← Chapter 2
English Composition · Chapter 2

The Sentence Spin Lab

One fact goes in; a great many arguments come out. Turn the four dials — who appears as the actor, which words carry the fact, how much confidence is claimed, and which clause gets the word although — and read what happens in the panel on the right. Nothing about the world changes. Everything about what a reader can conclude does.

Four dials, one fixed fact

The event — locked; this never changes
What happened
Which event — try all three
Dial 1 · The actor — who occupies the subject slot?
Dial 2 · Diction — connotation, not denotation
Dial 3 · Confidence — hedge to boost
Over-hedgedPlainOver-boosted
Dial 4 · Subordination — which clause is the point?
Ten-second experiment. Set dial 4 to each of its two although positions in turn and read the sentence aloud both times. Identical facts. One is a defence and one is an indictment, and nothing changed but which clause got subordinated. Subordination is an argument.

The sentence you just built

What the sentence is doing

Actor visible
Moral charge
Confidence claimed