III to 75, IV to 100, and V (spondyloptosis) beyond, with the inverted Napoleon hat sign on the AP view. In isthmic slips the palpable step is at the spinous process above the slipped level (its posterior arch stays behind); in degenerative slips it is at the slipped level.
Reasoning: The history and the stork test strongly suggest an acute pars stress reaction (early spondylolysis), which is often invisible on plain films in its early stage. Normal films do not exclude it. Recommend MRI (or SPECT or limited CT) to detect the stress reaction, and remove her from extension loading. Early lesions can heal with rest and, in some protocols, bracing; continuing gymnastics risks a complete defect and slip. Avoid extension thrusts at the lumbosacral junction while it heals.
Extremity fractures and dislocations
| Injury | Hallmark and view | Complication or trap |
|---|---|---|
| Anterior shoulder dislocation | Head anterior, inferior, below coracoid on AP; Y view confirms | Hill Sachs (posterolateral head impaction), Bankart (anteroinferior glenoid), axillary nerve injury |
| Posterior shoulder dislocation | Lightbulb head (fixed internal rotation), rim sign (widened glenohumeral space over 6 mm), trough line | Missed on AP alone; seizures and electrocution |
| Supracondylar humerus (child) | Posterior fat pad; anterior humeral line passes anterior to middle third of capitellum | Brachial artery and median nerve, Volkmann ischemic contracture |
| Monteggia | Proximal ulna fracture with radial head dislocation | Radiocapitellar line must hit capitellum in every view |
| Colles | Distal radius, dorsal angulation (dinner fork), FOOSH, osteoporotic women | Smith is the reverse (volar angulation); Barton involves the articular rim |
| Scaphoid | Waist fracture, often invisible initially; scaphoid (ulnar deviated PA) view | Proximal pole AVN and nonunion; snuffbox tenderness means splint and repeat films at 10 to 14 days or MRI |
| Perilunate and lunate dislocation | Lateral: lunate tipped volarly (spilled teacup); PA: piece of pie lunate | Median nerve compression; emergency reduction |
| Femoral neck | Elderly fall, shortened externally rotated limb; disrupted trabeculae, sclerotic impaction line | Intracapsular: AVN and nonunion; occult cases need MRI |
| Tibial plateau | Lateral plateau depression; lipohemarthrosis on cross table lateral | Peroneal nerve, compartment syndrome |
| Maisonneuve | Medial ankle injury with proximal fibula fracture | Syndesmosis disruption; palpate the whole fibula |
| Jones and pseudo Jones | Jones: proximal fifth metatarsal diaphysis (metaphyseal diaphyseal junction); pseudo Jones: tuberosity avulsion (peroneus brevis) | Jones has high nonunion rate; avoid weight bearing, refer |
| Lisfranc | Widening between first and second metatarsal bases; second metatarsal base not aligned with middle cuneiform; fleck sign | Frequently missed; weight bearing films |
The Ottawa ankle and knee rules limit unnecessary films (malleolar or midfoot bone tenderness at the specified sites, or inability to bear weight four steps). Every fracture needs two views at right angles, including the joints above and below for shaft injuries.
Pediatric fractures
Children's bones are more pliable, have a thick periosteum and contain open physes (growth plates), which are weaker than the ligaments. A force that would sprain an adult ligament fractures a child's physis instead. Patterns unique to children include the torus (buckle) fracture, a bulge of the cortex on the compression side of the distal radial metaphysis; the greenstick fracture, which breaks the tension side cortex and bends the compression side; and plastic bowing, a bend without a visible fracture line, most often in the forearm.
The Salter Harris classification describes physeal fractures. Type I runs straight through the physis (Straight or Slipped; often a normal film with tenderness over the plate). Type II passes through the physis and exits through the metaphysis (Above; the most common, about 75 percent; the metaphyseal fragment is the Thurston Holland fragment). Type III passes through the physis and exits through the epiphysis (Lower, below the plate; intra articular). Type IV crosses metaphysis, physis and epiphysis (Through). Type V is a crush injury of the physis (Rammed or Ruined), often recognized only later by growth arrest. The mnemonic is SALTR. Risk of growth disturbance rises from type I to V; types III and IV need anatomic reduction, often surgical.
Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) affects overweight adolescents (about 10 to 16 years) and may present only as knee pain. On the AP view Klein line along the superior neck fails to cross the epiphysis and the physis is widened; the frog leg lateral shows the slip earliest. It is bilateral in up to a third. Make the patient non weight bearing and refer urgently; no hip manipulation.
Nonaccidental trauma is suggested by metaphyseal corner fractures, posterior rib fractures, fractures of different ages, and any long bone fracture in a nonwalking infant, especially when the history does not fit. Chiropractors are mandated reporters: report to child protective services and arrange medical evaluation with a skeletal survey.
Stress fractures
A fatigue fracture is normal bone under abnormal repetitive load; an insufficiency fracture is weakened bone (osteoporosis, osteomalacia, radiation, steroids) under normal load. Plain films are often normal for 2 to 3 weeks, then show faint periosteal reaction or a sclerotic band perpendicular to the trabeculae; MRI is the best early test. Common sites are the second and third metatarsals (march fracture), tibia, calcaneus, femoral neck, pubic rami and, in elderly women, the sacrum (the H shaped or Honda sign on bone scan). High risk sites that displace or fail to heal are the tension side (superolateral) femoral neck, anterior tibial cortex, navicular and proximal fifth metatarsal diaphysis; a superolateral femoral neck stress fracture needs same day referral.
Reasoning: Knee pain with a normal knee examination in an overweight adolescent is slipped capital femoral epiphysis until proven otherwise, because hip pain refers along the obturator nerve to the knee. Order AP pelvis and frog leg lateral views of both hips; look for a Klein line that fails to cross the epiphysis and a widened, blurred physis. Make him non weight bearing on crutches and refer urgently to pediatric orthopedics for pinning. Hip manipulation is contraindicated, and the other hip must be checked because SCFE is often bilateral.
Use NEXUS or the Canadian C spine rule to decide on neck films, the three column model to judge spinal stability, and two perpendicular views for every suspected fracture. Unstable patterns (Jefferson with over 7 mm overhang, type II dens, flexion teardrop, bilateral facet dislocation, burst, Chance, fracture dislocation) and the urgent pediatric problems (SCFE, physeal fractures, nonaccidental trauma, femoral neck stress fracture) mean stop, stabilize and refer, not treat.
Section 5Soft tissue trauma signs on film
Why soft tissues are read first
A fracture line may be invisible, but the bleeding and swelling it causes usually are not. Soft tissue signs are therefore the indirect evidence of injury, and they often decide whether a normal looking film is truly normal. The habit to build is a systematic soft tissue search on every trauma film: the prevertebral space on the lateral cervical view, the fat pads of the elbow, the fat stripes of the wrist, the suprapatellar recess of the knee, the paraspinal lines of the thoracic spine and the psoas shadows of the lumbar spine.
Prevertebral soft tissue swelling in the neck
On the neutral lateral film, measure the retropharyngeal space from the anteroinferior corner of C2 to the airway and the retrotracheal space at C6. Adult upper limits are 7 mm at C2 and 22 mm at C6 (children 7 and 14 mm). Swelling suggests hemorrhage from fracture or ligament tear, but also abscess or tumor, and crying infants can mimic it. A normal width does not exclude injury because swelling can take hours to develop.
Displacement of the prevertebral fat stripe and, in the thoracic spine, bulging of the paraspinal line are other signs of hematoma.
Cervical alignment lines and the atlantodental interval
Four lines should be smooth on the lateral film: the anterior vertebral, posterior vertebral (George line; a step over about 3 mm means translation), spinolaminar and posterior spinous lines. The atlantodental interval (ADI) should be no more than 3 mm in adults and 5 mm in children; more implies transverse ligament insufficiency (trauma, rheumatoid arthritis, Down syndrome). A sagittal canal under about 12 mm (Torg Pavlov ratio under 0.8) indicates developmental stenosis.
In young children, pseudosubluxation of C2 on C3 (up to about 3 to 4 mm, normal under about age 8, confirmed by the posterior cervical line of Swischuk) and the pseudo Jefferson overhang of C1 on the open mouth view are normal.
Fat pad and fat stripe signs in the extremities
Joint fluid displaces the lucent fat around a joint. On a true lateral elbow at 90 degrees, a thin anterior fat pad is normal, but when lifted it forms a triangle, the sail sign. The posterior fat pad hides in the olecranon fossa and is never visible normally. After trauma a visible posterior fat pad means an occult intra articular fracture: a radial head fracture in adults, a supracondylar fracture in children. Treat it as a fracture (splint, repeat films in 7 to 10 days or CT).
- Pronator quadratus fat line: a thin lucent stripe on the volar aspect of the distal forearm on the lateral wrist view; bowing or obliteration suggests a distal radius fracture.
- Scaphoid (navicular) fat stripe: a lucent line parallel to the radial side of the scaphoid on the PA view; displacement or loss suggests a scaphoid fracture.
- Knee effusion: on the lateral view, the suprapatellar recess between the quadriceps fat and the anterior femoral fat widens beyond about 5 to 10 mm.
- Lipohemarthrosis: on a horizontal beam (cross table) lateral of the knee, a fluid level separates lucent fat floating on top of denser blood, the FBI sign (fat blood interface). Fat comes from the marrow, so a lipohemarthrosis means an intra articular fracture, most often of the tibial plateau, even when the fracture is not seen. It also occurs in the shoulder and hip. A vertical beam film will not show it.
- Soft tissue gas: after a penetrating wound, gas tracking along tissue planes raises concern for gas forming infection (gas gangrene) or a foreign body track and needs emergency care.
| Soft tissue sign | Where and which view | What it suggests | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prevertebral swelling | Lateral cervical: over 7 mm at C2 or 22 mm at C6 | Fracture, ligament injury, abscess | Immobilize; CT; emergency referral after trauma |
| Posterior fat pad | Lateral elbow at 90 degrees | Effusion; occult radial head (adult) or supracondylar (child) fracture | Splint, repeat film in 7 to 10 days or CT or MRI |
| Sail sign | Lateral elbow, elevated anterior fat pad | Effusion | As above |
| Lipohemarthrosis (FBI sign) | Cross table lateral knee | Intra articular fracture | CT and orthopedic referral |
| Displaced scaphoid fat stripe | PA or scaphoid view | Scaphoid fracture | Thumb spica, repeat films or MRI |
| Bowed pronator quadratus line | Lateral wrist | Distal radius fracture | Additional views, splint |
| Widened paraspinal line | AP thoracic | Hematoma from fracture (or abscess, tumor, aortic injury) | CT |
| Soft tissue gas | Any view after wound | Gas forming infection or foreign body | Emergency department |
Flexion and extension views for instability
Ligament injuries may leave a neutral film perfectly aligned, because muscle spasm holds the segments in place. Flexion and extension lateral views (dynamic or stress views) are used to uncover instability, particularly after whiplash with persistent pain, in rheumatoid arthritis, in Down syndrome, and in patients with degenerative spondylolisthesis being considered for surgery. Signs of cervical instability include:
- Horizontal translation of one vertebral body on the next of more than 3.5 mm (or more than 20 percent of the body width), measured at the posterior body line.
- Angulation between adjacent end plates that differs by more than 11 degrees from the adjacent segments (White and Panjabi criteria).
- Fanning, an abnormal widening of the interspinous distance at one level, indicating posterior ligament complex disruption.
- Loss of facet parallelism, perched facets, or a focal kyphotic angle; an ADI over 10 mm implies alar ligament disruption too.
In the lumbar spine, translation over about 4.5 mm (about 15 percent) is commonly considered abnormal.
Timing and safety matter as much as the measurements. In acute trauma, flexion and extension views are contraindicated until fracture and gross instability have been excluded by neutral films or, more often today, CT; a patient with a neurological deficit or high risk mechanism should never be asked to flex and extend. The movements must be active and patient controlled, never forced by the examiner. Early after injury, muscle guarding can prevent the motion needed to show instability, producing a false negative; so if pain persists, repeat dynamic views at about 7 to 14 days (some protocols say 2 to 3 weeks) when spasm has eased, or use MRI to look for ligament edema. Delayed instability is a classic cause of a missed injury after whiplash.
Reasoning: CT excludes fracture but not ligament injury. Translation over 3.5 mm with interspinous fanning on flexion indicates ligamentous instability at C4 to C5 from a posterior ligament complex tear, a delayed instability that was masked by spasm initially. Do not manipulate the segment. Place him in a collar for comfort and protection, order MRI, and refer to a spine surgeon promptly; surgical stabilization may be needed. Document the measurement in the report with a clear recommendation.
Read the soft tissues on every trauma film, because they reveal fractures you cannot see: 7 mm at C2 and 22 mm at C6, a visible posterior elbow fat pad, a fat fluid level on a cross table knee film. Flexion and extension views uncover ligament instability (over 3.5 mm translation or 11 degrees angulation in the neck), but only after fracture is excluded and often only after spasm has settled.
The chapter in one breath
- Spinal anomalies are failures of formation (hemivertebra, butterfly vertebra) or segmentation (block vertebra, occipitalization, unsegmented bar).
- Os odontoideum has smooth corticated margins and a hypertrophied C1 anterior arch; it is unstable and a contraindication to upper cervical thrust; a fresh type II dens fracture has sharp margins.
- A congenital block vertebra has a wasp waist and an oval foramen; infection and ankylosing spondylitis fuse without a waist.
- Count levels carefully with transitional segments (Castellvi I to IV) and report how you counted; a cervical rib comes from C7 and can cause thoracic outlet syndrome.
- Variants are corticated, bilateral and in typical locations; fractures are sharp, focal and tender.
- In DDH, the femoral head belongs in the lower inner quadrant of Hilgenreiner and Perkins lines, the acetabular index is normally 30 degrees or less, and Shenton line is unbroken; refer promptly.
- Scoliosis is 10 degrees or more by Cobb; use Risser grade and size to choose observation (10 to 25), bracing (25 to 40 in a growing child) or surgical referral (over 45 to 50); atypical curves need MRI.
- Unstable spinal injuries include Jefferson with over 7 mm overhang, type II dens, flexion teardrop, bilateral facet dislocation, burst, Chance and fracture dislocation; involve the middle column means unstable.
- A pars defect is a collar on the Scotty dog; grade slips by Meyerding quarters; early stress reactions need MRI.
- Pediatric fractures follow Salter Harris SALTR; SCFE presents as knee pain in an overweight teen; posterior rib and metaphyseal corner fractures suggest abuse.
- Stress fractures hide on early films; the tension side femoral neck stress fracture is a same day referral.
- Soft tissue signs (7 at 2, 22 at 6, posterior fat pad, FBI sign) and flexion and extension instability criteria (3.5 mm, 11 degrees) reveal injuries the bones hide.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Occipitalization | Congenital fusion of the atlas to the occiput, a failure of segmentation that loads the C1 to C2 joint and may cause late instability. |
| Os odontoideum | A smooth, corticated ossicle separate from a shortened dens; it moves with C1 and makes the atlantoaxial joint unstable. |
| Ponticulus posticus | A bony bridge over the vertebral artery groove of the posterior arch of C1, formed by ossification of the oblique atlantooccipital ligament. |
| Block vertebra | Congenital fusion of two or more vertebral bodies, recognized by a narrow waist at the level of the missing disc. |
| Klippel Feil syndrome | Congenital fusion of multiple cervical segments, associated with Sprengel deformity, renal and cardiac anomalies. |
| Hemivertebra | A vertebra with one half missing, appearing as a wedge with a single pedicle and causing a sharp congenital curve. |
| Butterfly vertebra | A vertebral body with a central sagittal cleft, seen on AP as two triangles with reciprocally shaped neighbors. |
| Spina bifida occulta | Failure of the laminae to fuse in the midline without exposure of neural tissue, most often at L5 or S1. |
| Transitional segment | A lumbosacral vertebra with features of both lumbar and sacral segments (sacralization or lumbarization), graded by Castellvi. |
| Cervical rib | An extra rib arising from C7 that may compress the brachial plexus or subclavian artery. |
| Limbus bone | A corticated triangular fragment at the anterosuperior corner of a lumbar body from disc herniation through the ring apophysis. |
| Bipartite patella | A developmental unfused superolateral patellar fragment with smooth sclerotic margins, usually bilateral. |
| Acetabular index | The angle of the acetabular roof relative to Hilgenreiner line; above about 30 degrees suggests dysplasia. |
| Shenton line | A smooth arc along the superior pubic ramus and medial femoral neck; a break means the femur has moved upward. |
| Cobb angle | The angle between the end plates of the most tilted vertebrae at the ends of a curve, the standard scoliosis measurement. |
| Risser sign | Grade 0 to 5 of iliac crest apophysis ossification, used to estimate remaining spinal growth. |
| Jefferson fracture | A burst fracture of the ring of C1 from axial load, with lateral mass overhang on the open mouth view. |
| Chance fracture | A horizontal flexion distraction fracture through the posterior elements and body, typically from a lap belt, with frequent bowel injury. |
| Spondylolysis | A defect of the pars interarticularis, seen as a collar on the Scotty dog on oblique views. |
| Meyerding grade | A scale of spondylolisthesis in quarters of the lower vertebra's end plate, grade I to IV, with grade V beyond 100 percent. |
| Salter Harris fracture | A fracture involving the growth plate, classified types I to V by its path through physis, metaphysis and epiphysis. |
| Slipped capital femoral epiphysis | Posteromedial slippage of the femoral head through the physis in an adolescent, judged with Klein line and a frog leg view. |
| Fat pad sign | Displacement of the elbow fat pads by joint fluid; a visible posterior fat pad is always abnormal. |
| Lipohemarthrosis | A fat fluid level in a joint on a horizontal beam film, indicating an intra articular fracture. |
| Atlantodental interval | The space between the anterior arch of C1 and the dens; over 3 mm in adults or 5 mm in children is abnormal. |
Check yourself
Image Interpretation III: Tumors, Miscellaneous Osteoarticular Disease and Soft Tissue
A lytic hole in a vertebra can be a harmless hemangioma, a myeloma, or a metastasis that will collapse next week; a dense vertebra can be Paget disease or prostate cancer. The board shows you the film and asks what it is, what else it could be, and how fast the patient must be seen. This chapter teaches a systematic approach to bone lesions, the hallmarks of tumors, infection, vascular and metabolic disease, and the chest and abdominal findings that turn up on spinal films, each with the recommendation you would write.
By the end of this chapter you can
- Describe a bone lesion by location, margin and zone of transition, matrix, periosteal reaction and age, and decide whether it looks aggressive.
- Recognize the benign lesions: hemangioma, osteoid osteoma, osteochondroma, enchondroma, simple and aneurysmal bone cyst, fibrous dysplasia and giant cell tumor.
- Recognize osteosarcoma, chondrosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma and multiple myeloma, and identify metastasis by the missing pedicle and by lytic or blastic pattern.
- Identify the bone signs of sickle cell disease, avascular necrosis, osteomyelitis, discitis and tuberculosis, and separate infection from tumor by the disc.
- Distinguish osteoporosis, osteomalacia, rickets, hyperparathyroidism, Paget disease, renal osteodystrophy and acromegaly by their signature signs and labs.
- Name the vertebral body patterns: picture frame, rugger jersey, H shaped, codfish, ivory and corduroy.
- Recognize lung masses, pneumothorax, pleural effusion, cardiomegaly, abdominal aortic aneurysm, renal and gallstones, and other abnormal calcifications, and choose the right urgency of referral.
Section 1Benign tumors and tumor like lesions
A systematic approach to any bone lesion
Before naming a lesion, describe it. The features that predict behavior are, in order of usefulness:
- Age of the patient: the single most powerful filter. Under 30, think of primary tumors and cysts; over 40, think first of metastasis and myeloma, whatever the lesion looks like.
- Number: multiple lytic lesions in an older adult are metastasis or myeloma until proven otherwise.
- Location: in a long bone, epiphysis (chondroblastoma, giant cell tumor after physeal closure, infection), metaphysis (most primary tumors: osteosarcoma, osteochondroma, simple bone cyst, nonossifying fibroma) or diaphysis (Ewing sarcoma, fibrous dysplasia, myeloma, lymphoma); central, eccentric or cortical. In the spine, the body (hemangioma, metastasis, myeloma, giant cell tumor, chordoma) versus the posterior elements (osteoid osteoma, osteoblastoma, aneurysmal bone cyst).
- Margin and zone of transition (Lodwick pattern): a geographic lesion with a thin sclerotic rim and a narrow zone of transition grows slowly and is usually benign. A geographic lesion without a rim is less certain (giant cell tumor, myeloma). A moth eaten pattern (multiple coalescing holes) or a permeative pattern (innumerable tiny holes with a wide, indistinct zone of transition) indicates aggressive disease: Ewing sarcoma, lymphoma, myeloma, metastasis or osteomyelitis.
- Matrix: chondroid matrix forms rings and arcs or popcorn calcification (enchondroma, chondrosarcoma); osteoid matrix is fluffy, cloudlike and dense (osteosarcoma); ground glass is fibrous dysplasia.
- Periosteal reaction: solid or thick undulating reaction means slow, benign processes; lamellated (onion skin), spiculated (sunburst or hair on end) and the Codman triangle (periosteum lifted at the edge of a mass) mean an aggressive lesion that outruns the periosteum.
- Soft tissue mass and cortical destruction favor malignancy or infection.
Benign lesions of the spine
Vertebral hemangioma is the most common benign tumor of the spine, present in roughly 10 percent of adults, usually in the thoracic or lumbar body. Thick vertical trabeculae separated by lucent vascular spaces produce the corduroy (or jailhouse, vertical striation) appearance on plain film and the polka dot appearance on axial CT. The body is normal in size and shape; the lesion is bright on both T1 and T2 MRI because of fat. Nearly all are incidental. Rarely, an aggressive hemangioma expands into the posterior elements and canal and causes cord compression, especially in pregnancy. Recommend nothing further for a typical lesion; recommend MRI only if there are neurological signs or atypical features.
Osteoid osteoma occurs from about age 10 to 25, more in males, in the femur and tibia (cortical diaphysis or metaphysis) and in the posterior elements of the spine. The hallmark is a small lucent nidus under 1.5 cm, sometimes with a central dot of calcification, surrounded by dense reactive sclerosis that may hide the nidus on plain film (CT shows it best). The history is diagnostic: night pain relieved dramatically by aspirin or NSAIDs (the nidus produces prostaglandins). In the spine it causes painful scoliosis with the lesion on the concave side near the apex. Differential: Brodie abscess (lucent tract), stress fracture (linear), osteoblastoma (nidus over 1.5 to 2 cm, less sclerosis, less NSAID response). Refer for CT guided radiofrequency ablation. Osteoblastoma is the larger cousin: expansile, posterior elements of the spine in about 40 percent, and it may behave aggressively.
A bone island (enostosis) is a dense focus of compact bone in the medulla, round or oval, with brush border thorny spicules blending into surrounding trabeculae. It is common in the pelvis and proximal femur, is usually under 1 cm and is "cold" or only mildly warm on bone scan. A dense lesion that is large, growing or hot on bone scan in an older adult needs workup for blastic metastasis.
Cartilage lesions
Osteochondroma (exostosis) is the most common benign bone tumor. It is a cartilage capped bony projection from the metaphysis, most often around the knee and proximal humerus, that points away from the joint. The defining feature is that the cortex and medulla of the lesion are continuous with those of the parent bone. It may be pedunculated (on a stalk) or sessile. Growth stops at skeletal maturity. Malignant transformation to chondrosarcoma occurs in under 1 percent of solitary lesions and in a few percent of hereditary multiple exostoses. Warning signs are new pain or growth after skeletal maturity, a cartilage cap thicker than about 1.5 to 2 cm on MRI, and irregular calcification in the cap. Osteochondromas also cause mechanical symptoms: bursitis, tendon snapping, nerve or vessel compression and fracture of the stalk.
Enchondroma is a medullary cartilage tumor, the most common tumor of the small bones of the hand (phalanges and metacarpals), where it is a well defined lytic lesion with endosteal scalloping, mild expansion and stippled or rings and arcs calcification. It often presents with a pathological fracture. In long bones, the distinction from low grade chondrosarcoma is critical: enchondromas are painless, small, and scallop less than two thirds of the cortical thickness. Ollier disease is multiple enchondromas; Maffucci syndrome is multiple enchondromas with soft tissue hemangiomas (phleboliths visible on film); both carry a high risk of chondrosarcoma.
Cysts and fibrous lesions
The simple (unicameral) bone cyst occurs before age 20, in the proximal humerus or proximal femur, as a central metaphyseal lytic lesion with a thin sclerotic margin and mild expansion. Its long axis parallels the shaft, and it migrates away from the physis with growth. It usually presents with fracture, and a fragment of cortex may fall to the dependent part of the fluid filled cyst: the fallen fragment sign, which is pathognomonic.
The aneurysmal bone cyst (ABC) also occurs under age 20 but is eccentric, markedly expansile and blown out, with a thin eggshell cortex and internal septations (soap bubble). In the spine it involves the posterior elements and may extend into the body. MRI shows fluid fluid levels. About a third are secondary to another lesion (giant cell tumor, chondroblastoma, osteosarcoma, especially telangiectatic osteosarcoma, which must be excluded).
The nonossifying fibroma (and its small cortical version, the fibrous cortical defect) is an eccentric, metaphyseal, lytic lesion with a scalloped, sclerotic, often multilocular border in a child or teenager, most often around the knee. It is a classic do not touch lesion that heals by sclerosis.
Fibrous dysplasia replaces medullary bone with fibrous tissue and woven bone. Lesions are long, expansile, and have a hazy ground glass matrix with a thick sclerotic margin (the rind sign). Common sites are the ribs (the most common benign rib lesion), proximal femur (where repeated microfractures produce the shepherd crook deformity), tibia, skull and facial bones (leontiasis ossea). It may be monostotic (about 70 to 80 percent) or polyostotic. McCune Albright syndrome combines polyostotic fibrous dysplasia, cafe au lait spots with irregular coast of Maine borders, and precocious puberty or other endocrinopathy.
Giant cell tumor
Giant cell tumor (GCT) occurs between about 20 and 40, after physeal closure. It is a lytic, eccentric, epiphyseal lesion that extends from the metaphysis to within about 1 cm of the subarticular bone, with a narrow zone of transition but no sclerotic margin. Sites are the distal femur, proximal tibia and distal radius; in the spine, the sacrum is classic. It is locally aggressive, recurs after curettage in a meaningful fraction, and rarely metastasizes to lung. The four rules for GCT are: open physes exclude it, it reaches the articular surface, it is eccentric, and its margin is not sclerotic.
| Lesion | Age and site | Radiographic hallmark | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hemangioma | Adults; thoracolumbar body | Corduroy vertical striations; polka dot on CT | None if typical; MRI if neurological signs |
| Osteoid osteoma | 10 to 25; femur, tibia, spinal posterior elements | Nidus under 1.5 cm with dense sclerosis; night pain eased by NSAIDs | CT; refer for ablation |
| Osteochondroma | Under 20; knee, humerus | Corticomedullary continuity, points away from joint | MRI and referral if pain or growth after maturity |
| Enchondroma | Any; hand phalanges | Lytic, rings and arcs, endosteal scalloping | Follow; refer if pain without fracture (chondrosarcoma) |
| Simple bone cyst | Under 20; proximal humerus | Central, metaphyseal, fallen fragment | Orthopedic referral, fracture care |
| Aneurysmal bone cyst | Under 20; posterior elements, long bones | Eccentric, blown out, fluid fluid levels on MRI | MRI and orthopedic oncology referral |
| Nonossifying fibroma | Children; knee | Eccentric scalloped sclerotic border | Leave alone |
| Fibrous dysplasia | Under 30; ribs, femur, skull | Ground glass, rind sign, shepherd crook | Usually observation; refer if deformity or fracture |
| Giant cell tumor | 20 to 40; distal femur, proximal tibia, distal radius, sacrum | Eccentric subarticular lytic, no sclerotic margin, closed physis | Orthopedic oncology referral |
Reasoning: Night pain relieved by NSAIDs plus a small nidus inside dense cortical sclerosis in a teenager is osteoid osteoma. The main alternatives are a stress fracture (a linear lucency and activity related pain) and a Brodie abscess (a larger lucency, often with a tract). Recommend thin section CT to confirm the nidus and refer to orthopedics or interventional radiology for radiofrequency ablation. Manipulation and soft tissue work will not change the pain, and long term NSAID use is a poor substitute for definitive treatment.
Describe before you diagnose: age, number, location, margin, matrix, periosteal reaction and soft tissue. A narrow zone of transition with a sclerotic rim in a young patient is reassuring; permeative destruction, aggressive periosteal reaction and a soft tissue mass are not. Know each benign lesion's signature (corduroy, nidus, corticomedullary continuity, rings and arcs, fallen fragment, fluid levels, ground glass, subarticular eccentric lysis) and the few that need prompt referral.
Section 2Primary malignant and metastatic disease
Why age and location decide most cases
Primary malignant bone tumors are rare; metastases are far more common than all primary bone malignancies combined in adults, and multiple myeloma is the most common primary malignancy of bone. A destructive lesion in a patient over 40 is metastasis or myeloma until proven otherwise. Primary sarcomas cluster by age: osteosarcoma and Ewing sarcoma in the second decade, chondrosarcoma after 40, and secondary osteosarcoma in older adults with Paget disease or prior radiation.
Osteosarcoma
Conventional osteosarcoma has a peak between about 10 and 25 years with a second peak in older adults (secondary to Paget disease or radiation). About half arise around the knee (distal femur, proximal tibia), then the proximal humerus, in the metaphysis. The film shows a poorly defined, mixed lytic and sclerotic lesion with cloudlike osteoid matrix, cortical destruction, a soft tissue mass containing tumor bone, and aggressive periosteal reaction: sunburst spiculation and Codman triangles. Pain that is constant and worse at night, swelling and a mass are typical; alkaline phosphatase may be raised. Lungs are the main metastatic site, so chest CT is part of staging. Variants: parosteal osteosarcoma (adults 20 to 40, a dense lobulated mass stuck to the posterior distal femur, with a thin lucent cleft between tumor and cortex; low grade) and telangiectatic osteosarcoma (lytic, mimics ABC).
Chondrosarcoma
Chondrosarcoma affects adults over about 40, in the pelvis, proximal femur, shoulder girdle and ribs. It is a lytic lesion with chondroid (rings and arcs) matrix that differs from an enchondroma by being larger (over about 5 cm), painful, by deep endosteal scalloping over two thirds of the cortical thickness, by cortical thickening or breakthrough, periosteal reaction and a soft tissue mass. Pain in a known cartilage lesion of a long bone or pelvis in an adult is a red flag. It may arise from an enchondroma or osteochondroma (secondary chondrosarcoma).
Ewing sarcoma
Ewing sarcoma is a small round blue cell tumor (EWSR1 translocation, typically t(11;22)) of children and teenagers aged about 5 to 20. It arises in the diaphysis or metadiaphysis of long bones and in flat bones (pelvis, ribs, scapula). The classic film shows a permeative lytic lesion with a wide zone of transition, lamellated (onion skin) periosteal reaction, sometimes a saucerized cortex and a large soft tissue mass out of proportion to the bone change. Because patients often have fever, raised ESR and leukocytosis, it mimics osteomyelitis; other differentials are lymphoma and Langerhans cell histiocytosis (eosinophilic granuloma, which in the spine causes vertebra plana, a uniformly flattened body in a child).
Multiple myeloma and plasmacytoma
Multiple myeloma is a malignant plasma cell proliferation in adults over about 50, presenting with bone pain (often back pain), fatigue, recurrent infections and the CRAB features: hypercalcemia, renal insufficiency, anemia and bone lesions. Laboratory clues are a very high ESR, rouleaux on the smear, a monoclonal (M) protein on serum protein electrophoresis and immunofixation, serum free light chains, and Bence Jones protein in the urine. Radiographic patterns:
- Multiple small, round, uniform, punched out lytic lesions without sclerotic rims, especially in the skull (raindrop skull), spine, ribs, pelvis and proximal long bones.
- Diffuse osteopenia with multiple compression fractures, which may be indistinguishable from osteoporosis on film (the most common presentation in the spine).
- Endosteal scalloping of long bones.
- Because myeloma begins in the vertebral body (red marrow) and lacks osteoblastic response, the pedicle is preserved until late, unlike metastasis; and bone scan is often cold (normal), so a skeletal survey, low dose whole body CT, MRI or PET CT is used instead.
A solitary plasmacytoma is a single expansile lytic lesion, often in a vertebral body or pelvis, sometimes with a soap bubble look; many progress to myeloma. POEMS syndrome is a rare sclerotic form.
Skeletal metastasis
Metastases travel in the blood to red marrow, so they favor the axial skeleton: spine (especially the thoracic and lumbar bodies, via the valveless Batson venous plexus), pelvis, ribs, skull and proximal femur and humerus. Lesions below the elbow and knee are uncommon (acral metastases suggest lung primary). The most common primaries are breast, prostate, lung, kidney and thyroid (with breast and prostate dominating), plus myeloma and lymphoma in the differential.
About 30 to 50 percent of trabecular bone must be lost before a lytic lesion is visible on plain film, so a normal film does not exclude metastasis; MRI is the most sensitive test for the spine, and bone scan screens the whole skeleton for blastic and mixed disease. The pedicle sign (winking owl sign) is the classic plain film finding: on the AP lumbar or thoracic view, each vertebra resembles an owl face with the pedicles as eyes, and destruction of one pedicle makes the owl wink. The pedicle is destroyed because the tumor extends from the posterior body into the pedicle; it is often the first visible sign. Other signs are a collapsed body with a convex posterior border, an ill defined lytic area in a body, a soft tissue mass and, typically, a preserved disc space (tumors spare the disc, infection destroys it).
| Pattern | Typical primaries | Film appearance | Differential |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purely lytic | Lung, kidney, thyroid, breast (often), myeloma | Ill defined holes, cortical destruction, collapse | Myeloma, infection, osteoporotic fracture |
| Lytic and expansile (blow out) | Kidney and thyroid | Bubbly expanded bone, vascular | Plasmacytoma, ABC, GCT |
| Blastic (sclerotic) | Prostate (men), breast after treatment, carcinoid, bladder | Round dense foci or diffuse sclerosis; ivory vertebra | Paget disease, bone islands, lymphoma, osteopetrosis |
| Mixed | Breast, lung, cervix | Lytic and sclerotic areas together | Treated metastasis, Paget disease |
The ivory vertebra (a uniformly dense body of normal size) has a short differential: blastic metastasis (prostate, breast), Hodgkin lymphoma and Paget disease. Paget disease enlarges the body and thickens its cortex (picture frame), whereas metastasis and lymphoma do not enlarge it; anterior scalloping suggests lymphoma. Low grade infection and osteoid forming tumors are rare causes.
Chordoma, from notochord remnants, is the most common primary malignant tumor of the sacrum in adults (the sacrococcygeal region and the clivus are the classic sites): a midline destructive sacral lesion with a large soft tissue mass and amorphous calcification, often presenting with long standing low back or coccyx pain and later bowel or bladder change. Lymphoma of bone produces permeative destruction with a soft tissue mass, often with surprisingly preserved cortex.
Writing the recommendation for a suspicious lesion
For a lesion that looks aggressive, the report should say so in plain words, give the differential in order, and recommend the next steps: MRI with contrast of the region, laboratory work (CBC, ESR or CRP, calcium, alkaline phosphatase, serum protein electrophoresis with free light chains, PSA in men), chest imaging, and prompt referral to the primary physician or oncology. Urgency rises sharply with neurological findings: new weakness, sensory level, or bowel and bladder change in a patient with known or suspected cancer means metastatic spinal cord compression, an emergency that needs same day MRI and corticosteroids. Manipulation of an involved segment is contraindicated; a pathological fracture can follow a modest force.
Reasoning: A missing pedicle (winking owl) plus multiple sclerotic foci in a man with prior prostate cancer indicates metastatic disease with mixed lytic and blastic lesions. The night pain and constant character fit. Do not manipulate. Recommend MRI of the whole spine, a PSA, CBC, calcium and alkaline phosphatase, and a prompt referral to his oncologist within days. Warn him to seek emergency care immediately if leg weakness, numbness in the saddle area, or bladder or bowel changes develop, because cord or cauda equina compression requires same day treatment.
Over 40, a destructive bone lesion is metastasis or myeloma until proven otherwise. Look for the missing pedicle, preserved disc, convex posterior wall and soft tissue mass. Know the age and site signatures of osteosarcoma (teens, knee, sunburst), Ewing sarcoma (child, diaphysis, onion skin, mimics infection), chondrosarcoma (over 40, pelvis, painful rings and arcs) and myeloma (punched out holes, cold bone scan, M protein). Report aggressive lesions clearly and refer promptly; neurological signs make it an emergency.
Section 3Hematologic, vascular and infectious disease
Sickle cell disease and other anemias
In sickle cell disease, sickled cells occlude small vessels, causing bone infarcts, while chronic hemolysis drives marrow hyperplasia. The radiographic signs follow from these two processes:
- H shaped vertebrae (Lincoln log vertebrae): square central depressions of the end plates from infarction of the central end plate supplied by end arteries, with the periphery spared. This is nearly pathognomonic.
- Avascular necrosis of the femoral and humeral heads, often bilateral.
- Bone infarcts in the medullary cavity: serpiginous, sclerotic, calcified borders in the metaphysis and diaphysis.
- Dactylitis (hand foot syndrome) in infants, with periosteal reaction of the small tubular bones.
- Osteomyelitis, where Salmonella is unusually common (though Staphylococcus aureus remains frequent).
- Marrow expansion: osteopenia, widened medullary spaces, and in the skull a widened diploic space with hair on end striations, more marked in thalassemia major, which also causes rodent facies, obliterated sinuses and paraspinal masses from extramedullary hematopoiesis.
Avascular necrosis and the osteochondroses
Avascular necrosis (AVN, osteonecrosis) of the femoral head results from interrupted blood supply. Remember the causes with ASEPTIC: alcohol and AIDS, steroids and SLE, sickle cell, pancreatitis, trauma (femoral neck fracture, hip dislocation), idiopathic (Legg Calve Perthes), infection, caisson disease (dysbaric) and Gaucher disease. Patients present with groin pain and painful internal rotation. Radiographic stages (Ficat and Arlet style): stage I normal film (MRI positive with the double line sign), stage II mottled sclerosis and lucency with a preserved round head, stage III the crescent sign (a subchondral lucent line that marks collapse of the necrotic segment) and flattening, stage IV secondary osteoarthritis with joint space loss. MRI is the most sensitive test and should be ordered for a high risk patient with hip pain and normal films; early referral matters because core decompression works only before collapse.
The osteochondroses are AVN of a growth center in children and adolescents:
| Eponym | Site and patient | Film findings | Key management point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legg Calve Perthes | Femoral capital epiphysis; boys 4 to 8 | Small dense epiphysis, subchondral crescent, fragmentation, flattening; widened medial joint space (Waldenstrom) | Pediatric orthopedics; limit impact; contain the head |
| Kienbock | Lunate; adults 20 to 40, short ulna (negative ulnar variance) | Sclerotic, then collapsed lunate | Hand surgeon |
| Freiberg | Second metatarsal head; adolescent girls | Flattened, sclerotic metatarsal head | Offloading, podiatry or orthopedics |
| Kohler | Tarsal navicular; boys 3 to 7 | Small, dense, flattened navicular | Self limited |
| Preiser | Scaphoid, often after fracture | Sclerotic proximal pole | Hand surgeon |
| Osgood Schlatter | Tibial tubercle apophysis; active adolescents | Fragmented tubercle, soft tissue swelling of patellar tendon | Activity modification; clinical diagnosis |
| Scheuermann | Thoracic spine; adolescents | Three or more adjacent vertebrae wedged 5 degrees or more, Schmorl nodes, irregular end plates, kyphosis over 40 to 45 degrees | Bracing if progressive and immature; refer large curves |
Osteomyelitis
Hematogenous osteomyelitis in children lodges in the metaphysis, where slow flow in looping capillaries favors bacterial seeding; Staphylococcus aureus is the most common organism at all ages. Adults more often have spinal infection or contiguous spread (diabetic foot ulcers, open fractures, surgery). The key radiographic fact is the delay: bone destruction is not visible for about 10 to 14 days. The sequence is deep soft tissue swelling with loss of fat planes (days), then ill defined metaphyseal lysis and periosteal reaction (1 to 2 weeks), then in chronic infection a sequestrum (a dense fragment of dead bone), an involucrum (a shell of new periosteal bone around it) and a cloaca (an opening through which pus drains). A Brodie abscess is a subacute, well walled off lucency with a sclerotic rim, often with a serpiginous tract toward the physis. MRI is the best early test; ESR and CRP are raised. Septic arthritis is an emergency, with joint aspiration the key test; in a child, fever, refusal to bear weight, ESR over 40 and WBC over 12,000 (Kocher criteria) predict septic arthritis rather than transient synovitis.
Discitis and vertebral osteomyelitis
In adults, spinal infection usually starts at the vertebral end plate and spreads across the disc to the next vertebra (spondylodiscitis). Risk factors are age over 50, diabetes, intravenous drug use, immune suppression, recent urinary tract infection, endocarditis and spinal procedures. Patients have constant, severe back pain, often fever (absent in up to half), and a very high ESR and CRP. The radiographic sequence:
- First, disc space narrowing (within the first 2 to 3 weeks).
- Then loss of the end plate cortical line and erosion of the adjacent end plates on both sides of the disc.
- Later, destruction of the bodies, paraspinal soft tissue swelling and, with healing, reactive sclerosis and eventual bony fusion.
The defining contrast with tumor is the disc: infection crosses and destroys it, while metastasis and myeloma usually spare it. Degenerative disc disease narrows the disc too, but the end plates stay sharp and sclerotic, with osteophytes and often a vacuum phenomenon (gas virtually excludes infection). Recommend urgent MRI with contrast, ESR, CRP, CBC and blood cultures, and same day medical referral; neurological deficit or sepsis means emergency department. In children, discitis presents as refusal to walk or sit, or back or abdominal pain, and the disc space narrows a few weeks later.
Tuberculous spondylitis (Pott disease)
Spinal tuberculosis favors the thoracolumbar junction and lower thoracic spine. It begins in the anterior vertebral body, spreads beneath the anterior longitudinal ligament to involve multiple contiguous (and sometimes skip) levels, causes anterior wedging and collapse with a sharp angular kyphosis (gibbus), and forms a large paraspinal (cold) abscess that may calcify and track along the psoas into the groin. Compared with pyogenic infection, it is slower (months), the disc is relatively preserved early, sclerosis is less, and constitutional symptoms (weight loss, night sweats) are prominent. Risk groups include immigrants from endemic areas, people with HIV and the incarcerated. Peripheral tuberculous arthritis shows Phemister triad: juxta articular osteoporosis, peripheral (marginal) erosions and gradual joint space narrowing (pyogenic arthritis narrows the joint rapidly). Refer for MRI, chest film, interferon gamma release assay or skin test, and infectious disease care.
Reasoning: Constant pain, risk factors, recent infection, low grade fever and a narrowed disc with loss of the end plate lines on both sides spell pyogenic spondylodiscitis. Degeneration would leave the end plates sharp and sclerotic; metastasis would usually spare the disc. Order ESR, CRP, CBC and blood cultures, and arrange same day medical referral with MRI with contrast; neurological signs or sepsis would mean the emergency department. No manipulation of the infected segment.
Vascular and hematologic disease leaves signature shapes: H shaped vertebrae in sickle cell disease, crescent sign and flattening in AVN, fragmentation of growth centers in the osteochondroses. Infection lags 10 to 14 days on film, so MRI and inflammatory markers come first. In the spine, infection crosses and destroys the disc; tumor spares it; tuberculosis spreads under ligaments with a large cold abscess and gibbus.
Section 4Nutritional, metabolic and endocrine disease
Osteoporosis
Osteoporosis is a reduced quantity of normally mineralized bone. Plain film is insensitive: about 30 to 50 percent of bone mass must be lost before it looks osteopenic, so the diagnosis rests on DXA (T score of minus 2.5 or lower at the spine, hip or forearm; minus 1.0 to minus 2.5 is osteopenia) or on a fragility fracture. The film shows increased radiolucency, thin pencil line cortices, loss of horizontal trabeculae with accentuated vertical trabeculae (which can mimic hemangioma, but the body is uniformly involved), the empty box look, and fractures: wedge fractures in the thoracic spine (producing a dowager hump), biconcave (codfish) vertebrae in the lumbar spine, and fractures of the hip, distal radius and sacrum. Secondary causes to consider are glucocorticoids, hyperthyroidism, hyperparathyroidism, hypogonadism, malabsorption, myeloma, and immobilization. Steroid induced osteoporosis often shows dense marginal condensation of the end plates.
Before you call it osteoporosis in an older adult, exclude myeloma and metastasis (SPEP, calcium, CBC) when there are atypical features. Recommend DXA, a basic metabolic workup, vitamin D, and medical management, and modify manipulative technique (low force, no long lever thrusts) in proportion to bone fragility.
Osteomalacia and rickets
Osteomalacia is inadequate mineralization of osteoid in adults, from vitamin D deficiency (poor sun, malabsorption, liver or kidney disease) or phosphate wasting. Labs show low or normal calcium, low phosphate, high alkaline phosphatase, low 25 hydroxy vitamin D and raised PTH. The film shows osteopenia with blurred, fuzzy trabeculae and the hallmark Looser zones (pseudofractures, Milkman syndrome): bilateral, symmetric, transverse lucent bands with sclerotic margins running perpendicular to the cortex, typically at the medial femoral neck, pubic rami, axillary border of the scapula, ribs and posterior proximal ulna. Severe cases cause bowing, protrusio acetabuli, basilar invagination and codfish vertebrae.
Rickets is the same defect in children, expressed at the growth plate, which widens because cartilage fails to calcify. The signs are widened physes, cupping, fraying and splaying of the metaphyses (best seen at the wrist and knee), bowing of the legs once walking, the rachitic rosary (enlarged costochondral junctions), Harrison groove, frontal bossing and delayed fontanelle closure. Refer to pediatrics for laboratory confirmation and treatment.
Hyperparathyroidism and renal osteodystrophy
Primary hyperparathyroidism (usually a parathyroid adenoma) causes high calcium, low phosphate and high PTH ("stones, bones, groans and psychiatric overtones"). The pathognomonic film sign is subperiosteal bone resorption along the radial aspect of the middle phalanges of the index and middle fingers. Others are resorption of the distal clavicles, phalangeal tufts (acro osteolysis), the medial proximal tibia and the sacroiliac joints (which can look widened); salt and pepper skull from trabecular resorption; brown tumors (osteoclastomas, lytic expansile lesions that heal after treatment); loss of the lamina dura around teeth; chondrocalcinosis; and nephrocalcinosis or kidney stones.
Renal osteodystrophy is the bone disease of chronic kidney disease, combining secondary hyperparathyroidism (subperiosteal resorption, brown tumors less often), osteomalacia or rickets, osteosclerosis and soft tissue and vascular calcification. The classic spinal sign is the rugger jersey spine: broad bands of sclerosis under each end plate with lucent centers, like the horizontal stripes of a rugby shirt. Contrast this with the sharper, thinner end plate sclerosis of the sandwich vertebra in osteopetrosis.
Paget disease
Paget disease of bone is disordered remodeling with excessive osteoclastic resorption followed by chaotic osteoblastic formation, in adults over about 55, more often men, and of northern European ancestry. The pelvis is most commonly involved, then the spine, skull, femur and tibia; it may be monostotic or polyostotic. It runs in three phases: lytic (osteoporosis circumscripta of the skull; the blade of grass or flame shaped advancing lucent front in a long bone, which starts at the end of the bone and moves toward the shaft), mixed (the most common at diagnosis) and blastic (cotton wool skull, ivory vertebra). Hallmarks in every phase are bone enlargement, cortical thickening and coarsened trabeculae. In the spine the enlarged body has a thick cortical rim, the picture frame vertebra; in the pelvis there is thickening of the iliopectineal line and trabeculae. Complications include bowing and banana (transverse) fractures on the convex side, basilar invagination, deafness from skull involvement, spinal stenosis, high output heart failure, secondary osteoarthritis, and sarcomatous degeneration (under 1 percent; suspect it when pain changes or a lytic area appears). Labs show a markedly high alkaline phosphatase with normal calcium and phosphate. Refer for medical management (bisphosphonates) when symptomatic or at risk sites are involved.
Acromegaly
Acromegaly (growth hormone excess after physeal closure, usually a pituitary adenoma) causes soft tissue and bone overgrowth: heel pad thickness over about 23 mm in men (about 21.5 mm in women), spade shaped phalangeal tufts with widened bases, widened joint spaces early (cartilage hypertrophy) and premature osteoarthritis later, an enlarged sella turcica, frontal bossing, enlarged sinuses, prognathism, increased vertebral body size with posterior vertebral scalloping and thickened skin. Before physeal closure the same excess produces gigantism. Refer to endocrinology (IGF 1, glucose suppression test, pituitary MRI).
| Condition | Calcium | Phosphate | Alkaline phosphatase | Signature film sign |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Osteoporosis | Normal | Normal | Normal | Thin cortices, wedge and codfish vertebrae |
| Osteomalacia or rickets | Low or normal | Low | High | Looser zones; cupped, frayed metaphyses in children |
| Primary hyperparathyroidism | High | Low | Normal or high | Radial middle phalanx subperiosteal resorption, brown tumors |
| Renal osteodystrophy | Low or normal | High | High | Rugger jersey spine, vascular calcification |
| Paget disease | Normal | Normal | Very high | Enlarged bone, picture frame vertebra, blade of grass |
| Myeloma | Often high | Normal | Usually normal | Punched out lesions, cold bone scan |
Reasoning: Bone enlargement, a picture frame vertebra, coarse trabeculae, iliopectineal thickening, an enlarging skull and a very high alkaline phosphatase with normal calcium are Paget disease. The main differential, blastic metastasis from prostate, does not enlarge bone; a PSA is still reasonable. Refer for medical management, ask about hearing and neurological symptoms (skull and spinal stenosis), and use low force technique over involved bone. Report any new focal pain or lytic change promptly because of the small risk of sarcoma.
Match each metabolic disease to its signature: osteoporosis (thin cortices, codfish and wedge fractures, DXA T score minus 2.5 or lower), osteomalacia (Looser zones, low phosphate, high alkaline phosphatase), rickets (wide, cupped, frayed physes), hyperparathyroidism (radial middle phalanx resorption, brown tumors), renal osteodystrophy (rugger jersey, soft tissue calcification), Paget disease (enlarged bone, picture frame, blade of grass, very high alkaline phosphatase) and acromegaly (thick heel pad, spade tufts, big sella).
Section 5Soft tissue findings in the chest and abdomen
Why the chiropractor reads beyond the spine
Every thoracic, lumbar and rib film includes lung, heart, aorta, kidneys and abdomen. The person who orders the film is responsible for everything on it, and some of the most important findings on a spinal film are not in the bones: an aortic aneurysm on a lateral lumbar view, an apical lung tumor on a cervicothoracic film, a pneumothorax on a rib series. Read the soft tissues with a checklist every time: lungs and apices, pleura, heart and mediastinum, diaphragm and free air, aorta, kidneys and gallbladder region, and abnormal calcifications.
Lung masses and nodules
A pulmonary nodule is a rounded opacity up to 3 cm; a larger one is a mass, which is malignant until proven otherwise. Features favoring malignancy are size over about 8 mm to 1 cm, spiculated or lobulated margins, growth on comparison films, upper lobe location, smoking history and age over 40. Features favoring benignity are benign calcification patterns (central, diffuse, laminated or popcorn, the last typical of hamartoma) and no growth over 2 years. Comparison with old films is the single most useful step. Any new nodule or mass needs chest CT through the primary physician; follow up follows the Fleischner Society guidelines.
The Pancoast (superior sulcus) tumor deserves special attention because it presents as musculoskeletal pain. A lung cancer at the apex invades the brachial plexus (C8 and T1), the sympathetic chain and the upper ribs, producing shoulder and medial arm pain, weakness and wasting of the hand intrinsics, and Horner syndrome (ptosis, miosis, anhidrosis). On film, look for asymmetric apical pleural thickening over about 5 mm, an apical mass, and destruction of the posterior first to third ribs or adjacent vertebrae. Refer promptly for CT. Other chest findings that may appear include hilar enlargement (lymphoma, sarcoidosis, cancer), consolidation with air bronchograms (pneumonia) and a widened mediastinum (aortic injury after trauma, lymphoma, aneurysm).
Pneumothorax and pleural effusion
A pneumothorax is air in the pleural space. The sign is a thin white visceral pleural line with no lung markings beyond it, best seen at the apex on an upright film; an expiratory film makes a small one more obvious. On a supine film, air collects anteriorly and inferiorly, producing a deep, lucent costophrenic angle, the deep sulcus sign. Causes are spontaneous (tall, thin young men who smoke; emphysema), trauma (rib fractures) and procedures (acupuncture or dry needling over the chest wall can cause it). Tension pneumothorax shifts the mediastinum and trachea away from the affected side, flattens or inverts the hemidiaphragm, and causes hypotension and respiratory distress: call emergency services; this is a clinical emergency, not a film diagnosis. Do not confuse a skin fold (which extends beyond the chest and has lung markings beyond it) with a pleural line.
A pleural effusion is fluid in the pleural space. On the upright PA film, about 200 to 300 mL blunts the lateral costophrenic angle, while about 50 to 75 mL blunts the posterior angle on the lateral view, so the lateral is more sensitive. Larger effusions form a meniscus, a concave upper border higher laterally. A lateral decubitus film shows free fluid layering and detects as little as 5 to 10 mL; ultrasound is also excellent. Causes include heart failure (usually bilateral, right larger), pneumonia, malignancy (breast, lung, lymphoma), pulmonary embolism and trauma (hemothorax). A unilateral effusion with weight loss or a mass needs prompt workup.
Cardiomegaly and the mediastinum
The cardiothoracic ratio is the maximum transverse cardiac diameter divided by the maximum internal thoracic diameter on a PA upright film at full inspiration; over 0.5 indicates cardiomegaly. An AP or supine film magnifies the heart and cannot be used for this ratio. A poor inspiration also exaggerates heart size. Enlargement may reflect chamber dilation (heart failure, valvular disease, cardiomyopathy) or pericardial effusion, which gives a globular water bottle shape. Signs of congestive heart failure include cephalization of vessels, Kerley B lines, perihilar haze and bilateral effusions. A tortuous or dilated thoracic aorta and calcification of the aortic knob are common in older adults; a widened mediastinum after trauma suggests aortic injury.
Abdominal aortic calcification and aneurysm
The lateral lumbar film shows the abdominal aorta just anterior to the L1 to L4 vertebral bodies when its wall is calcified. Calcification itself is a marker of atherosclerosis and cardiovascular risk. An abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) is a diameter of 3 cm or more, usually infrarenal (below about L2), recognized when the two calcified walls are separated by more than about 3 to 3.8 cm or bow outward in a fusiform or saccular shape. Plain film cannot exclude AAA (the wall may not be calcified), so the screening test of choice is abdominal ultrasound; CT is used for surgical planning. Risk factors are age over 65, male sex, smoking, family history and hypertension; current guidance supports a one time ultrasound screen in men aged 65 to 75 who have ever smoked.
Management depends on size and symptoms:
| Finding | Clinical picture | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| Aortic calcification, normal caliber | Asymptomatic | Report; address cardiovascular risk with the primary physician |
| AAA 3.0 to 3.9 cm | Asymptomatic | Ultrasound surveillance about every 2 to 3 years; vascular referral |
| AAA 4.0 to 5.4 cm | Asymptomatic | Vascular surgery referral; surveillance every 6 to 12 months |
| AAA 5.5 cm or more (about 5.0 cm in women) or growth over 0.5 cm in 6 months | Asymptomatic | Prompt vascular surgery referral for repair |
| Any AAA with new back, flank or abdominal pain, tenderness, or hypotension | Possible expansion or rupture | Call emergency services immediately |
The classic missed diagnosis is an older male smoker with deep, boring low back pain not changed by movement, a pulsatile abdominal mass, and sometimes flank or groin pain. Avoid deep abdominal soft tissue work and lumbar rotary thrust techniques over a known aneurysm, and never treat new pain in a patient with an AAA without vascular clearance.
Kidney stones, gallstones and other calcifications
Renal and ureteral calculi: about 80 to 90 percent are radiopaque (calcium oxalate and phosphate, struvite, cystine faintly); uric acid stones are radiolucent on film but visible on CT. A staghorn calculus fills the renal pelvis and calyces, usually struvite from urease producing organisms (Proteus). Ureteral stones lie along the course of the ureter (tips of the transverse processes, over the sacroiliac joint, toward the bladder) and must be distinguished from phleboliths, which are round, pelvic, smooth and have a central lucency, and lie lower and more lateral. Renal colic presents with severe colicky flank pain radiating to the groin, restlessness and hematuria; noncontrast CT is the definitive test. Fever with an obstructing stone is a urological emergency. Nephrocalcinosis (calcification of the renal parenchyma) suggests hyperparathyroidism, medullary sponge kidney or renal tubular acidosis.
Gallstones are radiopaque on film in only about 10 to 20 percent (mostly cholesterol stones, which are lucent); ultrasound is the test of choice. They lie in the right upper quadrant, often faceted with laminated rims. A porcelain gallbladder (calcified wall) carries an increased risk of carcinoma and warrants surgical referral. Right upper quadrant or right scapular pain after fatty meals suggests biliary colic.
| Calcification | Location and look | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Pancreatic | Stippled, across L1 to L2 midline | Chronic pancreatitis (alcohol); rule out cancer |
| Phleboliths | Small round pelvic densities with lucent centers | Benign venous calcification; mimic ureteral stone |
| Calcified lymph nodes | Irregular, mottled, mesenteric or hilar | Old granulomatous disease (TB, histoplasmosis) |
| Uterine fibroid | Popcorn mass in pelvis | Benign leiomyoma |
| Costal cartilage | Along anterior rib ends | Normal aging |
| Arterial (Monckeberg) | Pipe stem tracks in small arteries of legs and pelvis | Diabetes, renal disease |
| Splenic granulomas | Multiple small dots in left upper quadrant | Old histoplasmosis |
| Rice grain calcifications | Oval densities aligned with muscle fibers | Cysticercosis |
| Myositis ossificans | Mass in muscle with peripheral (zonal) ossification 3 to 6 weeks after a contusion | Benign; separated from bone by a cleft; do not biopsy early or massage aggressively |
| Calcific tendinitis | Amorphous density above greater tuberosity | Hydroxyapatite in supraspinatus; acute painful phase with resorption |
Free intraperitoneal air (pneumoperitoneum) appears as a lucent crescent under the diaphragm on an upright chest or abdominal film, meaning a perforated viscus (ulcer, diverticulum): emergency department immediately. Dilated bowel loops with air fluid levels suggest obstruction.
Reasoning: A large abdominal aortic aneurysm with new pain, tenderness and relative hypotension suggests expansion or impending rupture, a surgical emergency with high mortality. Do not manipulate, do not send him home, and do not arrange an outpatient ultrasound. Call emergency services, keep him lying still, and communicate the findings directly to the receiving team.
Read every spinal film for its soft tissues. A mass over 3 cm, a spiculated or growing nodule, or apical thickening with arm pain needs chest CT; a pneumothorax shows a pleural line without markings beyond it; an effusion blunts the costophrenic angle; a cardiothoracic ratio over 0.5 on a PA film is cardiomegaly. Calcified aortic walls 3 cm or more apart mean an aneurysm, and pain with an aneurysm means an emergency. Most kidney stones show on film, most gallstones do not.
The chapter in one breath
- Describe every lesion by age, number, location, margin, matrix, periosteal reaction and soft tissue; a wide zone of transition and aggressive periosteal reaction mean trouble.
- Benign signatures: corduroy hemangioma, osteoid osteoma nidus with NSAID responsive night pain, osteochondroma corticomedullary continuity, enchondroma rings and arcs, fallen fragment simple cyst, blown out ABC, ground glass fibrous dysplasia, subarticular giant cell tumor.
- Over 40, a destructive lesion is metastasis or myeloma until proven otherwise; the winking owl (missing pedicle) is classic for metastasis.
- Osteosarcoma: teens, knee, sunburst and Codman triangle. Ewing: child, diaphysis, onion skin, fever. Chondrosarcoma: over 40, pelvis, painful chondroid lesion.
- Myeloma: punched out lesions, raindrop skull, cold bone scan, M protein, CRAB features.
- Lytic expansile metastases come from kidney and thyroid; blastic from prostate; ivory vertebra means blastic metastasis, lymphoma or Paget.
- Sickle cell: H shaped vertebrae, infarcts, AVN, Salmonella osteomyelitis. AVN: crescent sign means collapse; MRI first.
- Infection destroys the disc and both end plates; tumor spares the disc; tuberculosis spreads under ligaments with a gibbus and cold abscess.
- Osteomalacia: Looser zones; rickets: cupped, frayed metaphyses; hyperparathyroidism: radial middle phalanx resorption; renal osteodystrophy: rugger jersey.
- Paget: enlarged bone, picture frame, blade of grass, very high alkaline phosphatase; acromegaly: heel pad over 23 mm, spade tufts.
- Chest: pneumothorax pleural line, effusion blunted angle, cardiothoracic ratio over 0.5 on PA, Pancoast tumor at the apex.
- Abdomen: AAA 3 cm or more anterior to the lumbar spine (pain makes it an emergency), opaque kidney stones, mostly lucent gallstones, phleboliths with lucent centers.
Words worth knowing
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Zone of transition | The border between a lesion and normal bone; narrow suggests slow growth, wide suggests aggressive disease. |
| Permeative pattern | Innumerable tiny lucent holes with an indistinct border, typical of round cell tumors and infection. |
| Codman triangle | A triangle of periosteal new bone at the edge of a lesion where the periosteum is lifted by an aggressive process. |
| Sunburst reaction | Spiculated periosteal reaction radiating from bone, classic for osteosarcoma. |
| Onion skin reaction | Lamellated layers of periosteal new bone, seen with Ewing sarcoma and osteomyelitis. |
| Chondroid matrix | Rings and arcs or popcorn calcification produced by cartilage tumors. |
| Nidus | The small central lucent core of an osteoid osteoma that produces prostaglandins and pain. |
| Corduroy vertebra | Coarse vertical trabecular striations of a vertebral hemangioma. |
| Fallen fragment sign | A cortical fragment lying in the dependent part of a fluid filled simple bone cyst after fracture. |
| Ground glass matrix | A hazy, uniform density typical of fibrous dysplasia. |
| Shepherd crook deformity | Varus bowing of the proximal femur from fibrous dysplasia. |
| Winking owl sign | Absence of one pedicle on an AP spinal film, a classic sign of metastasis. |
| Ivory vertebra | A uniformly dense vertebral body; differential is blastic metastasis, lymphoma and Paget disease. |
| Batson plexus | A valveless vertebral venous network that allows pelvic and abdominal cancers to spread to the spine. |
| M protein | A monoclonal immunoglobulin detected by protein electrophoresis in myeloma. |
| Vertebra plana | A uniformly flattened vertebral body, classically eosinophilic granuloma in a child. |
| H shaped vertebra | Square central end plate depressions from infarction in sickle cell disease. |
| Crescent sign | A subchondral lucent line in the femoral head showing collapse in avascular necrosis. |
| Sequestrum | A dense fragment of dead bone within an area of chronic osteomyelitis. |
| Involucrum | A shell of living periosteal new bone surrounding a sequestrum. |
| Brodie abscess | A walled off subacute bone abscess with a lucent center and sclerotic rim. |
| Gibbus | A sharp angular kyphosis from collapse of one or more vertebrae, classic in tuberculosis. |
| Looser zone | A pseudofracture, a lucent band perpendicular to the cortex, characteristic of osteomalacia. |
| Brown tumor | A lytic expansile collection of osteoclasts and fibrous tissue in hyperparathyroidism. |
| Rugger jersey spine | Bands of sclerosis along the end plates in renal osteodystrophy. |
| Picture frame vertebra | An enlarged vertebral body with a thick cortical rim in Paget disease. |
| Blade of grass sign | The V shaped lytic advancing front of Paget disease in a long bone. |
| Cardiothoracic ratio | Heart width divided by chest width on a PA film; above 0.5 suggests cardiomegaly. |
| Deep sulcus sign | An abnormally deep lucent costophrenic angle on a supine film, indicating pneumothorax. |
| Phlebolith | A calcified pelvic venous thrombus with a central lucency, often mistaken for a ureteral stone. |
| Pancoast tumor | An apical lung cancer that invades the brachial plexus and sympathetic chain, causing arm pain and Horner syndrome. |
| Myositis ossificans | Heterotopic bone in muscle after injury, ossifying from the periphery inward. |