📖 ContentsChapter 13 · Diagnostic Imaging Interpretation
Part III Clinical Competency · Chapter 13 · Diagnostic Imaging Interpretation

Image Interpretation II: Congenital Anomalies, Variants, Scoliosis and Trauma

Half of what you see on a spine or extremity film is not disease at all: it is anatomy that formed a little differently, or a growth center that has not yet fused. The board tests whether you can tell a harmless variant from a fracture, a congenital block from a fused infected segment, and a stable injury from one that needs the emergency department today. This chapter teaches the radiographic hallmarks of congenital anomalies, variants, scoliosis and trauma, and the exact recommendation you would write in the report for each.

By the end of this chapter you can

  • Recognize occipitalization, os odontoideum and ponticulus posticus, and say which threaten stability.
  • Distinguish a congenital block vertebra from acquired fusion, and identify hemivertebra, butterfly vertebra, spina bifida, transitional segments and cervical rib.
  • Separate accessory ossicles and variants from fractures with the corticated margin rule.
  • Use Hilgenreiner, Perkins and Shenton lines and the acetabular index to evaluate DDH.
  • Measure scoliosis by Cobb, grade the Risser sign, and choose observation, bracing or surgical referral.
  • Recognize the major spinal fractures and judge stability with the three column model.
  • Grade spondylolisthesis, identify a pars defect, and name key extremity, Salter Harris and stress fractures.
  • Apply prevertebral swelling, fat pad and lipohemarthrosis signs, and read flexion and extension views for instability.

Section 1Spinal congenital anomalies and variants

Why anomalies matter on the board and in the office

An anomaly matters clinically when it does one of three things: it makes a segment unstable (os odontoideum, some occipitalizations), it overloads the neighbors (block vertebra, Klippel Feil fusion, transitional segment), or it signals other anomalies elsewhere in the body (hemivertebra with renal and cardiac defects, Klippel Feil with Sprengel deformity and renal agenesis). On the exam, an item showing an upper cervical anomaly almost always asks one of two things: what is it, or what you should do before adjusting. The answer to the second is usually flexion and extension views to assess stability, and modification or avoidance of high velocity rotary thrust at that level.

Anomalies arise from failure of formation (part of a vertebra missing: hemivertebra, butterfly vertebra, pedicle agenesis) or failure of segmentation (two vertebrae fused: block vertebra, occipitalization, unsegmented bar), the same scheme used for congenital scoliosis.

Upper cervical anomalies

Occipitalization (atlanto occipital assimilation) is fusion of the atlas to the occiput. On the lateral film the posterior arch of C1 merges with the occiput with no joint space. The C1 to C2 joint must then provide all upper cervical motion, which promotes late atlantoaxial instability; it is also associated with basilar impression and Chiari malformation. Recommend flexion and extension views, and MRI if there are long tract signs or headache with Valsalva.

Os odontoideum is a smooth, round ossicle above a hypoplastic dens, separated from C2 by a wide gap (most likely an old ununited childhood fracture). The ossicle moves with C1, so the transverse ligament no longer controls C1 on C2. It has smooth, corticated margins and the anterior arch of C1 is often enlarged and rounded from chronic stress. A type II odontoid fracture has a thin, irregular, noncorticated line and a normal sized arch; an ossiculum terminale is a small, stable unfused center at the dens tip. Os odontoideum contraindicates upper cervical thrust; recommend flexion and extension views and surgical referral, urgently if there is myelopathy.

Agenesis of the posterior arch of atlas ranges from a trivial midline cleft to complete absence; the smooth margins and an enlarged C2 spinous process separate it from fracture. Ponticulus posticus (arcuate foramen) is ossification of the oblique atlantooccipital ligament forming a bony ring over the vertebral artery groove of C1, seen in roughly 10 to 15 percent of people; it is a variant, but many clinicians modify upper cervical rotary thrust in its presence, so mention it in the report. Basilar impression (dens tip more than about 7 mm above McGregor line) may accompany occipitalization, Paget disease and rheumatoid arthritis.

Board tip. The single best discriminator between os odontoideum and an odontoid fracture is the margin: smooth and corticated means old or developmental, sharp and noncorticated means fresh. The size of the anterior arch of C1 is the second clue: it hypertrophies only after years of abnormal load.

Block vertebra and Klippel Feil syndrome

A congenital block vertebra is failure of segmentation of two or more vertebral bodies, most often at C2 to C3 and C5 to C6 in the neck and in the lumbar spine less often. The hallmarks on the lateral film are: a narrow waist at the level of the absent disc (the wasp waist sign), a rudimentary disc space that may persist as a thin sclerotic line, a combined height equal to two vertebrae plus the missing disc, fused facets and often fused spinous processes, and an enlarged intervertebral foramen that is shaped like a keyhole or oval. The segments above and below are hypermobile and degenerate early.

Acquired fusion lacks the waist: surgical fusion shows hardware or graft, ankylosing spondylitis shows syndesmophytes, juvenile idiopathic arthritis fuses facets with small bodies, and healed infection leaves an irregular sclerotic, often kyphotic fusion.

Klippel Feil syndrome is congenital fusion of multiple cervical segments; the classic triad (short neck, low hairline, restricted motion) is present in under half. It is associated with Sprengel deformity (high scapula, sometimes with an omovertebral bone), scoliosis, renal anomalies, heart disease and hearing loss, so renal ultrasound is advised. Never manipulate the fused block and treat the hypermobile adjacent levels gently.

Hemivertebra and butterfly vertebra

A hemivertebra results from failure of formation of one half of the vertebral body. On the AP film it appears as a wedge shaped body with a single pedicle, producing an abrupt lateral angulation, a short sharp scoliosis. A lateral hemivertebra causes scoliosis; a dorsal (posterior) hemivertebra, in which the anterior body fails to form, causes a sharp kyphosis (gibbus) with risk of cord compression. Hemivertebrae may be fully segmented (discs above and below, greatest growth potential), semisegmented, or incarcerated (tucked into the curve, least deforming). The extra or missing pedicle and rib count help confirm the diagnosis.

A butterfly vertebra (sagittal cleft vertebra) results from failure of fusion of the two lateral chondral centers. On the AP film the body is narrowed centrally with two triangular halves pointing toward the midline, and the adjacent end plates of the vertebrae above and below are reciprocally shaped to fill the cleft. On the lateral film it can look like a compression fracture; the AP appearance and the reciprocal deformity of the neighbors settle the question. Butterfly vertebrae are associated with Alagille syndrome and other anomalies but are usually isolated and asymptomatic.

Block vertebra (lateral) Hemivertebra (AP) Butterfly vertebra (AP) Wasp waist at the missing disc; oval enlarged foramen waist foramen one pedicle Lateral wedge, single pedicle: short, sharp congenital scoliosis central cleft reciprocal Two triangles point to midline; neighbors fill the gap; not a fracture
Figure 13.1 Three failures of development. The block vertebra (failure of segmentation) shows a waist where the disc should be; the hemivertebra and butterfly vertebra (failures of formation) are identified on the AP view by the wedge with one pedicle and by the paired triangles with reciprocally shaped neighbors.

Spina bifida and other posterior element variants

Spina bifida occulta is a midline lucent cleft where the laminae fail to unite, most often at L5 and S1, and is usually insignificant. A hair tuft, dimple or lipoma over it in a child with gait change, foot deformity or bladder symptoms suggests tethered cord and calls for MRI. Spina bifida vera (meningocele, myelomeningocele) is evident at birth with widened interpedicular distances. A knife clasp deformity is an elongated L5 spinous process that drops into an S1 cleft in extension, causing extension pain.

Agenesis of a pedicle must be distinguished from the destroyed pedicle of metastasis (Chapter 14): congenital absence shows a hypertrophied, sclerotic contralateral pedicle. A limbus bone is a corticated triangular ossicle at the anterosuperior corner of a lumbar body, formed when disc material herniates through the ring apophysis before it fuses; it is often mistaken for a teardrop fracture. Unfused apophyses at transverse, spinous or articular process tips also mimic fractures but are smoothly corticated.

Transitional segments

A lumbosacral transitional segment occurs in roughly 10 to 15 percent of people. Sacralization means L5 takes on sacral features (an enlarged transverse process forming a joint with or fusing to the sacral ala); lumbarization means S1 behaves like a lumbar vertebra with a well formed disc below it. The Castellvi classification grades the anomaly: type I is a dysplastic, enlarged transverse process (at least 19 mm tall); type II is a pseudarthrosis (a diarthrodial joint) between the transverse process and the sacrum; type III is complete bony fusion; type IV is type II on one side and type III on the other. Each type may be unilateral (a) or bilateral (b).

A unilateral type II pseudarthrosis can itself cause pain (Bertolotti syndrome), and the disc above a transitional segment degenerates early. The practical point is level counting: state how you counted (from C2 or from the lowest rib bearing vertebra) so advanced imaging and procedures use the same numbering.

Cervical rib

A cervical rib arises from the costal element of C7 (about 0.5 to 1 percent of people, often bilateral). The C7 transverse process points downward, whereas T1 transverse processes point upward and carry the first rib. A complete rib or an invisible fibrous band from an incomplete one can compress the lower trunk of the brachial plexus or the subclavian artery (thoracic outlet syndrome). Correlate with C8 to T1 findings, and refer promptly for vascular studies if there are signs of arterial compromise.

AnomalyBest view and hallmarkMain mimicHow to tell them apart
Block vertebraLateral: wasp waist, combined height, oval foramenFusion from infection or ankylosing spondylitisInfection: irregular, sclerotic, kyphotic, no waist; AS: syndesmophytes
HemivertebraAP: wedge with one pedicle, sharp scoliosisCompression fractureFracture keeps both pedicles; hemivertebra changes rib or pedicle count
Butterfly vertebraAP: two triangles, reciprocal neighborsCompression fracture on lateralAP view; reciprocal end plate shape above and below
Spina bifida occultaAP: midline lucent cleft at L5 or S1Fracture of laminaMidline, smooth, no trauma history
Transitional segmentAP: enlarged L5 transverse process joint or fusion with alaMiscounted levelsCount from C2 or rib bearing T12; state the method
Cervical ribAP: downward pointing C7 transverse process with ribNormal first ribFirst rib arises from T1 whose transverse process points upward
Case. A 34 year old office worker presents with suboccipital headaches after a minor rear end collision. Neurological examination is normal. The neutral lateral cervical film shows a smooth, rounded ossicle above a short dens and a large, rounded anterior arch of C1; the atlantodental interval is 2 mm in neutral.
Reasoning: The corticated margins and hypertrophied anterior arch point to os odontoideum, a long standing developmental lesion, not a fresh fracture. The key issue is stability, which a neutral film cannot show. Recommend flexion and extension lateral views (or dynamic imaging ordered with medical colleagues) and refer for a spine surgery opinion; any motion of the ossicle with C1 relative to C2 indicates instability. Do not perform upper cervical high velocity thrust. If she had myelopathic signs (hyperreflexia, Hoffmann sign, gait change), referral would be urgent with MRI.
Key point

Classify every spinal anomaly as a failure of formation or of segmentation, then ask three questions: is it stable, does it overload neighbors, and does it predict other anomalies? Smooth corticated margins point to development rather than injury. Upper cervical anomalies that compromise the transverse ligament (os odontoideum, Down syndrome, some occipitalizations) demand flexion and extension views before any thrust technique.

Section 2Extraspinal anomalies and variants

The corticated margin rule

The single most useful principle in this section is simple: a developmental ossicle or unfused apophysis has a smooth, rounded, completely corticated margin on all sides, and the parent bone next to it is also corticated and often shaped to receive it. An acute fracture fragment has a sharp, irregular, noncorticated edge on the fracture side, it fits like a jigsaw piece into a defect in the parent bone, and there is usually soft tissue swelling and focal tenderness. Bilateral symmetry also favors a variant; when in doubt, a comparison view of the other side is a cheap and classic answer. An old ununited fracture will eventually corticate, so history matters as well.

Accessory ossicles of the foot and ankle

Other common variants

FindingVariant featuresFracture featuresNext step if unsure
Fifth metatarsal base in a childApophysis parallel to shaftLine transverse to shaftCompare with other foot; examine for focal tenderness
Patella fragmentSuperolateral, bilateral, smoothMid patella or inferior pole, acute effusionContralateral view, check extensor function
Hallux sesamoidMedial, bilateral, larger than partner, smoothSharp edges, pieces sum to normal sizeContralateral view or MRI
Dens base lineMach band extends beyond boneLine confined to bone, displacement, swellingRepeat open mouth view with altered angle, CT
Long bone cortex lineNutrient foramen: one cortex, oblique, predictable directionBoth cortices, focal painSecond projection
Acromion lineOs acromiale on axillary view, often bilateralFracture after direct blow, swellingAxillary view, compare sides
Board tip. Three questions settle most "variant or fracture" items: is the margin corticated, is it bilateral, and is it in a textbook location for an ossicle? If all three are yes, it is a variant. If the patient has focal bony tenderness at the site after trauma, treat it as a fracture until proven otherwise.

Developmental dysplasia of the hip

Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) ranges from a shallow acetabulum to frank dislocation. Risk factors are female sex, breech presentation, first born, family history and tight swaddling; the left hip is involved more often. In the newborn, Barlow (adduction with posterior pressure) dislocates an unstable hip and Ortolani (abduction with anterior lift) reduces it with a clunk. After about 3 months these become negative, and the signs are limited abduction, a positive Galeazzi sign and asymmetric thigh folds; a walking child limps. Use ultrasound before the femoral head ossifies (about 4 to 6 months), then an AP pelvis:

Imaging depends on age. Before the femoral head ossifies (about 4 to 6 months), ultrasound is the study of choice. After that, an AP pelvis is used with these lines:

Residual adult dysplasia shows a shallow acetabulum with a lateral center edge angle under about 20 to 25 degrees and leads to early osteoarthritis. Refer any suspected DDH to pediatric orthopedics promptly; a Pavlik harness works well in the first months.

Perkins Perkins Acetabular index under 30° normal Hilgenreiner Head in lower inner quadrant Small head, upper outer Femur moved up and out Shenton arc smooth Shenton arc broken Normal hip (patient right) Dislocated hip (patient left)
Figure 13.2 Reading an infant AP pelvis for developmental dysplasia. The femoral head ossification center belongs in the lower inner quadrant formed by Hilgenreiner and Perkins lines, Shenton arc should be continuous, and the acetabular index should not exceed about 30 degrees.
Case. A 9 month old girl, born breech and first born, is brought in because her mother notices she resists diaper changes on the left. The left thigh appears shorter with the knees flexed, and left hip abduction is limited. Ortolani and Barlow are negative.
Reasoning: Negative Ortolani and Barlow tests do not exclude DDH after about 3 months; limited abduction and a positive Galeazzi sign are now the key findings, and the risk factors (female, breech, first born, left side) all fit. At 9 months the femoral head is ossified, so an AP pelvis is appropriate: expect a small left ossification center in the upper outer quadrant, an acetabular index over 30 degrees and a broken Shenton line. Refer promptly to pediatric orthopedics; this is not a case for observation or manipulation, and delay worsens the outcome.
Key point

Before calling any extremity fragment a fracture, check the margin, the opposite side and the textbook location of ossicles: corticated, bilateral and typically placed means variant. Know the infant hip lines cold (Hilgenreiner, Perkins, acetabular index, Shenton), remember that Ortolani and Barlow fade after 3 months, and refer any suspected DDH promptly because early treatment works and late treatment often does not.

Section 3Scoliosis

Definitions and classification

Scoliosis is a lateral curvature of the spine of 10 degrees or more measured by the Cobb method on an upright AP or PA film. It is a three dimensional deformity: the vertebrae also rotate, with the bodies turning toward the convexity and the spinous processes toward the concavity, which is why the ribs form a posterior hump on the convex side during the Adams forward bend test. Curves are named for the side of the convexity (a right thoracic curve is convex to the right) and by the apex: cervical (apex C1 to C6), cervicothoracic (C7 to T1), thoracic (T2 to T11), thoracolumbar (T12 to L1), lumbar (L2 to L4) and lumbosacral (L5 to S1).

A structural curve has fixed rotation and does not correct on side bending; a nonstructural (functional) curve is flexible and has a cause outside the spine, such as a leg length inequality, muscle spasm or a painful lesion. A functional curve from leg length difference disappears when the patient sits or when the short leg is lifted. Curves are also called major (largest, most structural) and minor or compensatory.

TypeShare and featuresRadiographic clueWhat to do
Adolescent idiopathic (age 10 to skeletal maturity)About 80 percent of structural scoliosis; girls with progressive curves outnumber boys about 7 to 1Typically right thoracic, smooth, normal vertebraeMeasure, grade maturity, observe or brace or refer by size
Juvenile and infantile idiopathic (under 10)Higher progression risk; infantile more often left thoracic in boysVariable curvesOrthopedic referral; MRI often advised
CongenitalFailure of formation (hemivertebra), segmentation (unsegmented bar) or bothAbnormal vertebrae, short sharp curveOrthopedics; screen kidneys and heart; MRI for cord anomalies
NeuromuscularCerebral palsy, muscular dystrophy, spinal muscular atrophy, myelomeningoceleLong C shaped curve, pelvic obliquityManage with medical team
Degenerative (de novo adult)Over 50, lumbar, from asymmetric disc and facet degenerationLateral listhesis, osteophytes, apex L2 to L3Conservative care; refer if progressive neurological deficit
Secondary or symptomaticOsteoid osteoma, infection, tumor, disc herniation (sciatic scoliosis)Painful, rigid curve, often atypicalFind the cause; advanced imaging

Features that make a curve atypical and call for MRI of the neural axis: a left thoracic curve, a short sharp curve, rapid progression, onset under age 10, pain (especially at night), abnormal abdominal reflexes, cavus foot or other neurological signs (syrinx, Chiari, tethered cord, tumor). Painful scoliosis with night pain relieved by NSAIDs suggests osteoid osteoma on the concave side near the apex (Chapter 14).

In congenital scoliosis the worst prognosis is a unilateral unsegmented bar with a contralateral hemivertebra. Because the somites form alongside the kidneys and heart, renal (about 20 to 30 percent), cardiac and intraspinal anomalies are common and must be screened.

Measuring the curve: the Cobb method

The Cobb method is the standard measurement. First identify the end vertebrae: the most tilted vertebrae at the top and bottom of the curve, those whose end plates tilt most toward the concavity. Draw a line along the superior end plate of the upper end vertebra and along the inferior end plate of the lower end vertebra. If the end plates are hard to see, the tops or bottoms of the pedicles may be used. Then draw perpendiculars to those two lines; the angle where the perpendiculars intersect equals the Cobb angle (with large curves you can measure the angle between the end plate lines directly). The measurement error between observers is about 3 to 5 degrees, so a change must exceed about 5 degrees to count as true progression. The apical vertebra is the most horizontal and most laterally displaced vertebra (or disc) in the curve, and it shows the most rotation.

Rotation is graded by the Nash Moe method, by how far the convex side pedicle migrates toward the midline.

Superior end plate, upper end vertebra Inferior end plate, lower end vertebra Apical vertebra (most rotated) Cobb angle Thoracic scoliosis, schematic PA view Risser sign 1 2 3 4 ASIS PSIS Ossifies from ASIS to PSIS; 0 none, 1 to 4 by quarter, 5 fused to ilium
Figure 13.3 The Cobb method. Lines along the most tilted end plates at each end of the curve, or their perpendiculars, form the Cobb angle. The inset shows the Risser sign: the iliac crest apophysis ossifies from anterolateral to posteromedial, graded by quarters.

Skeletal maturity: the Risser sign

The Risser sign grades ossification of the iliac crest apophysis, which advances from the ASIS posteriorly: 0 none, 1 to 4 by quarters, 5 fused to the ilium (skeletal maturity). Peak growth occurs before Risser 1, near triradiate closure and before menarche.

Predicting progression

Progression risk rises with larger curves, Risser 0 to 1, premenarchal status, female sex and thoracic or double curves: a 20 to 29 degree curve progresses in about two thirds at Risser 0 to 1 versus about one quarter at Risser 2 to 4. After maturity, thoracic curves over about 50 degrees progress about 1 degree a year.

Cobb angle (skeletally immature)Usual recommendationFollow up interval
Under 10 degreesSpinal asymmetry, not scoliosis; reassure, recheck clinicallyClinical recheck as growth continues
10 to 25 degreesObservation; exercise and conservative care may be used; document Risser gradeEvery 4 to 6 months with standing film during growth spurt
25 to 40 or 45 degrees with Risser 0 to 2Orthopedic referral for bracing (also if a curve over 20 degrees has progressed by more than 5 degrees)Per orthopedist
Over 40 to 50 degreesSurgical consultationPer surgeon
Any curve with red flags (pain, neurological signs, left thoracic, rapid change)MRI and referral regardless of sizePrompt

Bracing (worn roughly 13 or more hours a day) reduces progression to surgical size but does not permanently correct a curve. Chiropractic care may help pain and function but has not been shown to halt progression, so a progressing curve in a growing child calls for referral for bracing assessment. Use PA projection and minimal views to limit radiation in serial films.

Board tip. Rotation in scoliosis turns the vertebral bodies toward the convexity and the spinous processes toward the concavity. The rib hump is on the convex side. If an item shows a left thoracic curve in a teenager, the expected answer is MRI to search for an underlying neural axis cause.
Case. A 12 year old girl, premenarchal, is found to have a right thoracic rib hump on a school screening. The standing PA film shows a right thoracic curve from T5 to T12 measuring 28 degrees by Cobb, Risser 0, with normal vertebral shapes. She has no pain and a normal neurological examination.
Reasoning: This is a typical adolescent idiopathic scoliosis, but the combination of a curve over 25 degrees, Risser 0 and premenarchal status puts her at high risk of progression during the coming growth spurt. Recommend referral to an orthopedic scoliosis specialist for bracing assessment now. Supportive care and exercises can continue alongside, but observation alone or manipulation alone would not be appropriate. If she had night pain, a left thoracic curve or abnormal abdominal reflexes, MRI of the neural axis would be added.
Key point

Scoliosis is a curve of 10 degrees or more by Cobb. Measure from the most tilted end plates, add a Risser grade, and decide by size and maturity: observe 10 to 25 degrees, refer for bracing at 25 to 40 degrees in a growing child, refer for surgery over about 45 to 50 degrees. Atypical features (left thoracic, pain, neurological signs, rapid change, young age) call for MRI regardless of size.

Section 4Skeletal trauma

Who needs films after neck trauma

Two validated rules decide whether an alert, stable adult needs cervical imaging. NEXUS clears the neck if there is no posterior midline tenderness, no focal deficit, normal alertness, no intoxication and no distracting injury. The Canadian C spine rule mandates imaging for age 65 or older, a dangerous mechanism (fall from 3 feet or 5 stairs, axial load, high speed or rollover crash, ejection, bicycle collision) or extremity paresthesias, and otherwise requires that the patient can actively rotate 45 degrees each way. In hospitals, CT has replaced plain films for significant trauma; in the office, recognize instability and transfer rather than image and treat.

The three column concept

The Denis three column model divides the thoracolumbar spine into the anterior column (anterior longitudinal ligament, anterior two thirds of the body and annulus), the middle column (posterior third of the body and annulus, posterior longitudinal ligament) and the posterior column (pedicles, facets, laminae, spinous processes and the posterior ligament complex). Injury to two or more columns, and in particular any injury involving the middle column, is considered unstable. Newer systems (TLICS and the AO classification) also weigh neurological status and the integrity of the posterior ligament complex, but the three column model remains the board standard.

Upper cervical fractures

Lower cervical fractures and dislocations

InjuryMechanismRadiographic hallmarkStability
Clay shoveler fractureForced flexion or muscle avulsionOblique avulsion of a spinous process, C7 most often (then C6, T1); ghost spinous on APStable
Simple wedge compressionFlexionAnterior body height loss, intact posterior wallUsually stable
Flexion teardropSevere flexion with axial load (diving)Large anteroinferior body fragment, posterior body displaced into canal, facet wideningHighly unstable; anterior cord syndrome
Extension teardropHyperextension, often C2 in elderlySmall triangular avulsion of the anteroinferior corner, fragment taller than wideStable in flexion, unstable in extension
Unilateral facet dislocationFlexion with rotationAnterolisthesis about 25 percent of body width; bow tie sign of facets on lateral; rotated spinous on APUsually stable but needs reduction
Bilateral facet dislocationSevere flexionAnterolisthesis 50 percent or more, perched or locked facetsUnstable; high cord injury rate

A fragment from the anteroinferior corner of a body after trauma is a teardrop fracture until proven otherwise; a corticated triangle at the anterosuperior corner of a lumbar body is a limbus bone. A fused spine (ankylosing spondylitis, DISH) fractures like a long bone after minor trauma; new pain after a fall in such a patient needs CT.

Thoracic and lumbar fractures

Osteoporotic versus pathological compression fracture

Favoring osteoporosis: diffuse osteopenia, an intact posterior wall and pedicles, and a level below T6. Favoring malignancy: a destroyed pedicle, a convex posterior wall, a soft tissue mass, a level above T5 and other lytic or blastic lesions (Chapter 14). Recommend MRI and labs when features are atypical.

Pars defects and spondylolisthesis

Spondylolysis is a pars interarticularis defect, usually a fatigue fracture, in about 5 to 6 percent of people and more in athletes who hyperextend (gymnasts, linemen, fast bowlers); L5 accounts for about 85 to 90 percent. On the oblique view the posterior elements form the Scotty dog (nose transverse process, eye pedicle, neck pars, ear superior facet, front leg inferior facet, body lamina); a defect is a collar, and a slip decapitates the dog. Early stress reactions need SPECT, CT or MRI.

Spondylolisthesis is forward slip of one vertebra on the one below. Wiltse types: I dysplastic, II isthmic (pars defect), III degenerative (facet arthrosis, typically L4 to L5 in women over 50, intact pars, rarely beyond grade I), IV traumatic, V pathological and VI iatrogenic. Meyerding grading uses quarters of the lower end plate: I up to 25 percent, II to 50, III to 75, IV to 100, and V (spondyloptosis) beyond, with the inverted Napoleon hat sign on the AP view. In isthmic slips the palpable step is at the spinous process above the slipped level (its posterior arch stays behind); in degenerative slips it is at the slipped level.

Oblique view: Scotty dog Lateral view: Meyerding grade Nose: TP Eye: pedicle Ear: superior facet Collar on neck: pars defect Front leg: inferior facet Body: lamina Sacrum (S1) I II III IV L5 body anterior posterior L5 corner (red) has moved into quarter I: grade I slip
Figure 13.4 Pars defects and slips. On the oblique view a pars defect is a collar on the neck of the Scotty dog. On the lateral view the sacral end plate is divided into quarters, and the Meyerding grade is the quarter reached by the posterior inferior corner of the slipped body.
Case. A 15 year old gymnast has 6 weeks of low back pain worse with back walkovers and relieved by rest. Single leg hyperextension (stork test) reproduces right sided pain. Lumbar films including obliques are normal.
Reasoning: The history and the stork test strongly suggest an acute pars stress reaction (early spondylolysis), which is often invisible on plain films in its early stage. Normal films do not exclude it. Recommend MRI (or SPECT or limited CT) to detect the stress reaction, and remove her from extension loading. Early lesions can heal with rest and, in some protocols, bracing; continuing gymnastics risks a complete defect and slip. Avoid extension thrusts at the lumbosacral junction while it heals.

Extremity fractures and dislocations

InjuryHallmark and viewComplication or trap
Anterior shoulder dislocationHead anterior, inferior, below coracoid on AP; Y view confirmsHill Sachs (posterolateral head impaction), Bankart (anteroinferior glenoid), axillary nerve injury
Posterior shoulder dislocationLightbulb head (fixed internal rotation), rim sign (widened glenohumeral space over 6 mm), trough lineMissed on AP alone; seizures and electrocution
Supracondylar humerus (child)Posterior fat pad; anterior humeral line passes anterior to middle third of capitellumBrachial artery and median nerve, Volkmann ischemic contracture
MonteggiaProximal ulna fracture with radial head dislocationRadiocapitellar line must hit capitellum in every view
CollesDistal radius, dorsal angulation (dinner fork), FOOSH, osteoporotic womenSmith is the reverse (volar angulation); Barton involves the articular rim
ScaphoidWaist fracture, often invisible initially; scaphoid (ulnar deviated PA) viewProximal pole AVN and nonunion; snuffbox tenderness means splint and repeat films at 10 to 14 days or MRI
Perilunate and lunate dislocationLateral: lunate tipped volarly (spilled teacup); PA: piece of pie lunateMedian nerve compression; emergency reduction
Femoral neckElderly fall, shortened externally rotated limb; disrupted trabeculae, sclerotic impaction lineIntracapsular: AVN and nonunion; occult cases need MRI
Tibial plateauLateral plateau depression; lipohemarthrosis on cross table lateralPeroneal nerve, compartment syndrome
MaisonneuveMedial ankle injury with proximal fibula fractureSyndesmosis disruption; palpate the whole fibula
Jones and pseudo JonesJones: proximal fifth metatarsal diaphysis (metaphyseal diaphyseal junction); pseudo Jones: tuberosity avulsion (peroneus brevis)Jones has high nonunion rate; avoid weight bearing, refer
LisfrancWidening between first and second metatarsal bases; second metatarsal base not aligned with middle cuneiform; fleck signFrequently missed; weight bearing films

The Ottawa ankle and knee rules limit unnecessary films (malleolar or midfoot bone tenderness at the specified sites, or inability to bear weight four steps). Every fracture needs two views at right angles, including the joints above and below for shaft injuries.

Pediatric fractures

Children's bones are more pliable, have a thick periosteum and contain open physes (growth plates), which are weaker than the ligaments. A force that would sprain an adult ligament fractures a child's physis instead. Patterns unique to children include the torus (buckle) fracture, a bulge of the cortex on the compression side of the distal radial metaphysis; the greenstick fracture, which breaks the tension side cortex and bends the compression side; and plastic bowing, a bend without a visible fracture line, most often in the forearm.

The Salter Harris classification describes physeal fractures. Type I runs straight through the physis (Straight or Slipped; often a normal film with tenderness over the plate). Type II passes through the physis and exits through the metaphysis (Above; the most common, about 75 percent; the metaphyseal fragment is the Thurston Holland fragment). Type III passes through the physis and exits through the epiphysis (Lower, below the plate; intra articular). Type IV crosses metaphysis, physis and epiphysis (Through). Type V is a crush injury of the physis (Rammed or Ruined), often recognized only later by growth arrest. The mnemonic is SALTR. Risk of growth disturbance rises from type I to V; types III and IV need anatomic reduction, often surgical.

Metaphysis Physis Epiphysis I StraightII AboveIII LowerIV ThroughV Rammed through platemost commoninto jointall three zonescrush, worst corner fragmentneeds reductionneeds reductiongrowth arrest
Figure 13.5 Salter Harris physeal fractures (SALTR). The red line shows the fracture path. Prognosis worsens from type I to type V, and types III and IV cross the articular surface and need anatomic reduction.

Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) affects overweight adolescents (about 10 to 16 years) and may present only as knee pain. On the AP view Klein line along the superior neck fails to cross the epiphysis and the physis is widened; the frog leg lateral shows the slip earliest. It is bilateral in up to a third. Make the patient non weight bearing and refer urgently; no hip manipulation.

Nonaccidental trauma is suggested by metaphyseal corner fractures, posterior rib fractures, fractures of different ages, and any long bone fracture in a nonwalking infant, especially when the history does not fit. Chiropractors are mandated reporters: report to child protective services and arrange medical evaluation with a skeletal survey.

Stress fractures

A fatigue fracture is normal bone under abnormal repetitive load; an insufficiency fracture is weakened bone (osteoporosis, osteomalacia, radiation, steroids) under normal load. Plain films are often normal for 2 to 3 weeks, then show faint periosteal reaction or a sclerotic band perpendicular to the trabeculae; MRI is the best early test. Common sites are the second and third metatarsals (march fracture), tibia, calcaneus, femoral neck, pubic rami and, in elderly women, the sacrum (the H shaped or Honda sign on bone scan). High risk sites that displace or fail to heal are the tension side (superolateral) femoral neck, anterior tibial cortex, navicular and proximal fifth metatarsal diaphysis; a superolateral femoral neck stress fracture needs same day referral.

Board tip. In a runner or recruit with focal bony pain and normal films, the answer is not reassurance: it is MRI (or repeat films in 2 to 3 weeks if MRI is unavailable) with protected weight bearing. If the site is the femoral neck, stop weight bearing immediately and refer the same day.
Case. A 13 year old boy who weighs 82 kg presents with 3 weeks of right knee pain and a limp. Knee examination is normal. Hip internal rotation is limited, and when the hip is flexed it rotates externally (obligatory external rotation).
Reasoning: Knee pain with a normal knee examination in an overweight adolescent is slipped capital femoral epiphysis until proven otherwise, because hip pain refers along the obturator nerve to the knee. Order AP pelvis and frog leg lateral views of both hips; look for a Klein line that fails to cross the epiphysis and a widened, blurred physis. Make him non weight bearing on crutches and refer urgently to pediatric orthopedics for pinning. Hip manipulation is contraindicated, and the other hip must be checked because SCFE is often bilateral.
Key point

Use NEXUS or the Canadian C spine rule to decide on neck films, the three column model to judge spinal stability, and two perpendicular views for every suspected fracture. Unstable patterns (Jefferson with over 7 mm overhang, type II dens, flexion teardrop, bilateral facet dislocation, burst, Chance, fracture dislocation) and the urgent pediatric problems (SCFE, physeal fractures, nonaccidental trauma, femoral neck stress fracture) mean stop, stabilize and refer, not treat.

Section 5Soft tissue trauma signs on film

Why soft tissues are read first

A fracture line may be invisible, but the bleeding and swelling it causes usually are not. Soft tissue signs are therefore the indirect evidence of injury, and they often decide whether a normal looking film is truly normal. The habit to build is a systematic soft tissue search on every trauma film: the prevertebral space on the lateral cervical view, the fat pads of the elbow, the fat stripes of the wrist, the suprapatellar recess of the knee, the paraspinal lines of the thoracic spine and the psoas shadows of the lumbar spine.

Prevertebral soft tissue swelling in the neck

On the neutral lateral film, measure the retropharyngeal space from the anteroinferior corner of C2 to the airway and the retrotracheal space at C6. Adult upper limits are 7 mm at C2 and 22 mm at C6 (children 7 and 14 mm). Swelling suggests hemorrhage from fracture or ligament tear, but also abscess or tumor, and crying infants can mimic it. A normal width does not exclude injury because swelling can take hours to develop.

Displacement of the prevertebral fat stripe and, in the thoracic spine, bulging of the paraspinal line are other signs of hematoma.

Cervical alignment lines and the atlantodental interval

Four lines should be smooth on the lateral film: the anterior vertebral, posterior vertebral (George line; a step over about 3 mm means translation), spinolaminar and posterior spinous lines. The atlantodental interval (ADI) should be no more than 3 mm in adults and 5 mm in children; more implies transverse ligament insufficiency (trauma, rheumatoid arthritis, Down syndrome). A sagittal canal under about 12 mm (Torg Pavlov ratio under 0.8) indicates developmental stenosis.

In young children, pseudosubluxation of C2 on C3 (up to about 3 to 4 mm, normal under about age 8, confirmed by the posterior cervical line of Swischuk) and the pseudo Jefferson overhang of C1 on the open mouth view are normal.

Airway C2C3C4C5C6C7 ADI: 3 mm adult, 5 mm child Retropharyngeal C2: up to 7 mm Retrotracheal C6: up to 22 mm Anterior vertebral Posterior vertebral Spinolaminar Posterior spinous All four should be smooth, unbroken arcs Anterior is to the left; canal lies between the blue and orange lines
Figure 13.6 The lateral cervical trauma checklist. Four alignment lines should be smooth, the atlantodental interval small, and the prevertebral soft tissues thin: no more than about 7 mm at C2 and 22 mm at C6 in an adult.
Board tip. Remember "7 at 2, 22 at 6" for adult prevertebral soft tissue, "3 and 5" for the adult and child atlantodental interval, and "3.5 mm and 11 degrees" for cervical instability on flexion and extension.

Fat pad and fat stripe signs in the extremities

Joint fluid displaces the lucent fat around a joint. On a true lateral elbow at 90 degrees, a thin anterior fat pad is normal, but when lifted it forms a triangle, the sail sign. The posterior fat pad hides in the olecranon fossa and is never visible normally. After trauma a visible posterior fat pad means an occult intra articular fracture: a radial head fracture in adults, a supracondylar fracture in children. Treat it as a fracture (splint, repeat films in 7 to 10 days or CT).

Soft tissue signWhere and which viewWhat it suggestsNext step
Prevertebral swellingLateral cervical: over 7 mm at C2 or 22 mm at C6Fracture, ligament injury, abscessImmobilize; CT; emergency referral after trauma
Posterior fat padLateral elbow at 90 degreesEffusion; occult radial head (adult) or supracondylar (child) fractureSplint, repeat film in 7 to 10 days or CT or MRI
Sail signLateral elbow, elevated anterior fat padEffusionAs above
Lipohemarthrosis (FBI sign)Cross table lateral kneeIntra articular fractureCT and orthopedic referral
Displaced scaphoid fat stripePA or scaphoid viewScaphoid fractureThumb spica, repeat films or MRI
Bowed pronator quadratus lineLateral wristDistal radius fractureAdditional views, splint
Widened paraspinal lineAP thoracicHematoma from fracture (or abscess, tumor, aortic injury)CT
Soft tissue gasAny view after woundGas forming infection or foreign bodyEmergency department

Flexion and extension views for instability

Ligament injuries may leave a neutral film perfectly aligned, because muscle spasm holds the segments in place. Flexion and extension lateral views (dynamic or stress views) are used to uncover instability, particularly after whiplash with persistent pain, in rheumatoid arthritis, in Down syndrome, and in patients with degenerative spondylolisthesis being considered for surgery. Signs of cervical instability include:

In the lumbar spine, translation over about 4.5 mm (about 15 percent) is commonly considered abnormal.

Timing and safety matter as much as the measurements. In acute trauma, flexion and extension views are contraindicated until fracture and gross instability have been excluded by neutral films or, more often today, CT; a patient with a neurological deficit or high risk mechanism should never be asked to flex and extend. The movements must be active and patient controlled, never forced by the examiner. Early after injury, muscle guarding can prevent the motion needed to show instability, producing a false negative; so if pain persists, repeat dynamic views at about 7 to 14 days (some protocols say 2 to 3 weeks) when spasm has eased, or use MRI to look for ligament edema. Delayed instability is a classic cause of a missed injury after whiplash.

Case. A 41 year old man was rear ended at moderate speed 2 weeks ago. He was cleared at the emergency department with a normal CT. He now has persistent neck pain, no neurological signs, and neutral cervical films are normal. Flexion and extension views show 4 mm of anterior translation of C4 on C5 in flexion with widening of the C4 to C5 interspinous space.
Reasoning: CT excludes fracture but not ligament injury. Translation over 3.5 mm with interspinous fanning on flexion indicates ligamentous instability at C4 to C5 from a posterior ligament complex tear, a delayed instability that was masked by spasm initially. Do not manipulate the segment. Place him in a collar for comfort and protection, order MRI, and refer to a spine surgeon promptly; surgical stabilization may be needed. Document the measurement in the report with a clear recommendation.
Key point

Read the soft tissues on every trauma film, because they reveal fractures you cannot see: 7 mm at C2 and 22 mm at C6, a visible posterior elbow fat pad, a fat fluid level on a cross table knee film. Flexion and extension views uncover ligament instability (over 3.5 mm translation or 11 degrees angulation in the neck), but only after fracture is excluded and often only after spasm has settled.

The chapter in one breath

  • Spinal anomalies are failures of formation (hemivertebra, butterfly vertebra) or segmentation (block vertebra, occipitalization, unsegmented bar).
  • Os odontoideum has smooth corticated margins and a hypertrophied C1 anterior arch; it is unstable and a contraindication to upper cervical thrust; a fresh type II dens fracture has sharp margins.
  • A congenital block vertebra has a wasp waist and an oval foramen; infection and ankylosing spondylitis fuse without a waist.
  • Count levels carefully with transitional segments (Castellvi I to IV) and report how you counted; a cervical rib comes from C7 and can cause thoracic outlet syndrome.
  • Variants are corticated, bilateral and in typical locations; fractures are sharp, focal and tender.
  • In DDH, the femoral head belongs in the lower inner quadrant of Hilgenreiner and Perkins lines, the acetabular index is normally 30 degrees or less, and Shenton line is unbroken; refer promptly.
  • Scoliosis is 10 degrees or more by Cobb; use Risser grade and size to choose observation (10 to 25), bracing (25 to 40 in a growing child) or surgical referral (over 45 to 50); atypical curves need MRI.
  • Unstable spinal injuries include Jefferson with over 7 mm overhang, type II dens, flexion teardrop, bilateral facet dislocation, burst, Chance and fracture dislocation; involve the middle column means unstable.
  • A pars defect is a collar on the Scotty dog; grade slips by Meyerding quarters; early stress reactions need MRI.
  • Pediatric fractures follow Salter Harris SALTR; SCFE presents as knee pain in an overweight teen; posterior rib and metaphyseal corner fractures suggest abuse.
  • Stress fractures hide on early films; the tension side femoral neck stress fracture is a same day referral.
  • Soft tissue signs (7 at 2, 22 at 6, posterior fat pad, FBI sign) and flexion and extension instability criteria (3.5 mm, 11 degrees) reveal injuries the bones hide.

Words worth knowing

TermWhat it means
OccipitalizationCongenital fusion of the atlas to the occiput, a failure of segmentation that loads the C1 to C2 joint and may cause late instability.
Os odontoideumA smooth, corticated ossicle separate from a shortened dens; it moves with C1 and makes the atlantoaxial joint unstable.
Ponticulus posticusA bony bridge over the vertebral artery groove of the posterior arch of C1, formed by ossification of the oblique atlantooccipital ligament.
Block vertebraCongenital fusion of two or more vertebral bodies, recognized by a narrow waist at the level of the missing disc.
Klippel Feil syndromeCongenital fusion of multiple cervical segments, associated with Sprengel deformity, renal and cardiac anomalies.
HemivertebraA vertebra with one half missing, appearing as a wedge with a single pedicle and causing a sharp congenital curve.
Butterfly vertebraA vertebral body with a central sagittal cleft, seen on AP as two triangles with reciprocally shaped neighbors.
Spina bifida occultaFailure of the laminae to fuse in the midline without exposure of neural tissue, most often at L5 or S1.
Transitional segmentA lumbosacral vertebra with features of both lumbar and sacral segments (sacralization or lumbarization), graded by Castellvi.
Cervical ribAn extra rib arising from C7 that may compress the brachial plexus or subclavian artery.
Limbus boneA corticated triangular fragment at the anterosuperior corner of a lumbar body from disc herniation through the ring apophysis.
Bipartite patellaA developmental unfused superolateral patellar fragment with smooth sclerotic margins, usually bilateral.
Acetabular indexThe angle of the acetabular roof relative to Hilgenreiner line; above about 30 degrees suggests dysplasia.
Shenton lineA smooth arc along the superior pubic ramus and medial femoral neck; a break means the femur has moved upward.
Cobb angleThe angle between the end plates of the most tilted vertebrae at the ends of a curve, the standard scoliosis measurement.
Risser signGrade 0 to 5 of iliac crest apophysis ossification, used to estimate remaining spinal growth.
Jefferson fractureA burst fracture of the ring of C1 from axial load, with lateral mass overhang on the open mouth view.
Chance fractureA horizontal flexion distraction fracture through the posterior elements and body, typically from a lap belt, with frequent bowel injury.
SpondylolysisA defect of the pars interarticularis, seen as a collar on the Scotty dog on oblique views.
Meyerding gradeA scale of spondylolisthesis in quarters of the lower vertebra's end plate, grade I to IV, with grade V beyond 100 percent.
Salter Harris fractureA fracture involving the growth plate, classified types I to V by its path through physis, metaphysis and epiphysis.
Slipped capital femoral epiphysisPosteromedial slippage of the femoral head through the physis in an adolescent, judged with Klein line and a frog leg view.
Fat pad signDisplacement of the elbow fat pads by joint fluid; a visible posterior fat pad is always abnormal.
LipohemarthrosisA fat fluid level in a joint on a horizontal beam film, indicating an intra articular fracture.
Atlantodental intervalThe space between the anterior arch of C1 and the dens; over 3 mm in adults or 5 mm in children is abnormal.

Check yourself

A lateral cervical film shows a well corticated, rounded ossicle above a short dens, and the anterior arch of C1 is large and rounded. What is the finding, and what must be done before any upper cervical adjusting?
Answer. Os odontoideum. The smooth margins and hypertrophied C1 arch indicate a longstanding lesion rather than an acute type II fracture. Obtain flexion and extension views to assess atlantoaxial instability, avoid upper cervical thrust, and refer for surgical opinion.
Two fused cervical bodies show a narrowed waist at the level of the absent disc and an enlarged oval foramen. What is the most likely diagnosis, and what does it predispose to?
Answer. Congenital block vertebra (most often C2 to C3 or C5 to C6). The wasp waist distinguishes it from acquired fusion. It overloads the adjacent segments, which become hypermobile and degenerate early.
On an AP lumbar film, the L5 transverse process on the left forms a joint with the sacral ala while the right is normal. Name and classify it.
Answer. A lumbosacral transitional segment, Castellvi type IIa (unilateral pseudarthrosis). It may be painful (Bertolotti syndrome) and requires careful level counting, which should be stated in the report.
A 10 year old's foot film shows a lucent line at the base of the fifth metatarsal running parallel to the shaft. Fracture or variant?
Answer. Variant: the normal apophysis runs parallel to the shaft. A fracture line at the base runs transverse to the shaft.
On an infant AP pelvis, which quadrant should the femoral head ossification center occupy, and what acetabular index suggests dysplasia?
Answer. The lower inner quadrant formed by Hilgenreiner and Perkins lines. An acetabular index above about 30 degrees suggests developmental dysplasia; refer to pediatric orthopedics.
A 13 year old premenarchal girl has a 32 degree right thoracic curve with Risser 1 and no neurological findings. What is the best next step?
Answer. Referral to an orthopedic scoliosis specialist for bracing assessment. A curve of 25 to 40 degrees in a skeletally immature patient is in the bracing range and at high risk of progression.
An open mouth view after a diving injury shows the lateral masses of C1 overhanging C2 by a combined 9 mm. What is the injury and its significance?
Answer. A Jefferson burst fracture of C1. Combined overhang over about 7 mm (rule of Spence) indicates transverse ligament rupture and an unstable injury; immobilize and transfer to the emergency department for CT.
After a car crash with only a lap belt, a 24 year old has a horizontal fracture through the L1 spinous process, pedicles and body. Besides the spine, what must be urgently evaluated?
Answer. Intra abdominal injury, especially bowel and mesentery. This is a Chance (flexion distraction) fracture, which is associated with abdominal injuries in up to half of cases and is unstable.
An overweight 12 year old boy has knee pain and a limp; knee films are normal. What view is most sensitive for the likely diagnosis?
Answer. A frog leg lateral of both hips, looking for slipped capital femoral epiphysis (Klein line failing to intersect the epiphysis). Make him non weight bearing and refer urgently.
On a neutral lateral cervical film after trauma, the retropharyngeal soft tissue at C2 measures 10 mm. What does this mean, and what is the next step?
Answer. It exceeds the adult limit of about 7 mm and suggests hemorrhage or edema from an occult fracture or ligament injury. Immobilize the neck and refer to the emergency department for CT; do not obtain flexion and extension views or manipulate.